4 ms·
Once again, using the private platform argument here: YouTube (owned by Google) reserves the right to terminate and de-platform anyone's account who has been in
by rvz 5y ago
Once again, using the private platform argument here: YouTube (owned by Google) reserves the right to terminate and de-platform anyone's account who has been in violation of YouTube's guidelines and terms of service.
You can criticise, protest, appeal, scream or throw a tantrum about it, etc but you should finally see that this can happen to anyone sitting on private platforms like YouTube.
YouTube will never change and it will only get worse.
- gmemstr 5y agoThat's not the issue here. The issue here is letting automated systems having final say on such destructive actions as terminating an account entirely, with no concrete way to appeal. From what I am aware of, few channels wrongfully suspended get reinstated through support but rather through public outcry on the likes of Twitter.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI don't think that's in disagreement with the parent. Whatever means YouTube uses to determine who to drop and who to keep is irrelevant because the point is that if you host content on someone else's servers you are giving them control.
- segfaultbuserr 5y agoI don't think so. The original comment says that YouTube has: > the right to terminate and de-platform anyone's account who has been in violation of YouTube's guidelines and terms of service. The problem here is letting automated systems, with a history of producing false-positives for content that didn't violate the Guidelines or ToS, having final say on account termination, with no concrete way to appeal - To me this is a fair criticism. If the original comment says "the right to arbitrarily terminate and de-platform anyone's account", then I'll say that you have a point.
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoThere is apparently a large contingent of people on this site holding the belief that if your private platform is large then the government should step in to force you to host things you don't want to host. It's kinda funny, because it's effectively saying that they want to nationalize tech companies for being successful.
- throwawaylinux 5y agoNo that's not true, there is a vast difference between regulation on business practices like this and nationalization.
- Gollapalli 5y agoIf you think about it, publicly traded companies are precisely that: nationalized. They exist as partly as government fiat, and partly of managerial control, but not as property. They are, by necessity, of somewhat unknowable, and almost always unaccountable ownership, ownership so diffuse it may be regarded as a generally representative subset of and equivalent to the general public. As such, can any public company be regarded as private? Or treated as private? Their ownership is public, and no individual, or small, knowable, and generally convenable group of people can say: these are our servers. On the contrary, a group of people equivalent to the general public, a subset of them in fact public or pseudo-public institutions (pension funds, university endowments), are the owners. As such, public institutions should very much be treated as public entities. After all, it is the general public which owns them.
- WhyNotHugo 5y agoPublicly traded companies have a main goal of making profits for shareholders. This seldom aligns with the public's interest. For many (most?) companies, only the rich have any voting power, whereas the majority of the population just has to follow along. Publicly traded companies are like a democracy where you get more votes the more money you have. The implication here is that your voice/needs are only important if you're rich, and are unimportant if you're average or poor (which kind of explains why the US is the way it is).
- _null_ 5y ago>YouTube will never change and it will only get worse. Private entities can be swayed by their customer's demands. Not saying that YT _will_ be swayed, just that this sort of creator outrage has a place in the market system, and "throwing a tantrum" over their bad behavior doesn't always have to be met with "private entities can do whatever they want!"
- mrkstu 5y agoThat actually sounds like a good test for monopoly status- do you have to worry about what your customers want/desire or are you so entrenched that you don’t care?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- WhyNotHugo 5y agoNot sure why this guy is getting downvoted. I wish he were wrong, because he's saying sucks, but he's just telling the hard truth the way it is. YouTube won't change, yet we continue using it as if it didn't have the track record it does.
- pessimizer 5y ago> the private platform argument No part of what you said is an argument. Do private platforms have unlimited latitude? If not, what are the underlying philosophies underlying current limitations, and can those be seen to imply that other limitations should be made? Should private platforms have unlimited latitude? Those are discussions that could be had. "Private things are allowed to do whatever they want" is not only a thought-terminating cliché that avoids all ethical or tactical judgement, but a simple falsehood.
- rvz 5y ago> Do private platforms have unlimited latitude? Who is arguing that? No need to create a straw-man argument. > "Private things are allowed to do whatever they want" Who are you quoting here? So YouTube (owned by Google) doesn't reserve the right to terminate and de-platform anyone's account who has been in violation of YouTube's guidelines and terms of service? I already said the offended users can appeal, didn't I? I'm just saying that not only this can happen to anyone, but YouTube (Google Inc.) will not change and we'll see more of this regardless if it is automated or not.
- pessimizer 5y agoI'm not saying that you're arguing anything. > Who are you quoting here? Nobody. But if the fact that Google reserves the right to ban people for reasons described in its ToS is an argument for something, I'd like to know what else it could be an argument for. Who cares what Google reserves? edit: I'm being sloppy. "Google reserved the right to delete for this reason," and "private things that reserve rights get them", and "Google is private" equals "Google gains this right." This would be an argument you could make. However, you haven't made this argument. Are you making an argument about choosing youtube? I might be mistaking a pragmatic observation for a political/legal discussion.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoI'm out of the loop- what rules were broken?
- grey_earthling 5y agoI hope cases like this lead more people to understand that proprietors of private services do have so much control (even if they often wield it soberly), and persuade them to consider decentralised or protocol-based open alternatives. As ever, Tony Benn's five questions are instructive: “what power do you have; where did you get it; in whose interests do you exercise it; to whom are you accountable; and, how can we get rid of you?” => https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1998-11-16/debates/db35bbc5-17ba-4097-bcec-b18ba5057ad7/EuropeanParliamentaryElectionsBill#contribution-6dbb256d-47c3-484c-b7be-8e3d466aaa0a https://hansard.parliament.uk/commons/1998-11-16/debates/db3...
- maccolgan 5y agoPrivate platforms can indeed do whatever they want, but I think there's a discussion to be had about whether what they are doing is right or wrong...