12 ms·
Apple Watch production delayed as engineers wrestle with quality issues
- klgpyktnfnmf 5y agoAt what point "Designed in California" becomes a lie, when all the hardware and manufacturing experts are in Asia? What part of "designed" still happens in US, besides box design?
- echelon 5y agoSome brave engineering team has to design the clever spying techniques while chortling to themselves about the "screeching" public that just doesn't understand the need to monitor everyone. Some turtlenecked business genius has to come up with money printing schemes. Like turning the world where we could repair and freely install into one where we could do neither. Or how to charge $200 for 8 GB of RAM and have their customers also not notice the missing cables and chargers. The marketing department has their work cut out to paint removal of the 3.5mm jack as a religious experience and not a move to sell more expensive hardware. Or how holding the phone wrong is user error. And it certainly takes a lot of courageous people to stop pay equity discussions amongst the low level employees.
- btmiller 5y agoThese flippant type of comments are not why people come to HN comments. Please be better.
- CamperBob2 5y agoI dunno, you can quibble with the delivery but they're not wrong per se.
- stouset 5y agoBoth the delivery and the content are of negligible value.
- echelon 5y agoI didn't do anything wrong or say anything that I find morally objectionable. The things that the Apple corporation does to our society and the computing field are horrific, and I've sardonically enumerated many of them. I think there are plenty of people on HN that agree with me, share my sentiment, and are already or just beginning to speak out against the incredible evil that Apple performs. I've gone as far as asking my representatives to bring an antitrust case against the company to protect us from the harm they cause. I'm hoping others here do the same. edit: to respond to the person below me, the reason I'm getting downvotes is because it's predominantly Apple fans that read threads about Apple iWatch. Elsewhere, the votes would be inverted.
- drcongo 5y agoIs that why you're getting so many upvotes?
- CamperBob2 5y agoA value judgment stated as an objective fact. Just what we all come here for.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- rad_gruchalski 5y agoInteresting take on the article. Which part suggests that something hasn’t been designed in California?
- loughnane 5y agoNot op but “designed” isn’t binary. If a design starts out in CA but is half-baked when it gets tossed over to China and so requires Chinese engineers to make changes to make it real… who really designed it?
- threeseed 5y agoExcept that’s a scenario you’ve just made up. Having worked at Apple for a number of years that’s not how it works. It’s much more like an architect/builder relationship where Apple is supplying detailed construction and interior design plans as well as overseeing the overall execution.
- feteru 5y agoYour point send valid, but architect/builder is usually the bouncing back and forth type relationship though, plans are usually half baked and the surveys aren't right so stuff has to change. And builders are the ones on site every day overseeing, usually the architects just check in.
- loughnane 5y agoBit delayed, but I wasn’t trying to imply that’s what happens at Apple. I know a lot of mechanical engineers there and I understand the approach they take is as you say. My point was more in general. Should’ve clarified that.
- birdyrooster 5y agoIn 2077 for a few months when China invades the United States through Alaska triggering nuclear war. You’ll have a spooktacular Halloween with your Chinese-designed Apple Watch 69. Edit: yeah you caught me, I’m fishing for downvotes to create a smurf HN account. Thanks!
- twoodfin 5y agoThis is strange to me: We’re likely less than two weeks out from this device being announced alongside the new iPhones. How can “small-scale” production only be beginning now? I think the reporting is confusing issues with 2022’s Apple Watch & the upcoming 2021 edition.
- wmf 5y agoIf this report is true, Apple will delay the announcement. They're not going to pull an AirPower with a product as important as the Watch.
- krono 5y agoWhy not? They do it with their Macbook all the time
- wmf 5y agoWhen they announce that a Mac will be released in a month, that's because it's already in volume production and they know there are no manufacturing problems. If the manufacturing is still being worked on and they can't know when it will be ready then it isn't safe to announce the product.
- krono 5y ago> and they know there are no manufacturing problems There are always manufacturing problems, and new, even significant ones, are discovered all the time. They might delay the announcement, but at some point the cost of further delays will grow beyond their projections of what shipping a first batch of faulty products will cost them in repairs/replacements/legal fees.
- oblio 5y agohttps://www.statista.com/statistics/382260/segments-share-revenue-of-apple/ https://www.statista.com/statistics/382260/segments-share-re... Mac revenue is somewhat small and stagnant while wearables revenue is growing and it's probably their future.
- wholien 5y agoHmm, some of the details of this story doesn't seem to agree with most Apple-watchers (as in people who try to figure out what the new features on the new products will be). For example, the story mentions the addition of blood pressure sensors as a reason for the issues: > The next Apple Watch will come with new features such as blood pressure measurement, they said, which means production involves fitting a greater number of components into a similar size body. Mark Gurman of Bloomberg says there is "no chance" [0] that the Apple Watch 7 will have blood pressure sensors. He points to his story with Debby Wu [1] instead: > The new watches also have screen technology that brings that display closer to the cover glass using a different lamination technique, Bloomberg previously reported. That display layer may be causing some of the production woes, the person said. It's probably a combination of larger watch sizes, new techniques/technologies, the usual upgrades, COUPLED with covid-related disruptions that are causing the delays! --------------------------- 0: https://twitter.com/markgurman/status/1432798940676730886 https://twitter.com/markgurman/status/1432798940676730886 1: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-08-31/apple-s-new-watch-will-likely-be-delayed-over-production-snags https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2021-08-31/apple-s-n...
