4 ms·
I really think employer hosted employee activism is just ... always a problem. It's a minefield, and one with slack where the employer has all that data, what
by duxup 5y ago
I really think employer hosted employee activism is just ... always a problem.
It's a minefield, and one with slack where the employer has all that data, what was said, and who... that's just a mess for EVERYONE.
>But that rule has not been evenly enforced. Currently, Apple employees have popular Slack channels to discuss #fun-dogs (more than 5,000 members), #gaming (more than 3,000 members), and #dad-jokes (more than 2,000 members).
I would find those more acceptable if I were an employer, even an employee.
Edit: I had a bad typo in this post where I said "employee hosted" and intended it to say "employer" now fixed, thus some of the responses.
- fsckboy 5y agoemployer hosted you mean... i'll delete after you correct, cheers but the apple anti-trust enforcement action I'd like to see enforced would be them keeping dad-jokes all to themselves, denying competitors the same comic relief
- moate 5y agoJust out of curiosity: what are your thoughts on Unions, the epitome of "employer hosted employee activism"? Of course management is going to be least tolerant of things that represent financial risk to them, and there's nothing more financially risky than employees realizing where all the excess profits go...
- duxup 5y agoI wouldn't expect an employer to host the union communication channels. Edit: My bad I had a terrible typo in my original post where it said 'employee hosted' and not 'employer' as I intended. I think the folks working towards that stuff would be much better served to have their own slack disconnected from the employer's systems.
- crazygringo 5y agoRealistically, discussions about unions and organization are always going to need to happen at least partially using "employer hosted" spaces. Whether that means communication that happen in meeting rooms, in break rooms, in cafeterias, or over e-mail, Slack rooms, or other employer-hosted message boards. It's important to have union communication spaces outside the workplace too -- whether at union headquarters, Slack rooms, etc. -- but nobody's even going to find out about those without discussion and recruiting happening on-site. If employees are allowed to approach each other about organizing in a cafeteria or break room or by the water cooler (which is critically important), then Slack is no different -- the "social" Slack channels are just the digital equivalent.
- KingMachiavelli 5y agoI think there is a difference in the slack channel being hosted on Apple's Slack compared to an employee telling another about their independent Slack instance & channel over an existing Slack channel and/or DM.
- duxup 5y agoBut those discussions aren't recorded typically... Slack is, the whole setup is a mess.
- kelnos 5y agoI don't think it's at all reasonable to say that a Slack channel is an "equivalent" to spreading information by ad-hoc meetings in the cafeteria/break room/near the water cooler. I can reach all people in a Slack channel by spending a few seconds typing something. Reaching any large number of people through chance encounters in an office on break time requires perhaps hours of work spread out over days or weeks. And you'll never reach employees who work in another location if you can only physically talk to the ones who work in your office.
- elicash 5y agoFor folks who don't know, one thing right out of the union-buster handbook is that you first remove the ability of workers to organize themselves at work -- and then when they have to resort to visiting their co-workers at their homes to organize them, you make those home visits an argument against the union.
- loudtieblahblah 5y agoit's 2021. There's no reason employees can't meet to talk on another platform or around a hashtag or something. it's a far cry from union busting to ask that you use the million tools available, for free, to everyone. And it's a win-win for the employees - b/c now it's beyond the control of the company in question.
- elicash 5y agoSo you're suggesting Apple will allow an email to go out to everyone that alerts employees of the EMPLOYEE-hosted slack space? Because if not, we're back to having to tell them via home visits. Any other method (for example, spreading the word in the break room) would get the worker organizers in trouble if they got caught.
- loudtieblahblah 5y agoyou can ask "hey can i have your phone #" and then text them. you can ask them "can i have your email" and then email them. people far more innovative than I could come up with other methods I'm all for unionization. But i don't get this forcing companies to supply you with the tools to enable you to do so.
- elicash 5y ago"You want my phone number, why?" "Oh, I'm not allowed to say while on company property." Yeah, that makes sense.
- 5y ago
- qweqwweqwe-90i 5y ago#dad-jokes must be a dangerous place to be. One wrong post and you can be cancelled forever.
- ro_bit 5y agoWhat kind of dad jokes do you make?
- malfist 5y agoYou've got quite the victim complex there
- dang 5y agoPersonal attacks will get you banned on HN, so please don't. Please also stop posting unsubstantive comments generally. We want thoughtful, curious conversation here. If you wouldn't mind reviewing https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and taking the intended spirit of the site more to heart, we'd be grateful.
- duxup 5y agoI always thought of dad-jokes as inherently clean / punny. Dude shows up in #dad-jokes to pull some blue / edgy stuff I'd be surprised.
- adolph 5y agoNo, no, its "and the whole fence goes down"
- nostromo 5y agoI think the challenge is most of our major tech corporations love to publicly tout their progressive bonafides at every possible opportunity. Right until it hurts their pocket book that is. Then suddenly all of the politics they've been pushing go out the window and they want to have an apolitical workforce. If corporations want to be non-political, they should stay non-political. I've personally become quite cynical about their motives. I think these woke tech companies are happy to talk about equity and climate because it doesn't cost them anything -- it's basically free marketing -- but if their workers organized or their taxes were raised, they'd suddenly show their true colors.
- lotsofpulp 5y agoRegarding this specific issue, I do not see what paying people for what they negotiate has to do with progressivism. Equity in pay potential is progressive (i.e. not discriminating against race, etc), but I do not see why everyone should have the same pay. I pay people (and businesses) differently based on what I think my second best option would cost. Is that not what everyone does?
- duxup 5y agoI agree. What exactly people mean about pay equity may or may not seem progressive ... no matter if they wrap themselves in that title or not. Most people aren't very disciplined about their political ideology.
- joshuamorton 5y ago> Equity in pay potential is progressive (i.e. not discriminating against race, etc), but I do not see why everyone should have the same pay. I pay people (and businesses) differently based on what I think my second best option would cost. Is that not what everyone does? People aren't generally advocating for "the same" pay (precise lockstep), but broadly transparency and auditability. To use Google as an example, roles have bands. Two people in the same role aren't paid the precise same amount, but you'll generally know that they'll be +-, say, 20%. And someone at L+1 will earn more than someone at L. In other words, there is a fairly straightforward way to calculate $$$ given performance review data. So there's rules and things work within the rules. This allows individuals to see that their performance is getting compensated the same as someone else's performance, via the same rules. If and when there are exceptions, the employer should be able to justify those exceptions. Why is John, at L, getting paid more than James at L+1? Because James was just promoted, and John has been a top performer at L for the last 5 years.