20 ms·
Google Chrome to remove detailed cookie and site data controls
- staticassertion 5y agoSeems like there should be a bug report to include more detailed information on the new page.
- dylan604 5y agoClosed, won't fix
- tehwebguy 5y ago> By the way, before anyone runs off and yells "Switch to Safari" or something like that, keep in mind that Safari is actually in a worse state and doesn't have detailed cookie and site information at all. It does, but it's split between two places. You can see a list of all sites that have stored data in Preferences > Privacy > Manage Website Data... (no option to view here, just delete). You can also navigate to the site in the browser and then view the detailed data: - Check "Show Develop menu in menu bar" in Preferences > Advanced - Develop > Show Web Inspector - Navigate to the Storage tab On the left you'll see options for Cookies, Local Storage & Session Storage.
- Kiro 5y agoSame for Chrome so not sure what this article is about.
- DangitBobby 5y agoThe article is quite clear. The question is, why did they go backwards on functionality. They took a simple user interface and removed a single useful feature from it, and what remains is a much more tedious way to do the same thing. Why? What was the benefit? The author speculates that it's to make user cookie control more difficult.
- shock-value 5y agoThe reason was probably that no one ever needs to delete just a subset of cookies from a site. I certainly never have, and I'm a pretty technically-minded user. (Other than for development, in which case I'm using dev tools anyway.)
- IIsi50MHz 5y agoCounterpoint: I've many times had to fix presentation of or access to a site by purging just specific cookies. Two sites that have previously had these problems are RingCentral's web interface and AutoTask. Maybe a dozen or more others, but admittedly not many…however, when I've needed it, the problem has been persistent, requiring multiple fixes per day, over a few consecutive days or or even a couple weeks.
- SquareWheel 5y agoNeeding to delete specific cookies does arise occasionally, and we have dev tools or the cookie viewer under the lock for that. However, needing to delete those cookies without first viewing the page due to side effects - that is a very niche use case.
- xemdetia 5y agoIs it? I feel like most of my atrocious cookie hand fix cases end up being broken redirects where you get redirected to some new url that errors, so loading the page doesn't help to get rid of the offending cookie.
- SquareWheel 5y agoThat would be an atrocious bit of engineering from the developer. But I suspect that even in that case, holding Escape as you load the page would kill the redirect.
- 5y ago
- gsich 5y agoWhy Safari? The only sane choice is Firefox.
- kortex 5y agoOr Brave. Safari gives me too many issues. Brave has all the compatibility you'd expect from chromium.
- gsich 5y agoIf Brave is keeping Chromium updated, then it is possible that this will effect them also.
- techrat 5y agoBrave is just a shitcoin mining, referral link hijacking reskin of Chrome.
- brnt 5y agoBy default it doesnt, and although I'd certainly advise going over all Brave's settings once, then you have the safest (as in not outdated like some other privacy forks) and privacy respecting Chrome based browser around.
- techrat 5y agoStop drinking the kool aid, buh. If you have to go over the settings... A safe, privacy respecting browser wouldn't resort to any shady tactics in the first place.
- brnt 5y agoI'm not drinking any koolaid, I just have not found anything better, apart from Firefox.
- nyolfen 5y agobrave's default settings are almost certainly exactly what a privacy-oriented person would choose. it does not mine crypto, and it only pays you in crypto to view notification ads if you opt-in. i even gave the ads a shot but decided it wasn't worth the $2 a month or whatever, so now i just have a maintained, de-googled chrome, which is basically a description of the optimal browser in 2021. does firefox ask you if you want to install pocket yet?
- officeplant 5y agoFrom the blog it sounds like Chrome's will be in a similar state after the update. Just another thing I'll have to navigate to in a tedious manner.
- fartcannon 5y agoUse Firefox?
- Datagenerator 5y agoI'm into watching telemetry data using tools like Pihole, Wireshark, DNSLookupView. Firefox is the only browser which does not invoke spontaneous connections and gives the user the Freedom to inspect and clear the cookie data. Google notoriously creates VPN tunnels to hide what it is sending and receiving. Your browser preference might determine many people's privacy if the narrative is limited to not so important things to me like speed and ease of use.
- yunohn 5y ago> Google notoriously creates VPN tunnels to hide what it is sending and receiving. I’ve never heard about this, could you provide a source?
- Datagenerator 5y agoThe due diligence starts with research on the topic 1e100.net for example https://superuser.com/questions/75841/what-is-1e100-net-and-why-do-i-have-tcp-ports-open-to-it#75847 https://superuser.com/questions/75841/what-is-1e100-net-and-...
- notafraudster 5y agoNo comments I can see there seem to address VPNs; one notes that if you DNS block one of their domains, they connect via IP. But there's no discussion of VPN tunnels. I made sure to view all comments. Do you think you could forward a link that makes that claim? Unless you just mean that sending data over plain HTTP to these servers is in some sense a VPN tunnel because the resulting servers could forward it elsewhere?
