17 ms·
So You Want to Study Philosophy
- sigmaprimus 5y agoThis is quite a long reading list, especially if one was to read everything four times as the author suggests. Personally I enjoy philosophy but in a much less indepth sense. I have no doubt that after reading all of these books I would become a most unbearable expert on philosophy that considered themselves the smartest person in the room.
- sjg007 5y agoOnly if you read the analytic stuff.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoMy approach to philosophy is to essentially choose a masterpiece and study only that masterpiece in depth, with secondary academic texts. His list takes too long, and my life is too short to read a bunch of fluff. The books I have studied in depth are: Thus Spoke Zarathustra by Nietzsche The Republic by Plato A Critique of Pure Reason by Kant The Phenomenology of the Spirit by Hegel Life is so short, read nothing but the cornerstones (this may not be that) of western thought. A great author for secondary texts is Stanley Rosen. He presents the material in a way that captures my imagination, and makes the philosophy understandable for a lay man. I would also argue, that for most serious texts, if you arent reading them with a guide (in my case often multiple), then you are wasting your time.
- kranner 5y ago> Life is so short, read nothing but the cornerstones (this may not be that) of western thought. I'd like to recommend Bryan W Van Norden's book "Taking Back Philosophy: A Multicultural Manifesto" for those willing to concede that maybe life is not short enough to ignore everything but Western thought. https://www.amazon.com/Taking-Back-Philosophy-Multicultural-Manifesto/dp/0231184379 https://www.amazon.com/Taking-Back-Philosophy-Multicultural-... edit: my original comment was asking "Why only western thought?" I removed it as it wasn't substantial enough.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoWith all due respect, please do not denigrate western philosophy by asserting its ubiquity is due to eurocentrism.
- kranner 5y agoNot denigrating Western Philosophy at all -- whose ubiquity may well be due to Eurocentrism primarily -- just saying there's more to look at elsewhere if one is interested in philosophy in general.
- cyber_kinetist 5y agoAny specific pointers on what books you should read? (Apart from the popular books / manifestos, I’m searching for real alternatives)
- kranner 5y agoThe Further Reading sections at the ends of volumes 3 (Philosophy in the Islamic World) and 5 (Classical Indian Philosophy) by Peter Adamson et al are great.
- cyber_kinetist 5y agoThe problem seems to be that, most non-Western philosophy I've heard is either from Chinese Confucianism (which personally I don't really like as a Korean, Korea has a long history of dealing with the problems of Confucianism for centuries), or from Buddhist/Zoroastianist/Islam religious literature (which I'm hesitant to read, since I don't have much of a religious background and think it's kind of superfluous, although I get why its existence is necessary) Maybe I just need to open my mind more, but as others have said I don't have much time left to cram other things into my (already very slow) hobby of reading continental philosophy. Hell, even most philosophers outside of Western countries doesn't really seem to look at non-Western philosophy that seriously. (Maybe it's because it's a Western thing to be a philsopher as a profession?) Chinese philosophers like Yuk Hui might be currently trying the synthesis of Western and Eastern thought, but it still seems like a long way to go (plus my objections on Confucianism).
- sammyq 5y agoThose are good recommendations though mostly modern. However, they’re notoriously known to be difficult readings for most people, even with a guide.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoYeah. One thing I didn't mention, is that I generally will spend 6 - 8 months or more on a book. I'm not always in the right state of mind to read, and often I can spend a really long time on one passage. I don't really see finishing the book as a goal, just to peel back the layers and try as hard as possible to understand the depth. For some reason German philosophy has always caught my thought process. It started with Nietzsche, and then went outward from there.
- PradeetPatel 5y agoThank you for the list, I've been trying to expand my philosophy horizon by reading non-European philosophers over last few months. I don't suppose anyone have any recommendations from Africa or the Polynesian people?
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoReading through your past comments, this one above looks like a thinly veiled political statement
- FranzFerdiNaN 5y agoThe excellent podcast History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps did a whole series on African philosophy: https://historyofphilosophy.net/series/africana-philosophy https://historyofphilosophy.net/series/africana-philosophy And Bryan van Norden, a professor of Chinese and comparative philosophy, made a reading list for non-western philosophy: http://www.bryanvannorden.com/suggestions-for-further-reading?s=09 http://www.bryanvannorden.com/suggestions-for-further-readin...
- timoth3y 5y agoThat's very interesting. I take the exact opposite approach. I start by reading wide surveys and overviews and then dig deep (both original works and commentary) into areas and writers the resonate with me personally. Some of my deeper dives have included Camus, Epictetus & Seneca, Popper and Spinoza. It's a pretty eclectic mix, and few would consider these foundational authors, but their works have had a great deal of influence on me personally.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoI think sometimes its a little masochistic, since not all of the material will be interesting. Part of the drive is knowing that these works offer some of the most depth of human thought known to man. My thinking is it would be a shame to live and not experience just a piece of what they have to offer. On my list are also the great epics, the Illiad and Odyssey
- curiousgal 5y agoI just went for Sophie's World which sums everything up.
