3 ms·
Sorry but this is the dumbest thing I've heard in the entire internet today. So basically what they did was they trained a deep neural net to predict the behavi
by YeGoblynQueenne 5y ago
Sorry but this is the dumbest thing I've heard in the entire internet today. So
basically what they did was they trained a deep neural net to predict the
behaviour of a simulated rat neuron. Then they claimed that the number of layers
and units in the deep neural net is somehow a measure of the complexity of a
"biological neuron".
First of all, they didn't try to model the behaviour of a biological neuron,
only of a model of a biological neuron, and an incomplete model at that. The
article points that out itself.
More importantly, the claim rests on the assumption that a deep neural net
architecture is somehow a sensible measure of the complexity of a completely
unrelated process (as far as I can tell, deep neural nets are not in anyway
related to simulated rat neurons). But this is a big, huge, gigantic assumption.
Suppose I train a bunch of humans to predict the behaviour of a simulated rat
neuron. Suppose I find out that I need to train at least 1000 humans to
accurately predict the simulated rat neuron's behaviour. What does that mean?
That 1000 human brains are as complex as a simulated rat neuron?
Come to that- can a single human brain predict the behaviour of a simulated rat
neuron? I'm prepared to wager that, no, it can't, because human brains are
rubbish at prediction tasks like that. What does that mean? That a simulated rat
neuron is more complex than a human with an entire human brain?
The entire premise of the work is absurd nonsense and it probably only got a
mention in Quanta because it's something released by DeepMind. Irritating.
- orbifold 5y agoScience is in large part also about story telling, especially in some areas. This is a good story, even if the details make it much less spectacular. They also produced very nice visualisations, which blew up on Twitter. All of these things are something to learn from as a scientist.
- dekhn 5y agoThe lesson is that while people say they make data-driven decisions, scientists like everybody else just goes for the narrative with the prettiest picture that also looks like what people think is already true.