11 ms·
Robert Sapolsky on Depression (2009)
- cung 5y agoThe chemicalization, medicalization and commercialization of depression is a dead end. While the chemical imbalances might be real, the symptoms are due to actual situations in your life. Treating the symptoms with drugs is a pretend solution that only works because it is often the first step people take to actually better their life.
- Broken_Hippo 5y ago" it is often the first step people take to actually better their life." What makes you think this - and what makes you think that so many folks have so much agency in their life? A lot of folks don't, and if you have depression, you generally have even less of it because you wind up with an inability to see options you do have... if any. It isn't like everyone can escape poverty or a bad spouse (it takes money to divorce someone or even leave if you need to get your own place). It isn't like anyone can magically make a disease diagnosis go away nor does changing jobs always fix things, especially if the reason you stay is because you desperately need the health insurance or because no where else pays as much in your area (and moving costs money). We don't make sure folks have tools to improve their life. Additionally, this really just blames the victim and I really hope you don't say this to folks actually suffering.
- pjerem 5y agoI 100% agree with your post but i’d like to add something about this : > It isn't like everyone can escape poverty or a bad spouse You are right and medicalization is useful to overcome this. But there is a real risk, as a society, that we find it normal to treat the depression induced by those issues, rather than the issues themselves. We should treat poverty and work towards making divorce less painful rather than thinking medication allows a status-quo. But that’s another topic on its own and absolutely not a counter argument of your answer.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoPoverty and spousal abuse aren't actually statistically significant causes for depression. You seem to labor under the fallacy to think that anti-depressants are some kind of lifestyle drugs that generally improve mood or tolerance of adversity. They don't.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- pjerem 5y ago> You seem to labor under the fallacy to think that anti-depressants are some kind of lifestyle drugs that generally improve mood or tolerance of adversity. They don't. I absolutely don’t see where I wrote that. I exactly know what anti-depressant are and are not. I’m currently taking them (though that’s for chronic anxiety). So I absolutely know that they don’t improve mood or tolerance of adversity. They « just » flatten the emotional curve, I don’t see how having flat emotions (even the good ones) are some sort of enjoyable « lifestyle ». But it does allow me to work on my anxiety issues without being submerged by ridiculously amplified anxiety.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoYou are probally right on chemicals that treat depression. I couldn't find the original Psychologist who decided to use The Freedom of Information Act to procure All the studies concerning the efficy of Antidepressant drugs. He collated the all the clinical studies, and not just the cherry picked ones. What he found puckered a few Psychiatrists arses, but they still prescribe like it's the end of the world, and rake in a very comfortable income. I can't remember the guy's name, but this study might suffice. https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antidepressants-do-they-work-or-dont-they/ https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/antidepressants-d...
- mellavora 5y agoI think you might mean this? https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/ Antidepressants and the Placebo Effect Abstract Antidepressants are supposed to work by fixing a chemical imbalance, specifically, a lack of serotonin in the brain. Indeed, their supposed effectiveness is the primary evidence for the chemical imbalance theory. But analyses of the published data and the unpublished data that were hidden by drug companies reveals that most (if not all) of the benefits are due to the placebo effect. Some antidepressants increase serotonin levels, some decrease it, and some have no effect at all on serotonin. Nevertheless, they all show the same therapeutic benefit. Even the small statistical difference between antidepressants and placebos may be an enhanced placebo effect, due to the fact that most patients and doctors in clinical trials successfully break blind. The serotonin theory is as close as any theory in the history of science to having been proved wrong. Instead of curing depression, popular antidepressants may induce a biological vulnerability making people more likely to become depressed in the future.
- bayesian_horse 5y agoThat is a wrong and damaging statement. You are ignoring the reality of depression as a disease. It has been shown that depression, in the medical definition, is often not caused by situations in the patient's life. Thus it is equally foolish to believe, the patients could "better their life" and thereby alleviate depression. Somehow assuming the symptoms of depression actually allow any of that. Hard to improve your life if you can barely get out of bed. Your comment is the exact kind of stigmatizing, patient-blaming and "just stop being depressed" bullshit that hasn't worked for centuries and contributes to the problem.
