6 ms·
More like sketchy behavior coming out of Coinbase. Coinbase terms: Acknowledgement of Risk. By opting into Lend, you are acknowledging the following: Lend is n
by Animats 5y ago
More like sketchy behavior coming out of Coinbase. Coinbase terms:
Acknowledgement of Risk. By opting into Lend, you are acknowledging the following: Lend is not a checking account nor a bank savings account, and Coinbase is not a bank. By participating in Lend, you are making a loan of your eligible Digital Currency to Coinbase, Coinbase is your counterparty and you will have only a contract claim against Coinbase for the return of Loaned Digital Currency. As with any loan transaction, you could lose all your Loaned Digital Currency if we are unable to repay your loan. Coinbase does not provide you with collateral for the Loaned Digital Currency. You acknowledge that while you have the right to make a Return Request at any time, if Coinbase becomes insolvent or bankrupt or is placed in receivership your Loaned Digital Currency may be lost. Your Loaned Digital Currency is not protected by the Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation, the Securities Investor Protection Corporation or other insurance.
Coinbase may use Loaned Digital Currency in its sole discretion, including uses which generate returns for Coinbase in excess of the Lend APY, which Coinbase is entitled to as compensation for Lend. Any returns generated by the use of Loaned Digital Currency are not returned to you as part of Lend interest. Therefore, although the interest rate will be determined in accordance with Section 2, the interest rate is determined by Coinbase and Coinbase may have a conflict of interest with you in setting the Interest Rate.
OK. So Coinbase wants to borrow your money, invest it in something else, not tell you what that something else is, and hopefully pay you back. In the real world, they're selling you a bond or commercial paper. That's a security.[1]
Morrison and Forster lists these requirements for commercial paper that doesn't have to be registered as a security.
- Negotiable (No)
- Prime quality (No)
- Eligible for discount at Federal Reserve banks (No)
- Not ordinarily purchased by the general public (No)
- Used to facilitate “current transactions” (No)
- Maturity of nine months or less with no automatic roll-over. (No)
Nope, doesn't qualify.
Coinbase is trying to pretend to be a bank without qualifying as a bank. They have to know this; they're a public company and have now filed SEC filings for two whole quarters.
[1] https://media2.mofo.com/documents/151203commercialpaperprograms.pdf https://media2.mofo.com/documents/151203commercialpaperprogr...
- MrWiffles 5y agoThanks for this - I found it particularly enlightening. I viewed the Twitter thread thinking “damn SEC!” but now? While the SEC should probably be more transparent here, clearly CB is up to shenanigans, which justifies their threat of lawsuit.
- ALittleLight 5y agoI don't know about the regulation part of it, but why shouldn't the SEC just respond to a company asking for clarification with a clarification? I'm assuming, based on the Twitter thread, that they have not done so.
- DenisM 5y agoSEC clarified that the program must not be launched or a lawsuit will follow. As to why - apparently SEC is collecting information to provide a guidance. You don’t want to rush guidance.
- 3np 5y agoThanks for that link, gives great context for the US situation around the regulatory situation around commercially offered crypto lending program. There's a good summary on page 17. From reading, the requirements you quote are specifically to be excluded under Section 3(a)3. There is also the possibility to be excluded under Section 4(a)2. Looks to me that out of those, the following points rule that out as well: - the issuer cannot use general solicitation or advertising to market the securities - the issuer may sell its securities to an unlimited number of accredited investors and up to 35 other purchases - each resale of CP, including each resale by a purchaser in the secondary market, must be made in a private placement transaction Now, my question is: How does this apply (or not apply) to interest on accounts with banks or credit unions? I think it's also quite clear that those don't apply here; is there some separate legislation (that I assume have other requirements, like holding some form of banking license) that regulate these? Kraken has a Wyoming banking license since last year, making them federally recognized as a bank. I'd be curious to know if this means that they have a way to offer lending services that Coinbase aren't allowed to. > They have to know this; they're a public company and have now filed SEC filings for two whole quarters. This makes me think there may be something we're missing here. In any other case I have the impression of CB to be doing their best to play by (their interpretation of) the book. They employ some of the most competent advice in the states on compliance matters. It'd be inconsistent of them to just flagrantly ignore something like this without having any ground at all to stand on. I wouldn't blink if Poloniex/Circle or Binance US did any kind of shenanigans and excusing themselves with "regulatory uncertainty" but it's not congruent with what we've seen from Coinbase so far. EDIT: Alternative take: CB are so worried about an exodus of liquidity if they can't match lending terms of other exchanges that they knowingly violate securities regulations to stay competitive. Under this model BA's tweets are theater. This would indicate a significant shift in values but not impossible.
- DenisM 5y agoOk - seems strange, how can lending be a security? The naïveté of this statement by CB beggars belief. If you ask people for money now in exchange for more money later you’re creating a security. The law has been on the books since 1933.
- darksaints 5y agoA security is by definition a tradable instrument. Your bank account is not tradable, and therefore is not a security, despite the fact that you are lending the bank money and interest is paid in return.
- ehnto 5y agoBut coinbase is explicit abut not being a bank, so is it a tradeable instrument or a savings account? Or can it be something else?
- darksaints 5y agoYou don't have to be a bank to offer an interest bearing account.
- TomSwirly 5y agoYour implied claim is that you can set up a system to offer interest bearing accounts, and not be subject to any sort of regulation. This is false. Either you are something like a bank or an insurance company that has its own regulation, or you are regulated by the SEC. You can't just magically say, "I'm a not a thing at all, you can't regulate me!" This is the "sovereign citizen" argument applied to the SEC.
- darksaints 5y agoWhat the actual fuck? Never once have I said that these wouldn't be regulated, nor has the Coinbase CEO, and I have no fucking clue how you would jump to that conclusion. Jesus Christ...what a fucking moronic straw man. There are over a dozen financial regulatory bodies that are not the SEC. FINRA is the most likely choice here, considering the fact that they already regulate securities lending.
- floatingatoll 5y agoNivertech below lists the Howey test, which I'm going to reuse here. 1. An investment of money - You're certainly not depositing it for safekeeping when they don't insure you against loss, and the only thing that inspires people to deposit unsafely is an earning on their investment 2. In a common enterprise - Coinbase Loan is a common enterprise umbrella, everyone using Loan expects to get paid when they all do the same common thing 3. With the expectation of profit - Laundering the investment gains through interest earned and skimming is the novel argument being constructed here 4. To be derived from the efforts of others - If you aren't doing any work and you're getting paid, that's the effort of others, and depositing the coin doesn't count as work So I expect the SEC to win using a "money laundering" interpretation, and they'd rather not explain that to Coinbase yet. Coinbase is trying to money launder the profits of their investments through an "interest rate" for all "depositors", but that's not likely to stand up in a court of law. If they're thinking ahead far enough in political strategy terms, this product offering is bait for an eventual SEC settlement that incorporates terms that legitimize Bitcoin and destroy their competitors. I hope the SEC doesn't take the bait and just convicts them of offering an illegal/unregistered/whatever investment opportunity. It'll be interesting to see if the SEC argues that it doesn't matter whether Bitcoin is a currency for the sake of Howey, since doing this with an investment opportunity derived somehow from Beanie Babies would end up being illegal in the same way, even if the market didn't exist at all. (I am not your lawyer, internet forum posts are not legal advice, etc.)
- rootsudo 5y ago100% This. It's sad, but whomever calls another sketchy first, sets the optics.