44 ms·
This leans far too heavily on the word “intelligence” to describe the behavior of fungus. Yes indeed almost every organism reacts to the world around it, a good
by colechristensen 5y ago
This leans far too heavily on the word “intelligence” to describe the behavior of fungus. Yes indeed almost every organism reacts to the world around it, a good word for that is “alive”. Intelligence requires a lot more than simple stimulus response and internal changeable state, much less consciousness or sentience.
Calling mushrooms intelligent appeals to a certain sort of person and publishing articles like this are just taking advantage of those people for their attention.
The behavior of fungi is interesting without having to project intelligence on to it.
- micromacrofoot 5y agoWhat is intelligence?
- exo-pla-net 5y agoThe article is written by a professor of biology, a scientist. Per the article, a fungus can somehow remember where it previously found food. That degree of spatial awareness/memory is surprising. Thus, in the way that biologists use the word "intelligence", fungi are intelligent. They'd be pretty dumb on any intelligence scale, but they have intelligence. Yeah, hippies get a little too excited about the mind of the fungus or whatever when they hear the word "intelligence" applied to fungi. Who cares.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think my sibling post is relevant and addresses these points. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28408847 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28408847
- colechristensen 5y ago>Yeah, hippies get a little too excited about the mind of the fungus or whatever when they hear the word "intelligence" applied to fungi. Who cares. I care about the inflation of terms like intelligence and the selling of science as "woah dude" to get clicks. A professor of biology isn't necessarily an expert in what should be called "intelligence" or immune to writing things worth criticism. People are constantly amazed that things that are alive aren't as inert as a rock, yes life is cool, but you don't need to thing that everything which interacts with the environment has an experience like "thinking". >Thus, in the way that biologists use the word "intelligence", fungi are intelligent In the way that this biologist is using the word, but it is well worth questioning that use of the word. Saying everything in the world is intelligent sort of makes the term not have any meaning. Is my mechanical thermostat intelligent? Really simple systems can have complex behavior when you don't understand how they work, and when you do figure the system out you can be impressed by how something simple can accomplish but simple machines aren't intelligent, intelligence is something different and much more special.
- retrac 5y agoNot everything in the world. Rocks are not intelligent. That's simple enough. They don't encode any information as far as I can see, they certainly don't actively process or transform it. Living systems seem to. Even bacteria. Information theory seems too applicable when I look at DNA. All living systems seem intelligent, to varying degrees, as they are storing, duplicating and conditionally applying patterns to various biochemical problems in the task of propagating the rulebook of solutions further, the same task that the intelligence of the brain was evolved for. I worry this is more pseudospiritual woo rather than philosophy, though.
- 5y ago
- nemo44x 5y agoYou eat enough of the right mushrooms and it can all make sense. They’ll even talk to you!
- a9h74j 5y agoWhen I am stranded on an island I am certain I will be talking to the mushrooms.
- goldenkey 5y agoOnce on a trip, I realized that the mushroom of our zeitgeist, the Alice in Wonderland / Mario mushroom, Amanita Muscaria [1], when spoken, sounds a lot like "A man eater must scare ya" And to me, this universe is (at least metaphorically) a man eater, and it constantly has reminders for us [2]. And if you subscribe to any sort of notion of morality, it seems like the things that do scare us, like regret, do make us live our lives in better ways. Most people are afraid of psychedelics because even those of us who do them, find them to be jarring. They show us the shitty things we've done, who we really are, and how we really think subconsciously. They wake us up from the slog of our usual comfortable lives. The motivational speakers of time and time again have always said that comfort is the enemy. I find this is why even near death experiences are life-renewing. Anything that makes us afraid, reminds us how short our lives are, and how important every detail, every moment, every butterfly effect is. So the man eater must scare us, if it is to help us do what is expedient. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanita_muscaria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Amanita_muscaria [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchronicity https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Synchronicity
- Optimal_Persona 5y agoYes, and Ellis Dee asked: "Has anyone seen the Silly Sigh Bin?"
- goldenkey 5y agoAnd the HNer replied "How dare you mock my anti mystical view of the world?!!" and proceeded to slap the downvote button so hard that their mouse exploded into a poof of dark smoke! Once the smoke cleared, the HNer realized their screen was also black. They hastily smacked their computer's power button, quickly realizing it had also died. A sickly black billowy puff of smoke then emanated from their once neon-lit PC case. They thought of that dumb joke from grade school about being punched so hard that their grandma felt it. Had they really done that to their PC by hitting their mouse so hard? "Impossible!" they thought, "Coincidences are ALWAYS just improbable events!" All of a sudden the PC speaker inside the case started rattling. Then a voice echoed from it: "You kicked the Llama's ass!" The HNer fell down on their knees. They couldn't believe that a Winamp loving entity ruled the universe. Was life a musical thing? "Things will never be the same." they muttered angrily as they downvoted yet another post by /u/carljung via their iPhone 47 Pro Max Plus Platinum Collector's Edition.