- xqyf 5y agoSure, both browsers have developer tools. This is much more opaque than a Settings menu.
- samizdis 5y ago> You can also navigate to the site in the browser and then view the detailed data The author addresses this point (or has now addressed it) in the addendum to point out an "observer effect" shortcoming: This information can be seen with the web inspector in both Chrome and Safari. Yes, but the crucial difference is that you have to navigate to an individual site in a browser window in order to see the site data in the web inspector. Whereas in the Preferences, you can get to the site data, for every website, without having to load the sites. And remember, the very act of loading a site can make the site data change, so there's an "observer effect" if you try to examine or delete it in the web inspector.
- BoorishBears 5y agoNot that I think this has actually been applied by anyone in the wild, but it'd be fun to make a site that take advantage of this You can detect developer tools being open in Chrome pretty reliably, so detect dev tools have been open then "clean up your act" before there's a chance to view anything of note
- codezero 5y agoCould you see the original cookie by inspecting the headers of the network request? This would presumably be the value before the page loads and gives access to document.cookie or a change triggered by a server-side header.
- sk5t 5y agoConsider using something like https://mitmproxy.org/ https://mitmproxy.org/ to deal with a site so devious as to detect browser-level tools being used to inspect headers/cookies/etc.
- duskwuff 5y agoThis has absolutely been used "in the wild". One particularly nasty strain of ad-block-evasion scripts would detect the developer tools being opened, and would reload the page and disable most of its features to prevent them from being analyzed.
- a3n 5y agoWhat a weird design. Listing and viewing would often be done when you want to "clean things up, but not everything. Disclosure: never used or saw safari, and i don't have a mac, nor the mac nature.
- kiliancs 5y agoWhat is the mac nature?
- gopher_space 5y agoIt's either an internally consistent UX or matching belt and shoes, depending on who you ask.
- PostThisTooFast 5y agoOr cafe-oriented hipster douchebaggery, depending on whom you ask.
- ashtonkem 5y agoSafari is also generally trending in the right way, while Chrome is headed in the wrong way.
- Bellamy 5y agoWhy so?
- ashtonkem 5y agoApple doesn’t make money from ads (yet), so there is no harm and a lot of marketing benefit in pushing privacy from ad trackers. Google is an ad company, so good privacy controls in Chrome hurts them.
- FractalHQ 5y agoSafari privacy is a joke until I can install UBlock Origin on MacOS and iOS Safari. Until they support proper browser extensions outside of their App Store, Safari will remain a privacy leaking toy compared to chromium and gecko browsers. Also the amount of bugs and missing features I face in Safari as a web developer is a nightmare. Cute animations though.
- ashtonkem 5y agoI’d argue that Apple’s incentives are mostly aligned for privacy on Safari, but the incentives for it to spend its resources on Safari in general are not aligned. Apple has long had a native-app only outlook which has hampered its work on browsers for a long time.
- ksec 5y ago>Apple doesn’t make money from ads (yet) Apple doesn’t make money from web ads (yet). Although even that is changing as Apple now offer personalised Ads in Apps, they might one day offer that on the web as well.
- nomoreplease 5y agoUse Firefox?
- phone8675309 5y agoSounds like Chrome is moving more toward being a surveillance tool and ad delivery platform that also browses the web (well, more than it is right now anyway).
- minikites 5y agoThat's what happens when a browser made by an advertising company becomes dominant.
- booi 5y agoIt’s more and more obvious we need competition in the browser space. Firefox as an excellent and performant alternative. Personally I use Chrome for work and Firefox for personal stuff.
- gaoshan 5y agoI've had decent luck with Vivaldi lately.
- nicce 5y agoPlease note, that it is Chromium based as well.
- vimy 5y agoWhy not use Edge if you need to use a chromium based browser?
- krono 5y agoIt's like Chrome, but better in pretty much every way. Never thought I'd say this but Edge is actually pretty good! Very frequent and large feature updates, deepening ecosystem integration that uncharacteristically doesn't get the way if you don't use it. I always get a bit anxious when one of these massive enterprises suddenly gets up and starts moving with newfound focus, and MS is pretty much sprinting on Adderall at this point.
- Ajedi32 5y agoSeems reasonable. If you want detailed information about the contents of individual cookies that's what developer tools are for. A simple "clear data" button seems far more usable for normal users.
- sschueller 5y agoWhat the hell happened to Google? Who are these complete idiots running the show?
- da_chicken 5y agoThe same idiots looking ad and data mining revenue, and then seeing what their customer's demands are. Their customers being the ones who are buying services from Google. Not you. You're the product.
- beerandt 5y agoTired of this excuse. If the audience is the product, Google still has an interest in selling a quality product. That means not running off more and more of the most tech savvy "product" segment.
