8 ms·
> The sad thing is that they're still better than everything else out there. They haven't ever been better than Apple laptop hardware, even in Intel-land. The
by sneak 5y ago
> The sad thing is that they're still better than everything else out there.
They haven't ever been better than Apple laptop hardware, even in Intel-land.
There seems to be this common bias in PC laptop evaluation that excludes Apple machines from consideration when doing comparisons.
Apple makes the best x64 laptops, and has for years. Sadly, they will stop soon.
- PostThisTooFast 5y ago"They haven't ever been better than Apple laptop hardware, even in Intel-land" Except of course for the monumentally defective and offensive keyboards Apple saddled its customers with for FIVE YEARS. And there are the soldered-in SSDs and RAM now, and glued-together chassis. And the hodgepodge of laptop & desktop parts crammed into the iMac to make it "thinner," which is absolutely asinine in a desktop computer.
- fffad6ca80dcc 5y agoI have always liked the keyboard more. My opinion is that Apple prioritizes how the keyboard looks and how thin it is over the actual function and experience of using it. It blows my mind that people buy their desktop keyboard which is basically a laptop keyboard in small case. I believe the ability to repair or swap components has always been better with Lenovo. Apple beats Lenovo in a lot of other ways though, audio quality being one that I personally experienced. On my old T430s the speakers were so bad I wished they had just not included them at all. They were like the speakers in those talking greeting cards.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoFinding a good Mac-layout mechanical keyboard that I liked was a total chore, I eventually got the Vinpok Taptek which I'm really pleased with but I can't find replacement keycaps for the life of me.
- grincho 5y agoOne good source of Mac mechanicals is Matias, e.g. https://matias.ca/quietpro/mac/ https://matias.ca/quietpro/mac/. In fact, it's the only company I've found that makes a true Mac layout: that is, a full symmetric set of command, option, and control keys on each side.
- reaperducer 5y agoI had one of the Matias wireless keyboards with the numeric keypad. I bought it because at the time, Apple didn't make a wireless version of its full Magic Keyboard. It was good for about a year. Then i started having connectivity problems. The Letter in the keys wrote off quickly. And a few of the keys started becoming less responsive. The quality just wasn't there. Luckily, by then Apple came out with its version, and it's been flawless for a few years now. It's worth the extra money to go with Apple, if you're getting that kind of keyboard.
- tristor 5y agoI... don't understand this. I've been using exclusively mechanical keyboards since the very early 90s, and I've been using nearly-exclusively Macs since the very early 2000s. I've never had an issue here. Mechanical keyboards, as a general rule, are programmable, and have swappable keycaps. It's a simple matter to swap the keycaps if you are adjusted to the Windows mandated keyboard layout ordering and how that's mapped automatically in macOS, or slightly more work to remap the keys /and/ change the keycaps. That's not even considering that some of the greatest pre-built mechanical keyboards in the 90s and early 2000s were Mac specific, like options using Alps key switches for instance. There are many many many many mechanical keyboard options to use with a Mac. If you're legitimately having difficulty finding a solution, feel free to reach out to me via the contact information in my profile and I'll be happy to make some specific recommendations.
- BoxOfRain 5y agoJudging by yours and the sibling comments it would appear that my research into the subject of mechanical keyboards a couple of years ago was somewhat lacking!
- panda88888 5y agoI use a standard US layout TKL mechanical keyboard and remap the keys with karabiner. Are you looking for things beyond that?
- Octoth0rpe 5y agoI recently picked up a keychron k3, and am mostly satisfied. https://www.keychron.com/pages/keychron-k3-wireless-mechanical-keyboard https://www.keychron.com/pages/keychron-k3-wireless-mechanic...
- tristor 5y agoAlso, for low profile keycaps you can get them on Novel Keys. I don't think anyone else makes low profile compatible keycaps, but that's one of the trade-offs for using low profile switches.
- mattigames 5y agoSo the "best" laptop hardware lacks USB-2 ports forcing me to use a bunch adapters, has a touch bar which is absolutely useless and takes keyboard space, plays poorly with any non-Apple mouse, keyboard keys are too thin, the keyboard is distributed in the most annoying way (fn at corner? And yeah I know about remapping), and it's made to be has hard to repair as possible (on purpose). Yeah hard pass on the "best laptop".
- remram 5y agoDo they sell anything comparable to 2012 MacBook Pros?
- mrec 5y agoI've only ever owned one Mac, but I had more hardware problems with it than with every other machine I've owned in ~30 years put together. Motherboard melted down (fixed for free despite being out of warranty, to Apple's credit), optical drive crapped out, ACPI crapped out, keyboard backlighting crapped out, screen discoloured, spectacularly awful thermals and fan noise, and of course the daft-by-design Mac keyboard layout. Obviously that's all anecdotal and may be an outlier, but I don't find a naked assertion that "Apple makes the best x64 laptops" very convincing.
