4 ms·
Most clocks that we can think of involve a clear entropic flow as part of the intrinsic mechanism: an unwinding spring, falling sand, a descending weight, a di
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Most clocks that we can think of involve a clear entropic flow as part of the intrinsic mechanism: an unwinding spring, falling sand, a descending weight, a discharging battery.
But the very first clocks don't rely on this at least not as a principle mechanism. Sundials, early astronomical observatories such as Stonehenge, or simply observing transits and occlusions, don't involve an entropic process. Rather, they track the regular and sustained rotational or orbital movement of the Earth, Moon, and planets. They track the passage of periods of time, but that tracking itself doesn't necessitate entropic flow.
(The light that's necessary to observe the movements, of course, does. But that would be part of any time-based observation, and isn't fundamental to the regular movement itself being measured.)
- zadler 5y agoThe light is fundamental... without particles bouncing between planetary bodies there would be nothing keeping them in sync. Thought experiment: imagine a box through which 0 information passes; no light, heat, radio waves nothing. There’s a clock in the box. Does the clocks progress reflect the progress of time outside the box? No, because time is based on causality and in space that’s propagated largely by massless particles.
- dredmorbius 5y agoLight is not keeping the Earth and Moon "in sync". Gravitational force is.[1] That force propogates at the speed of light. It isn't light itself. Light does play a role in illuminating the system, rendering it observable. It's a signalling component. But again, that's exogenous to the system itself. (See discussion of Maxwell's Daemon and the resolution of that paradox for the role of light in that specific thermodynamic process.) But, and this is key: ANY clock needs some way of passing information on to the observer. From TFA, that might be light, or sound, or chemical potential (received as the smell of rotting garbage). But that is a common element, part of the signalling mechanism, but not of the timekeeping mechanism itself. For an astronomical clock, in most cases, the regular rotational or orbital motion is the timekeeping mechanism. The signalling mechanism is entirely separate. E.g., in the Earth-Moon system, timekeeping is noted by both the daily rotation of the Earth, and the monthly orbit of the Moon. The kinetic energy of both those regular motions is not driven in any sense, nor is it measuring a decay.[2] The signalling comes from an exogenous light source (the Sun) which illuminates both bodies. But the Sun isn't powering the timekeeping mechanism in question. And is equally significant in providing the light necessary for you to read a wristwatch or wall clock (of a non-illuminated variety). ________________________________ Notes: 1. I'm going to leave discussion of just what gravity is and/or how it's manifested out of this discussion. Veritassium tackled this recently though: https://youtube.com/watch?v=XRr1kaXKBsU https://youtube.com/watch?v=XRr1kaXKBsU 2. Yes, there's tidal friction. That's removing energy from the system, and is measurable with sufficiently precise clocks and over time. But that's also incidental and secondary to the motions in quesiton. We could use far more remote bodies (e.g., the Earth and another planet) in which mutual tidal forces are minimal, to eliminate this consideration. Or presume tidally-locked bodies in which orbital / rotational kinetic energy and angular momentum are constant.
- nextaccountic 5y ago> But the very first clocks don't rely on this at least not as a principle mechanism. Sundials, early astronomical observatories such as Stonehenge, or simply observing transits and occlusions, don't involve an entropic process. Rather, they track the regular and sustained rotational or orbital movement of the Earth, Moon, and planets. They track the passage of periods of time, but that tracking itself doesn't necessitate entropic flow. The clock here isn't the sundial but the movement of Earth (the sundial or the astronomy observatory is effectively a measurement device). If you see the movement of Earth as a whole, it's clear it's losing energy to heat, like all clocks. Something else that can be said is that clocks are computing devices; and computers are thermal machines too.
- dredmorbius 5y agoIs the rotation (or orbit) of the Earth a driven process, or one based on momentum alone? What's the thermal process driving the rotation or orbit? That is: as the Earth rotates or orbits, is it going through some cyclical energy potential flux of any significant magnitude? I'd maintain that it's not. The rotation of an astronomical body, or its orbit, is reversible in ways that thermodynamic events are not. If you were to observe a single body spinning in space, or two bodies orbiting one another, you could not tell from a simple observation of the movement whether you were seeing the motion played forward or backward. (With sufficient numbers of bodies, or a sufficiently long period of time, this would eventually be disernable. But not at a macro level.) For other thermodynamic clocks, this seems in general not to be true. Not only does a clock measure time and do so using a thermodynamic gradient, but we can tell which way is forward in time by casually observing the clock itself. Weights fall, springs unwind, batteries discharge, chemicals dissipage or entropise, etc., etc. That is, an orbit is unlike falling sand, a discharging electric cell, an excited atom, or an unwinding spring. It's not even a periodic exchange of potential for kinetic energy as with a pendulum.
