4 ms·
All governments, everywhere, suck, but the UK coalition appears to have been sucking less than most recently...
by peteretep 15y ago
All governments, everywhere, suck, but the UK coalition appears to have been sucking less than most recently...
- arethuza 15y agoGive them time - I will admit that they do seem to be doing an unexpectedly decent job so far, but even New Labour seemed to be decent enough in their first couple of years. Edit: Maybe what we need is a limit on the number of years a PM can serve for?
- peteretep 15y agoI have this pet theory that coalition is always going to be the way forward for the UK. All the mainstream parties have some pretty good ideas, with a few pieces of radical idiocy on the edges. In coalition, parties can drop the radical bullshit parts, while implementing all the sensible ideas they have.
- Zumzoa 15y agoHowever, this system also blunts such 'radical edges' as civil unions, equalizing the age of consent, reform of drug laws and large infrastructure reforms.
- arethuza 15y agoWe should have some way of the public identifying "extraordinary" issues (e.g. online petitions) and then having periodic referendums where the public can vote directly on these topics. Otherwise, as you point out, there are many topics that will simply be ignored.
- pbhjpbhj 15y agoWe do have an online petition system, http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/ http://epetitions.direct.gov.uk/. I'll agree that we need some system like that in Switzerland where a large enough proportion of the population can force a referendum.
- mhw 15y agoI agree with you to some extent, but the problem is that the political parties have decades of experience with the current winner-takes-all model. If we were to move to a model where they have to share power and cooperate they would have to completely rethink the way the parties market themselves to the electorate. At the moment they write a manifesto, and people expect them to deliver on what the manifesto says if they get in. With a coalition no party can guarantee that, so the manifesto loses its value. The criticism that the Liberal Democrats ran in to demonstrates the problem: they campaigned for proportional representation, which I believe would be more likely to deliver coalition governments, and even on their most optimistic days I don't think they would believe they could gain a parliamentary majority. Knowing that, publicly signing a pledge around student tuition fees was hopelessly naive, as there was no way they could ever guarantee they would deliver on their pledge. And if the Lib Dems haven't worked out how to market themselves in a coalition government, you can guarantee the two main parties won't have done.
- pbhjpbhj 15y ago>Maybe what we need is a limit on the number of years a PM can serve for? We do, the country votes every 5 years. That's a democratic limit. PMs die too but I guess you were thinking of a shorter hard limit.
- rickmb 15y agoIn countries where corporate political financing is not a decisive factor in the elections, it takes some time for corporations to buy their way into a new government. Plus those in power take some time to switch their focus from dealing with the immediate issues to the corrupting issue of "building their legacy". Just be patient.