- OJFord 5y agoI don't necessarily agree with GP, but I think your comment is the worst-possible reading of it, as in taking it in the worst light. > stigmatizing, patient-blaming and "just stop being depressed" is coming from > the symptoms are due to actual situations in your life ? Isn't that the opposite, GP is saying yes it is real, but arguing that the drugs are like spraying air freshener in a room that still contains the source of the stink? Again, not saying I agree, I just didn't read it as stigmatising or 'just stop' at all.
- Honga 5y agoWould you have any sources to back this up? Seems like a big claim to go against standard practice. I suffer from chronic episodic depression. But my life is objectively great and fulfilling. Are you saying that I should not be at peace with my lifestyle? Or that my depression is a nurture rather than nature type issue? I'm both triggered and curious to hear your thoughts.
- pjerem 5y agoI don’t agree with you about the « dead end » of medicalization. Medicalization really help you to break the circle. It temporarily treats the symptoms and allows you a timeframe where you can work towards the origin of your issues. And if for some reason, you can’t, it at least helps you live a more supportable life. Here we are in a mental disease but you can easily make an analogy with any disease. If you need re-education after an accident that broke something, the first step is generally to treat the symptoms that could block you to achieve re-education. As an example, my dad completely lost its equilibrium after a brain stroke. Re-education was long and hard, eventually succeeded, but would have been totally impossible without medication against nausea, which you constantly get when your equilibrium system is failing. And I would add that, AFAIK, some forms of depressions are purely chemical issues. And it isn’t surprising. There exists tons of diseases that are chemical issues.
- himinlomax 5y agoThis is complete nonsense as well as damaging for people who suffer from depression and who would believe your nonsense instead of seeking science-based help.
- frereubu 5y agoYou can split definitions of depression in a number of ways, but one that's been around for a long time is exogenous (external causes) and endogenous (internal causes). The idea that symptoms are only due to life situations is simplistic and wrong. This feels a bit like the straw man arguments about economics only treating people as rational actors, whereas economists have been aware of the issues with that for decades.
- gatestone 5y agoThe conflict between the external world and your inner self (psychology, neurology,nurture) is a situational problem, not so much medical. You don’t have to seek blame, not from outside or inside in your self. But you can look for a solution in changing either or both.
- gatestone 5y agoYou may be an exceptional character: very dumb or smart; maybe too sensitive of too unemphatic; on some strange neurodiversity spectrum; maybe you was raised by a bit too personal parents; maybe you adopted radical or odd ideologies etc., ad infinitum Or you may live in an exceptional external situation. It can be good (you are a rock star) or bad (many). Either way, either case or a bad mix of internal and external may wear you out in the long run, and you stop functioning, you burn out, you become depressed.
- haxiomic 5y agoDepression is a symptom that can be the result of a multitude of physiological causes and not always psychological. One could induce the effects of serious depression in a person through gene therapy, specific nutritional deficiency, certain drugs, for example. It can be hard to understand the cause for each person, and I do believe strongly we currently under-treat and under-investigate depression and it’s sources in people The arguments put forward in the article and video are good and do a better job than I could at explaining what we know about depression
- OJFord 5y agoIs it not contradictory to say it's a 'dead end', and also (only) 'works because it is often the first step people take to actually better their life'? (emphasis mine) I don't have strong feelings either way (and basically will just do what a doctor tells me to do as long as I somewhat understand it seems to make sense) but I've vouched (not voted) for the parent comment because I think there's already the beginning of interesting discussion here; people can (have) disagree(d), but there's not really a reason to flag it IMO.
- belorn 5y agoThe environment impact the chemical balance of the human body. The chemical balance impact how the environment impacts the chemical balance. Depression is the inability to recover from loss. With some of the more extreme depressions the mind can even invent losses which does not exist in the form of delusions. There are also seasonal depression where individuals lose temporarily the ability to handle loss. The actual situations in your life is not major factors in those, through the environment could provide protective benefits.
