7 ms·
ListMonk – High performance, self-hosted newsletter and mailing list manager
- Semaphor 5y agoLast posted 2 years ago, one of the creators is in the thread, 50 comments: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20421243 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=20421243
- knadh 5y agolistmonk author here. Interesting to see it on the frontpage again. Some updates to the linked comment (which is from 2019): - Tons of active development has happened and listmonk crossed 1.0 this year. 2.0 is on the horizon and there are quite a few listmonk instances in production. - Our production setup at work now has ~7mn subscribers and listmonk works quite well. No issues with deliverability or IP reputation with our self-hosted EC2/Postal SMTP setup. - listmonk now supports generic "Messenger" HTTP webhooks to which any message provider can be connected, allowing it to send arbitrary message campaigns like WhatsApp and SMS, not just e-mails.
- ignoramous 5y ago> Interesting to see it on the frontpage again. I believe OP may have picked it up from my comment elsewhere today: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28389308 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28389308 Anyways, I wanted to ask a few questions, if I may: 1. Why is listmonk AGPLd? It doesn't look like listmonk is core to Zerodha (even if it is released on your personal GitHub) and so curious about the licensing, because MIT/Apache could have done just as nicely, especially since xGPLv3 software is pretty much a no at most tech firms. 2. How do you decide if a repo is going to land on knadh vs zerodha GitHub? 3. Any plans to take it fully serverless with Aurora Serverless + Fargate or fly.io, for examples. Thanks.
- knadh 5y ago1. I think AGPL is a good license for web apps that can also dissuade Elastic/Mongo-like fiascos. Mastodon, Metabase, Grafana, Minio etc. are AGPL and are widely used. 2. We see ourselves as a group of hackers and not really as a corporate entity. Many projects that come out of our team are largely individual efforts. For instance, I have spend considerable personal time working on listmonk over the last couple of years just because I like it. There is no Zerodha mandate involved. Only projects that have to be branded as Zerodha or involve a lot of multi-dev effort go under the official handle (ref: https://zerodha.tech/projects https://zerodha.tech/projects) 3. listmonk offers a one-click Heroku button (a bunch of simple scripts really), so it should just be a matter of creating deployment scripts for other platforms as well. I have not looked into it personally.
- ignoramous 5y agoThanks. > I think AGPL is a good license for web apps that can also dissuade Elastic/Mongo-like fiascos Fair but listmonk doesn't seem like it is core to any for-profit business that zerodha or you run, and so could have been permissively licensed? See also: https://blogs.apache.org/foundation/entry/the-apache-way-to-sustainable https://blogs.apache.org/foundation/entry/the-apache-way-to-... Nothing against the xGPLs, because they protect a user's freedom better than MPLs / EPLs / APLs, even if the license's nuances are not well-understood (which is why they're restricted for use by some tech firms).
- tlamponi 5y agoWhat would their benefits for releasing it under a permissive license be? AGPLv3 is a good trade, you get to use it for free but if you make improvements they need to be released, which often means that they are directly unstreamed as that is easier in the long in regard to code maintenance and tarball/source-control hosting for the modified sources. So win-win for all users and the devs. > even if the license's nuances are not well-understood Which nuances are not understood? > which is why they're restricted for use by some tech firms Only those companies that want to actually modify the source and directly integrate it in a proprietary project, iow taking all but giving back nothing. All companies that just want to use it unmodified, just accessing the API or integrate it in a compatible project with releasing any changes are just fine to do so.
- anaganisk 5y agoI believe its to prevent AWS from launching Elastics CopyPasteMailer.
- gwbrooks 5y agoIs bounce/unsub handling on the roadmap?
- knadh 5y agoUnsub has been available from day one. Bounce handling (generic webhooks, POP3, SES+Sendgrid webhooks) is already merged into the repo and will be available in the upcoming release.
- ChrisMarshallNY 5y ago> Interesting to see it on the frontpage again. I suspect that this may have something to do with it: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-01/intuit-said-in-talks-to-buy-mailchimp-for-more-than-10-billion https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-09-01/intuit-sa...
- e12e 5y ago> No issues with deliverability or IP reputation with our self-hosted EC2/Postal SMTP setup. So that's: https://docs.postalserver.io/ https://docs.postalserver.io/ I'd kind of forgotten about that. Ruby on rails smtp server? Any comment/idea on how it stacks up vis-a-vis postfix or opensmtpd in terms of performance and security?
- vxNsr 5y agoIsn’t the main pain point with mailing lists clean IP address management/not being labeled as SPAM by the big 3 (Google/MS/Yahoo). And isn’t like 90% of that just being big enough that you have to be taken seriously? I know there are a fair number of people on hn who run their own mail servers but I feel like their biggest complaint is being taken seriously by GMY…
- xrisk 5y agoSome of us run mailing lists on internal networks :)
- cloudking 5y agoAssuming you can connect this system to external servers for sending email, you could use something like ListMonk + Amazon SES to get a much cheaper solution than MailChimp etc. That would solve the spam problem.
- buro9 5y agoLet's say that you have a very large marketing list with 200k people, but you only email once per month. MailChimp = $1,190 per month if sent as marketing email priced on number of contacts, $200 per month if sent as transactional email priced as number of emails SendGrid = $90 per month priced as number of emails Just using ListMonk with SendGrid if you have a large number of subscribers would be worth it. ListMonk represents the solution to mailing list management, IP reputation is a separate problem. For things like charities that have tight budgets and potentially huge contact lists, ListMonk would really help them embrace email more because the pricing wouldn't put them off.
