5 ms·
Note that there's a difference between what makes sense as a public health measure and which interventions are ethical for medics, and thus between government p
by tialaramex 5y ago
Note that there's a difference between what makes sense as a public health measure and which interventions are ethical for medics, and thus between government policy (public health focused) and what medics agree to do (ethics). Specifically, the medical ethics concern benefits specifically to the patient being treated, while public health is interested in the whole population.
This is why HPV vaccination for boys was much delayed compared to girls. As a public health measure, vaccinating boys obviously makes sense because as likely future sexual partners they can give the girls HPV and thus induce cervical cancer. But, from a medical ethics point of view that's not beneficial to them at all, why should they care if some one night stand they never saw again dies of cancer?
However, once there was enough data to say that vaccinating boys likely protects them from non-cervical cancers induced by HPV, yet significant side effects were very rare, that's a clear benefit to giving them a vaccine, while the public health outcome (fewer women die of cervical cancer) means it makes sense to spend money on delivering it.
So, it can be true that vaccinating all 12 year olds would benefit public health e.g. by reducing the amount of disease spread in the community, while at the same time being true that vaccinating them wouldn't be ethical because the risk to them is similar to or greater than the benefit of not getting COVID-19 when you're young and healthy and very likely to survive with few problems.
- landemva 5y ago'by reducing the amount of disease spread in the community' We were told the vaccine would reduce severity of symptoms thus lightening burden on hospital beds. You claim it reduces transmission, though the studies on that are not complete. Let's keep the public health speculation about transmission based on peer reviewed studies rather than arm waving speculation.
- bryan0 5y agoI wouldn't worry as much about what you're "told" and instead follow the data, of which there is a ton that demonstrates Covid vaccines reduce infections, severe illness, and transmission: > Data from multiple studies in different countries suggest that people vaccinated with Pfizer-BioNTech COVID-19 vaccine who develop COVID-19 have a lower viral load than unvaccinated people.(41-44) This observation may indicate reduced transmissibility, as viral load has been identified as a key driver of transmission.(45) Two studies from the United Kingdom found significantly reduced likelihood of transmission to household contacts from people infected with SARS-CoV-2 who were previously vaccinated for COVID-19.(25, 46) https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-briefs/fully-vaccinated-people.html https://www.cdc.gov/coronavirus/2019-ncov/science/science-br...
- vimy 5y agoBut what about Israel? 60 % of hospitalized patients are vaccinated: > What is clear is that “breakthrough” cases are not the rare events the term implies. As of 15 August, 514 Israelis were hospitalized with severe or critical COVID-19, a 31% increase from just 4 days earlier. Of the 514, 59% were fully vaccinated. Of the vaccinated, 87% were 60 or older. “There are so many breakthrough infections that they dominate and most of the hospitalized patients are actually vaccinated,” says Uri Shalit, a bioinformatician at the Israel Institute of Technology (Technion) who has consulted on COVID-19 for the government. “One of the big stories from Israel [is]: ‘Vaccines work, but not well enough.’ https://www.science.org/news/2021/08/grim-warning-israel-vaccination-blunts-does-not-defeat-delta https://www.science.org/news/2021/08/grim-warning-israel-vac... Natural immunity offers better protection than the vaccine: > The new analysis relies on the database of Maccabi Healthcare Services, which enrolls about 2.5 million Israelis. The study, led by Tal Patalon and Sivan Gazit at KSM, the system’s research and innovation arm, found in two analyses that never-infected people who were vaccinated in January and February were, in June, July, and the first half of August, six to 13 times more likely to get infected than unvaccinated people who were previously infected with the coronavirus. In one analysis, comparing more than 32,000 people in the health system, the risk of developing symptomatic COVID-19 was 27 times higher among the vaccinated, and the risk of hospitalization eight times higher. https://www.science.org/content/article/having-sars-cov-2-once-confers-much-greater-immunity-vaccine-vaccination-remains-vital https://www.science.org/content/article/having-sars-cov-2-on... Disclaimer: I’m vaccinated.