- da_chicken 5y ago> Tired of this excuse. When it stops being true, it will stop being trotted out as the explanation for why Google keeps making their browser better for their ad revenue business. > If the audience is the product, Google still has an interest in selling a quality product. That means not running off more and more of the most tech savvy "product" segment. Why do you think the most tech savvy segment is the target audience? Do you have any idea how many advertising dollars there are in the 12-17 and 18-24 brackets?
- beerandt 5y ago>Why do you think the most tech savvy segment is the target audience? Tech savvy doesn't equal hn users. You think teenagers and college kids aren't using ad blockers or selectively clearing browser history? There are tech savvy users across all marketing demographics. >When it stops being true, it will stop being trotted out as the explanation It's not really an explanation, though. It's a half-baked observation. Movie theaters make money on concessions, but need the good movies to draw a crowd. Dealerships make their money on service, but still need to sell cars to get that customer base. Even if it's true by some skewed definition, it's mostly irrelevant. It implies that it doesn't matter what they do to users, and have no interest in keeping them satisfied, and that's false. They might want to increase ad business, but that don't do that by allowing users to slowly trickle to alternatives. Look at firefox's fall from the top. There wasn't a breaking point, but a constant trickle due to usability and performance.
- SubiculumCode 5y ago"Don't be Evil" he he he...almost forgot about them saying that. -posted from Firefox.
- edoceo 5y agoDamn. And we lost Servo just when it was getting close to being not shitty. While everything else is moving towards more shitty.
- tomxor 5y agoWe lost the servo team, but isn't servo complete enough to simmer in maintenance?
- kroltan 5y agoNot nearly complete enough if you want a browser. MAYBE, if you want a browsing engine / "webview".
- zamadatix 5y agoThat's exactly what Servo was/is, an embeddable browser engine. It was never aiming to build a usable reference servo browser with the engine. The packaged nightly binaries were just to demo the current state of the embeddable engine which is why they were so barebones.
- kroltan 5y agoYes, you're correct, but the ancestor comments kind of implied it being a hope for browsers at large. Bad phrasing from my part too, sorry.
- tomxor 5y agoAhh, i'm talking about the surviving parts that were adopted by Firefox: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gecko_(software)#Quantum https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gecko_(software)#Quantum I remember it clearly because Firefox got a big performance boost in it's renderer when quantum was released, often it's faster than Chrome.
- simfoo 5y agoWhat features would a browser need on top of regular webview APIs?
- melbourne_mat 5y agoI'm privacy conscious but would not consider looking at such detailed information. For me it's delete all site state on exit. Do people actually look at this stuff?
- RedComet 5y agoI do.
- alisonkisk 5y agoWhat's one interesting thing you've seen that isn't better displayed in Dev Tools?
- james-skemp 5y agoDeveloper bias, but being able to delete individual cookies is invaluable. Non-developer hat: PlayStation Network store also had a bug where you'd be logged in, but unable to buy anything. Instead of deleting all data you could delete one cookie and it would temporarily resolve the issue.
- ratata 5y agoJust fyi, you can delete individual cookies in the developer tools.
- bigwavedave 5y ago> Just fyi, you can delete individual cookies in the developer tools. While I very much agree with the point you're making, I can count on one hand (with fingers to spare) the number of family members I have who know what the developer tools even are, and that's because I showed them when troubleshooting an issue they were having. They aren't going to learn or remember how to access the dev tools to manage cookies, but they do know what it means to delete individual cookies and the current process to do so, and if they forget the exact steps they could certainly figure it out in settings/preferences. What they're not going to do is think "well, I can't find the thing I used to use to deal with cookies, I'd better go muck around in the developer tools." I'd imagine a very large percentage of non-technical people who have heard about cookies fall into the same category as my relatives, but that's my own bias talking and YMMV of course.
- dessant 5y agoLooking forward to a Google employee lecturing us about how users don't care about these details and how people don't want granular control over site data.
- quaintdev 5y agoOf course an average user does not bother about these controls. They don't even need to know what cookies are. Maybe they don't care today but now you are not even giving them opportunity to learn and take control back. The argument that no one uses it is just a front. Real reason is it serves in Google's interest to remove these and that is why they are doing it. Just like GTalk and RSS.
- BHSPitMonkey 5y agoWhy, in your view, does there NEED to be two UIs in the same application serving the same purpose?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- johncena33 5y agoJust out of curiosity, what's the percentage of users outside of devs do you think care about this feature?
- BHSPitMonkey 5y agoNot a Google employee, but yes - users absolutely do not care about manipulating individual cookie key/value pairs (and if they did, they would be web developers and know how to open Developer Tools).
- Cipater 5y agoYou don't need Google employees for that. Majority of the comments on this post are people telling others that if they care they can use developer tools to find the functionality so they should shut up about this change. And so it goes....
- alisonkisk 5y agoThe ranting in this post's HN comments is ridiculous. If you don't trust a site, delete its content or block it. It's not an invasion of your privacy because the UI doesn't let you pick apart the individual bits of encoded gobbledygook in the cookies. You need Dev Tools to make sense of cookies, and Chief provides that.
