5 ms·
Why people eat horse dewormer
- gdubs 5y agoThere’s a kind of parallel history of why people ended up taking ivermectin, which was The Dark Horse podcast with Brett Weinstein. On the show they talked extensively about their theory that ivermectin was an effective prophylactic against Covid-19, but because the drug was out of patent, pharmaceutical companies had not interest in slowing down the vaccines. (Their words, not mine.) IIRC some countries actually rolled out ivermectin at scale, but AFAIK, the studies have all been disappointing in terms of its effectiveness. One problem with everyone calling it horse dewormer and calling people stupid, is there seems to be a lot of people out there who consider themselves independent thinkers, have read a lot about the history of ivermectin, and see this kind of poking-fun as dishonest (and I would think probably hardening their views that there’s a manufacturing of consent happening.) I’m vaccinated — I just like to listen to lots of podcasts, read different people’s takes. FWIW, it doesn’t seem like ivermectin does what Weinstein suggested — and he made some very bold claims. I also don’t think the shorthand of “horse dewormers” is helping reach anyone who’s uneasy about the vaccines. But, that’s just my lay-person opinion.
- analog31 5y agoWhat I wonder is how absurd does this stuff have to get before we can no longer maintain the posture of political correctness with a straight face?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- input_sh 5y ago> IIRC some countries actually rolled out ivermectin at scale, but AFAIK, the studies have all been disappointing in terms of its effectiveness. Oh it's even worse than that. Argentinian study concluded that those who received ivermectin over placebo ended up on a respirator sooner[0]: > The mean time from study enrollment to invasive mechanical ventilatory support (MVS) was 5.25 days (SD ± 1.71) in ivermectin group and 10 days (SD ± 2) in placebo group, (p = 0.019). [0] https://bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s12879-021-06348-5 https://bmcinfectdis.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s128...
- bigbillheck 5y ago> but because the drug was out of patent, pharmaceutical companies had not interest in slowing down the vaccines. This is a thing that often gets claimed, but there's a special three-year "New Clinical Investigation Exclusivity" that's available. (https://www.fda.gov/media/135234/download https://www.fda.gov/media/135234/download p15)
- dariusj18 5y agoI agree that people seem to be too focused on the Horse part given that it is approved for and used by humans. Same thing with Ketamine though and it is still mostly referred to as a Horse tranquillizer. I think at it's core though I think the derogatory nature is similar to making fun of the drunk asshole who ate dog food at a party. It's not deemed fit for human consumption, and sure the manufacturer isn't intentionally trying to poison your dog with bad food, but it still wouldn't have the same level of quality control.
- skinkestek 5y ago> There’s a kind of parallel history of why people ended up taking ivermectin, which was The Dark Horse podcast with Brett Weinstein. Worth mentioning: those guys on that podcast were very positive to the vaccine, they only said that it was a shame that health authorities wouldn't use both. I tried pointing it out to the friend of me who sent it. It didn't work. He is still against Covid-19 vaccines. (I'm not taking a position right here and now, except that I find it weird that my anti-covid-vaccination friend can listen to only half of what is said in that podcast)
- SOLAR_FIELDS 5y agoI also agree that calling it “horse dewormer” is a pretty lazy attempt to denigrate people and doesn’t really do much to reach out in a mature or effective way. Regardless of its effectiveness for COVID, ivermectin has been a safe, commonly prescribed anti parasite drug for humans since the early 1970’s. It was also championed early on as a possible prophylactic and treatment option by reputable doctors, most notably Dr. Paul Marik of EVMS who has treated thousands of COVID patients. If you googled “EVMS COVID protocol” as late as May of this year you were treated to a long form PDF about inpatient and outpatient care authored by Marik claiming that there was significant benefit to using ivermectin to treat COVID. I tried to find the document to link here and I noticed that the old one referencing ivermectin has been conspicuously removed sometime in the last few months. So it seems like the lesson here is that once bad information gets out it’s really hard to change it. It’s not like this trend started by Dr. Oz or unqualified Youtubers or as some uncoordinated misinformation campaign. Actual qualified doctors that we should be listening to were claiming for a long time that it could help people. And now that we know that’s not the case it’s really hard to take that back.