- bryan0 5y agoI’m not sure what your point is since it aligns with these studies, and Israel is strongly encouraging all of its citizens to get vaccinated and get boosters based on the data. Israel has higher vaccinated hospitalizations than the rest of the world because they vaccinated their population, especially the oldest and most vulnerable, very early with pfizer, but it’s been shown in several studies now that pfizer immunity wanes faster than Moderna and apparently AZ (possibly because of dosing). that’s why they are doing a massive booster drive and the US should do the same. As for natural immunity, both vaccinated immunity and natural immunity are great if you can get it! If you’ve had Covid and are vaccinated you are very protected. But whether you were infected with Covid or not, adding vaccination provides order of magnitude benefits.
- didibus 5y agoThat's true, but from the data I've seen, the risk to under 18s of Covid is still higher for both hospitalization and death than that of the vaccine heart inflammation potential rare side effect. That said, compared to over 18, I admit it is not as clear cut, and I can understand being more hesitant.
- bombcar 5y agoBut if only 10% would ever get Covid and 80% would get the vaccine the numbers would need to be adjusted.
- didibus 5y agoThe data I've seen is already adjusted I believe, because even absolute count shows more hospitalization and death due to Covid, and its more likely less people have been exposed to Covid than have received the vaccine. My data is EMA in EU says for under 40 year old, of 197 million vaccines, only 321 had the heart inflammation and 5 died from it, the rest recovered. While CDC data says in the US till now, for under 49 year old, there's been 60902 hospitalizations for Covid (3782 under 18yr), with 24 deaths in the under 18 year range. The population in US for under 49 year old is 210 million. So even assuming worse case, that every under 49 year old in the US got exposed to Covid, we get: Vaccine (under 40yr - in EU): 321 hospitalization out of 197 million ~= 0.00016% 5 deaths out of 197 million ~= 0.0000025% Covid (under 49yr - in US): 60902 hospitalization out of 210 million (best case, likely inflated) ~= 0.03% 24 deaths (under 18yr) out of 82 million (best case, likely inflated) ~= 0.00003% Unfortunately, I find it hard to find good data, that's why for one I need to use data from EU EMA, and the other I'm using data from US CDC, and one includes the 40-49yr old group while the other doesn't. But I think those are far enough apart anyway that to me it seems clear that Covid even in the best case, where I assume everyone in the US in the age range was exposed to it, is much more likely to put you in the hospital or kill you, even if you are younger. But better data might be needed to confirm, especially data restricted to the under 18 year old age group, since their chances of getting the heart inflammation seems higher, and their chances of Covid complications is lower.
- tzs 5y agoOne difference between HPV vaccination in boys and COVID vaccination in kids is that if the unvaccinated boy eventually does give HPV directly to a girl she probably will not be his mother or sister. A kid spreading COVID on the other hand does have a good chance of giving it to siblings and parents. Does that make any difference ethically? In the HPV case you are weighing risk to the boy against potential harm to a vague ill-defined community. He's only endangering his sister or mother by perhaps slightly raising the level in the general population and so slight increasing the chances someone unrelated to him they have sex with will give it to them. In the COVID case you are weighing risk to the child against risk of harm to the rest of the child's immediate family. Losing immediate family can be pretty harmful to a child, perhaps enough to ethically justify taking some risk to the child to avoid it.
- asdfologist 5y ago-
- michaelmrose 5y agoVaccination decreases likelihood of transmitting Delta but doesn't absolutely prevent it. Vaccination prevents downstream spread and thus deaths and given the amplification of increasingly larger downstream generations this effect could still be very large when considering the entire population.
- mythrwy 5y agoHow much does vaccination decrease the likelihood of transmission of Delta? Does anyone know this?
- simonh 5y ago> Does that make any difference ethically? No, ethically your only concern is the patient.
- robocat 5y ago
- colordrops 5y agoI've kept seeing over the years that men can get throat cancer from HPV. Is this true, and if so, why wouldn't a vaccination help?
