16 ms·
The problem here is similar to what happens with the War on Terror. 1) It is noted that governments could, in theory, be spying on everything. Widely dismissed
by roenxi 5y ago
The problem here is similar to what happens with the War on Terror.
1) It is noted that governments could, in theory, be spying on everything. Widely dismissed as silly.
2) There is a trigger event (eg, 9/11). Inside government, a standard slips. They start spying on everything.
3) Years later it becomes public knowledge. It is too hard to monitor what is going on now though, so it is difficult to tell who specifically should be outraged about what.
4) The situation persists because it is convenient to the people in charge.
5) (TBD) It gets turned on political dissidents. I'm expecting everyone will agree on this point in 5 or so years, at the moment that is probably maybe more a partisan observation.
Apple's partnering up will follow the same pattern. There just isn't enough transparency about what closed source software does.
- onethought 5y agoI am really missing something in this whole thing. Everyone is already partnered with gov. Gov have access to all the servers. So that doesn’t explain this outrage, Microsoft, google, Apple will all comply with warrants asking access to cloud stored data. The outrage was: Apple were spying ON the device. But then they explained, they were hash matching so they didn’t need to give unfettered access to your cloud data. The device doesn’t notify police, it has protections from false positives and is no MORE access than any company already has. This seems like outrage with no substance behind it. Gmail scans your mail, Facebook your messages (on and off device). Why is Apple suddenly terrible for doing something that seems to honestly improve the situation not make it worse?
- avidiax 5y ago> no MORE access than any company already has Yes, Google and Apple are both capable of writing code to scan your device for anything. Only Apple (to our knowledge) has written this code. It's a distinction with meaning. For the moment, yes, they are only scanning things that will eventually be stored on their servers. It's just another minor policy change to scan things that you are keeping locally. My hope is that they will delay this until they can announce E2EE for iCloud, which would then at least be give and take on privacy, potentially a net win. As it stands, this is a net loss.
- simion314 5y agoImagine you use some OS, say Ubuntu or Windows and the company behind it canonical/Microsoft creates an application that scans your files for illegal shit and reports you to the government. This application is optional you download and install it if you want it. Who in the right mind would download and install such an application that runs in background , uses your resources and reports you to the police, no advantages for you. So the equation is clear, the user has nothing to gain, a lot to lose if the system triggers and the user also needs to blindly trust(no way to check the hashes or the binaries) that the system will not be abused. If you are a person that strongly thinks Apple should handle CSAM then ask them why they did nothing until now? They collaborate with FBI/NSA on other stuff.
- GeekyBear 5y ago> Imagine you use some OS, say Ubuntu or Windows and the company behind it canonical/Microsoft creates an application that scans your files for illegal shit and reports you to the government. You don't have to imagine it. This has literally been happening for the past decade. >The system that scans cloud drives for illegal images was created by Microsoft and Dartmouth College and donated to NCMEC. The organization creates signatures of the worst known images of child pornography, approximately 16,000 files at present. These file signatures are given to service providers who then try to match them to user files in order to prevent further distribution of the images themselves, a Microsoft spokesperson told NBC News. (Microsoft implemented image-matching technology in its own services, such as Bing and SkyDrive.) https://www.nbcnews.com/technolog/your-cloud-drive-really-private-not-according-fine-print-1c8881731 https://www.nbcnews.com/technolog/your-cloud-drive-really-pr... Google has been scanning everything in your account for the past decade as well. >a man [was] arrested on child pornography charges, after Google tipped off authorities about illegal images found in the Houston suspect's Gmail account https://techcrunch.com/2014/08/06/why-the-gmail-scan-that-led-to-a-mans-arrest-for-child-porn-was-not-a-privacy-violation/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/08/06/why-the-gmail-scan-that-le... Apple will only scan photos you post to iCloud Photos, and their system is set up in such a way that they cant see the scan results until a threshold of 30 matches is met, to protect you from being flagged to the government for a few false positives. (They do have a human verify there is a real issue, and that you haven't just somehow posted more than 30 false positives to iCloud) Google and Microsoft's systems have no such protection. Anyone who can issue a subpoena can maliciously use false positive data against you. We've seen the data trove companies like Google retain used to imprison innocent people before. >Innocent man, 23, sues Arizona police for $1.5million after being arrested for murder and jailed for six days when Google's GPS tracker wrongly placed him at the scene of the 2018 crime https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7897319/Police-arrested-innocent-man-murder-using-Google-location-data.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-7897319/Police-arre...