- antisthenes 5y agoIt's hard to tell from the article, but aren't detailed cookies still available through dev tools?
- grishka 5y agoYou don't even need the dev tools — you can view individual cookies by clicking the lock icon in the address bar and then "cookie settings".
- antisthenes 5y agoYeah, but if that's the case, then I'm completely lost about what's getting removed from Chrome?
- ehsankia 5y agoIn my experience cookie control in Chrome have always sucked. There's barebone support in dev tools but everyone time I've wanted to do anything serious, I've always relied on more powerful cookie editing extensions.
- putlake 5y agoI regularly use site-specific controls, mostly for Javascript. Let's hope Edge retains it.
- hpoe 5y agoThis is part of a strategy to eliminate the openness of the web, right now your client still has full view and control of the code running on it in the browser to a certain degree. Companies do not want this, this makes it possible to reverse engineer their process, to view what they are doing, and basically takes away control. They want a future where your browser is instead a portal to the web where various companies just deliver black boxes of bytes to your machine and you don't have visibility into the code that is running, the actions they are performing or what is going on. In such a world they control the platform the content and the delivery mechanism. Openness is contrary to the goals of these large companies because that causes them to lose control.
- nicce 5y agoI don’t know why you are getting downvoted, but this is the reality already. Maybe reasons behind are sometimes different, but the end result is the same. Google is rebuilding their Docs for using canvas only[1]. You have no control over it. Similar things are happening. Web assembly is getting more popular, and in more cases browser is just a sandbox running arbitrary code. E.g Microsoft has huge interest[2]. [1]: https://workspaceupdates.googleblog.com/2021/05/Google-Docs-Canvas-Based-Rendering-Update.html?m=1 https://workspaceupdates.googleblog.com/2021/05/Google-Docs-... [2]: https://www.infoworld.com/article/3613873/microsoft-gets-serious-about-webassembly.html https://www.infoworld.com/article/3613873/microsoft-gets-ser...
- NVHacker 5y agoAnyone still uses Chrome for personal stuff ?
- travoc 5y agoNo, my household has shifted everything to Brave or Safari with AdGuard.
- nicce 5y agoBrave is also developed by yet another ad based company, and is also Chromium based. I’m not so sure if grass is greener on this site, as the money always decides in the end.
- propogandist 5y agoIt's an operation that still need their bills paid. It's created and run by the guy that created firefox and javascript, I'd rather trust him than a publicly traded advertising company that generates 80% of its revenue by harvesting user data and influencing search results.
- nicce 5y agoThere is no denying he is innovative, but his morals or principles are not very pure. There is a reason why he left Mozilla and why some actions of Brave are quite questionable.
- SLWW 5y agoFirefox Nightly is a pretty good browser imho Also it just so happens that there are extensions that allow you detailed (read: raw and editable) cookie data for each website you visit!
- cpmsmith 5y agoYou don't even need extensions, that's available in the stock developer tools. Though you have to be on the site at the time to access it.
- einpoklum 5y agoFirefox crippled extension support several years ago, denying them access to the internal APIs for JS code. ... this, despite the fact that all the APIs are there, and internally, FF is essentially a bunch of "chrome extensions" on top of the C++ core. That is, the only thing that was removed was the ability to _load_ extensions. FYI.
- deathanatos 5y agoI use & love Firefox, too, but do note that the author's criticism directly applies to it, too: AFAIK, FF will not show you the individualized cookies, or all you to act on them individually. Now, as you say, you can download an extension (and indeed, I do!), but I think there is some merit to it being in the base app. (E.g., not having to trust an extension. But also, it's part of Firefox's data, and FF should provide decent tooling for itself.)
- yborg 5y agoFirefox used to show individual site cookies in the Manage Data dialog, this was removed at some point.
- kenhwang 5y agoI'm running the latest developer build and it still has this. It only shows number of cookies by domain and allows deletion by domain, and you'd have to use dev tools if you wanted to look at or delete a single individual cookie.
- bronlund 5y agoIf you move the letters G (Google) and C (Chrome) two letters down the alphabet, you get IE.
- forgotmypw17 5y agoAs of today, my main workstation is an "early 2008" iMac, at El Capitan and Chrome maxed out at 83.x... In addition to Chrome, I'm using six other browsers which work well with HN, my own sites, fb, gmail, ... I think in today's Web we've achieved an incredible level of compatibility, interoperability, and accessibility. Are there many sites which don't work across 25 years or 15 years or even 5 years worth of client software? Sure, but... There are also restaurants I don't go to, roads I don't walk down, and people I don't associate with... When a site tells me my browser is not good enough, I just turn around and stop visiting, e.g. twitter, reddit, imgur... The Web is better than ever for me, thanks to this strategy. I've heard it called boundaries and self-respect. -- Written on a 2012 iPad mini with iOS 9.x Safari.
