10 ms·
GoDaddy is cutting off Texas Right to Life’s abortion ‘whistleblowing’ website
- m0zg 5y agoAre there any good hosts in the United States that won't cut you off on ideological grounds? This shit should be plainly illegal, IMO. If it's in compliance with US law, I should be able to host whatever the fuck I want. I'd argue this is a better deal for the hosting companies as well. Why? For the same reason why your company can't cancel your line if it doesn't like what you're discussing on the phone.
- wmf 5y agoAFAIK Epik is the main Nazi-friendly hosting company these days.
- josephcsible 5y agoYou're really referring to hosting providers that allow anti-abortion websites as "Nazi-friendly" when Nazis were in favor of abortions? https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/as-many-abortions-as-possible-12118 https://www.ewtn.com/catholicism/library/as-many-abortions-a... > "When girls and women in the Occupied Territories of the East have abortions, we can only be in favor of it; in any case we should not oppose it." > "The means for abortion and contraceptive means may be offered publicly without police restriction."
- bingohbangoh 5y agohttps://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/ https://www.nearlyfreespeech.net/ comes to mind
- Grieving 5y agoIIRC they've said they have no problem kicking people off for ideological reasons, and that the name has more to do with pricing than anything.
- booi 5y agoPrivate companies in the US can discriminate or otherwise choose who they want as customers except if the criteria is a protected class. Currently, political reasons are not protected so Godaddy would be within its rights to deny service.
- elmerfud 5y agoPrivate companies can discriminate against non-protected classes and you are correct political reasons or position on abortion is not a protected class. The problem is in allowing this behavior to continue by companies unchecked eventually the law will come in and start assigning new protected classes. People have forgotten their history and why certain attributes have become protected classes for which discrimination is not allowed. This was not done due to some moral altruism by the laws and courts. These were assigned protective class status because private companies began to exclude people and eventually all or most private companies in an area started excluding people of a certain race or gender etc... This results in people not being able to participate in society. While they remain free people and the businesses have their freedom to choose it is not real freedom when you cannot participate in the society that you are part of. This is why we now have enforced protected classes. When we do not stand up as reasonable people and participate in the process to indicate the companies we do not want them to be the moral arbiters of our lives we are effectively letting them determine who can participate in the online society and who cannot. The idea that just because of company can do something does not mean it should and does not mean that we should allow it. If we get to the point that we have to make laws to protect someone's race or sex or now what's coming is political affiliation or opinion then we as a society have failed in our duty to each other. Creating a new law and codifying the fact that people should be allowed to participate in society even with opinions that we do not like should cause everyone to take a hard look in the mirror and realize they are the problem. Whatever happened to the idea that I do not agree with what you say but I will defend your right to say it.
- minikites 5y ago>started excluding people of a certain race or gender Race and gender is about something you are, political opinions are not something you are.
- commandlinefan 5y ago> This shit should be plainly illegal, IMO Although I'm pretty outraged that a hosting provider would pull something like this, I can't for the life of me think of a way to "safely" outlaw it without creating all sorts of unintended consequences. Then again, I'm not a lawmaker, so maybe they're more clever than I am. It seems that a lot of private enterprise in the Unites States believes that the US conservative movement is so irrelevant as to be safe to completely ignore - if it turns out they're wrong, they're in for a rough next few years.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoThey violated GoDaddy's terms of service. You want a hosting provider with no ToS ?
- France_is_bacon 5y agoI'm outraged that I can't live in your house or apartment with you, and that you have the legal right to kick me out of your home. Private property is one of the main reasons for what the USA stands for. GoDaddy is a private company. Conservatives are ALWAYS outraged when something like this goes against them, but when they want it the other way it is perfectly ok - like the bakery where the owners didn't want to create a wedding cake for two homosexuals. Then it was all, "A private business can do what they want, which means not working for the gay." As far as the religious freedom law goes, it is supposed to acknowledge deeply held religious beliefs. For example, Satanic Temple just cites Religious Freedom Restoration Act to request access to abortion drugs in aftermath of Texas ban. But, I'm SURE that the religious freaks that support the Religious Freedom Restoration Act, WON'T support it because they are hell-bent (pun intended) on violated the First Amendment of the Constitution of the United States of America allowing the freedom of religion, with some lame-ass excuse like saying that the Satanic Temple is not a religion. To them it isn't. But for those who belong to it, it sure is.
- m0zg 5y agoI regularly see on this very site liberals outraged about things "private" companies are fully within their rights to do. You can't be for and against something depending on the political affiliation of the affected party. That's pure hypocrisy. Then again, hypocrisy is the main currency of politics, as well as the only true manifestation of power. Fortunes change, though. Don't wail 10 years from now when corporations decide that they like the conservative side better and ban you from the internet. Because that's within their rights too.