- nradov 5y agoWe don't know that that's not the case. There have been many studies so far, some of which showed significant positive results and others which showed no benefit. The science remains unclear. That's why the NIH has prioritized ivermectin for a large scale clinical trial. https://www.nih.gov/research-training/medical-research-initiatives/activ/covid-19-therapeutics-prioritized-testing-clinical-trials#activ6 https://www.nih.gov/research-training/medical-research-initi...
- sojournerc 5y agoA recent Israeli study showed effectiveness. Of course that was ivermectin made for humans and administered by a doctor. https://m.jpost.com/health-science/israeli-scientist-says-covid-19-could-be-treated-for-under-1day-675612 https://m.jpost.com/health-science/israeli-scientist-says-co...
- nradov 5y agoA recent small Lebanese clinical trial also showed effectiveness. Naturally the doctors administered the human formulation, not veterinary. https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4915/13/6/989 https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4915/13/6/989
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoI think India pushed it pretty hard. And Japan is now, so that will be interesting to see. Is the Ivermectin in the horse product different from the human version? Or does the FDA just have higher standards for animal v human products and no one knows if the line making the horse product is clean and free of things like benzene (industrial solvent, liquid cancer, that sometimes makes it into products, sunscreen most recently)?
- nradov 5y agoThe molecule is the same in all formulations. The FDA also has high standards for veterinary products. Most likely idiots are just taking way too much. With medicine some people have the idea that if a little bit is good then more must be better. (I am not recommending that anyone take medication for unapproved purposes.)
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoMakes sense. That syringe on the horse paste is insane anyone would trust that. But if you were to measure a sub-gram amount on a good scale, that seems a lot safer than taking almost any recreational drug besides pot.
- meheleventyone 5y ago
- akamaka 5y agoIs there a way to read the entire thread without logging in, or has Twitter completely blocked public access now?
- xwdv 5y agoWhy do people eat horse dewormer? Mostly because people are desperate to do anything that doesn’t involve taking an actual vaccine.
- farmerstan 5y agoI’ve been following ivermectin since about June 2020. I’m still not convinced and haven’t taken it because there have no home run studies as far as I’ve been concerned, but the sheer absurd propaganda calling it horse dewormer is really suspicious as hell. It’s one of the safest drugs known to man. Literally billions of doses have been given to humans in poor countries. If you take the animal version, of course you would get sick just like taking the animal version of antibiotics. The key thing to remember is that ivermectin has more positive outcomes from trials (50+) than remdesivir ever did. In fact remdesivir doesn’t even appear to work, and yet remdesivir was approved after a single positive trial. And I purchased Gilead stock in 2020 because of remdesivir potential but it is clear by now it doesn’t work. All the media bashing of ivermectin as “horse dewormer” when remdesivir has no such ire but is costing us billions is really really suspicious. It reeks of when the media was bashing the lab leak theory which was ultimately wrong.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThe thread is talking literally about taking the product designed for horses because there is too much demand for the doctors who are willing to prescribe human versions.
- farmerstan 5y agoBut that isn’t the overall propaganda in the media. The media is painting it as only an animal dewormer. Look at the discourse around Joe Rogan. One of the drugs he took was ivermectin. That’s all the media talks about and they call it horse dewormer when it was prescribed by a doctor. They don’t mention monoclonal antibodies or z-pak or drip vitamins. The propaganda is crazy. And yes he is a fool for not getting vaccinated. But once he got covid and he was getting worse he took every single drug he could.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThen you should make that clear in your post, since this thread is very very specifically about a veterinary product for horses and it is 100% reasonable to use this title. This thread is doing precisely the thing you are expecting of the media.