- kayodelycaon 5y agoEh… that really depends on what the source of the depression is. I’m bipolar and I’ll never be free of depression, hypomania, anxiety, and the various parts of my brain that are broken. While medication and therapy can reduce symptoms, there is no cure. When I get depressed, I just have to ride it out. All I can do is accept that. There are forms of depression that are biological in nature, just like bipolar is, and there is no cure, only mitigation.
- dec0dedab0de 5y agoI don't think everyone should be piling on, you're mostly correct. Except that your first and last points are contradictory. A dead end and a first step are different things. Though I thought it was common knowledge that these drugs are supposed to be a first step, that too many people use as a crutch, while thinking they are a cure.
- s5300 5y agoThe entire article is pretty spot on, experience wise at least (can't comment on the chemistry of it) However > Inside the body is going through a massive stress response that is similar to what your body would be doing if you were fleeing an armed assailant. All the time. This right here... is important, and something I don't think most are aware of. It's also something I don't think one can fully understand without having experienced it. I have been mugged at gunpoint/knifepoint and also had bullets fired in my direction in an attempted carjacking (thank you downtown St. Louis) at an earlier time in my life. The fight or flight reflex was definitely about as strong as you might imagine it would/should be in that situation, perhaps slighty dampened by a hobby that required a lot of situational awareness/vigilance. Cue coming down with a pretty severe chronic physical illness a couple years later and no financial means nor support to fully deal with it (fuck Vascular Ehlers Danlos and Thoracic Outlet Syndrome) - obviously, some severe depression comes with the hopelessness of things like this. The fight or flight reflex... just, came on as symptoms became severe. It was quite noticable and fluctuated in severity the first month or so, but soon became an all encompassing baseline normal... now going on for years. Simply put, figuratively, I could walk straight up to somebody shooting at me and touch them on the face without any fear/monkey brain instinct to save my life. Literally, I would likely be quickly dead because bullets do that to you and it's not hard to hit somebody walking straight up to you. I really do not mean this in a suicidal sense whatsoever, just the fact that there is absolutely no further stress response from any situation I may find myself in, no matter how dangerous (well, I haven't been plastered in easily visible US military gear in the middle of Afghanistan with people shooting at me, so perhaps I may be slightly too full of myself). But, the stress response one would normally get that invokes the fear and adrenaline to run away from imminent dangers, it essentially no longer suddenly happens, as it's just been a part of daily life for so long. I can't walk down a busy street without the instant mental registration of where every sound I'm able to hear is coming from. Basically, extreme hypervigilance. It is outright extremely exhausting, and once in a blue moon slightly convenient (like when not having realized the bar you're coming out of at 2am is less than a block from Skid Row and you've got quite a walk to get where you're headed). I wish more people were aware of this aspect of this mental illness, and I very much hope that there's not a point of no return from it. Something makes me think that there has to be though - whether that's years, or decades of the non-stop fight or flight stressor, and perhaps dependent on what portion of your development you experience it in.
- CretinDesAlpes 5y agoThis 2018 talk from Dr Yapko, "Keys to unlock depression: Why skills work better than pills" - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVgQ_tgWMyU https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TVgQ_tgWMyU - suggests a multidimensional viewpoint rather than purely biological. He says the causes are: 1. Biological. He says "Yes, biology matters, but surprisingly not as much as you would think, that when we look at what’s termed genetic variance, how much do genes play a role in depression? Is there a depression gene? No. Are there genes that make people vulnerable to depression? Definitely. So if we look at biochemistry, yes it’s a factor. If we look at disease processes, there are many diseases where depression is a predictable consequence. If we look at drugs, there are many drugs that have depression as a predictable side effect. Biology matters, but when we look at genetic variance, that figure is between .3 and .4. That represents a mild, moderate at best, genetic influence." 2. Psychological. In particular what is known as "Attributional/Explanatory style" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explanatory_style https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explanatory_style), i.e. the person's habitual or reflexive way of attaching meaning to life events. He says "It isn't what happens to people that increases their risk for depression so much as how they interpret and respond to what happens to them." 3. Social At the end, he says "the goal is not to cure depression, the goal is to learn how to manage your mood. You don't exercise once and now you're done with the exercise thing."