- blueprint 5y agoEverything that exists reacts to the world around it ;)
- 6510 5y agoIts all logic operations and all results are stored until the next.
- throwaway14356 5y agothis has me convinced https://blogs.biomedcentral.com/bugbitten/2014/11/05/zombie-ants-have-been-manipulated-by-secretions-from-a-killer-fungus/ https://blogs.biomedcentral.com/bugbitten/2014/11/05/zombie-... I mean wtf?
- s1artibartfast 5y agoThis is a compiles and amazingly complex mechanism of propagation, but doesn't require any intelligence or awareness on the part of the fungus. Just millions of years of evolution and deterministic neurochemistry.
- colechristensen 5y agoIt shouldn't. Diseases very often modify the behavior of the host to help them spread. They don't do it "intelligently" they do it on accident by hitting on a modification of the host which results in better transmission of the disease. Covid makes you cough to spread little droplets filled with virii, rabies makes mammals violent so they'll bite to spread infection through saliva. It isn't through intense manipulation, it's by pulling a few levers. One species taking advantage of another species through biochemistry is extremely common. Every psychoactive drug, poison, etc. are all manipulations through chemistry.
- mtqwerty 5y agoIn my mind, alive is a binary term. Something is alive or it is not. We don't say something is more alive than something else. Rocks, road signs and tables are not alive. Humans, pigs and fungi are alive. That is a useful distinction but it disregards differences in the latter group. Fungi are reacting to stimuli with more complex behaviors than a single-celled organism can. We can't say fungi are more alive than the single celled organisms, so what are they? Where does one draw the line with intelligence? In your opinion, what organisms can appropriately be considered intelligent?
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Something is alive or it is not. We don't say something is more alive than something else. Yes we do. There's a whole continuum from prions through viruses to cells.
- mtqwerty 5y agoI didn't think my education would be out of date so quickly. You're absolutely right. I was taught prions/viruses were in the gray area between alive and dead but alive is clearly just a spectrum. Thank you for not ending your comment with "read up".
- billiam 5y agoAre viruses alive? What about prions? Self-replicating clay molecules? Read up.
- Jweb_Guru 5y agoThat's pedantry, the point is that both free-living bacteria and fungi are very firmly on the "alive" side of that gray area.
- mtqwerty 5y agoIf you hadn't said read up at the end of this, it would've been a helpful comment. You clearly have read up based on your other posts but being a jerk to people who aren't as read up as you won't make you any happier.
- _nub3 5y ago> This leans far too heavily on the word “intelligence” to describe the behavior of fungus. True dat. However since there is not a single valid definition for intelligence, I started to speak and think of heuristics when others are referring to intelligence. As long as any traits can be learned and trained their testing has nothing to do with what I'd call intelligence.
- billiam 5y agoYou would appear to have not read the article, which specifically and persuasively makes points about the semantic limitations to a human-centered definition of intelligence. generalizing it to emergent and organized behavior will help us learn about all living things behavior as well as our own.
- lr4444lr 5y agoThis is a very good point, but what alternative line in the sand do you draw? I would personally set the bar pretty high to showing purposeful control of behavior that is not the direct result of an evolved organism or species survival instinct, i.e., eating, fighting, fleeing, and mating doesn't count. Resourceful looking for food could count, as could certain camouflage maneuvers during flight, or multi-member hunting and defense, and all tool use. Definitely deception to win mates
- colechristensen 5y ago"Intelligence" might be defined as requiring at least an internal abstracted ability to represent the world around which is not innate or hard-coded into biological mechanisms.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"Calling mushrooms intelligent appeals to a certain sort of person and publishing articles like this are just taking advantage of those people for their attention." s/mushrooms/computers/ re: incessant "AI" hype
- rdevsrex 5y agoOk, but you have to admit those studies on slime mold being able to able to find the fastest path to food is impressive. It may not be individual ego-centric intelligence like we have (it seems to me more genetic and predetermined), but it's still impressive.
- caycep 5y agothat being said, I wonder if enough quantifiable data exists to estimate the amount of computation possible, i.e. basic computer science/turing machine/kolmogorov complexity stuff?