6 ms·
Someone could be tracking you through your headphones
- taude 5y agoNot sure there's anything new or unknown with this. Just Google "Bluetooth Proximity Marketing" to see the types of technology stores are using to track customers when they walk in....
- mmgu 5y agoI don't think that many stores track customers and that a lot of the hype from a couple of years ago never ended up in a successful commercialization of the technology. (Full disclosure: Author of linked article.)
- Verdex 5y agoYeah, I got excited when I read "bluetooth proximity marketing" because I was hoping that with a few weekends I could start tricking stores into thinking that everyone I ever bump into just walked into the store with me. However, google returns a bunch of results talking about the stores sending the customer data. And not the other way around. Also the customer needs a specific app. It doesn't sound like anyone is tracking anyone via bluetooth. At the very least, if they are, then "bluetooth proximity marketing" is the wrong keyword to search for.
- OJFord 5y agoI think something similar but very different: not many stores mention it, not much news about it, hardly anybody aware of it. Even companies that provide it talk on their websites about what they'll give you, the data and tooling, not how they'll take it from your customers. (It's also hard to talk about without sounding tin-foil hat... I don't mean to. I'm mostly resigned to it, the state of advertising etc., I mean I'll block it digitally of course, but I'm not going to go shopping in a balaclava with exaggeratedly not-mine gait or anything, just still dislike that that would be necessary if one did care enough, if you see what I mean.)
- spzb 5y agoI agree this is stuff which is common knowledge amongst those of us who know a bit about tech. I think the following quote [0] is probably the novel value of the project : "What is interesting about the dataset is that the best example for location tracking of movements are not vehicles, smartphones or even activity trackers – but headsets that do not have MAC randomization, which may make it easier to track the movements of an individual headset rather than the individual’s smartphone." [0] https://www.hegnes.tech/2021/09/01/location-tracking-of-wifi-access-point-and-bluetooth-devices/#htoc-7-conclusion https://www.hegnes.tech/2021/09/01/location-tracking-of-wifi...
- slipheen 5y ago"Everybody already knows about this, you have no reason to be upset" is a common industry refrain when people get caught doing something they know there is a public outcry against. Whether or not you know about a given thing is irrelevant, it's not a contest. A lot of people don't, and articles to explain it to them are a good thing. Things like this are really invasive, and not appropriate – just because they've been happening for a while doesn't make it more OK, it's just means they've been getting away with it.
- timw4mail 5y agoMaybe I'm just old, but I really like the simplicity of wired headphones. No pairing nonsense, and no tracking (at least from the headphones).
- toast0 5y agoNo lag, no charging, compatible with almost every device that makes noise on a regular basis. Not compatible with recent iOS devices, any Cisco iOS devices, about a years worth of higher end Androids, one flavor of Nintendo GameBoy advance (GBA SP, I think), and some Speak & Spells (modern ones don't have a jack, but some of the antiques do).
- strogonoff 5y agoAdd a small portable DAC/amplifier and you get every benefit of wired plus superior sound quality. With one I started randomly telling apart new notes and passages from individual instruments in songs I heard tons of times before. This is with Ikko Zerda, picked up because it’s what was in stock, most likely this device isn’t special and anything is an improvement over built-in jack. (Lossless music and inexpensive SE215.) Meanwhile, most popular audio codecs that work over BT cap bitrate, making lossless truly useless; most headsets and phones don’t support LDAC, and if you get a lucky combination that does music will likely stutter if you’re anywhere close to a busy area of the city or if your phone is in the wrong pocket. (Where some wireless headsets do win is state of the art active noise cancellation, -30 dB when you’re in a really noisy place without an option to use IEMs or earplugs can be a bliss.)
- sslayer 5y agoAs "Technologist" I hate that we are so quick to dismiss solid, reliable technology in favour of the latest and greatest.
- Abishek_Muthian 5y ago> Where some wireless headsets do win is state of the art active noise cancellation Also audio amplification apps provide hearing aid features on even basic TWS earphones while a typical hearing aid can be very expensive. I was tracking this need on my validation platform[1] and it's one the top most visited problem thread consistently implying many are searching for enabling hearing aid features on their wireless earphones. [1] https://needgap.com/problems/22-enabling-hearing-aid-features-on-tws-earphones-audio-hearingaid https://needgap.com/problems/22-enabling-hearing-aid-feature...
- dogman144 5y agoFinding high quality noise canceling without a voice assistant is getting harder. My sense is if you can find a Bluetooth one w/o registering it with the company app and no voice assistant, privacy risks are low (compared to the cellphone in your pocket).
- takk309 5y agoI have had a great experience with my Audio Technica over-ear headphones. They offer a great line up for most budgets. The feature I like the most is that many of their line up can be used wired or wireless! https://www.audio-technica.com/en-us/headphones/type/wireless https://www.audio-technica.com/en-us/headphones/type/wireles...
- dogman144 5y agoThanks for the Rec
- perryizgr8 5y agoI have galaxy buds and I've turned off the voice assistant feature completely. For now, it is still possible.
- sails 5y agoBose 700 NC have a horrid app, terrible mic, frustrating noise cancelling (NC), and all the tracking too. The Sony equivalent experienced the same issues. I've repaired two pairs of Bose QC25 (wired only) to the point where they no longer have NC, but eventually had to retire them. The NC is very poor relative to modern models. A modern wired-only NC headphone would find a niche but receptive market. Edit: Not to mention the only way to use is through the app.
- makomk 5y agoThe trouble is that traditionally, I think the permanent Bluetooth MAC was how phones knew to reconnect with devices like headphones so it couldn't easily be randomized. This was all designed in an era when people were less paranoid about how tech could be abused.
- est31 5y agoAdmittedly, back then, there has been way less abuse of that kind of tech.
- kook_throwaway 5y agoIts probably fair to say that tech was less abused in that era, not that people were less paranoid about it. Your run of the mill telemetry would have been considered spyware (a term that's nearly dead) back in the day.
- post_break 5y agoHouston highways track Bluetooth to check for traffic speed. You can track cars tpms as well.
- jrochkind1 5y ago> referring to the commercial availability of Bluetooth modules that can listen to messages sent up to one kilometer away. Is this accurate? I had no idea. Following the link it's not clear to me if you can use this module to pick up 'ordinary' bluetooth from a km away (as they imply), or if you'd need a similarly 'strong' special bluetooth on the other end to communicate over 1km.
- titzer 5y agoI'm just so tired all devices being my enemy these days.