4 ms·
> those other manufactured gasses trap heat thousands or tens of thousands of times better than CO2 does, and are already a big part of the Problem. If by big
by marcosdumay 5y ago
> those other manufactured gasses trap heat thousands or tens of thousands of times better than CO2 does, and are already a big part of the Problem.
If by big you mean 1/5 of the problem, ok. But that is really not big enough to remove the focus from the other 4/5 And the way those gases work on the long term, in that the amount of them on the atmosphere is proportional to the speed of emission, instead of total emissions makes any change of focus from CO2 actually harmful to solving the problem.
And by the way, half of the non-CO2 emissions are methane, that comes mostly from fossil fuels mining and handling, and 2/3 of the rest are nitrous oxides, that comes almost entirely from fossil fuel burning. So "big" is really, really pushing it.
A source:
https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/overview-greenhouse-gases https://www.epa.gov/ghgemissions/overview-greenhouse-gases
- ncmncm 5y agoBig, meaning that even eliminating all of the excess CO2, would not get us back to the pre-industrial heat-forcing condition. We have reasons not to want to take CO2 concentration below that point, but to want forcing to reach that point. Just getting the excess CO2 out is a big enough job, and one responsive enough to known practical measures, that it leaves some time for research on the tails, if we start now. Nothing about this unfolding disaster is small, or about any measure to counter it.
- marcosdumay 5y ago> Big, meaning that even eliminating all of the excess CO2 Well, it gets you >87% of the way, and stabilizes there as long as emissions do not grow. Where going to 97% depends on lots of changes on agriculture, and only the last 3% is about the gases you cite. Of course, for 100% you will need to cure all the causes. But "87% solved and not getting any worse" does really not sound like an emergency. I maintain that changing any focus away from CO2 is a mistake.
- ncmncm 5y agoIt is fortunate that you are not in charge of efforts to replace use of SF6 in current high-voltage electrical equipment; or to phase out HFCs, and to ensure that the HFCs replaced or in decommissioned equipment are destroyed safely. Each person working on those has more effect than any thousand working on carbon. But we also need all those thousands working on carbon. According to EPA, just three companies release the overwhelming bulk of problem fluorine-containing gases today. It is much easier to get three companies to change what they do than to get tens of thousands in line. In practice, carbon is such a big problem that a solution will only come very slowly. Anything that can be done more quickly has outsize impact.