- blacksmith_tb 5y agoIt's laudable to keep old hardware in service, but there are a lot of serious security issues with such old versions of the browsers. If that machine is your only option, I personally would install Ubuntu on it, which would get you current versions of Firefox and Chrome (but of course wouldn't run OSX apps you may depend on).
- chrononaut 5y agoAre you not worried about security vulnerabilities?
- forgotmypw17 5y agoFrom where?
- Sunspark 5y agoSpeaking for myself here, no. It's not actually that easy to just "own" people randomly through their browser or network connection. First you have to be malicious, then you have to get them to engage with you directly, then you have to be skilled enough to have code ready to go for their specific circumstances. Most of the sites I visit are normal ones like HN. The ones that are not, there's only so much malware an advertising network can stuff in when ublock is present.
- jacquesm 5y agoThey are really on a roll there, how many user hostile moves is that in the last 30 days? I think I lost count at 4. And all in the name of 'helping our users to improve their experience'. Since when is removing features that users depend on a positive? But with the competition as good as dead they can do whatever they want: the bulk of the audience is now captive and has lost either the willpower or the means to attempt to escape. It's about time we reboot this web thing.
- firebaze 5y agoJust sell your google stock in the next few months. I wonder why Microsoft doesn't sue Google, they're repeating the Internet Explorer story almost step-by-step.
- SquareWheel 5y agoThey've abandoned their browser for five years until it stagnated, slowing progress on the web for all?
- jraph 5y ago> the bulk of the audience is now captive And they don't know it for the most part. People not into computers don't realize what is going on. Sadly, many people into computers don't really care neither. I still try to speak about privacy and why I think we should care when natural in the conversation with people who are likely to be interested. Often, people actually show interest, especially if you take their perspective in account.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hughrr 5y agoBack to Gopher!
- decremental 5y agoLook around you. Does it seem like doing bad things that some people have a problem with is some of kind impedes? There is always an overwhelming majority of people who don't care. That is their power. It's not going away.
- londons_explore 5y agoHow many users are there who want to delete some but not all cookies for a site, yet aren't able to use the F12 developer tools to do so? I can see some users delete cookies to prevent tracking, but should those users really be deciding which cookies to keep and which to delete when nearly all cookies have very user unfriendly names and data contents? Given that, I agree with the Chrome team here. There shouldn't be a general-public UI to manipulate individual cookies, since making a mistake is very likely and leaks the user's private info. Power users can use the F12 tools.
- indymike 5y ago> There shouldn't be a general-public UI to manipulate individual cookies, since making a mistake is very likely and leaks the user's private info. Power users can use the F12 tools Um, I'm pretty sure deleting a cookie or too isn't going to leak my private data. If it does, it is because some third party website defaults to doing the stupidest thing possible.
- londons_explore 5y agoThe leak is that you think you've deleted the right tracking cookie, but since the site uses 20 cookies for tracking different kinds of state you haven't.
- indymike 5y agoUm... there are reasons other than privacy to delete a cookie. Many reasons.
- foota 5y agoI don't get why people think this is a move with some agenda, most likely they just don't think enough people use the single cookie deletion functionality to warrant having it in the settings vs the dev tools.
- BHSPitMonkey 5y agoThe hyperbole in this thread is insane. I would wager that none of the furious "this is pure evil!" commenters in this thread even knew this particular settings page existed before today (and I'd bet they still don't know the information is already exposed in the URL bar). Nobody who isn't a web developer is out there trying to guess what individual cookie names/values mean or wants to delete individual ones. At most, they just want to be able to clear them per-site (or across the entire browser). Anyone else will use the Developer Tools UI that's better suited for the task.
- jychang 5y agoDeleting cookies for a group of sites is essential, though, and they're removing that. Think facebook.com, fbcdn.net, etc. I end up having to delete cookies for Cars.com every other week, because sometimes the search function would corrupt something and every page would return a blank white screen.
- BHSPitMonkey 5y agoNo they're not. That feature exists on chrome://settings/content/all, which the article states they're keeping (as it's preferred over the separate menu being removed).
- crazygringo 5y agoExactly this. All the functionality is already built into Chrome right here: https://developer.chrome.com/docs/devtools/storage/cookies/ https://developer.chrome.com/docs/devtools/storage/cookies/ Contrary to the headline, Chrome isn't removing the ability to do anything -- they're just removing it from the preferences interface, where I'm not sure it really ever made sense to include in the first place. Truly, editing/deleting individual cookies isn't something any regular user ever needs to do -- just clearing per-site, which continues to exist in preferences.
- cptskippy 5y agoSo why do developers still use Chrome?
- x0x0 5y agoI have access to browser stats for a b2b saas. The majority of our customers use chrome for the app. Approx 70% chrome, 28% chromium, 2% safari (almost entirely mobile). NB: we discourage mobile or you'd see more ios; the main site is approx 50% safari (of that, > 95% mobile). Last time I looked, only one person had used firefox in the trailing 3 months.