- noptd 5y agoTo put it bluntly, because whataboutisms do not compose a valid argument for accepting a new client-side system with a high potential of abuse.
- onethought 5y agoThere is almost 0 potential for abuse… it’s scan workflow ends in a human verifying that it isn’t a false positive. Not whataboutism, the alternative to apples solution is companies openly scan your entire photo library. That’s what’s happening right now. People are upset because Apple suggested: “how about we only scan when we suspect there is something not right?”
- matheusmoreira 5y agoBecause it's my device, it belongs to me and should obey me instead of gigantic corporations or governments. I don't care about some government agenda trying to improve whatever situation. I want my computer out of it. They can go "honestly improve the situation" elsewhere, hopefully as far away from me as possible. And we don't need to provide any other justification either. They're the ones who need damn good reasons and warrants before stepping foot in my property.
- vbezhenar 5y agoDevice belongs to you, but software belongs to the Apple. If you want your device to fully belong to you, you need to find a device supporting software which you can control. Otherwise you're at corporation mercy when it comes to privacy and other sensitive topics.
- feanaro 5y agoI agree this is effectively how it is today in some countries, but I don't consider this an acceptable stance. Software cannot be exempted from normal rules of physical ownership of sold goods. You sold me a device, which also means you sold me the software within because the device is useless without it. The software is not separate from the device, it is the device. Of course, that doesn't mean I can do whatever I see fit with the software; I cannot redistribute it under my own terms. But insofar the actions I take with the software strictly pertain to my own usage of my own device, I should be allowed to do it. And it also means you (the company) shouldn't be able to do with the software installed on my device as you see fit.
- yunohn 5y ago> Otherwise you're at corporation mercy when it comes to privacy and other sensitive topics. Despite HN’s desire, the vast majority of touch points in our daily lives are NOT open source. I’d rather laws be setup to safeguard my privacy versus relying on “FOSS” as if that’s a panacea.
- summm 5y agoYour own device? That ship has sailed long ago, as you decided to buy it and not root/jailbreak it. You never had any power over that device.
- hypothesis 5y agoSo this is step 1 then and we’re basically waiting for an event for step 2, because “privacy-preserving” surveillance system is production ready at this point and is going to be deployed in near term. Just a minor update away from a ML-powered thought crime prevention as step 3.
- laurent92 5y agoSo… await elites making a big pedophile catch (perhaps recycling Epstein’s story, which gained a lot of popularity among the youths), and using it as a launchpad for “see, we needed an automatic iPhone search”.
- sharken 5y agoYou can either have privacy or surveillance, Apple is trying to sell the idea you can have both which is a false statement. Since Apple have been pushing privacy as a differentiator with Android, i can see their problem when they also want surveillance. The answer is simple: Drop all plans for surveillance also known as on-device scanning.
- ectopod 5y agoSadly, “privacy-preserving” surveillance is already a thing. After the Snowden revelations the NSA didn't stop collecting everyone's data, they just refined the legal justification. They claim that it isn't illegal surveillance if they don't look at the data. So if you become a person of interest they get a warrant and then trawl through your digital life since forever.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoThis. It literally happened to me yesterday. The internet was blocked altogether and one Sim card service was allowed after a long time so I did something interesting. I asked a friend in another country to log into an old reddit account, I dictated him the text I wanted to post and he pushed it. I had kept that reddit account dormant for over 7 months for this very purpose because I remember somehwere about reddit 90 days history policy or something. This is the level of threat I am looking at. I was willing to dictate PNG base54 character by character so that the other person could reconsititute it but they reopened internet the next day but this is the level of threat facing a casual internet user https://m.thewire.in/article/media/internet-shutdown-blocks-news-in-kashmir-geelani-death https://m.thewire.in/article/media/internet-shutdown-blocks-...