- codetrotter 5y ago> In particular what is known as "Attributional/Explanatory style" (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explanatory_style https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Explanatory_style) Thanks for the link! I’ve been thinking quite often about these things for the past couple of years, having observed similar differences between people I’ve interacted with, but never knew that there was a name for it. Nice to know. My own pet theory is that the experiences and our surroundings affect us a lot more than we may think. And it is also a useful reminder for myself, as for years now I have tended to be rather harsh against myself at times, and to look negatively on the future and on what is possible, based on really a small set of bad experiences, some of them recent and some of them earlier in my life. It’s difficult a lot of the time, to stay positive. And for the past couple of months I’ve been going through what I am pretty sure qualifies as burnout. And during this time I’ve also increasingly thought negatively about myself. And I think the end of your comment, where you bring up a quote "the goal is not to cure depression, the goal is to learn how to manage your mood. You don't exercise once and now you're done with the exercise thing." is also probably key.
- deskglass 5y agoAfter enjoying Sapolsky's lectures on YouTube (including this one) I began reading his book Behave. I was surprised to see that it refers to theories that fail to replicate (eg priming) as if they were solid theories. Stuart Richie (a psychologist who wrote a book on the replication crisis) enumerates other examples in his review https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/rules-of-behaviour/ https://www.spectator.co.uk/article/rules-of-behaviour/ Please be wary of this failure to drop unreplicated findings when reading Sapolsky's works.
- aritmo 5y agoI wouldn't give too much importance to Stuart Ritchie. He is right-wing and conservative, and conservatives hate Sapolsky. Ritchie's political views are evident in his book.
- deskglass 5y agoI read Science Fictions and don't recall politics coming up much. Ironically, his most political point was his defense of the Mertonian norm of universalism from both leftist and rightist critiques. That norm is relevant in this discussion :P. That said, I haven't read his other book. Politics aside, those theories did fail replication. Forget I mentioned Ritchie at all and the problem remains.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe replication crisis would be with us even if every right-wing pundit suddenly disappeared. Much like heliocentrism exists independent of Copernicus or the Church. Replication crisis isn't political at its core, it is scientific.
- bjourne 5y agoYes, but it should be contextualized. The replication crisis is present in many fields other than psychology. For example in ML and Computer Science, where most "findings" aren't verified empirically at all.
- 5y ago
- SlySherZ 5y agoIf you like this, do yourself a favor and go watch the entire Human Behavioral Biology course from Standford, it's also taught by Sapolsky: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NNnIGh9g6fA https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NNnIGh9g6fA What I think makes the course so good is that it gives you a brief but solid introduction to many different fields: - Behavioral Evolution - Molecular Genetics - Behavioral Genetics - Ethology - Neuroscience - Neurology and Endocrinology And then combines all of those to try to make sense of human behavior, by looking at animal and human behavior from all these different lenses.
- junon 5y agoSeconded. I've only watched the first five or so, but they are absolutely worth it. They changed a lot about how I think through certain situations and have proven their worth many times. The man is also just an incredible lecturer, too.
- arketyp 5y agoGreat lectures. He even manages to cover chaos theory. Philosophy students should look into this series for some biology orientation, in my humble opinion.
- xorfish 5y agoEspecially if they want to discuss Free Will.
- seg_lol 5y agoThe lectures are good, the LECTURER is galaxy class. Everyone regardless of discipline should watch the lectures for their metacognitive qualities alone. Sapolsky could literally give a lecture on shit and I'd be at the bus stop, someone would mention just a sliver of a lead and I'd intergect with, "I just saw this amazing lecture on shit by Sapolsky ..." to a complete stranger. His lectures are that good. He is science jesus.
- belorn 5y agoI often bring up his lecture series as an shining example of how to explain scientific theories with a critical qualifier that almost always is otherwise missing. He first explains a concept with logically and narrative consistency in order to explain why something occur. Then at the end he goes and demonstrate all the wholes in the theory and through that shine a light at where the narrative fails. It is only after going through multiple different competing theories that the edges start to get defined.