- userbinator 5y agoTwo words: Google propaganda.
- dlvktrsh 5y agoflutter
- mark_l_watson 5y agoA bit off topic, but I frequently just delete all cookies on all browsers on my devices. Since I just use Safari on iOS/iPadOS/macOS and Chrome on Linux, this is such a quick thing to do. I also try to make using a private browser tab or page as my normal way to do web browsing.
- melbourne_mat 5y agoAgreed. Duck Duck browser on Android has a very prominent "burn" button next to the URL bar which deletes everything. It's great!
- nichos 5y agoSame with Firefox focus on Android. Has a trash can ready to reset the browser.
- arathore 5y agoIt's not even a niche use cases, many times IT teams would suggest deleting the cookies and cache for a specific site to overcome common login issues.
- gerash 5y agoLooks like a reasonable change. Individual cookies are website implementation details that's only useful to the website developer.
- hamburgerwah 5y agoJust how much of a middle finger can they give to users before people wake up and move to Firefox? There was a time Firefox had some performance problems but that time has passed, it works every bit as well as Chrome does now, if not better.
- franklyt 5y agoFirefox is not as performant as Chrome is. This is something a web developer will have come across, if not an average user.
- butz 5y agoWhile Chrome performance is obviously better for browsing, somehow opening DevTools makes it work much slower. As for casual user, installing ad-blocker makes web browsing way faster.
- SquareWheel 5y agoIf you leave Disable Cache checked under the network tab, the web will be substantially slower with dev tools open. This is (likely) the default setting, because it's important for testing.
- qutreM 5y agoIncremental changes toward a shitty browser.
- rdiddly 5y agoAre we even sure what the final page is going to look like? "We're deprecating the old one" doesn't necessarily mean "We're finished building the new one."
- zmmmmm 5y agoWe're getting into the scary space now where it's becoming feasible for sites to insist on Chrome and drop support for other browsers. I've hit two such apps in the last month where not only did the app not work on FireFox, but the experience was completely broken (blank page, etc). So they aren't even bothering with enough testing to put up a "please use chrome" message. I use FireFox for everything personal and Chrome for development. I'd encourage others to do the same. Apart from expressing a "vote" for web standards and interoperability, it also ensures that by default you are separating personal from work / dev which makes things a lot easier when you want to nuke all your browser settings / cache / cookies etc.
- munro 5y agoSame, I switched to FireFox recently as well. Lol if they think they can make these changes, and remain dominant (speaking Apple as well), then they should look at what happened to Freenode. Personally, I'm really just lazy, but I can go back to compiling my own Linux distros if it means I can control my system.
- echelon 5y agoDemand the break up of Google! Now! Email your reps. Tell them this is dangerous and that Google shouldn't be allowed to run the entire web. Take chrome away!
- warning26 5y agoThe issue here is that "making a web browser" isn't a sustainable business. You could force Google to spin off Chrome...and then what? The new "Chrome Inc." would probably need to either start integrating ads or start charging money to even have a chance at not immediately going under. The only reason Firefox is even able to exist is Google propping them up with lots of extra money.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoThere are some interesting experiments around Firefox forks funded by Patreon. Though not sure how viable they are against a hostile web.
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago"As far as I know, there's been no public discussion of this change, and Google employees may have accidentally leaked the information to me in my innocuous bug report." There are constant changes to Chrome and these get pushed out in "updates" to selected groups of users, aka "Field Trials". I have never seen any public discussion of any of these changes prior to including them in automatic updates. What makes this change to user control over site data any different. In fact, I can recall years ago Chrome used to let users change Javascript and Cookies settings on a global or per site basis, and from the Address Bar not only a "Settings" page. Then, without any discussion or debate amongst end users, Google changed Chrome. (Note Javascript is needed to store site data via "LocalStorage".) Today, in "Guest mode" on a Chromebook, it's impossible for the user to disable Javascript or Cookies globally in Chrome. Being logged in to the Chromebook is a prerequisite for globally disabling Javascript or Cookies. There is never debate on these design decisions. These are dark patterns. How effective are user complaints at influencing Chrome development. Please cite evidence. Perhaps what we need are user-controlled solutions. Side note: I can remember a time when it was considered a monumental task to get the entire web-using population to download a new/updated web browser. Almost like a flag day. Today, there is no need for a campaign to get users to "install the latest version of [web browser]." The