- geraltofrivia 5y agoI’m really sorry to know this. And I’d like to apologise for not being able to convince some of my close friends to not vote the fascists in, in the last national elections.
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoEh. You need a billion people to change their opinion. I am in a small minority which gets trampled on.
- C19is20 5y agoI see your words, but what are you exactly apologising for?
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agoThe upcoming mau Zedong or xi is the cow in charge of India. That is what he/she is apologising for. This person is saying they did not know in 2014 the country would crumble like this,
- colordrops 5y agoThe US government was spying on everything well before 9/11 [1]. This sort of surveillance has been happening since the dawn of civilization. It's imperative for elites that wish to stay in power. [1] https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/ECHELON
- gambiting 5y agoYes, and it's almost expected at this point. But a private corporation doing it voluntarily(apple really doesn't have to implement this, lots of articles on this point) is at least something we can discuss and hopefully vote with our wallets against. Can't do that against a government.
- noptd 5y agoExactly, and even if it's already occurring in some fashion, that doesn't mean we should sit idly by and allow it to get worse.
- colordrops 5y agoThat's the thing, is it really voluntary? I'm not sure if apple has as much leverage as everyone is thinking. The Chinese government certainly forces companies to do this sort of thing, and there is precedent in the US as well with national security letters and warrant canaries. AT&T has basically been an extension of the NSA, with tap rooms built into their centers, and I'm certain all kinds of things have been forced on companies using some sort of leverage behind the scenes.
- yunohn 5y ago> (TBD) It gets turned on political dissidents. This is not TBD. All the people who exposed this and similar coverups (Snowden, Assange, Manning) are being prosecuted by the USA.
- mdp2021 5y agoI think it meant "inactive dissidents" or "potentially one day active". Non-conformants. As is very, very frequent in history - today, with more instruments.
- quantum_solanum 5y agothis is also already happening. "If you Tweeted about BLM protests last yr, there's a good chance your Tweets were forwarded to the LAPD. Even if you don't live in LA." https://twitter.com/ShotOn35mm/status/1434203354696019971 https://twitter.com/ShotOn35mm/status/1434203354696019971 https://www.lataco.com/lapd-social-media-surveillance-protest/ https://www.lataco.com/lapd-social-media-surveillance-protes...
- busymom0 5y agoAssange is being punished by almost all western countries. Sweden had a big role in it too and so does UK. And Australia is doing absolutely nothing to prevent it from happening to their citizen.
- varjag 5y agoTo be fair the (5) been professed for decades and is yet to happen. I've been hearing that all my life and my hair is greying. The worst hit democracy has taken was not from sinister NSA bureaucrats but from kooks calling themselves citizen journalists, real estate developers, one-book activists and Crossfit trainers.
- noelsusman 5y agoI've been wondering for decades if privacy advocates are ever going to go back and examine the dystopian proclamations they've been making to see how many actually turned out to be true.
- andy_ppp 5y agoThis is happening with Extinction Rebellion in the UK now. The Home Secretary is using the police to harass groups she disagrees with and changing the law to stop protests she doesn’t like. I think having “infinite surveillance” with someone like this in charge is a terrifying idea.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- GordonS 5y agoEver since Theresa May, I've always thought that the Home Secretary is one of the most dangerous people in the UK - they always want more surveillance and anti-privacy measures, it's never enough for them.
- snthd 5y agohttps://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/may/13/cruel-paranoid-failing-priti-patel-inside-the-home-office https://www.theguardian.com/politics/2021/may/13/cruel-paran... >The long read: Cruel, paranoid, failing: inside the Home Office Some of the why (at least, according to The Guardian).
