7 ms·
Remember that in this story, as strange as this is to say, Amazon is the good guy. Elastic changed their products from a FOSS license to a proprietary one, and
by josephcsible 5y ago
Remember that in this story, as strange as this is to say, Amazon is the good guy. Elastic changed their products from a FOSS license to a proprietary one, and Amazon did exactly what you're supposed to do in that case: fork and continue development of the last FOSS version.
- wmf 5y agoThey changed the license after Amazon took all their revenue.
- josephcsible 5y agoI don't fault Elastic for choosing to change their license. I fault them for their choice of the new one. They should have moved to the AGPL instead, like Grafana did under basically the exact same circumstances.
- whateveracct 5y agoyep - not going AGPL is just greed
- zokier 5y ago> We have experienced significant growth, with revenue increasing to $608.5 million in the year ended April 30, 2021 from $427.6 million in the year ended April 30, 2020 and $271.7 million in the year ended April 30, 2019, representing year-over-year growth of 42% for the year ended April 30, 2021 and 57% for the year ended April 30, 2020 https://s2.q4cdn.com/265747582/files/doc_downloads/2021/Elastic-Annual-Report-Fiscal-Year-2021.pdf https://s2.q4cdn.com/265747582/files/doc_downloads/2021/Elas... Revenue for FY2018 and 2017 was $160M and $88M respectively. Is that what Amazon taking all their revenue looks like?
- true_religion 5y agoThe fact that they grew despite Amazon doesn't mean that AWS Elasticsearch wasn't a viable competitor. It just means that at the moment it was not an existential threat. However, when competing with a literally A in FAANG, one must be very careful about writing them off. To compare, I knew a company that 10 years ago made really great business intelligence integrations into Excel. They'd operated for 15+ years and were a major local employer. They thought Palantir was going to be their competitor, but then Microsoft came out with Power BI. At first, revenue grew because Microsoft's marketing shined a great spotlight on the field (plus MS had only entered because the field was growing in the first place). Then as the situation matured, MS's capacity to offer integrations to the rest of the stack became a key sales point. Like AWS, the point of investing in their stack isn't one particular product but the fact that all the billing, support, and integrations happen via one company. You can even accept it if any particular product is deficient (e.g., some say that about Teams or Skype), but in the case of an open-source product like Elastic--the value of the software itself is 100% the same. AWS was going to eventually kill Elastic. Not just because of all I wrote above, but also because Elastic's got a significant part of its revenue by selling Elastic as a distribution on top of AWS. Anyone would want to cut out the middleman and simply use AWS's version even if it lagged behind the current Elastic.
- tedivm 5y agoI'd have more sympathy for that viewpoint if Elastic didn't start off by using the open source community before switching to a proprietary license. The never would have gotten to the level where they mattered if it wasn't for being open source, and turning their back on that community makes them the bad guys.
- foota 5y agoIsn't elastic still open source, just not in the way the open source diehards like?
- zokier 5y agoA small history tidbit is that AWS has been offering ES service since 2015, while Elastic launched Elastic Cloud in 2016, after acquiring Found (a ES SaaS company) in 2015.
- truetraveller 5y agoDoesn't matter. If you don't have the courage for FOSS, don't do it. And you also won't get the good will FOSS gives you.
- Salgat 5y agoYou talk like they're entitled to that. When you make software open source, the social contract is that you accept free contributions, in the form of commits, issues, and code reviews, in exchange for being held accountable by the community to ensure you provide the best product. If another company provides a superior service and support, that's part of the risk. If they want to go back to closed source, they can't be surprised if everyone jumps ship.
- echelon 5y ago> Amazon is the good guy in this story That is so twisted. Elastic did all of the hard work. Amazon came in and took it. Open source is fair when there aren't giants plucking it out of the hands of workers and co-opting it into their massive platform options with god-tier leverage. You can't compete in that world. We need licenses even stronger than the AGPL to require that platforms running the code are open all the way down to the billing stack.
- tapoxi 5y agoDid Elastic do the hard work, or Lucene?
- DanielVZ 5y agoThere's so much on top of lucene that I'd say both
- dhd415 5y agoEspecially considering ~11 of the Apache Lucene committers are Elastic employees as well as 10 members of the Apache Lucene Project Management Committee.
- _msw_ 5y agoDisclosure: I work for AWS where I build infrastructure services that sit low in the stack. I am a relative novice when it comes to Java-heavy codebases like Apache Lucene, Elasticsearch, or OpenSearch. But I know a thing or two about Open Source and Communities. I think it is hazardous to count the number of committers and PMC members that are part of a project that is built at the Apache Software Foundation. It is helpful to keep track of these things to make sure that the project keeps its independence, and is not unduly influenced by the interest of any one company or organization. Committers and PMC members earn their position based on their own efforts as individuals. They don't represent their employers. The current Apache Lucene PMC chair just happens to work for Amazon today. A number of folks that used to work for Elastic now work at Amazon. But over-focusing on that, and keeping careful track of what company contributes how much to ASF projects, is bad for community health in my personal opinion. See also Doug Cutting at https://twitter.com/cutting/status/1359160158723711002 https://twitter.com/cutting/status/1359160158723711002
- atarian 5y ago>Amazon is the good guy This is exactly what Amazon wants you to think. That's why they're calling it "OpenSearch" and not "AmazonSearch".
- truetraveller 5y agoAnd it's exactly correct. Amazon got burnt by Elastic. Doesn't matter if it's $100 billion company. And mind you, Elastic is no tiny startup. It has 2000+ employees.
- jusonchan81 5y agoIt’s one of those things. Until Amazon does this to you, you will love that company no matter how many people they will screw over. Mind you this company basically is a monopoly in multiple domains. I’m afraid of the world where we align with the villain on something only because it’s convenient for us.
- Sebb767 5y agoNot everything Amazon does is evil. And not everything Elastic did is good. I highly doubt a lot of people in this thread would sign off that Amazon generally is a good company; it's just that in this case, they're on the right side, in part just because Elastic made it easy to be.
- josephcsible 5y ago> I’m afraid of the world where we align with the villain on something only because it’s convenient for us. We're not. We're aligning with them because they happened to do something legitimately good. Being a villain doesn't mean that literally everything you do is bad.
- jusonchan81 5y agoI’m curious though, did Elastic’s license change impact you in anyway? Were you planning on offering Elasticsearch as a managed cloud offering? What exactly is the legitimate good Amazon did here?