7 ms·
The Shareholder Value Myth (2013)
- roenxi 5y agoThe question is different to what the article is implying. The broad social question is that of the nature of ownership. What does it mean for shareholders to 'own' a company? It doesn't mean literally anything, because the company is subordinate to the law. So the question is what owners can do within that framework. The core of the capitalist argument is it doesn't matter what Lynn A. Stout, I or a company's board thinks the shareholders want. The shareholders just need the tools to replace the board when they wish, and the rest will sort itself out.
- enkid 5y agoThe article literally says shareholders do not legally own the company according to the law, they just have a contract with it. The company owns itself.
- marcosdumay 5y agoWell, if the focus on shareholder value harms shareholder value, that's a failure of management practices, not of the focus. The focus itself is ideological by nature, and can not be right or wrong.
- enkid 5y agoIt's about the specific actions, such as executive incentives and altering stock structure based in the ideology of "maximizing shareholder value." The "ideology" should lead to some specific actions based on the logic of what you are trying to maximize (mostly stock price), but they actions don't work, so we have to look for some other "ideology" that operates better.
- marcosdumay 5y agoIf the ideology leads to actions that harm its own goals, that's because you are acting based on a wrong theory. You can try to proxy it over the goals of another ideology, and since your first theory was wrong, it may get you better results, but changing your ideology to improve its goals isn't a thing. But anyway, improving your theory normally leads to better results on practice. Notice that I'm not saying it's a good ideology. Personally, I highly disagree with it, but the article is misrepresenting the problem it talks about.
- refurb 5y agoThis was always my take. If shareholders are only focused on the short term then the company should as well. If shareholders are focused on long term but company on short term then the shareholders should be pissed. I mean it’s not like there is a right way and wrong way to run a company. The people that fund the venture should have a say it how it’s run?
- larrydag 5y agoShareholder Value has been slowly changed as a focus for a while now. This article gives Steve Jobs as an example of focusing on the customer. https://hbr.org/2011/10/steve-jobs-and-the-purpose-of https://hbr.org/2011/10/steve-jobs-and-the-purpose-of
- amin 5y agoNearly every long term shareholder understands that, in order to create shareholder value, the company needs to prioritize delighting customers over and over again first and foremost.
- simonh 5y agoKind of. I wouldn't describe Ryanair as having ever delighted me as a customer. They offer fantastic value, so I suppose you could say I was 'delighted' at not having to pay more, but that comes with a significant dose of resignation at the stress I'm going to go through.
- Filligree 5y agoI fully refuse to fly with them, no matter what. Once was enough. I wouldn’t say they’ve delighted, but they certainly impressed.
- heavenlyblue 5y agoUhm. I come from a pretty poor country. When I was a student I would fly Ryanair because otherwise I would just not fly. Ryanair provided me with a service that would otherwise be not available to me at all if it was not making be nervous. So it provides services to a bunch of poor people who are probably _used_ to being nervous anyway in other situations. "Refuse to fly with them". Would you refuse to fly at all if you could not afford alternatives?
- Ma8ee 5y agoI refuse to fly at all nowadays. Even on a relatively short flight, I would be responsible for more greenhouse gases than all my other consumption and transports for several months give rise to.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIn case you live in an US style suburb detached single family home lifestyle, I feel like suburb living contributes far more greenhouse gases than a short flight, since living in dense communities reduces how far all mass has to move, and suburb living increases how far all mass has to move.
- xcdfgvd 5y ago>Shareholders are suffering their worst investment returns since the Great Depression This aged horribly. The S&P 500 has increased an average of ~15% per year since the article was published. That's more than twice the average over the last century.
- simonh 5y agoThat doesn't take into account the roughly 50% churn rate per decade in the S&P 500. The companies that were in the S&P 500 in 2013 did not all benefit from and average 15% stock price increase, not even close. The point was that, according to the research, publicly listed companies following the shareholder value strategy did not perform significantly better than those which didn't. The historical performance of the index as a whole will vary significantly depending on when you do the analysis, but comparing the relative performance of companies over a sufficiently long enough period is reasonable regardless of when you do it.
- xcdfgvd 5y agoThe companies didn't benefit, but the shareholders did. Churn rate is indicative of a competitive and healthy economy. Removal doesn't necessarily imply failure or stagnation; mere under performance is sufficient for removal. Companies that are removed might even see their average performance regress upwards: https://finance.yahoo.com/news/the-company-tesla-booted-from-the-sp-500-is-outperforming-it-over-50-202435898.html https://finance.yahoo.com/news/the-company-tesla-booted-from...
- simonh 5y agoI'm not saying churn is a bad thing per se, I'm saying it renders any naive usage of the S&P as a proxy for company returns introduces a huge dollop of survivorship bias. You're adding up all the increased returns of the companies that did well and culling out any influence on the stats from companies that did sufficiently poorly, which is about half of the companies.
- 5y ago
- streamofdigits 5y agoBoth words in "shareholder value" are deeply problematic. Who is the "shareholder"? The working person toiling away today and hopping to strike a contract with society (via insurance/pension investments) to have some support and protection during old age? Or the army of intermediaries helpfully "managing" his/her contract till there is nothing of it left? And what is "value", or rather "who's values"? Is that the same person as above? What does the average person thing of superior financial returns that are at explicitly at the expense of environment and society? Friedman, of "the business of business is profit" fame, is throwing a party at his grave: "Goddam Nobel-granting suckers: I never told them that this construct will never work if their society is run as if morally bankrupt and, of course, they would never admit it being so themselves."
- gruez 5y ago>Who is the "shareholder"? From wikipedia: A shareholder (also known as stockholder) is an individual or institution (including a corporation) that legally owns one or more shares of the share capital of a public or private corporation. >And what is "value" From wikipedia: The term "shareholder value", sometimes abbreviated to "SV",[1] can be used to refer to: * The market capitalization of a company; * The concept that the primary goal for a company is to increase the wealth of its shareholders (owners) by paying dividends and/or causing the stock price to increase (i.e. the Friedman doctrine introduced in 1970); * The more specific concept that planned actions by management and the returns to shareholders should outperform certain bench-marks such as the cost of capital concept. In essence, the idea that shareholders' money should be used to earn a higher return than they could earn themselves by investing in other assets having the same amount of risk. The term in this sense was introduced by Alfred Rappaport in 1986.[2] > or rather "who's values"? the word that came before it: "shareholder"
- streamofdigits 5y agosee above my clarification. parroting definitions that were questionable already back in 1970 will not get us to any agreeable future
- rmah 5y ago