4 ms·
"Money also has diminishing marginal utility, so as you accumulate more of it, at some point it has less use." Thats true assuming the same scope, like living
by giantg2 5y ago
"Money also has diminishing marginal utility, so as you accumulate more of it, at some point it has less use."
Thats true assuming the same scope, like living expenses. It gets a little more nuanced if the person changes the activities in scope. If you're giving billions away in a philanthropic organization that you run (ie Gates), then you've found new utility for that money. So in some ways it has more possible uses, but less pressure to actually use it. But I think your implied point of limited choices for people with lower income/capital is still valid.
- whimsicalism 5y agoIt's unequivocally true, diminishing marginal utility of money is basically an axiom.
- giantg2 5y agoIf it's unequivocally true, how about a source that shows scope does not impact it? I'm simply stating that money does not have fewer uses as one gets more of it. Usually the person's scope changes to include new uses that were not previously possible. The important thing to note is that utility is being used in mixed definition here. Strictly speaking it's definition is happiness or satisfaction. The part about having less use doesn't necessarily match this.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- nonameiguess 5y agoDiminishing marginal utility is an axiom over fixed magnitude amounts of a good. Bill Gates still gets less out of an additional $10 even with new opportunities for philanthropy than a panhandler who is hours from starving to death and currently has $0. "Diminishing" doesn't mean it has to go to zero, but Bill Gates is not going to be in any situation where some number of dollars given to him on top of what he has means the difference between life and death. Heck, this exact fact is the very reason why Bill Gates engages in philanthropy. He realizes that other people need the money more than he does.
- giantg2 5y agoYes, but that wasn't what was explained. "Money also has diminishing marginal utility, so as you accumulate more of it, at some point it has less use." The additional money does not have less use. It's just not going to add as much to quality of life or dictate "life and death". There are still many uses for it, so of which may not be possible with lower amounts.
- ttt333 5y agoIf you consider "add to quality of life" a synonym for marginal utility I think you may be in agreement. Yes, $10 buys the same Mcdonald's lunch regardless of how much money one has, but two people, one with $0 and one with $1bn in net worth will be excited about that lunch to very different degrees.
- giantg2 5y ago"Money also has diminishing marginal utility, so as you accumulate more of it, at some point it has less use." This thread in response to this, to point out that the use of money is not the same as the marginal utility.
- lottin 5y agoDiminishing marginal utility of money means that each additional dollar spent results in a smaller increase in quality of life. This is true of all consumption goods. For example, if you don't have a car, and you buy a car, your quality of life will improve a lot. If you buy a second car, it will improve only little. By the time you have 15 cars in your garage, buying another car will do nothing to improve your quality of life, or it could even worsen your living conditions.
- giantg2 5y agoYes, but that wasn't what was explained. "Money also has diminishing marginal utility, so as you accumulate more of it, at some point it has less use." The additional money does not have less use. It's just not going to add as much to quality of life. There are still many uses for it.
- whimsicalism 5y agoThe word utility is being used in a fashion different from your lay understanding.
- giantg2 5y agoMaybe you can tell me what you think it means and what I think it means then. Investopedia and my work in finance both seem to support my take.
- whimsicalism 5y agoSure. Utility, in this sense, is a proxy for the enjoyment/satisfaction gained by the consumer from the thing. You seem to be interpreting utility in terms of the quantity of things the money can be used for or in terms of the societal benefit that can be obtained from the money, it is not entirely clear.
- giantg2 5y ago
- HarryHirsch 5y agoSaying it's an axiom is correct - economists generally pose this as a fact, but where would we end up if it was the opposite, if the utility of money rose with the amount you have? In other words: if the diminishing utility axiom were true we could start redistributing now, but one would predict the money owners would be against it. It's proof by contradiction - everyone knows money is political power.
- skadiddle 5y ago> if the diminishing utility axiom were true we could start redistributing now, but one would predict the money owners would be against it. If something has diminishing *marginal* utility if doesn't follow that a third party has a right to seize it(property rights, different/tangential topic). Therefore this: > It's proof by contradiction - everyone knows money is political power. Is an inconsequential conclusion.
