5 ms·
There's similar research that shows padded gloves have lead to more injuries in boxing.
by hnlmorg 5y ago
There's similar research that shows padded gloves have lead to more injuries in boxing.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- blix 5y agoThere's some evidence that increased padding leads to increased impact force in a wide range of sports, from boxing to running, that have a padded person initiating impact. Anecdotally, this is well known among hockey players and there's a social stigma against wearing more protective gear than average. I've even seen it implicated in pedestrian deaths as a result of driving.
- elevenoh 5y agoProtective gear wont save ya much from concussions though. Doesn't matter whats on your head if you're head is caught with an elbow, shoulder or the glass. Tis a tough problem.
- matwood 5y agoI've seen some of that research. MMA for example looks worse b/c of the potential for cuts and blood, but a single good punch typically ends a fight (and if a fighter does get to a position to really tee off, the ref stops the fight). Whereas in boxing, the boxer takes repeated punches over many rounds, and that doesn't count the training they do.
- linguistbreaker 5y agoMore head injuries. The gloves are to protect the hands.
- hnlmorg 5y agoYes, that's what I said :)
- marttt 5y agoTangentially related: I do odd jobs in forestry, in the former Soviet Union. An experienced forester once told me how during the old times, all workers were using regular boots or wellingtons -- that is, boots with no steel toe or other safety elements. By the early 90s, Husqvarna chainsaws and pro-level protective logger boots had gradually become the norm in our country. And guess what -- now, by the end of the day, the old forester would occasionally receive workers' boots with obvious chainsaw tracks across the toes. So, as long as the men were using regular, layman's boots, something like this had, obviously, never happened. No logger had ever cut in his toe. Pro-level safety gear, however, made many of them inattentive or careless. I wonder if this is also true to a degree when it comes to bike helmets. I often seem to ride faster and with more bravado when I'm wearing a helmet. I would, however, never let a 5yo child bike on a sidewalk without protection these days -- even though this is exactly how I grew up myself.
- gnu8 5y agoI'm reminded of the story about improving the armor on airplanes in World War 2. They were looking at where the fighters had been hit by enemy fire and improving the armor in those areas, until someone realized they should be armoring the areas where there were no bullet holes - because the planes hit in those areas didn't come back at all. Likely the same principle applies to the logging boots. Logging boots without steel toes were probably damaged to the point of. being unusable (to say nothing of the logger's foot) and they were discarded. I don't claim to know anything about sports but in the industrial environment, I am not going to be convinced that less PPE to make people work more carefully is a good idea. The idea is attractive as a paradox but it is beyond absurd to consider in practice - in fact it is barbaric.
- dyingkneepad 5y agoNot only research, but you can also see differences because there are events without gloves (bareknuckle boxing), events with small gloves (MMA) and events wtih big gloves (Boxing, but also Sparring which generally uses even bigger gloves). For olympic boxing they removed the helmets because they think it's safer. Also, the gloves are extremely useful to protect the hands. Bareknuckle boxing exists (and you can watch it on youtube!), and the gameplan for these guys is very different. You can't go 100% since you risk breaking your hand. There's no closing your eye and throwing a haymaker here. Defending a punch with your forehead suddenly becomes a viable strategy since it's likely the damage to their hand will be bigger than the damage to your forehead. Knuckle conditioning, wrist adjustments, etc. So many changes! I find it extremely fascinating. Extrapolating even further you can see how Jiu Jitsu becomes a whole different thing if you allow headbutts (just watch the 90's Brazilian Vale Tudo fights if you wanna see this, but I warn you that's it's much more violent than today's MMA fight). But that doesn't make it any safer so I may be diverging :)