- ablerman 5y agoYou can host whatever the fuck you want. So can GoDaddy.
- Minor49er 5y agoApparently you can't host whatever you want. Otherwise we wouldn't be in this comment section talking about this story.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoNot sure you understand the meaning of the word "host" in this context.
- Minor49er 5y agoRest assured, I do
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWell, then your post is obviously nonsense to you, just as it was to several other people. You buy a server, find a coloc facility, pay the price to colocate, plug your server in, host whatever you want, free of essentially all terms of service. That's "hosting whatever you want".
- josephcsible 5y agoWhat happens when the colocation facility throws you out too?
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoWhen you can't find another one that allows colocation with a ToS that will let you do whatever you want, you rent a T1 line or better to your own home. Have you ever heard of a ISP kicking someone off a rented dedicated cable? Maybe it has happened. I have no memory of ever hearing about this in any case where there wasn't prima facie illegal acitivit occuring over the line.
- watwut 5y agoThe whole site is about punishing people and their relations on ideological grounds.
- PaulDavisThe1st 5y agoGoDaddy [ EDIT: appears to be ] cutting them off for collecting information about other users or persons without the consent of those other users or persons. That would be a clear violation of their ToS. The cutoff might happen to align with GoDaddy's political views - god, I hope so - but the explicit reason for it is not political.
- commandlinefan 5y agoI'm too lazy to look it up, but I wonder if GoDaddy hosts any of those "is your neighbor a sex offender" websites - I'm sure that the people identified by those would rather remain anonymous.
- jdgoesmarching 5y agoIt’s dumb that profit-driven decisions that cause all sorts of human rights violations are rarely considered “political” by tech conservatives. However, the moment you trample upon the idealistic notion of a “free” internet that has long since been captured by a few corporate entities? Must be a giant threat to the future of society. Caring more about an ideological slippery slope than the actual people who will suffer under these laws in Texas is an amazingly insulated position that I can’t take seriously.
- mcphage 5y ago> Are there any good hosts in the United States that won't cut you off on ideological grounds? This shit should be plainly illegal, IMO. A similar case went all the way to the US Supreme Court, who decided that yes, it is legal to be refused service on ideological grounds: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colorado_Civil_Rights_Commission https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Masterpiece_Cakeshop_v._Colora...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- eesmith 5y agoIt's not the same reason. The phone company is a common carrier, under the Communications Act of 1934, which is why it can't cancel your line in the scenario you gave. GoDaddy is not regulated under common carrier laws. In the absence of any law saying otherwise, GoDaddy can exercise its freedom of association to kick off people for whatever reason, subject perhaps only to civil lawsuits for breaking any contract with their customers -- and of course the court of public opinion. In this case, they appear to be saying it's a ToS violation, and The Verge suggests it violates prohibitions on users who "“collect or harvest” any personal information “about another User or any other person or entity without their express prior written consent.”" That may well be the cover used to hide an ideologically reason, but why wouldn't that be enough? There are cases where your phone company is allowed to cut you off (try plugging the phone line to the power line.) Savannah, is a hosting site for "software forge for people committed to free software", at http://savannah.gnu.org/ http://savannah.gnu.org/ . They will cut you off on ideological grounds should you switch to a non-free license. Should that also be illegal?
- josephcsible 5y ago> GoDaddy is not regulated under common carrier laws. Maybe they, and other Internet infrastructure providers, should be. > Savannah, is a hosting site for "software forge for people committed to free software", at http://savannah.gnu.org/ http://savannah.gnu.org/ . They will cut you off on ideological grounds should you switch to a non-free license. > Should that also be illegal? In your example, would they be cutting off everyone who chooses a non-free license, or just singling out one person for political reasons, and turning a blind eye to a bunch of other people also using non-free licenses?
- treesprite82 5y ago> The phone company is a common carrier, under the Communications Act of 1934, which is why it can't cancel your line in the scenario you gave. > GoDaddy is not regulated under common carrier laws. > In the absence of any law saying otherwise, GoDaddy can exercise its freedom of association to kick off people for whatever reason [...] m0zg saying that it should be illegal presumably means that they already know that it's not currently illegal, rather they want similar regulations introduced (or the removal of existing protections) to affect GoDaddy. > Should that also be illegal? The way I often see it argued by those in favor of repealing/reinterpreting Section 230 is that a service shouldn't have the protections of a platform/carrier while acting as a publisher with full control over the content. A curated software library should be fine as a publisher, just that they'd only have the same protections as non-digital publishers.
