3 ms·
Of course we are, this too shall pass. There is a constant struggle to keep things afloat, people seem to forget that at times, especially the rent seeking clas
by mikewarot 5y ago
Of course we are, this too shall pass. There is a constant struggle to keep things afloat, people seem to forget that at times, especially the rent seeking class who place little to no value on infrastructure, both physical and societal.
If we get another FDR style reset, things should be good for a generation or two, if not... the horrors of history will rhyme once again.
Edit/Update: The New Deal provided a social safety net which greatly relieve the inequality that ripped apart Germany and other countries.
It also provided the infrastructure that just happened to make it much easier to out-manufacture the rest of the world in WWII, and benefitted society for decades later.
- TheBlight 5y agoFDR's initiative didn't provide any reset. WW2 was responsible for that.
- ncphil 5y agoAre you really so sure of that? I'm old enough to have known a lot of people who lived through the Depression _because_ of FDR's programs. Whether the New Deal alone could have saved the country is literally academic to the tens of millions who were saved by jobs in the CWA, WPA and CCC, or the relief provided by the FSA, SSA and economic aid to businesses under the NIRA. It seems unusually cold hearted for any historian or economist to ignore the tremendous suffering those measures spared so many, just because they didn't meet some theoretical threshold for full recovery.
- TheBlight 5y agoYes, I'm sure.
- timbit42 5y agoSince you provided no proof, you can be ignored.
- TheBlight 5y agoI don't have time to teach remedial U.S. history. You can find charts that clearly indicate the phenomenon here (for ones which show pre-WW2 data): https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ https://wtfhappenedin1971.com/ Probably the best chart: https://wtfhappenedin1971home.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/img_0658-1.jpg https://wtfhappenedin1971home.files.wordpress.com/2020/06/im...
- ineedasername 5y agoThe two are not mutually exclusive: FDR put the US on the path to active assistance & becoming one of the allied powers. It is also a path that might have been impossible if not for the social & jobs programs keeping people afloat in the years before that. A more complete collapse might have rendered the US too damaged to focus any effort outside of itself. As it was, many people opposed entering the war on precisely those grounds-- that the US should deal with its own internal problems rather than those a continent away. FDR plowed through those objections, and incidentally sparked the economic recovery fueled by massive industrial mobilization. Whether or not you agree with FDR's handling of the Great Depression, you cannot separate that from the course of events that shaped the outcomes of WW II (both good and bad)
- Aeolun 5y agoWW3 then? I’d rather attribute it to FDR I think.
- furyg3 5y agoYes, the 'great levelers' which seriously reduced income inequality were the Plague, the Black Death, and the two World Wars. https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/04/19/history-suggests-there-is-a-way-to-lower-inequality-but-youre-not-going-to-like-it/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/news/wonk/wp/2017/04/19/histo... https://read.amazon.com/kp/embed?asin=B01M34NBLZ&preview=newtab&linkCode=kpe&ref_=cm_sw_r_kb_dp_j049ybF13VJQ1&tag=thewaspos09-20&reshareId=BYRN0BM27QS3G914JM4S&reshareChannel=system https://read.amazon.com/kp/embed?asin=B01M34NBLZ&preview=new...
- grecy 5y ago> this too shall pass As long as the world remains human habitable, I agree with you. If even 10% of the landmass where humans currently live becomes uninhabitable due to the impacts of climate change like flood, heat, drought, stable society as we've know for ~50 years has little chance. Hundreds of millions of people will have no place to live, no food, and no water. The only possible outcome would be immense upheaval, violence and another world war.
- esarbe 5y agoYou are absolutely correct. What amazes me is people's ability to put their fingers into their ears and go "Lalala, I'm not hearing you. I'm not seeing the problem, lalala!" Every rational observer should be able see the calamity we're headed for. I guess even the prospect of /possible/ having to give up /some/ comfort is enough for most people to just stop thinking and retreat into the ivory towers of wishful thinking. "There's nothing wrong with our current societal setup. It's going good for me, isn't it? And of course there will be a magical mystery technology that will save us all." We're so fucked.
- runarberg 5y agoThere is another possibility: Governments lift their hostile immigration policies, and grant refugees a place in their society. Sure there will be tension, but a major upheaval and wars can absolutely be avoided if governments act humanely.
- grecy 5y agoWhat you describe would certainly be nice, though the realist in my simply can't believe it will ever happen. Every country on earth is going to suffer and struggle, and I find it impossible to believe any government would welcome millions more people who are struggling when their own system will already be stretched to breaking point. Governments have not done so in the past for civil war, natural disasters, humanitarian crises, genocide and much worse.
- rickdangerous1 5y agoMany parts of the world are very sparsely populated. The north American continent alone would easily double or triple its current population. We'd have to be smart about it, think carefully where we put new cities etc so that we hedge against climate change... it would be easily doable. Africa too, is capable of supporting a much higher population IF we want to get really serious about doing so.