4 ms·
I've never had the opportunity to view my website on a high-DPI screen. I strongly suspect that what looks good on my large HD monitor does not look good on a h
by lelanthran 5y ago
I've never had the opportunity to view my website on a high-DPI screen. I strongly suspect that what looks good on my large HD monitor does not look good on a high-DPI screen.
As you are someone who is on a high-DPI screen, can you tell me what changes you'd make to the font/typography in this link to make it more readable? Maybe screenshot it so I can see what it appears like on your screen.
http://www.lelanthran.com/simply_wordy/articles/the_average_developer_effect/main.html http://www.lelanthran.com/simply_wordy/articles/the_average_...
I realise that I'm asking a favour of you for primarily my own benefit, but I would be very appreciative of your feedback.
- eloisius 5y agoYou didn't ask me, but I'm on a 5K display and I'll give you my take. The paragraph text looks fine. Maybe bump the font size up a tiny bit and give it a little more width than 620px. This is personal preference, but I'm not a huge fan of small caps, especially when applied too liberally. It usually looks better on paper, but on the screen it looks too wide and too unbalanced to me. Last, the drop shadows are superfluous, look pretty ugly, and actually distract from the otherwise minimal and attractive design of your site, especially on my phone. Last last: I'd ditch or at least de-emphasize the social share icons. My hunch is that no one uses them anyway, and having them hang out at the top of the screen no matter where you scroll is distracting.
- lelanthran 5y agoThank you so very much! All of these items are noted and I'll give them a try. I's actually really hard to get an indication of how readable your blog is to HN viewers without actually spamming it to HN.
- jfk13 5y agoAnother small detail: don't use a hyphen as punctuation in cases like > let’s move on - what happens ... It looks rather lost and lonely, floating there between the parts of the sentence. What you want here is an em dash—like this—to separate the phrases. (It's Unicode character U+2014, or the — entity in HTML.) It is often set without any surrounding spaces, though some people — perhaps depending on the font being used — like to have a thin space (U+2009) before and after. A regular space is certainly too much.
- lelanthran 5y agoI'll look into that; I don't know how that is done in emacs (thee entire website is generated from emacs org mode files).
- oefrha 5y agoComputer Modern is known to be on the thin side for digital displays, and I've seen quite a few people argue that it's a risky choice for legibility. Personally, I find it perfectly legible on macOS/iOS, but renders poorly on Windows, especially in Chrome/Edge; Firefox handles it better.
- jfk13 5y agoI think it's true to say it is a "risky choice for legibility". If (as you say) it "renders poorly on Windows, especially in Chrome/Edge", that means the great majority of website visitors are going to see poor rendering, no matter how "perfectly legible" you find it on your system.
- agys 5y agoI have a few comments unrelated to high DPI that could better the readability, slightly: The indents of the first line of the paragraphs are not necessary as the paragraphs are already spaced vertically. Chose one: vertical separation or indentation, this will reduce the noise of the page slightly (or as I call it: the vibration). Justified text is very hard and I’d generally avoid it where it can’t be controlled (it’s ok for print or where it can be adjusted). There is too much space between words that will form “rivers”, again: noise on the page… You are probably safer with left aligned text. Footnotes could have a different aspect to differentiate from the body text. Smaller? Lighter? Up to you. Finally: the font renders perfectly on my hi DPI screen but I’m not sure about the bold weight; it looks like it’s derived from the book? Is the correct weight installed or is it computed?
- Sharlin 5y agoAlso unrelated to hiDPI, but I would rethink the heading font (Copperplate?) It’s both somewhat overused and IMHO not a great match with the body font, visually.
- kibbleble 5y agoIt's okay on mobile (Android, Google pixel 2). The font is slightly larger than HN's (HN is tiny for some reason). It's still small by modern standards, so bumping up the font a couple points will help. How it looks: https://ibb.co/Q84h9gM https://ibb.co/Q84h9gM In Opera's reader mode: https://ibb.co/HtsDnCV https://ibb.co/HtsDnCV
- 16bytes 5y agoI had the same issue on my screens in that the body font size was too small to read comfortably. I tried a few different CSS modifications, but it seems like that particular font just doesn't perform well on a wide variety of screens. As for a better option, it's hard to do a lot better than standard "web safe" fonts for body copy, or a typeface that was designed specifically for digital readability (e.g. Roboto, Open Sans, etc).
- Narishma 5y agoIt's hard to read even on my low DPI screen. The font is too small and thin. On the plus side, at least it's not light grey on white.
- Semaphor 5y agoOn my FHD screen, all but the italics looks good, the italic parts are hard to read (but that’s most certainly the font). On my QHD monitor, I need to zoom in (120%) to comfortably read the text. The heading font looks ugly on both.