- vestigialhonor 5y agoGoDaddy has been involved in controversy of this sort before (Verisign, Ratemycop, Family Album, Kata’ib Hezbollah). If profile whistleblower had done their research, might have seen it coming. I agree you should be able to host what the eff you want, but it's the choice of the host at the end of the day. I'm more than certain that the site had a massive influx of traffic clogging it, what with some using VPN and throw away emails to spam fake reports, and some who were trying to cash in. In a nutshell, usually a host includes a statement expressly reserving the right to terminate or cancel an account as per service terms, so they are well within their rights.
- elmerfud 5y agoWithout knowing exactly what's going on it's difficult to say. My better nature thinks that hopefully this is not a case of moral arbitration on the part of GoDaddy. It's quite likely if the site has generated huge amounts of traffic it could be counted as impacting services and this is why they need to move or perhaps get DDOS protection to prevent that. Giving godaddy's history I have my doubts that's the reason. Since this is not the first time GoDaddy has done similar things I do not know why anyone would continue to use GoDaddy for anything. I want the employees of GoDaddy to be politically active and participate in the democratic process but I do not GoDaddy as a company to be the moral arbiter of things. The CEO of GoDaddy, maybe not the current one I haven't kept up on things, has had his own troubles yet I don't recall him getting completely canceled by the company. This kind of Jim Crowesque behavior from companies always ends badly. This is literally what happens when people are single issue zealots. They seem completely incapable of understanding that the reasoning that they apply against their single issue will eventually turn around and be used against them. What we need is laws that companies cannot be moral arbiters. If companies do choose to become moral arbiters then all protections against them are removed. You cannot cancel someone because you do not like what they say and then turn it right around and claim common carrier status therefore you are not responsible for something else you're hosting. Yeah this is what we see repeatedly with a number of these companies they wish to feign ignorance and common carrier status but they also wish to selectively police things.
- wombatmobile 5y ago> My better nature thinks that... I'm not sure what you mean by "better" or "nature". It sounds like you may have some form of structure in your thinking that clearly delineates "politics" from "business" and "morality". Can we explore that a little? Do you consider it is the role of SCOTUS to be the moral arbiter of women's bodies? If not, and SCOTUS has overreached, whose role is it to push back against SCOTUS' activism? Nobody? Everybody? Somebody? The answers to these questions are not mathematical, scientific, or technical. They are political. If your "better nature" excludes companies from participating in the political process, how does it feel about companies donating to political parties e.g. to facilitate the building of oil pipelines across exempt areas of land, or to rezone land for mega warehouses, or to bust unions, or to facilitate casinos?
- literallyaduck 5y agoTime to report Godaddy, its move is aiding all of the future cases reported.
- gunapologist99 5y agoTook a second, but rotfl
- aaron695 5y agoThis website operates fully within the intent of Texas law. Almost all places have legal and illegal abortions. (Texas is obviously far shorter than most) The intent of the new law is to find places doing illegal abortions with whisle blowing. It has nothing to do with prosecution of women who have abortions. Neither does the website. It doesn't ask for, or want women's names. GoDaddy is overriding what Texans have voted for.
- xvector 5y agoHow severely can states curtail rights before the oppressed begin to respond in a violent manner? Tree of liberty and all that jazz. I feel like Texas lawmakers are walking the razor's edge here.
- dragonwriter 5y agoThe website is means by which the operators and their collaborators conspire to injure other persons on account of their having exercised rights guaranteed by the Constitution, and by threat of such injury intimidate others in the exercise of the same Constitutionally guaranteed rights, all of which is done under color of law and with the active collusion of State authorities (namely, the State legislature) with the intent of depriving persons of their federal Constitutionally protected rights, in criminal violation of 18 USC § 241 and 18 USC § 242, and civil violation of 42 USC § 1983. After the Texas Legislature’s tactic in crafting the law to evade standing and jurisdictional requirements for review before attempted enforcement by the federal courts, so that the blatantly, brazenly unconstitutional law could nevertheless have the maximum chilling effect on protected conduct, the federal executive brance announced a “whole of government” effort to rectify the issue. GoDaddy is wisely choosing to be out of the crosshairs of that effort by not actively participating and knowingly profiting from that criminal conspiracy.
- temp8964 5y agoWhich right is not guaranteed by the Constitution? Is "Constitutionally guaranteed rights" a meaningful term to separate other rights protected by the law of the land but not by constitution?
- dragonwriter 5y ago> Which right is not guaranteed by the Constitution? Statutory rights.
- cirrus3 5y agoGood.
- b215826 5y agoThis is just advertising, plain and simple. I doubt this group's website generates a lot of traffic and I doubt the revenue it brings GoDaddy is more than a few hundred dollars each year. But thanks to this move, GoDaddy is now trending on Twitter, has been covered by multiple news outlets, and SJWs will now flock to GoDaddy to host their websites. All the past transgressions of GoDaddy [1] (including hosting websites operated by known terrorists) will be virtue-signalled away. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GoDaddy#Controversies https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GoDaddy#Controversies