- savant_penguin 5y agoCalling it a horse dewomer is mostly political babble. I've asked a physician about it and the answer as to why they were being taken was mostly because there was some faint evidence that it works and the likelihood of side effects weren't that high compared to covid. To make it abundantly clear, I took the vaccine and I think you should too, but calling it horse dewomer is pure politics
- SV_BubbleTime 5y agoI get what you’re saying, but… You are right; calling Ivermectin a horse dewormer is MOSTLY polarization. It’s approved for humans. There are also a ton of off label uses for OTCs and that has always been OK and not ridiculed. We’ve moved on to polarizing everything so why not, “the other side” is always full of idiots, right? Side note: anyone that does recreational drugs has about no room to talk on this topic. In this case, he alternates between generally talking about the drug, and talking about the actual horse paste product. Which seems to be the exact same drug, but with some paste and not FDA approved. I wouldn’t, but the horse paste is probably safe if you use a scale to measure the sub-gram amount needed for a human, but who knows!? There could be benzene and garbage in there and no one would know, it’s not intended for humans. I think it’s all a bit ridiculous. And while people will hate what you said, it has a grain of truth in most cases when mocking people who are interested in Ivermectin, just to mock and belittle them.
- EamonnMR 5y agoPeople are literally purchasing it at a feed and supply store with a picture of a horse on it and a label that indicates that it is meant for horse use. Regardless of the active ingredient, that is unusual behavior and rightly garnered attention.
- ksaj 5y agoExactly. That's why whenever ivermectin shows up in the news, it's because someone has taken so much of it that it made them ill. A 900 pound animal dose for a 150 pound human is quite a tall order.
- 5y ago
- throwaway210222 5y agoVaccines have completed eliminated smallpox and rinderpest, (which infects cattle) and we as close as can be to eradicating polio (500 cases a year). Additionally vaccines have pretty much wiped out diphtheria, bacterial influenza, measles, mumps, rubella, and tetanus. So, no there is absolutely no rational reason to not take any of the double-blind tested vaccines. At this point it is just a cult.
- KETpXDDzR 5y agoAny cult big enough is a religion, right?
- throwaway210222 5y agoThe other way around.
- josephcsible 5y agoAren't the vaccines against those other diseases effective enough that once you get vaccinated, you don't need to worry about catching the disease anymore, and don't have to do things like wear masks too afterwards?
- 15155 5y agoHow many of those specific vaccines were leaky or had statistically significant escape metrics?
- logicalmonster 5y agoI find the more interesting question here to be why is a legitimate medical drug that has been given to humans for legitimate uses only labeled as a horse dewormer? For what it’s worth, I don’t know if ivermectin is effective against covid, but testing out a cheap drug that some doctors make arguments for seems like a smart risk-management decision.
- Jochim 5y agoI mean the FDA explains exactly why on their website[0]. Livestock are much bigger than humans meaning the medication has a much higher dosage and even if the active ingredient is the same the delivery mechanism doesn't have to be, which is why we have so many morons ending up in hospital. The real tragedy in all of this is that these idiots are killing innocent people by overwhelming hospital resources. https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/why-you-should-not-use-ivermectin-treat-or-prevent-covid-19 https://www.fda.gov/consumers/consumer-updates/why-you-shoul...
- logicalmonster 5y agoThe FDA would be making a very reasonable point about Ivermectin if they weren't the barrier in place preventing people from acquiring the version of the product meant for humans in the first place. They can't just block people from acquiring normal human doses and then smugly decry people trying to acquire it through other means. There should be much stronger "Right To Try" provisions in medicine to allow people the right to try drugs to cure them of disease and for society to gain information on its effectiveness. My Body, My Choice. This is a simple risk-management decision. Ivermectin is cheap and safe in human sized doses. If Ivermectin doesn't work: that would suck, but we'd at least eliminate one potential cure and can try other things. If Ivermectin does work: great, that means this thing would be over. What the hell do we have to lose other billions in Big Pharma profits? > The real tragedy in all of this is that these idiots are killing innocent people by overwhelming hospital resources. Which is it this week: are hospitals bursting at the seams with Covid patients or Ivermectin overdoses? I can't remember anymore, not that I see any flooded hospitals anyway.