- aasasd 5y agoPerhaps we should stop badgering the site to death. WBM has a mirror: https://web.archive.org/web/20210901085438/https://www.robertsapolskyrocks.com/depression.html https://web.archive.org/web/20210901085438/https://www.rober... I don't see images in the mirrored page, but I also have no idea if there were any in the article itself.
- cushychicken 5y agoIf you haven't read Sapolsky's A Primate's Memoir, do not walk, run to your nearest bookstore or Kindle and grab a copy. It is without a doubt one of the best books I have ever read. Highly recommended for fans of Finnegan's Barbarian Days.
- misiti3780 5y agopurchased!, although cant seem to see how Barbarian Days is related (it's about surfing, no?)
- cushychicken 5y agoTopically, it's completely unrelated. They are both memoirs, and they strike me as cut from the same cloth in tone and substance. They are both reminiscences to an earlier, much beloved time in someone's life. I really liked both of them, and many of the folks who have read one have liked the other when I've recommended it to them.
- ncmncm 5y agoWhy Zebras Don't Get Ulcers was the most profound book experience I have had in 50 years' reading. In the final chapter, it took me a half hour to read each page, because it was tying together threads from the whole rest of the book. Each sentence called out themes from widely separated chapters. I had always wondered how systems as elaborate as the human body could work at all. This book made it clear that, for any vital process, you have at least three and often more separate systems for each function, and they all suppress one another, so that if one is interrupted, it stops suppressing the others and they step up. But, each system is also doing more than one thing, so you never get just one effect. It's a massive Rube-Goldberg / Heath-Robinson contraption tuned over million of years for a sort of statistical robustness, at the extreme expense to simplicity. To be an endocrinologist, you need to be several times smarter and more careful and diligent than any other medical specialty. Another endocrinologist worthy of close attention is Robert Lustig. He has excellent lectures on youtube that, if you pay the close attention he deserves, will lead you to make radical changes in your daily habits.
- xorfish 5y agoI read his newer book, "Behave: The Biology of Humans at Our Best and Worst". The book changed my view of the world quite a bit. Especially about wealth, poverty, crime and justice.
- guerrilla 5y ago> The book changed my view of the world quite a bit. Especially about wealth, poverty, crime and justice. How so?
- xorfish 5y agoNobody is really responsible for their behavior, their success or their misfortune. This changes quite a lot about justice. There is no such thing as a just punishment. Criminals should be viewed more like we view a broken car. If someone can't be "fixed", then it is reasonable to seperate them from society. But it should be done as humanely as possible. They are not "evil". Similarly, anyone that becomes successful should be viewed the same as a lottery winner: Just lucky. Bacause money has marginal utility for individual, redistribution of wealth becomes an optimizing game to maximize the average well beeing. There is a good Two Minute Papers that explores somthing like that: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr2ga3BBMTc https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sr2ga3BBMTc Last poverty is not a moral failing. Just bad luck.
- amin 5y agoAdverse childhood experiences (ACE's) have been shown to have a strong correlation with depression rates later in life. In other words; someone who grows up in a warm and loving family, with both biological parents, is much more likely to end up happy than someone who grew up with an alcoholic father, emotionally absent mother, a handicapped sibling, and an uncle in prison. Source: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23595840/ https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23595840/
- sjg007 5y agoI don't think ACEs is sufficient in scope, there's a lower end of adverse experiences that they miss on the verbal abuse scale.
- iainctduncan 5y agoIf you love Sapolksy (and I do!) you will also love Frans De Waal. His books are fantastic too!
- zerop 5y agoA simple solution that works for depression mostly is meditation. Consistency is key.
- eimrine 5y agoWhat is your understanding of meditation, any differences in comparing to just doing nothing?
- zerop 5y agoIn short: focus, observe thoughts but don't react to thoughts... Goal is to eventually become observer than reacter. When done consistently, the subsconcious mind will learn it. You overall stop reacting in-general.