- GordonS 5y agoA good read covering immigration policies over the years - thanks for pointing me at it. This quote stood out: “They are terrified of the thought that any concession by them that can be perceived as soft or liberal or sympathetic, might leak out and be another set of Daily Mail or Sun or Telegraph stories,” There is a really toxic and dangerous relationship between a large segment of the British media (especially the tabloid press), a large segment of the British public, and the government. It very often feels like the likes of the Daily Mail are the tail that wags the dog, and I just can't see how this long-running status quo can ever end.
- collaborative 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- throwawayswede 5y agoThis sort of reminds me of the whole thing with lockdowns 1) It is noted that governments could, in theory, be requiring and enforcing lockdowns not because they're scientifically better for public health. Widely dismissed as silly and "anti-science". 2) Some scientists come out in opposition of lockdowns, evidence from other countries shows that lockdowns don't help, both get banned/censored or painted as lunacy. 3) Years later, it becomes public knowledge that lockdowns did not in fact help, and countries that had zero lockdown policy did just the same as those that did. It is also too hard to know what went through exactly and to hold people accountable, technically everyone was complicit. 4) The situation persists because it is convenient to the people in charge. 5) It gets turned turned on political dissidents. If a government wants to get rid of your noise, they can paint you as an endangerment to public health and suggest to the public to "cancel" you by banning or by being painted as a "conspiracy theorist". Australia is following this plan almost to the letter at the moment. People getting arrested for not wearing a mask while they're with their daughters and government officials "advising" the public not to talk to their neighbors and to avoid interacting with them socially, even in public, and even if wearing a mask. People are still treating this like "oh we don't know what's going on" or "it's still dangerous" while in a few decade or so, the way we're headed (if nothing changes) seems to be a form of soft-occupation by CCP ideology. It'll be too late to change anything, and then people wonder how can the Australian government pass a bill that allows police to add, delete, and modify your data during an investigation.
- hakfoo 5y agoI know there is a case to be made as to whether lockdowns are effective, but as someone who is not trained in epidemiology, it seems like something that you can try that's well-intentioned and within your available set of tools. This would be especially true during the early phases of a pandemic, when you don't necessarily have great models for disease transmission, preventing more precise restrictions. If the goal is to single out and persecute some specific opposition, this seems like an incredibly clunky and inefficient way to do so. Surely it's easier to tie them up ny having some proxies bury them in court actions or plant some drugs on them, than to throw the entire country into rictus. If nothing else, they're having to personally pay for the economic blowback of declaring a lockdown and all the inevitable egg-on-their-face moments when they themselves break it.
- Ansil849 5y ago> Inside government, a standard slips. They start spying on everything. There is no slippage. Wholesale surveillance has always been the aspirational standard.
- zionic 5y agoPer number 5, even sticking to just the verified stuff it is well known Obama used these powers to spy on Trump’s campaign, and Trump used them to spy on Biden/force Apple to be silent giving up Biden-people’s iCloud data via NSL gags.
- mkr-hn 5y agoEven if it's well-known, and I'm not convinced it is since this is news to me, it won't be forever. Sharing some sources would help a lot both for people now and people finding this post 10, 20, 30 years from now.
- hypothesis 5y agoIt’s going to be hard to avoid bit rot on that scale. Anyhow, I would guess he’s talking about “unmasking” issue with respect to Trump adjacent figures. [1] https://web.archive.org/web/20210813094317/https://www.cnn.com/2021/01/29/politics/kevin-clinesmith-sentencing-durham/index.html https://web.archive.org/web/20210813094317/https://www.cnn.c...
- BugWatch 5y ago"...force Apple to be silent giving up Biden-people’s iCloud data via NSL gags." I terribly misread that as SNL gags. My brain was awfully (in hindsing - hilariously) confused for a good two minutes... trying to figure out how exactly was Apple sidetracking the imposed silence coalmine-canary-style by creatively leaking some data to Biden's people - via the medium of Saturday Night Live gags. (My only defense is a self-eyeroll.)
- yodsanklai 5y ago> 3) Years later it becomes public knowledge. And Edward Snowden is still exiled in Russia for fear of retaliation (and considered a traitor by some).