- RandomLensman 5y agoIt's at best a strong hypothesis. There can be situations where utility is constant or even increasing (not necessarily monotone). If I can only afford one shirt then actually going for a situation where I can own three shirts could make my life a lot simpler, similarly, being able to afford a car could have strong positive effects. I think, the idea that getting rich does not create a lot of additional joy from diminishing utility is one the best fairy tales ever invented.
- giantg2 5y agoI sort of agree, but would say that fairy tale part might be better described as a psychological effect, but still consistent with your questioning it as other than a hard economic fact. What I mean is that the person's psychology may change as they become accustomed to a specific standard of living. For example, if someone grows up driving new BWMs, they might see it as "normal" and not derive as much joy from it as someone who got a new BWM after working for it for years. So it seems that the axiom is specific to an individual and their psyche, which provides provides few beneficial use cases beyond understanding that if people have 'a lot' of money, then money might not be a strong motivator.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> think, the idea that getting rich does not create a lot of additional joy from diminishing utility is one the best fairy tales ever invented. It's diminishing marginal utility. Every single comment I've gotten disputing this either misinterprets the word "marginal" or the word "utility", I encourage all of y'all to take an economics course.
- RandomLensman 5y agoSorry, just skipped the "marginal", but my point stands: the marginal utility does not need to drop. I could enjoy my 10th car just as much as my 9th... or even more (and I have taken some economics courses). Similarly, going from $1B to $2B might more than double my total utility, nothing is stopping that from happing a priori Edit: granted, there are a lot of observable situations that do indeed show diminishing marginal utility, but I think the concept is often too much taken at face value when actual data or analysis is scarce and the marginal utility might behave in a more complex way
- minikites 5y ago>If you're giving billions away in a philanthropic organization that you run (ie Gates), then you've found new utility for that money. Billionaires give away far less of their money compared to the average person: https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/ceo-says-billionaires-giving-to-charity-is-biggest-pr-scam/ar-BB1dYWx0 https://www.msn.com/en-us/money/other/ceo-says-billionaires-... >Based on these figures, MarketWatch reported Bezos donated just .5 percent of his net worth last year - a quarter of the 2 percent the average American donates each year. Also, why should money be concentrated in the hands of the ultra-wealthy, does their wealth make them more qualified to decide how it's spent compared to society/government? https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/12/americas-billionaire-class-donations https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2020/apr/12/americ... >First off, the amounts involved are tiny relative to the fortunes behind them. Bezos’s $100m, for example, amounts to about 11 days of his income. >Well-publicized philanthropy also conveniently distracts attention from how several of these billionaires are endangering their workers and, by extension, the public. >And why should we believe that Gates or any other billionaire’s “boldness” necessarily reflects society’s values and needs? Oligarchies aren’t the same as democracies.
- giantg2 5y agoI think you're getting off track or putting words in my mouth. "Based on these figures, MarketWatch reported Bezos donated just .5 percent of his net worth last year - a quarter of the 2 percent the average American donates each year." I'm not looking at percent of net worth. Most of the time that is not the "money" that we are talking about here and would not be subject to the utility and use being discussed. For example, the vast majority of Bezos' worth is tied up stock. Also, not every billionaire is the same. Some may not be giving much, but there are many who have pledged to give away the majority of their fortunes. "Also, why should money be concentrated in the hands of the wealthy, does that make them more qualified to decide how it's spent compared to society/government?" I've made no claims or mention on this topic. "Well-publicized philanthropy also conveniently distracts attention from how several of these billionaires are endangering their workers and, by extension, the public." Again, not part of my discussion. However, I will say that I find this to be untrue when you see articles coming out discussing this very thing (ie your quote). "Oligarchies aren’t the same as democracies." Again, off topic. I agree that they are different. I even agree with the implied part about living in an oligarchy. However, that oligarchy in my opinion is more based on if someone is in the ruling class with special privileges and the power to ignore laws when they want (politicians, judges, cops, DAs, etc) than being a billionaire (although money can help influence).