5 ms·
Atlassian products are vast, integrated, and support all the crazy draconian processes that every insane project manager wants to implement. You can't easily d
by cogman10 5y ago
Atlassian products are vast, integrated, and support all the crazy draconian processes that every insane project manager wants to implement.
You can't easily dump Jira if you are using Jira, confluence, bitbucket, and whatever their CI/CD product is called (bamboo?)
- nerdponx 5y agoHow many PMs actually use those features? In my organization, for example, I don't see any reason why we should prefer Atlassian over Taiga, other than familiarity and inertia.
- riffraff 5y agoThere's a ton of things you can do in Jira, and different organizations use different things. It's like excel or word, in that sense.
- yourapostasy 5y ago> How many PMs actually use those features? It isn't the set of features that makes them sticky. It is the 10% of features the lead PM can't live without, and the slightly-overlapping-but-different 10% of features the team PM's can't live without, and the slightly-overlapping-but-different 10% of features the developers can't live without, and the roll-up report features the leadership team can't live without... There has been some research into this phenomena [1]. I'm not aware of a handy term for the phenomena, would surely appreciate someone pointing me to it, and the industry recognizing it and building for it, though. Internally in my head I call it "multiplexing feature sets". Though I never say that aloud and just give the long-winded explanation if I have to bring it up in meetings. > ...I don't see any reason why we should prefer Atlassian over Taiga, other than familiarity and inertia. In large-organization dynamics, never underestimate the familiarity and inertia factors. I regularly see vendors screw this up so badly. Account management teams of even large organization vendors (so they should be taking action upon this, but apparently are not) regularly have no clue what kind of massive red flag it takes to push their decade(s)-entrenched product from "man we wish this could be better" to "you really need to fix this, or we need to start looking elsewhere". How do you tell when a customer is just kvetching and presenting empty threats, or is laying it on the line to you? Easy: the customer is happy to share with you specific details of how the product shortcomings/defects are impacting line of business processes and the business impact (ask for this under the cover of learning what the critical business impact is so your support teams can devise the most appropriate tactical technical solution for immediate partial/total relief), and is eager for live working sessions with the customer's engineers. And understand this: rarely will a customer reveal they have switched away until it is practically finished. They want to maintain what little interim support quality they have left, until they can step off. If your account management practices engage "all hands on deck" priority support when you get wind of a competitor in the wheelhouse, then you've lost before you even started. That's why the reveal is always a shock to vendors, and always a done deal when it is shared. The time to understand that your product and product support consumption experience for a particular set of customer needs is horribly broken is when you notice a customer requesting product support leadership engagement more than 2-3 times in a year. If you aren't tracking those engagement touch points, then I guarantee you are losing license sales. They just don't show up in the sales metrics. [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877705817302709 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187770581...
- sufyanadam 5y agoWhat are these features that PMs can't live without, that they don't get with an alternative such as, say, Pivotal Tracker?
- Aeolun 5y agoI think that the larger and more dystopian organisations cannot do better than Jira to fulfill their needs.
- nicoburns 5y agoClubhouse (soon to be renamed Shortcut) covers the first two. Github covers the latter two. It's easier to switch than ever.
- Cederfjard 5y ago> Clubhouse (soon to be renamed Shortcut) covers the first two. Even taking the following into account? >> Atlassian products are vast, integrated, and support all the crazy draconian processes that every insane project manager wants to implement.
- nicoburns 5y agoWell if your organisation wants crappy project management tools and processes then there's nothing to be done. But there are plenty of alternatives out there for those who seek them.
- rtpg 5y agoIt is actually possible to want bespoke tools to do certain things. And honestly? Confluence is slow, but at least it has all the features I could want and it works. People are like”use the shiny thing” forgetting the existing thing has, you know, stuff I actually use.
- Cederfjard 5y agoThanks, I got you. But you didn’t really address the point of the person you responded to, then, which was that part of why this space hasn’t been disrupted to a larger degree is that Atlassian products are entrenched in many companies, and that a lot of people do want that complexity (disagree with that as you or I might).
- gurkendoktor 5y ago> ... and that a lot of people do want that complexity (disagree with that as you or I might). As much as I love to hate Atlassian, I feel like complaining about Atlassian is like techies complaining about management in general. Every single anecdote is both terrible and true, but it's not quite as easy as it seems to do it better.
- pidminusone 5y agoGitLab has wikis, CI/CD and sprint / issue / project management features. We use it at $DAY_JOB and while not perfect it's a pretty great offering.
- closeparen 5y agoNot just product managers. All kinds of enterprise processes decompose nicely into tickets. Arbitrary workflows, transitions, validations, custom fields, filters, and reports make it one of the most successful “no code” tools behind Excel, and then the REST API is comprehensive and well documented. At my company JIRA bots are compelling and cheap alternatives to new web UIs for internal tooling needs, surprisingly often.