- motohagiography 5y ago> Depression is aggression turned inward . This was a very powerful reframing of the idea, especially after setting up the biological sources of aggression. Inventing new, accessible, and even useful outlets or ways to exernalize aggression instead of suppressing it could help a lot of people. The very idea that aggression could be a real need that benefits from relief could be a huge breakthrough in helping people manage their general mental health under extreme conditions like long term isolation. It also implies that suppressing aggression may cause depression, which any situation where you've been made to feel powerless is in effect, defined by. It sort of makes sense that our societies have created social taboos around aggression needs that started as necessary but metastasized over time, the same way we have managed to dement other needs like sexuality, food, and companionship with primative categorical tools that produce versions and understandings of them that are abominations. Analogously, in that framework, depression may also be such an artifact of a similar cognitive abomination. The idea of "men not talking about their feelings," makes more sense as men suppressing aggression because our societies use disgust taboos as a tool to manage them, in a very similar way that disgust is used to control womens' sexuality. When you view aggression as a physiological need, and then analogize it to how we obviously pervert other needs by managing them with disgust, some conceptual dominoes start to fall. Admittedly I'm sounding this out for the first time myself, but if aggression is a physiological response to being threatened, creative activities can relieve our aggression needs because they are a reassertion and expression of self that has been threatened. Powerlessness causes aggression, and creativity is often a response to it. The reason physicality "works," on depression because it directs all the faculties that would be an aggression response outward. Lifting weights, running, martial arts, even more advanced yoga, or any exercise is going to provide some relief of that need. It's different from peace, rest, sympathy, or entertainment and it could also apply to things like gambling and substance abuse, where the masochism (def: craving of intensity) is a release for inverted agressive needs. My close male friends are all type-A giant personalities, and the things we have in common are these intense activities that in effect, manage aggression. We do hyper intense things together like riding motorcycles and horses, snowboarding, lift weights, make heavy music, perform, code, and write (among other things), which are all high intensity activities that are assertions of self, and in effect, relieving a need for aggression. Viewed as something essential or a need, engineering people (socially or otherwise) to be immoderately less aggressive would be like doing the same for appetite, sexuality, or sociability, and literally make them the expression of the disgust that motivated altering them. Unbelievable what the reframing of a concept can unlock.
- neuroma 5y agoGreat Post thank you, I need to express my unending frustrating with the manner in which educators are bringing up the roles of neurotransmitters in psychiatry. Quoting neurochemical imbalances as originators, or targets to fix, is mostly false. That narrative is also harmful to people's self knowledge, and to progress in the field. Engineers: how would you feel if someone described a technical problem, a UX issue, a data handling nuance or a security flaw... all as 'down to electricity'. Whilst pedantically correct it serves little use and may harm us by arresting the first tendrils of thought that were reaching out, hoping to understand this mystery. The narrative that psychiatric illness relates to 'neurochemical imbalances' is largely a hangover from pharma marketing. Of course, neurochemicals are involved, and there will be patterns to be found. But let's collectively reject those oversimplifications that helped sell semi efficacious drugs for decades whilst doing little for societal progress in coping with psychiatric illness. These mental health problems are bio psycho social. And the bio component is enormously more complex than "low mood, low serotonin". Its okay to just say, "It's bio psycho social, and it's complicated".
- xibalba 5y ago> oversimplifications that helped sell semi efficacious drugs YES. Anyone who has rotated through the kaleidoscope of antidepressants seeking help knows this in their bones. Current pharma options barely work and come with many unpleasant side effects.
- pas 5y agoAt the same time many people got their life back thanks to those lame drugs. It's not a panacea.
- RobertRoberts 5y agoTo be fair, you have to consider a placebo effect for those same people.
