7 ms·
> Their navy and armament are rapidly approaching parity. With their economy, it'll likely surpass us. Their navy is approaching ours in terms of tonnage. But
by dragontamer 5y ago
> Their navy and armament are rapidly approaching parity. With their economy, it'll likely surpass us.
Their navy is approaching ours in terms of tonnage. But they're lacking in carriers at the moment.
This means that their navy can work anywhere with good missile/air force support. But they lack the ability to force project outward.
> What's the game plan?
Aircraft Carriers and the F35. How can they find our ships at sea, if their drones get shot down? How can they prevent us from finding their ships, if we have superior stealth?
If they can't see our ships, how can they attack, even with a hypersonic nuclear warhead? Aircraft carrier move at 35+ mph and turn on a dime. If it takes 10 minutes for a hypersonic nuclear warhead to be delivered to a location, the aircraft carrier is already 6-miles off target.
- echelon 5y agohttps://twitter.com/CovertShores/status/1431351847810392070?s=19 https://twitter.com/CovertShores/status/1431351847810392070?... https://twitter.com/RupprechtDeino/status/1410199656060133379?s=19 https://twitter.com/RupprechtDeino/status/141019965606013337...
- dragontamer 5y agoYeah. They have an 80,000 ton carrier coming. We have 120,000 ton carriers and F35s. Does China have an airplane that can beat our airplane? Our Aircraft Carriers can hold something like 4 or 5 squadrons and do nearly simultaneous launch + landing exercises. How quickly can that hypothetical 30% smaller Chinese Aircraft Carrier launch and land aircraft? Are there any advanced air platforms or stealth platforms that can spy on US Navy positions? China will have 3 aircraft carriers by 2030, all under 100,000 tons. US will have 7 of 120,000 tons all equipped with F35s, each with a veteran crew that's been training on those systems since 2015 (15 years of experience). Can those 3-Chinese carriers even take on one of ours in a fight on the open sea?
- echelon 5y agoYour tonnage argument is good for the short term, but they won't be behind for long. And if they hit our aircraft carriers with the hypersonic missiles they've developed, our advantage disappears outright.
- dragontamer 5y ago> Your tonnage argument is good for the short term, but they won't be behind for long. It takes years to build a carrier. There's no 100,000+ carrier being built by the Chinese at all. Its not their strategy. > And if they hit our aircraft carriers with the hypersonic missiles they've developed, our advantage disappears outright. How do those missiles hit a target they can't see? That's why the US has spent so much money shoving the most expensive radar suites on F35 fighters, so that those airplanes can radio-back to their ships about the position of enemies. Basically: to have the same sight and stealth as the USA, China has to develop an F35 analog of their own.
- sudosysgen 5y agoYou're not making a stealth carrier. You can't hide a carrier. And no, China doesn't need an F35 analog. They need frontal stealth and they can operate from runways. The game is the SCS, not CONUS.
- dragontamer 5y ago> You're not making a stealth carrier. You can't hide a carrier. Yes you can. Step 1: Run out to the ocean to an area where satellites aren't over consistently. Step 2: Move randomly at 35 mph with your twin nuclear engines. Step 3: Where's the carrier? -------- You can't scan the whole ocean. Its physically impossible, even with satellite coverage. No stealth capabilities needed at all, you just hide in the vast emptiness that is the ocean itself.
- sudosysgen 5y agoHow far are you going to go at 35mph in the 2 hour hole you have? 70 miles? How are you going to hide a 300m object in a 70 mile area? It just cannot be done. It's not possible.
- jbay808 5y agoFunny, 30% is also about how much larger the Yamato was than the Iowa class. But it turned out larger battleships weren't the deciding factor that time. Who knows whether larger carriers will matter for winning the next war?
- dragontamer 5y agoEach US Supercarrier has two runways and four catapults. That's why they weigh so much. Tonnage isn't the only factor. But presumably, having two runways on one carrier is a key advantage in carrier based combat. If you can launch aircraft faster than the opponent, you'll get more aircraft in the air before they can. Can China's 3x aircraft carriers launch as many airplanes as one of our supercarriers? How many Chinese aircraft need to launch to have a chance against an F35C?
- detritus 5y agoI feel the biggest advantage the West - in particular the US - has over china is 40-60 years worth of pretty much continual/high state of combat-readiness experience and culture.
- dirtyid 5y agoUSCGs can't stay out at sea forever. They have to dock eventually, even nuclear powered carriers. At minimal the oilers and replenishment fleet that sustains them will be vulnerable to port strikes with conventionally tipped ICBMs and shortened kill chain. USN can tactically sink every PLAN ship due to exquisit capabilities in an opening salvo, but operationally PRC can produce/harden enough land based rocketry forces to destroy/degrade enough of USN capita assets that any victory would be pyrrhic. We're in the era of 30CEP ICBMs. Fortress America isn't inpregnable anymore.
- yummypaint 5y agoChina has been building so called arsenal ships, which are a possible answer to aircraft carriers
- dragontamer 5y agoIts not too hard to sink an aircraft carrier. The question is: how do you __find__ the aircraft carrier. The sea is a large area.
- echelon 5y agoSatellites?
