10 ms·
How can the central bank _not_ interfere? For a central bank there's no such thing as no policy. Even inaction is a policy. (Of course, there are systems tha
by eru 5y ago
How can the central bank _not_ interfere?
For a central bank there's no such thing as no policy. Even inaction is a policy.
(Of course, there are systems that work without a central bank. And can work very well in fact. But that's not what the Dutch as part of the Euro zone have.)
- intothev01d 5y agoYes, they ultimately act at some point and not at others, and that is their policy or stance (action or inaction). The problem is the actions they've been taking that are leading to the results I'm referencing.
- GDC7 5y ago> Even inaction is a policy Inaction is the only policy. All the other actions are stuff that these people do to justify their existence . With all due respect for Jerome Powell, Bernanke etc. these people are kind of frauds. They are the only academic which are globally known and get all the respect and bows as well as recognition. But their craft is a pseudoscience. The Nobel committee knows this, in fact the Nobel Prize for Economics is commonly referred as such but in reality it's: "The Sveriges Riksbank Prize in Economic Sciences in Memory of Alfred Nobel" Worlds apart. If they were real men they'd pick a real science and face real irrelevance like real men if they are wrong or fail to make important contributions. Only in economics people are still around after getting it wrong so many times. It seems like the more wrong you are , the more recognition you get, as people anticipate that economists who shoot frequently will get it right more than those who shoot infrequently given the randomness of their predictions
- jfengel 5y agoThere's no Nobel at all in mathematics. Does that make it pseudoscientific?
- GDC7 5y agoMath is the foundation of sciences which gets the real Nobel, it would be redundant to have it in there.
- mpalczewski 5y agoMath isn't a science at all, nor does it pretend to be.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoI don't think mathematics is a science at all, nor has it been claimed to be one?
- 01100011 5y agoI don't know, I'm just an idiot on the internet, but it seems like a better solution to monetary stimulus would have been fiscal stimulus. The government could have passed an infrastructure bill 18 months ago and the fed could have backed off. I'll admit I'm pretty furious at the fed right now though. As someone with a lot of assets in cash who was hoping to buy a house last year, I have been double penetrated by inflation and spiraling home prices. The housing market accelerated just out of my reach before I could make a move and my cash pile is on fire. I'd have moved back into the stock market to protect it, but it seemed risky given historical valuations and such. Now I'm poorer and I can't help but think Powell effectively just stole from me and I've been punished for being defensive and not participating in the fueling of an asset bubble.
- arcticbull 5y ago> I'll admit I'm pretty furious at the fed right now though. I suspect you would have been a lot more furious at the Fed in the event they had sat back during COVID and presided over a deflationary spiral triggered by the lockdowns. Can't get a mortgage if you're out of work, ya know? > As someone with a lot of assets in cash who was hoping to buy a house last year... Let me stop you right there. Generally speaking, you shouldn't hold cash. Nobody should hold cash. Nobody should have ever held cash because even at the baseline expectation 2% inflation that's still a loss. > I have been double penetrated by inflation... Inflation is somewhere between 2 and 5%. That's not what I would call "penetration." Mild discomfort maybe. > ...and spiraling home prices. Housing affordability hasn't really changed on a monthly basis, because on a 30-year fixed rate mortgage the drop in interest rates from 4.xx% to 2.xx% means that a monthly payment two years ago on a $1M property is the same as it would be today on a $1.2M property. That's napkin math, I believe the spread is even larger IRL. In fact, if you can lock in a 2.xx% mortgage in a 2-5% inflationary environment then it is in real dollar terms a zero-interest loan. Before factoring in tax deductions. What's become more painful is making the down-payment. > Now I'm poorer and I can't help but think Powell effectively just stole from me and I've been punished for being defensive and not participating in the fueling of an asset bubble. You're not poorer, you're not as rich as you thought you'd be.
- 5y ago
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]