- fighterpilot 5y agoThe evidence that this isn't just placebo is pretty weak. At least 4/5ths of the effect is placebo. The evidence is especially weak for people with only moderate depression, where there's literally no difference with placebo. https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/ https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4172306/
- qwerty456127 5y agoWhat I ' not sure I understand is why does Dr. Sapolsky insist humans have exactly zero free will. Privileged to have (hmm, I'm not sure if this sounds humble or supercilious in this case) a rather healthy brain with sufficiently developed prefrontal cortex and other areas, no matter how depressed or aroused I am (I have probably never been either in a serious degree but nevertheless) I usually can "wake up", pause, overcome my urges and make a conscious decision to behave this or that way out of some logic, mindfully aware of the fact what I feel and think is subjective and mostly illusory. I agree the degree of freedom of the will in rather humble in the majority of people (me included) but why zero?
- steveads 5y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3O61I0pNPg8&t=356 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3O61I0pNPg8&t=356
- jessermeyer 5y agoHe mentions this in passing on the Mindscape podcast (with Sean Carroll). Essentially, he's read too many studies that have participants perform so called 'rational' tests whose outcomes are largely a function of the environment and not the 'given test' -- ie, the presence of a foul smell caused a statistical difference in the outcome of the test. Our capacity to reflect and internalize is, to him, another output of a vast and continual, unconscious, shaping all life undergoes.
- qwerty456127 5y ago> the presence of a foul smell caused a statistical difference in the outcome of the test But the fact there is a statistical difference does not mean it affects everyone and in the same degree. E.g. they probably didn't test many experienced Zen monks trained to impartially and vigilantly observe what they perceive and feel and a couple of weird guys who do this naturally also didn't affect the statistics. Statistics is both a great tool and also a problem of modern science. I bet some medications dismissed for failing to show statistical significance in DBPC trials could actually work (by means of some real phenomenon rather than the placebo effect) in some rare cases. > Our capacity to reflect and internalize is, to him, another output of a vast and continual, unconscious, shaping all life undergoes. It probably is. No action can exist without a sequence of past interactions which led to it. Even if I stop, think and make a conscious decision, even if I try to come up with a non-standard one, this means my previous experience led me to the idea I even should. But this doesn't mean "humans have no free will", it means "free will" is a meaningless concept outside the realm of logic and neither saying it exists nor saying it doesn't makes any sense and being sad about this doesn't make any sense either.
- hart_russell 5y agoI very much identify with the psychomotor retardation and sleep changes. I grind my teeth all night and wake up feeling exhausted. I’ve tried a SSRI and an SNRI and neither did anything for me.
- throwaway111213 5y agoSorry for the thread hijacking but I'd like to ask the HN crowd about my problems: For the past three years I have various health related problems like brain fog, tiredeness, breathing trouble, pain all over my body and a general bad mood. These things come and go (some times are worse some better) but for these years I remember myself always having some difficulty. I am very sad and can't enjoy anything anymore. I can't enjoy my family and I feel I am a problem to them for being always moody and sad. I don't want to go out with friends, only stay at home and do chores or play games. I am constantly afraid that I have a major health problem and try to think all the time what may I have or how I can get better. Actually I can't really think of anything else beyond my health problems. However after visiting a number of doctors and done lots of exams they couldn't find anything. Notice that I have never visited a psychiatrist or psychologist and I don't think that I had ever had any psychological problems. I may have some form of minor autism but that didn't stop me of being happy the years before. Do you think that I have some psychological problems? Maybe depression or some major anxiety? Should I visit a psychiatrist? I can't think of what to say to the psychiatrist... Should I keep visiting other doctors to do more tests? Any help would be much appreciated.
- fddhjjj 5y agoIf I felt said for a period of months without specific cause, yes, I would see a psychiatrist or psychologist. What did the doctors who you did see say when you told them about your symptoms? It strikes me as odd that they did not recommend a mental health specialist.
- throwaway111213 5y agoI feel sad because I feel that I have some major health problem. If somehow I knew that I didn't have anything and all my problems stopped then I believe I'd feel better. I don't talk to other doctors about being sad or not enjoying life or thinking about my health problems all the time. I am too shy to talk about that.
- borski 5y ago
- winrid 5y agoDepression is amazingly difficult to reason about when you are on the outside looking in, especially when you throw in sickness. Especially when you're a sick family member with depression and want your family to just let you die, but nobody wants that for you. Going through that right now with a relative.