- NoPicklez 5y agoThe article also says that the watch has a complete redesign, which as we know is rumoured to occur this year? So that adds more confusion.
- ksec 5y ago>some of the details of this story doesn't seem to agree with most Apple-watchers This is Nikkei, they have an exceptionally poor track record on anything Apple, as a matter of fact I cant even remember single decent signal coming from them. They are even worst than Digitimes. Basically a few years ago every single news media saw Apple headline drive click rate, and they decide to join the rumour race. And you mention Mark Gurman of Bloomberg, but before ~2015/2016 he was at 9to5mac.
- baybal2 5y ago> This is Nikkei, they have an exceptionally poor track record on anything Apple, as a matter of fact I cant even remember single decent signal coming from them. They are even worst than Digitimes. > worse than Digitimes What's wrong with digitimes? My own guess though is that manufacturing in Vietnam not working out for them.
- flemhans 5y agoI wonder how many engineers quit because of the client-side CSAM scanning, and whether it delays things at Apple. I know one Apple employee (albeit not an engineer) who already quit, and another two who started looking for other jobs.
- threeseed 5y agoApple has likely been doing server side scanning for years. So if they want to quit because now it’s client side to improve privacy then good luck to them.
- playcache 5y agoI just don't see any appeal in a smart watch, I already have my phone pinging me all the time wanting my attention why would I want a second source of that as a wearable. The only thing I can think of is health monitoring / fitness and I would rather have a Garmin there where the sensors are far better.
- yeswecatan 5y agoSame here. I got a Garmin watch several months ago, and so many people have asked "why didn't you just get an apple watch?" Then I have to give them my whole spiel about hating the constant distractions and oh by the way, have you ever tried turning off notifications on your phone...
- krisoft 5y ago> have you ever tried turning off notifications on your phone... Yes. I have them turned off. Could you please expand on what you mean there? Thank you.
- mvanbaak 5y ago> Then I have to give them my whole spiel about hating the constant distractions and oh by the way, have you ever tried turning off notifications on your phone oh by the way, have you ever tried turning off notifications on your watch? It's as easy as on your phone.
- Bud 5y agoHave had an Apple Watch since 2015. Took me about 30 seconds to permanently disable all unwanted sounds and notifications then, when I first got one. It's been six years now. They're all still disabled. So frankly? This isn't a real issue.
- iamacyborg 5y agoGarmin make great fitness watches but they’re not a replacement for an Apple watch if someone is looking for a smart watch. The multiple days-long battery life sure is nice though.
- obblekk 5y agoAre Apple Watch engineers doing better or worse than they would otherwise by being remote? Genuinely curious.
- canuckintime 5y agoWorking remote from Cupertino or remote from China? Travel/Quarantine restrictions in China might actually be a bigger factor. Who can forget the infamous Tim Cook anecdote [1] about Apple resolving problems in Asia: > One day back then, he convened a meeting with his team, and the discussion turned to a particular problem in Asia. "This is really bad," Cook told the group. "Someone should be in China driving this." Thirty minutes into that meeting Cook looked at Sabih Khan, a key operations executive, and abruptly asked, without a trace of emotion, "Why are you still here?" Khan, who remains one of Cook's top lieutenants to this day, immediately stood up, drove to San Francisco International Airport, and, without a change of clothes, booked a flight to China with no return date, according to people familiar with the episode. [1]https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-promotes-sabih-khan-svp-operations-tim-cook-china-story-2019-6 https://www.businessinsider.com/apple-promotes-sabih-khan-sv...
- exabrial 5y agoIf you use your watch for just athletic stuff and getting push notifications, Garmin watches like the Venu are a much better piece of hardware and software. The battery last for days, the app on the phone is better, the tracking is better, the sensor integration (Ant+) is better, and there are entire ecosystems that revolve around the Garmin/Strava combo. IF you are looking for more of a SOAW (Smartphone On a Wrist), I think iWatch is probably the best thing on the market.
- cunidev 5y agoI still don't understand how a watch with declared battery life of 18 hours is considered acceptable, or even supposed to exist in 2021. Any competitor offers at least 5x of such an essential parameter for a wearable. Necessary edit: don't get me wrong, I understand how useful or good it can be feature-wise, but this is still a huge dealbreaker.
- qzw 5y agoYes, but the Apple Watch will compile the Linux kernel twice as fast as those other watches. Seriously though, my Apple Watch is definitely the one device that runs out of battery the most in my life. I would love more battery life, so long as it doesn’t compromise any of the functionality or design. But there’s the rub.
- sva_ 5y agoI've recently been wondering if it would be technically feasible to make one of those more traditional metal watchbands, where the metal elements would be Li-Batteries. Perhaps too small though.
- qzw 5y agoI think the tricky part would be the linkages where you'd need an electrical connection. Making that robust enough to be in the band but not too bulky would be a serious challenge. You'd also lose the big variety of bands and the sweet profit margins that they bring.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- omgwwwlol 5y agoI find this to be encouraging. I like that Apple is continuing to push the envelope and that means engineers should be wrestling with difficult problems. Delays happen, but better than releasing a dud like that terrible keyboard design a few years ago.