- sjg007 5y agoIt would help.
- mc32 5y agoThat's what Michael Douglas alluded to in his ill-advised joke about his SO.
- wahern 5y agoAFAIU, yes, but the benefits just weren't as well understood at the time of the original debate, which as I recall revolved entirely around the ethics of vaccinating boys for the benefit of girls. It probably also helped that by the time recommendations were more generally extended to boys there was greater confidence in safety, as HPV-associated cancer in men isn't as prevalent[1] as in women. The cost-benefit tradeoffs were different. [1] This CDC page, https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/hpv/statistics/index.htm https://www.cdc.gov/cancer/hpv/statistics/index.htm, says the ratio is ~3/4 (19900/25400), which is surprising. But that might be a modern figure. I suspect this wasn't as well known or as appreciated 15 years ago. Also, it seems that throat cancer incidence has been increasing rapidly recently (see https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-q-and-a-increasing-incidence-of-throat-cancer-related-to-hpv/ https://newsnetwork.mayoclinic.org/discussion/mayo-clinic-q-...), so actual ratio may have been much smaller 15 years ago.
- roenxi 5y agoThat seems like a complicated and subtle argument. The traditional market option should be kept on the table - all the official groups can make recommendations and then people can decide for themselves what and how many vaccines to get. Ideally paying for it themselves since a vaccine dose seems to cost around $20-50. Trying to decide whether people should or shouldn't be forcing to get vaccinated is a bad policy. Most people already want to be vaccinated; just let them make their own choices and assume their own risk.
- belltaco 5y ago>Ideally paying for it themselves since a vaccine dose seems to cost around $20-50. Why discourage poor people from the vaccine? Surely the benefit to society(and the economy and the markets) is greater than the cost of that vaccine.
- roenxi 5y agoIf you think that, you can buy it on someone else's behalf. At the moment the argument seems to be whether people who believe the cost outweighs the benefit outweighs should be force-vaccinated and made to pay for it. There is a simple solution to this Gordian knot - let people do what they want to do. The vaccine seems to be a good idea that is unsuccessful at stopping the virus, so there is no need to force everyone to get one.
- belltaco 5y agoWho was talking about forcing it? It can be free without forcing people to take it, which is what is happening around the country. >If you think that, you can buy it on someone else's behalf. Does that mean you want to freeload the benefits paid by me? This situation comes to mind. https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna39516346 https://www.nbcnews.com/id/wbna39516346
- roenxi 5y agoIf you think that would be freeloading, then it will take some mental gymnastics for you to simultaneously believe the benefit is greater than the cost.
- neilwilson 5y agoIt's rather more direct than that. The Covid vaccine doesn't help that much in reducing transmission because it is not a sterilising vaccine. Hence we have rather more cases than we would like in countries where vaccination rates are in the high 80%s. So it is like giving boys an HPV vaccine that isn't that likely to stop them giving girls cervical cancer, but pretending to them that it does. With the knock on to behaviour patterns that belief may have. We are rapidly moving into the area of diminishing returns with Covid that cannot be avoided without better vaccines.
- cameldrv 5y agoMedical "ethics" is a very odd thing. Apparently doing something for reasons that aren't 100% selfish is unethical. If we applied this to the rest of life, we would shut down volunteer fire departments because the firefighters get no compensation and could be hurt while trying to save other's lives.
- tpoacher 5y ago> But, from a medical ethics point of view that's not beneficial to them at all, why should they care if some one night stand they never saw again dies of cancer? This is a very subtle but misleading rephrasing of what you should have said instead, which is: "But, from a medical ethics point of view that's marginally beneficial to them at the risk of inducing potential harm". The four pillars of medical ethics are Autonomy, Beneficence, Non-Maleficence, and Justice. Your phrasing effectively subtly side-stepped the third pillar as irrelevant, when presumably it was the one factor whose influence led to the delay you mention.
- tialaramex 5y agoI can't edit my comment now, but I endorse this revision.