- dragontamer 5y agoNot as reliable as you'd like, especially at sea. Satellites are either Geosynchronous (aka: the US Navy knows where they are and knows where to avoid them), or they are not Geosynchronous (aka: they only are over a certain area at certain times). Again: your Satellite feed goes dead for just 10 minutes, the Carrier is now 6-miles away (113-square mile search area), with no guarantee that the new area is covered by a satellite either.
- treis 5y agoSatellites + AI and/or lots of people. That will get you in the vicinity. After that, it's a combination of drones and/or smart missiles.
- LargoLasskhyfv 5y agoMaybe with an array of neutrino observatories, pinpointing the glow of any moving nuclear reactor? ;-)
- klyrs 5y ago> How can they find our ships at sea, if their drones get shot down? Satellites? And haven't we been getting pinged by drones in international waters that get away too quickly for us to identify?
- nradov 5y agoSatellites will be the first casualties on both sides in any major conflict. Anti satellite weapons have been successfully tested and are undergoing rapid development.
- sudosysgen 5y agoThe positions of all carriers are being tracked at any time. Antiship ballistic missiles are faster than antisattellite missiles. That said, there are many other possible ways of getting the positions of a carrier, from basic submarines to suicide drones.
- nradov 5y agoNo that's not how it works. The expectation is that satellites will be knocked out before sending carriers into really high threat environments. Antiship ballistic missiles have very limited sensors and maneuvering capability so it's hard to reliably hit a moving target without another platform data linking a continuous track at least through the midcourse phase. Both sides have only small numbers of attack submarines and long-range maritime patrol aircraft, including large drones. The small, cheap suicide drones are mostly useless for open ocean surveillance due to lack of range and weak sensors. This is the real world, not a Hollywood movie.
- sudosysgen 5y agoCost is relative. When you're attacking a carrier you can afford to sacrifice a lot. A surveillance drone can very well be used in a suicide role, and they have more than enough range for this task. Antiship ballistic missiles have strong maneuvering capabilities. You have to look at absolute displacement, not the relative change in velocity. And the sensors required to find a 7000m^2 target are much smaller and limited than you'd think.
- zbrozek 5y agoIs radar stealthiness still relevant? I would assume a combination of microphones&cameras everywhere, internet everywhere, ML everywhere, and satellites have made it obsolete.
- dragontamer 5y agoDo those microphones apply to the open seas? We don't even have geosync satellites that cover the seas today. Not enough travelers to make those areas worth it to cover the satellite launch costs.
- nradov 5y agoLow observable technology is more relevant than ever. It's not magic invisibility but greatly reduces the range at which sensors can detect and track. Microphones can't be placed at sea, and the speed of sound makes effective microphone range very short. Regular cameras are also short ranged, and don't really work at night or through clouds. IR search sensors have very narrow field of view. In any major conflict the reconnaissance satellites will be the first targets.
- zbrozek 5y agoI'm a little surprised by the downvotes of a straightforward and in-good-faith question. The answers are helpful - thanks to those who engaged!
- WJW 5y agoThe DF-21 anti ship ballistic missile (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/DF-21), affectionately known as the "carrier killer" is capable of maneuvering on the way back down from space, at speeds of mach 5-10. The initial guidance would be through satellites and then final phase guidance through a mix of electro-optical and radar guidance. Carriers, while being fairly fast for a ship, would not have enough time to maneuver away from an incoming missile. It is thought that they might not be able to outright sink a carrier but would inflict enough damage that the carrier would need extensive repairs and be out of the fight for several months at least, and that is for the conventionally armed versions. Nuclear tipped ballistic missiles would melt the ship and anything nearby. US anti ballistic missiles (mostly the SM-3 for naval use) have been tested against ballistic missiles but not (as far as I know) in anything other than a test environment. The launchers are mobile and stationed fairly far inland, specifically to be out of easy reach of naval force projection from a carrier group. Source: Used to be a weapons engineer in the Dutch Navy for 14 years, have been out of it for ~5 years now though. These kind of weapons were a major driver for doctrine revisions when I left, since much of Western naval doctrines were/are based on the idea that you could have a fairly safe and unreachable "seabase" a few hundred nm from shore from which to launch assaults. These kind of very long range area denial weapons upend that thought.
- dragontamer 5y agoI certainly agree that Taiwan / near China is going to be problematic because of missiles like that. China seems to have the advantage in a Taiwan-scenario. When those missiles are based on land with much more defenses available to them, its a problem. In a naval scenario (lets say China is attacking Hawaii as a hypothetical), those ballistic missiles will need to be launched from a Chinese ship of their own (3000km range vs Hawaii is still ocean), which means the Carrier + F35 has the edge once more. It seems more likely that our ships will find their ships first (or really, our F35 aircraft will find them first) and neutralize the missile before they lock in on our Carrier's location.
- WJW 5y agoAh yes, my comment was primarily written with a theatre near mainland China in mind. In blue water the carrier group still reigns supreme.
- senectus1 5y agoAlso the Us is very very practiced at force projection. China not so much. It'll still be a hell of a mess but yeah, the US is still better equipped in experience as well as equipment.