concept of automating updates is great, but I am not a fan of today's software using "automatic updates" because the way in which developers are using it is user-hostile. "In my opinion, this change is very unwelcome. It takes away a lot of information and control from the user. For what benefit?" BEGIN Devil's advocate/"Google's advocate" Since this is "the orange site", usually it begins with something like, "Googler here. Opinions are my own not Google's." Our confidential studies show that individuals like the blog author comprise a minority of Chrome users. The majority of users are not aware of such "issues"; they do not publish blogs or give feedback to Google. By all accounts the majority remain satisfied with Chrome as they are not switching to alternatives. We have dominant market share. Our focus is on delivering the best experience for users. Lucky for us, this also happens to be the best experience for our customers, advertisers, and therefore the best outcome for Google. Its win-win-win. It would not be an efficient use of our limited resources to offer a version of the Chrome browser (e.g., field trial) that met the requirements of this blog author, but failed to meet the evolving requirements of Google. Altough we provide free services to our users, we are a business not a charity. If we fail, then the entire world suffers. However we are continually experimenting with improvements to the browser, e.g., based on lawsuits that governments file against us, and we are testing them on various segments of our user base, without needing the user's prior approval for every update. We believe this is the best use of Google's limited resources. END Devil's advocate/Google's advocate The orange site commenter's task should be to refute the Google advocate (or defend it). Or even better, give us a more entertaining/thought-provoking Devil's advocate. A fundamental rule of negotiation is that if one can understand the other side's arguments, then she will be far more effective at advancing her own arguments. ("It's difficult to determine Google's motivation for this change." Maybe that's intentional. Maybe Google does not want to open these decisions up for "debate" or negotiation with those affected, i.e., end users.) "I hope to spur a public debate about it and give some pushback to Google before they make too much "progress" on the change in Chrome." Good luck. Can someone remind us when that has ever worked before in bringing about changes by Google for the sole benefit of users. With Privacy Sandbox/FLOC, it appears that debate did stop other browsers from adopting it, but it did not stop Chrome from adopting it. The more interesting question IMO is what are the possible solutions and how well do they work in practice. For example, 1. Stop using Chrome 2. Use some Chrome extension that "solves" the problem 3. Complain about Chrome on a blog or in a forum and hope for the best Personally, I have chosen to control site data outside the browser, using a forward proxy. The proxy software does not automatically update itself, it does not run "field trials", and it is not being sued by dozens of goverments. I do not have to make complaints on a blog to try to influence its development. Unlike a web browser from an online advertising funded entity, I have reasonable control over the operation of the software. Through the proxy I can control browsers like Chrome, including headers such as cookies and clear-site-data (https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Headers/Clear-Site-Data https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Headers/Cl...). Nonetheless, I fully subscribe to #1 as the current best solution.
- notatoad 5y agoi typically access this information by clicking the lock icon in the URL bar. is that going away too, or just the version in the settings page (which i didn't know existed until now)
- loosescrews 5y agoIs it possible that they are combining the pages and will still have the same functionality? I personally find it very confusing that Chrome has two different pages for managing cookies. I pretty much always want the manage individual cookies page, but each time I find the other page first which only lets me clear all cookies and have to track down the page I really want.
- butz 5y agoWe're coming up to times where websites are encrypted binary blobs and only browser who can open them is Chrome. And you have to provide your personal data, to access them, of course.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- theo-born 5y agoI mean, if you have Firefox with Temporary Containers addon installed you won't ever have to care about cookie management at all. Every time I have to use a browser without containers, I feel so exposed knowing how much tracking and telemetry is out there. It's like going out without using deodorant, thats the best way to put it.
- iamfbpt 5y agoHope brave does the same as soon as they can.
- iamfbpt 5y agoHope Brave Browser does the same asap.
- derefr 5y agoAnyone here ever wanted a UI outside of the Devtools for deleting individual keys out of a site’s localStorage? No? Didn’t think so. If this individual-cookies-manager settings page didn’t already exist, would you think it worth it to introduce one? More worth it than an individual-localStorage-keys-manager (which clearly nobody is scrabbling for)? If so, why?