- elric 5y agoCan I run Linux on them? Can I get them with keyboards that aren't awful? Can I get them with next-business-day-on-site warranty? Not trying to be snarky here, I haven't owned an Apple product since the iMac, so I literally don't know. But I suspect the answer is "no".
- Bud 5y agoYes, you can run the latest Linux. Linux now has native M1 support. Yes, Apple did finally fix the awful keyboards on its laptops from 2016-2020, and their keyboards are once again quite good. The trackpad is what it has always been: the best on any computer at any price. I'm not aware that Apple offers any kind of on-site warranty service, so that's a no, but the flipside is that you are much less likely to need it than you are with PCs. (Please, spare me the endless downvotes for saying this. I support hundreds of PCs and hundreds of Macs, and have for a couple decades now. I'm not just making this shit up for my health.)
- kcb 5y ago>Yes, you can run the latest Linux. Linux now has native M1 support. Lets not promise the moon here. The M1's Linux support is far from complete and definitely not ready for general use.
- Bud 5y agoThanks for the correction; it does have kernel support for the latest Linux kernel, but yeah, it's not a mature port yet. I do expect that it will have full support very soon, however.
- ac29 5y agoUntil the GPU has reasonable OpenGL and/or Vulkan support, some things are going to be pretty painful. I dont think that's happening any time soon.
- sneak 5y agoI’ve never understood the next-business-day-on-site warranty thing people seem so keen on. Apple products (top case stickers notwithstanding) are fungible: just buy another one from any Apple store in the universe and restore your backup, and let AppleCare deal with the busted one on their own schedule. There’s nothing special about your laptop except the data. The factory pumps out bazillions of them.
- DocTomoe 5y agoNone of my PC laptops ever had parts of the keyboard randomly die on me. None of my PC laptops, ever, had self-inflating batteries. I experienced both on employer-provided MacBooks. Now, I may have been particularly unlucky here, but I think Apple hardware quality never having been surpassed is a bit of an optimistic statement.
- gambiting 5y ago>>None of my PC laptops, ever, had self-inflating batteries. Lucky you then, I literally just replaced an inflated battery on a Dell latitude, can send some cool pics of the thing being swollen like a wet nappy if you want.
- poetaster 5y agoAfter 30 years of buying Apple, I gave up when it became common for the powerbooks to subject you to DC in the wrists, kill perfectly serviceable panasonic dvd drives and send HDs to nirvana on the clock. The number of recovery jobs I had to run for musicians and filmmakers between 2003 and 2010 was hair raising. Never again. My mac classic runs just fine.
- GekkePrutser 5y agoIt's not DC actually, it's leaking AC. I think the shielding of the power adaptor picks up some induction (or capacitance?) and you can feel that when you brush over it with your hand. If you use a grounded lead (the 3-prong cable that comes with the adaptor instead of the 2-prong duckhead) it doesn't happen. Because the voltage that will flow to ground and won't build up. You can indeed feel it very clearly because it makes the surface feel rough and tickly. I'm also sensitive to it. A lot of computers do this, my PC-XT did this back in the 80s. But Apple is one of the few with an all metal case. A lot of other makes have metal but it's usually just a sheet and not connected to the actual ground. What I hate about Apple's current laptops is the sharp edges that cut into my wrists, and the keyboards that are too shallow to have real feedback. They seem made more to please the eyes, not the hands.
- ajford 5y agoMaybe for certain subsets of the user group. I don't like the dongle-hell that is the Apple laptop line. I'll take my Lenovo or Dell laptop that has RJ45, multiple usb ports, and more. I also prefer a physical laptop dock (not USB3), but I always had such a headache with them for linux support. Apple laptops are always a fair bit pricier for a given set of hw specs than any other manufacturer would be. Additionally, they lack any level of reparability and a trip to the genius bar will often be quite expensive. Hell, look at the debacle that was the butterfly keyboard they pushed for something like 5-6 years. Apple's keyboards, even before/after the butterfly keyboard, are inferior (in my opinion) than the keyboard on the Thinkpad line, and feel quite mushy by comparison. The aluminum construction is quite solid, but not without it's issues. They seem to get far hotter in my experience, but perhaps that's them acting as heat sink so I'll give that a pass. The hard edges on the case are a pain-point to me. I know a lot of people seem to prefer the apple touchpads, but I've never liked them. I prefer physical mouse buttons, and the click never felt right to me on apple touchpads. Part of it might be that gesture inputs with the touchpads aggravated my RSI, so I was never able to make use of them. All said, I don't agree with Apple making the best x64 laptops, but they fielded a competitor like many others. They have the advantage of being the only true Apple laptop though, so if you're all-in on the Apple ecosystem, they're definitely the best choice. Otherwise, there are many laptops that might surpass the macbooks, depending on your individual preferences.
- lallysingh 5y agoNope. I've got a MacBook pro (work) and an x1 yoga (personal) right here on my desk. The yoga is the better machine.