- stkdump 5y agoTidal forces slow the rotation down over time, even in space. Also, the sun looses weight as it emits energy.
- baq 5y agowell, the way to keep time with a sundial is to look at the shadow it casts. sun is the heat source here and the dial itself heats up in the process of casting a shadow. also note that if there's no sun (no energy), time keeping functionality is severely limited.
- dredmorbius 5y agoWhat then would be the minimal requirements for a timekeeping function?
- baq 5y agoto tell time, i guess.
- reasonabl_human 5y agoReframing the analysis helps show that your thoughts still fit within the proposed model: Sundials and astronomical observations are not principle mechanisms of clocks.. they are a window of observation into the clock system of moving planetary bodies. Those planetary bodies indeed follow the thermodynamic principles outlined. Imagine you had a rotating disc occluding a light source with a thin slot cut in the disc such that every rotation at one small interval the light source is visible. Rotate it using, say, a coiled spring, and you have a clock, revealing a pulse of light with a constant frequency. This is easy enough to fit into the mold of a thermodynamic clock as proposed in the article. Now, we can think of earth orbiting the sun similarly to our disc rotating in front of the light source…. Every time earth rotates on its axis, half is exposed to the light and half is not…. Quite a wide ‘slot’ cut into our planetary ‘disc’, not useful for much more than knowing what day it is. All a sundial does is narrow that ‘slot’ to make a more accurate observation of our planetary clock’s state. Same goes for observing other planets / stars etc. While these planetary motions appear to be ‘regular and sustained’ on our timescales, they are still subject to the same thermodynamic principles as all other matter, and reach lower entropy over time, until the heat death of the universe :( Someone posted about two bodies orbiting each other, and not know time forward from backward.. again, you can’t ignore physics, those orbits will measurably and irreversibly decay over time until the bodies collide.. just not on timescales that would effect our species using them as clocks!
- amelius 5y ago> Sundials, early astronomical observatories such as Stonehenge, or simply observing transits and occlusions, don't involve an entropic process. How is the nuclear fusion happening in the Sun and other stars producing rays of light not an entropic process?
- dredmorbius 5y agoHow is that fusion relevant to the orbital motion of bodies? As I've suggested elsewhere in the thread: imagine a black dwarf and dead planet in orbit. Clock or no clock? Entropic or not entropic?
- amelius 5y ago> How is that fusion relevant to the orbital motion of bodies? Because without fusion we would not observe them.
- dredmorbius 5y agoSee my original comment. That's a common element to any observation-based system. Or, put another way: if a dead planet orbits a black dwarf whilst tidally locked in an utterly dark Universe, does time exist? Is the observer necessary?
- dredmorbius 5y agoSelf-reply answering a number of points: - I'm familiar with Eddington's "arrow of time" and the concept's fascinated me since I first encountered it listening to a lecture by Stephen Hawking, and reading his own A Brief History of Time. (The lecture was effectively a chapter from the book.) - The question of whether or not all clocks are entropic has bothered me ever since. - It's relatively recent delvings into origins of technology, and recognising that astronomy was in large part the science of time, as well as the fact that most of our historical measures of time were based on astronomical phenomena (the day, month, and year, as well as multiples and subdivisions --- reliance on nonastronomical standards is a modern departure largely undertaken for accuracy but not basis). - In the Seven Liberal Arts, the trivium concerns data input/output and processing (grammer: parsing input, logic: processing, rhetoric: output), whilst the quadrivum is quantitative: arithmatic is quantity, geometry is quantity in space, music is quantity in time, and astronomy is quantity in space and time. That adds an additional dimension to astronomy, but again, the role of ancient astronomers in timekeeping, prophecy, and navigation remains significant. Reducing my argument above to its essence, I like the formulation I arrived at in one subthread here, a variant on the "if a tree falls in a forest" conundrum: If a dead planet orbits a black dwarf whilst tidally locked in an utterly dark Universe, does time exist? Is the observer necessary?
- nextaccountic 5y agoIf the system returns back to the exact same configuration (highly improbable because there are other forces besides gravity), I think we could say that time makes a loop, because any observer can't distinguish whether it's currently in time t or time t+P where P is the period. Incidentally, I've been thinking about a time travel game along those lines: if you ever return to a save point but the game is at a previous configuration, this counts as a time travel (which can be, like.. a multiverse travel if time branched out.. which amounts to the same thing), just like if you selected a time travel in the UI.. two game states can't be in a different time if they are identical. Of course if the mechanic is just this, then this is just a regular save/load state with infinite save lots. Which is a funny observation. Then I need to add other mechanics on top, like carrying things from a timeline to another, which is where the physical analogy would break up.
- 5y ago