4 ms·
Yeah. They have an 80,000 ton carrier coming. We have 120,000 ton carriers and F35s. Does China have an airplane that can beat our airplane? Our Aircraft Carri
by dragontamer 5y ago
Yeah. They have an 80,000 ton carrier coming.
We have 120,000 ton carriers and F35s. Does China have an airplane that can beat our airplane? Our Aircraft Carriers can hold something like 4 or 5 squadrons and do nearly simultaneous launch + landing exercises.
How quickly can that hypothetical 30% smaller Chinese Aircraft Carrier launch and land aircraft? Are there any advanced air platforms or stealth platforms that can spy on US Navy positions?
China will have 3 aircraft carriers by 2030, all under 100,000 tons. US will have 7 of 120,000 tons all equipped with F35s, each with a veteran crew that's been training on those systems since 2015 (15 years of experience).
Can those 3-Chinese carriers even take on one of ours in a fight on the open sea?
- echelon 5y agoYour tonnage argument is good for the short term, but they won't be behind for long. And if they hit our aircraft carriers with the hypersonic missiles they've developed, our advantage disappears outright.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Your tonnage argument is good for the short term, but they won't be behind for long. It takes years to build a carrier. There's no 100,000+ carrier being built by the Chinese at all. Its not their strategy. > And if they hit our aircraft carriers with the hypersonic missiles they've developed, our advantage disappears outright. How do those missiles hit a target they can't see? That's why the US has spent so much money shoving the most expensive radar suites on F35 fighters, so that those airplanes can radio-back to their ships about the position of enemies. Basically: to have the same sight and stealth as the USA, China has to develop an F35 analog of their own.
- sudosysgen 5y agoYou're not making a stealth carrier. You can't hide a carrier. And no, China doesn't need an F35 analog. They need frontal stealth and they can operate from runways. The game is the SCS, not CONUS.
- dragontamer 5y ago> You're not making a stealth carrier. You can't hide a carrier. Yes you can. Step 1: Run out to the ocean to an area where satellites aren't over consistently. Step 2: Move randomly at 35 mph with your twin nuclear engines. Step 3: Where's the carrier? -------- You can't scan the whole ocean. Its physically impossible, even with satellite coverage. No stealth capabilities needed at all, you just hide in the vast emptiness that is the ocean itself.
- sudosysgen 5y agoHow far are you going to go at 35mph in the 2 hour hole you have? 70 miles? How are you going to hide a 300m object in a 70 mile area? It just cannot be done. It's not possible.
- dragontamer 5y ago> 70 mile area You missed a square and a pi. That's a 15,386 square mile area.
- sudosysgen 5y ago15k square mile is really not a lot for a 300m target in the ocean. I think you seriously underestimate modern surveillance.
- dragonwriter 5y ago> You can't scan the whole ocean. No, but you can scan the radius of uncertainty of where a known carrier-sized object may have gone in a satellite gap of a few hours at a top speed of say 40 kts, known maneuvering capability, and a known starting position and velocity, pretty easily. Now, if you add teleportation in so you have to scan the whole ocean, sure, but that’s a big “if”.
- dragontamer 5y agoIs there any reason to think your satellite, drone, or spy plane will survive that 2-hour window in a wartime scenario to in fact, pick out the aircraft carrier in the 15,000 sq. mile area it could have traveled?
- nradov 5y agoThat is a risk, but it's tough to localize and hit a moving target. In any major conflict the reconnaissance satellites are likely to be knocked out quickly on both sides, which means everyone will be relying on aircraft and submarines to develop missile targeting tracks. They can't be everywhere at once. And carrier escorts now carry ABMs which have proven at least moderately effective in tests.
- sudosysgen 5y agoCarriers are very big, very slow moving targets that change their velocity very slowly. With a 1200mm f/8 lens you can detect an aircraft carrier from 300km away.
- nradov 5y agoWhat platform is carrying that hypothetical lens? How does it avoid being destroyed before detecting and tracking the target? How does it data link targeting targeting data back to offensive platforms? What is the visible horizon range at its operating altitude? How well does it see at night, or through clouds?
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe lens is given as a general example you can easily apply the Rayleigh criterion to to verify. You can use many other types of sensors. You could carry such a sensor on a satellite, a drone, or even the missile itself. You need to get within 300km of the carrier once. It doesn't matter if it's the 15th try or if you don't survive either. You really overestimate air defences if you think an airwing can do that. And of course you can make even better sensors, we have the technology and it's been practically done.
- nradov 5y agoThe satellites are vulnerable and will likely be the first casualties in any major conflict. Neither side can afford to build enough long range drones with powerful sensors to blanket large areas of open ocean. Sometimes adversaries will get lucky and have the right platform in the right place at the right time, but it's hardly a sure thing. In the end it will probably come down more to timing and luck than any other factors.
- jbay808 5y agoFunny, 30% is also about how much larger the Yamato was than the Iowa class. But it turned out larger battleships weren't the deciding factor that time. Who knows whether larger carriers will matter for winning the next war?
- dragontamer 5y agoEach US Supercarrier has two runways and four catapults. That's why they weigh so much. Tonnage isn't the only factor. But presumably, having two runways on one carrier is a key advantage in carrier based combat. If you can launch aircraft faster than the opponent, you'll get more aircraft in the air before they can. Can China's 3x aircraft carriers launch as many airplanes as one of our supercarriers? How many Chinese aircraft need to launch to have a chance against an F35C?
- detritus 5y agoI feel the biggest advantage the West - in particular the US - has over china is 40-60 years worth of pretty much continual/high state of combat-readiness experience and culture.
- dirtyid 5y agoUSCGs can't stay out at sea forever. They have to dock eventually, even nuclear powered carriers. At minimal the oilers and replenishment fleet that sustains them will be vulnerable to port strikes with conventionally tipped ICBMs and shortened kill chain. USN can tactically sink every PLAN ship due to exquisit capabilities in an opening salvo, but operationally PRC can produce/harden enough land based rocketry forces to destroy/degrade enough of USN capita assets that any victory would be pyrrhic. We're in the era of 30CEP ICBMs. Fortress America isn't inpregnable anymore.