- knadh 5y agoThis is correct. Our listmonk instance has ~7mn subscribers to whom we've to send updates (sometimes mandatory regulatory ones within stipulated periods) every month. The cost of hosting listmonk and Postal SMTP servers (that we scale up momentarily when sending a campaign) on EC2 is peanuts. With proper SPF + DKIM + not sending spam, we haven't had any IP reputation issues.
- cmitsakis 5y agowarning: shameless self promotion. If you want a desktop app to send emails (and SMS) to your list, I just released: https://github.com/cmitsakis/polysender https://github.com/cmitsakis/polysender but I don't recommend it for production use yet.
- gonab 5y agoWe use this in production. This is very good software and easy to self host. Just use Amazon SES for email, S3 for storage and Postgres for database. That's it, you have an email server that costs pennies It just works.
- preya2k 5y agoLooks great! I've been looking for something like this in the FOSS world for a while now. Will give it a try. Suggestion to the author: A demo link would be great (doesn't need to actually send mails) – but just clicking through the UI would help a lot to understand the scope and features of a product.
- knadh 5y agoThanks. Will see how feasible a demo is. The app's website shows a few screenshots: https://listmonk.app https://listmonk.app
- tbabej 5y agoIt is worth noting that setting up a local demo with their docker-compose based script is roughly 30s of work: mkdir listmonk-demo sh -c "$(curl -fsSL https://raw.githubusercontent.com/knadh/listmonk/master/install-demo.sh)" This will setup a local server on localhost:9000. That said, I would personally recommend inspecting the bash script first before running it. The script in this case is not malicious, but it's a good habit to have.
- preya2k 5y agoYou need to be on a desktop device, you need to have Docker running and you need to have port 9000 still available. So I still think these are pretty high requirements to test a product out. Especially since this is a tool being used by non-IT people (E-Mails/Marketing). Might be helpful to have a demo, to help convince people who don't know what docker is, but can still vote/decide/argue for/against certain software solutions.
- denton-scratch 5y agoI'm not OK with the modern practice of recommending end-users download and execute a script from the big, bad web without first reading it. I guess I'm just an old fuddy-duddy, and if you feel it's OK, knock yourself out. But I really think software developers should know better than to rely on this practice simply because it makes their install process into a one-liner. I'm sure they could do better than recommending users execute random scripts from the intarwebs, sight-unseen.
- mrzool 5y agoHonest question: isn't there a risk of your emails getting preemptively rejected as spam by most mail servers if you self-host your own email server?
- CallMeMarc 5y agoProbably yes. But my best guess is most of them use AWS SES or a similar provider for the actual outgoing emails to avoid exactly this problem.
- rexreed 5y agoThen is there much of a cost-advantage to self-hosting or is it more about control?
- CallMeMarc 5y agoComparing with MailChimp and co, I’d say it’s definitely cheaper (going with SES for sending mails at least). I like it because I own the data of my email lists and in this sense, the control is also a big plus point! Plus it’s open source, probably easier to get something custom working than with any big provider out there.
- poetaster 5y agoControl, hygiene, the fun of bayes filter magic, strange prtocols like imap, your own gpg mailing lists. Internet 101.
- kawemi 5y agoI host my own email and most of the time I don't encounter any technical problems: I got rejected once (last week) since I started last year. Most of my problems have been trying to tell/have people read my non "@gmail/outlook/yahoo" domain! Probably depends on how you use your email, but it's been smooth pretty smooth sailing personally. IIRC, you avoid most of the problems if you set up your DNS accordingly (DMARC, SPF, etc). But for a mailing list AWS SES is probably the way to go to avoid all the trouble.
- 5y ago
- julienmarie 5y agoBeen using it since June with Haraka for the email sending of small newsletters (around 50k recipients a day). It's working great. Love the simplicity of it.
- rexreed 5y agoHow do you make sure you have maximum deliverability, don't end up spam flagged, and end up in the main inbox and not promotions / spam filtered?
- sodality2 5y agoDeliverability is affected by the IP address's trustworthiness and a few other factors. Avoiding spam filer is a bit harder as you likely have to set up your promotions to be way different from what most people think is normal. Add easy unsub headers, send few emails, make sure you don't send regular emails that have very low open rates, etc. You might be marked as spam (personally I don't mark as spam unless the unsubscribe request is ignored, or unwanted emails are sent daily). For example, I always open Microcenter's somewhat frequent emails, so I'm probably beneficial to them. Make frequent newsletters or marketing opt-in, this will not only keep open rates high (only interested readers will sign up, thus high open rates) but will also help avoid more ML-based spam filters that take open rates into consideration. You might be classed under "promotions" in Gmail regardless but that's less bad than classed as spam.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- poetaster 5y agoDoes it do gpg lists? Using schleuder for that and it sucks.
- ramsrib 5y agoI started using this recently in production after looking for self-hosted solution for a while. this is the best i found so far.
- vfulco2 5y agoI have had a horrible time getting this to work with dokku/docker, etc. after a few days of wrestling. Once "up", a couple of pages would not render for me at all. So I moved to mailcoach (early days, just being honest. mautic was too heavy, mailtrain seemed dated). I am trying to move away from projects with a small number of developers; it's too hard on all involved. I greatly admire the work and overall generosity of the offering however.
- knadh 5y agoThat is very surprising to hear. listmonk is a single exe with no dependencies (except for Postgres connectivity). Running the Docker setup is as simple as `docker-compose up app db`. If you don't want Docker, you can just download the binary and do `./listmonk`.
- vfulco2 5y agoYes, I was surprised too given I have some beginner/intermediate experience with docker/dokku. Will revisit again in the coming weeks. All the best.