3 ms·
Speaking of land value taxes, I fully understand that homeowners do not want to be kicked out but there has to be a middle ground. A progressive land tax would
by imtringued 5y ago
Speaking of land value taxes, I fully understand that homeowners do not want to be kicked out but there has to be a middle ground.
A progressive land tax would tax owner occupied housing less but then collect the shortfall when the owner sells his land. If for any reason the owner cannot pay, he can apply to defer taxes for 5 years which then result in eviction if the taxes are still due and the property will automatically be upzoned to prevent future evictions.
Land owned by companies does not qualify as owner occupied to prevent share deals.
Property investors will face increasingly higher land value taxes the more land they own in a single location. The idea is that instead of investing in thousands of plots in the same top 10 cities they will have a presence in multiple different cities. This should result in competition between landlords instead of regional consolidation like ISPs have done in the US.
And now the cherry on top. Deduct paid land value taxes from taxable income of the tenant or owner occupant. Finally, lower income taxes across the board and remove the deduction.
Ok, enough about land value taxes. The reason why I personally am against rent control is actually the reason why a minimum wage works. Supply and demand aren't perfectly inelastic. Raising the minimum wage turns the government into a union. But the real question is, who does this hypothetical union serve? People imagine that it will help minimum wage workers but that is just a story to sell the policy. The truth is that it works because the only people impacted by the policy are the poor. Any market distortion that the minimum wage achieves primarily benefits those who are below the previous level. If corporations are cash rich they can simply afford the higher wages so unemployment isn't as big a deal as the theory tells us. The downside of losing jobs that pay less than minimum wage may be overstated because those jobs merely save the government a few dollars on welfare but do not contribute to a meaningful existence.
Now, if a minimum wage has an impact on the poor then who does rent control have an impact on? Rent control is a price ceiling. Who is paying the most for rent? Of course, those who can afford high rents. There are lots of high end apartments that are simply not meant for low income people in which reliable and affluent tenants live in. Yet rent control starts with the most expensive housing first. Poor tenants are usually paying bottom or mid end housing. It doesn't reach them at all. What often happens as a result is that landlords raise rent on low and mid end housing to compensate for losses on high end housing. In my opinion people who advocate for rent control simply do not understand the policy they vote for.
It's a ban on renting in a market that badly needs more rental units.