- rtpg 5y agoUmmm loads of time I end up in weird redirect loops that I solve by deleting cookies one-by-one. When dealing with cookies I don’t want to just wipe all of them! Sometimes I just want to deal with some of them. Not as a developer but as a user of the SSO multidomain 20-redirect hellscape
- derefr 5y agoMaybe you didn't understand the rhetorical intent of my question. Let me restate. There are just as many weird problems with websites that cannot currently be fixed in this "pick and choose" manner, because the corrupted state is a single key in the site's localStorage. Instead, the current solution is "blow away the site's localStorage as a whole." (And, in fact, it's usually even less granular than this; you'd usually hit "clear Storage" in the Devtools, blowing away localStorage, AppCache, and a number of other things, all at once.) Sites' localStorage is thought of as a kind of opaque per-site database—not something to be picked through by users, but rather something that's either in a valid state, or in a corrupt state where it should be purged. And, as far as I know, that paradigm has been working just fine for everyone! Nobody knows enough about a site they didn't develop themselves to make a change to a single key in a site's localStorage that will take it from a corrupt state to a valid state. The average user—even the average developer—is only likely to corrupt the state further, by making changes roughly at random. We all just "purge localStorage" as one of the "the site is doing weird shit" debugging steps, and never ask for a finer scalpel than that—because that fine scalpel would essentially be akin to picking through the site's memory one raw address-value pair at a time. There'd be no context. It'd be useless, unless-and-until you went through a laborious brute-forcing process. It's great that you've figured out how to delete particular individual cookies for a site, but you must realize that you learned what worked in each case by brute-force trial and error, in ways that likely corrupted the site's state innumerable times before you created a new valid state. That what you were doing was essentially akin to creating a Game Genie code for the website, poking and prodding at its (opaque!) memory in the hopes that you'll get a useful result, rather than a program crash. And the argument being put forward in this comments section, is that the mindset required to create a Game Genie code or something like it, automatically implies that the right "home" for said process is the Devtools UX anyway. The Devtools UX gives you the tools needed for iteration and experimentation (a REPL; a live view of the site as you poke at it; etc); while the Settings UX is for knobs and switches where you know what button you want to press from the start, and just need an efficient navigation hierarchy that will let you find it and press it. By deleting individual cookies within a site's cookie jar, you're debugging that site—poking and prodding at it iteratively—whether you call it that or not. So why expose a secondary, non-iterative interface for doing so? You'd just be encouraging people to do an inherently-iterative process more painfully by using a non-iterative interface.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- andy_ppp 5y agoI decided a while ago that I should move away from Chrome and I’ve quite liked Edge but thinking about it I really don’t trust them either. I still don’t love Firefox on Mac OS, what else should I try?
- kataklasm 5y agoi have been using qutebrowser for quite some time now. it uses QtWebEngine based on chromium but it's a project entirely unique apart from that. vim-based comtrol scheme and relatively mininmal approach. https://qutebrowser.org https://qutebrowser.org
- freediver 5y agoOrion Browser is the new WebKit based browser for Mac which promises direct Chrome/Firefox extension support. https://browser.kagi.com https://browser.kagi.com
- flippinburgers 5y agoThis is just a move to obfuscate understanding of cookies per website. Weird.
- dheera 5y agoDoes this apply to Chromium as well, or can we just fork Chromium and keep adding the feature back?
- sub7 5y agofirefox has been the only half decent option for a long time google is shit spyware
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- xg15 5y agoOut of couriosity: Does anyone know how such decisions are made inside Google? It all seems very opaque.
- tzfld 5y agoI'm pretty sure you will not get an answer to this on a public forum.
- lrem 5y agoI'm a Googler working on something else, but I think the rough process will be the same: 1. Product management decides which audiences should get special attention. 2. UX researchers get hold of a number of users matching those audiences. Interview them what are their pain points with the product and observe them stumble through a bunch of critical journeys. 3. UX designers design how that should go instead. 4. Eng (including UI) design how to make that happen. 5. The design doc goes through approvals from all the above, but also legal, security, privacy and other stakeholders. After that, it's a simple matter of programming.
- Missthy59 5y agoI really liked this article you shared. Thanks for taking the time to write it <a href="https://driftboss.co https://driftboss.co"> drift boss </a>
- sopheadave 5y agoBad day for developers indeed
- PhantomBKB 5y agoCookie quick manager is a pretty good extension for managing cookies in Firefox. It gives you fine-grained control on all cookies for each domain. https://github.com/ysard/cookie-quick-manager/ https://github.com/ysard/cookie-quick-manager/
- bugmen0t 5y agoRegardless of the motivation behind this change, bear in mind in whose interest the company and browser is working: The shareholders. I can only think of one high-quality browser that belongs to a non profit. Mozilla Firefox. All money earned with it goes back to the browser. Sure, I’ve heard that executive may have been paid a subjectively “too high” salary and however true that may be: So far, no Executive who would actively question the mission and the core privacy principles has been able to stay for long. The web is the most open, most unowned application platform out there. It’s too important for single-vendor control.
- Razengan 5y agoOF COURSE they would remove that option! Google is one of the worst abusers of cookies: If you use any Google app on iOS, it makes you sign in through a web view, which sets some system-wide cookies. Meaning if you just want to sign into YouTube, and later search something in Safari etc., you will find yourself signed into Google Search! I always have to go into the cookies settings and filter by “Google” and remove all of them to get that scummy tracking off my ass. Same thing with any Google service on desktop browsers. Seriously, Fuck Google.
- _pmf_ 5y agoWell, it's their internet. They can do what they want with it.
- sharmin123 5y agoLet’s Secure WiFi Network and Prevent WiFi Hacking: https://www.hackerslist.co/lets-secure-wifi-network-and-prevent-wifi-hacking/ https://www.hackerslist.co/lets-secure-wifi-network-and-prev...
- timwaagh 5y agoNot so smart of Google. Ninety nine percent of their users won't use them and the ones that do are likely to be programmers. Maybe their own people. They have an outsize influence on what gets used and more importantly what gets supported. And that may mean a boost for the competition
- zxspectrum1982 5y agoWhy do browsers insist on alienating their users?