- abdullahkhalids 5y agoWhy should I read these decades, centuries, millennia old books as a beginner [1]? In no other field are beginners asked to read old primary texts. This is my general criticism of philosophers [2] and the way they have constructed their discipline. In physics/biology/economics/etc a super smart person comes along and does some excellent work. Then later on, other smart people learn the stuff and build upon it, and rewrite it to make it better. Modern textbooks on General Relativity are an order of magnitude better than what Einstein wrote. Why has no one understood Nietzsche, and written a better and more understandable version of Nietzsche's work? And why is everyone not reading that? [1] I have read some/part of the books you mention. [2] As a physics phd, I have engaged in and enjoyed and found useful practical philosophy around issues of epistemology.
- andi999 5y agoAgree. It is even worse, here you have to learn Latin and old Greek so you can read the original texts. It is believed that the translations are not accurate (due to the problem that multiple words can be used and people shd know if exactly the same concept was meant or not). Somehow this seems to imply that these text are closer to poetry than ideas.
- Veen 5y ago> Why should I read these decades, centuries, millennia old books as a beginner [1]? In no other field are beginners asked to read old primary texts. One possible answer to this question is the same as to the question: Why look at old paintings, read old novels and poetry, watch old plays, and study history? For me, it's partly because I am interested in what humans have created and thought in the past. It's partly because these works are often beautiful—an argument can be as beautiful as a work of art—and studying beautiful things is its own reward. Whether they are true or not is another matter, but just as it's useful to read what other cultures in our own time think about a topic, it's useful to read about what people from other times thought. "The past is a foreign country; they do things differently there." You can design a course of study that focuses purely on modern logic and epistemology etc if that's what you prefer. But philosophy is not a science (however much philosophers like to think it is) and its not maths. It is a branch of the humanities, and should be evaluated in similar terms to literary studies or history, not biology or physics.
- throw0101a 5y ago> Life is so short, read nothing but the cornerstones (this may not be that) of western thought. The cornerstone of Western thought would be more Aristotle, especially given the influence he had on Christian/Catholic thought via the Scholastics (Aquinas). Western values are Christian values (Catholic and later Protestant): * https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/nov/21/dominion-making-western-mind-tom-holland-review https://www.theguardian.com/books/2019/nov/21/dominion-makin... * https://historyforatheists.com/2020/01/tom-holland-dominion/ https://historyforatheists.com/2020/01/tom-holland-dominion/ * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_WEIRDest_People_in_the_World https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_WEIRDest_People_in_the_Wor...
- sandwichbop 5y agoI love the formatting, going over how and what to study with little summaries to get you interested. Not too interested in Philosophy, but I love math. I tried to double major in it but couldn't get past Multivariable Calculus without destroying my GPA. Would anyone happen to know if any other articles spoon-feed you a learning path for mathematics like this?
- chubot 5y agoI think some philosophy is useful and enlightening, but I'd like to see a more thorough advocacy of it (not necessarily in this article, but maybe a link). This feels pretty thin: There is great satisfaction in thinking through fundamental, important things deeply, and I promise you that studying philosophy will completely change your life. Also this strikes me as uncritical: The purpose of this guide is to provide a roadmap so that anyone who follows and completes it will walk away with the knowledge equivalent to an undergraduate degree in philosophy. I'd like to hear an "experience report" from people who got an undergrad degree in philosophy more than 10 years ago. From what I can see the outcomes are very bimodal, not just in terms of future employment, but also as to whether they found it worthwhile, etc. I guess what rubs me slightly the wrong way about this list is it seems focused on "who said what, and when" and not necessarily what's true.
- franksvalli 5y agoI got a philosophy degree 10+ years ago and have been yearning to go back ever since and at least get a graduate degree, even though I know employment prospects are dismal in academia. Definitely loved my time studying philosophy and found it super worthwhile.
- cmrdporcupine 5y agoWhen I retire from my FAANG job I intend on going back and getting the philosophy degree I didn't finish because I took off to join the .com frenzy... 25 years ago.
- srcreigh 5y agoLet me chime in. I shouldn't, considering I only got a minor in philosophy alongside a major in computer science, and graduated less than five years ago, but here we go. The core question of philosophy is: how to appreciate life? What is our responsibility? How should we act? These are vital questions. Everybody engages with them in some way. Everybody learns philosophy in some way, the vast majority of learnings have no explicit connection to any religion or philosophical writings. Real life teaches you philosophy. This list, and the philosophy curriculum, has issues. For one, it's not the best way to learn critical thinking. It's better to learn math proofs. Truth tables, contra-positive, breaking things out into cases, induction. For two, western philosophy rarely provides actual answers. It asks more paralyzing questions than provides answers. Don't get me wrong, there are many beautiful things in many of the books - what I'm saying is that they don't equip you to recognize their value.. none of them give you the full picture. If you read these books, you will find that very few books will claim to present the full and complete truth. That's because they don't. They are incomplete. I believe true philosophy is more psychological, pragmatic, and spiritual than most of the philosophy curriculum would teach you. What are thoughts? What is productive vs not productive uses of time? etc. After I graduated with my minor in philosophy I read a book called Be Here Now. It discusses common aspects of many spiritual traditions. I also read some of the books in the bibliography of Be Here Now -- Tao Te Ching, some Hindu/yoga books, some Christian books. Today I am an Eastern Orthodox Christian. In Orthodoxy we understand Wisdom to be another way of talking about Christ. That's philosophy after all - philo sophia - love of wisdom. I can attest that the orthodox church has the fullness of truth and all the answers to any questions I have. It is the true philosophy.
- 50 5y agoThe latest philosophical text I've been living in is E.M. Cioran's On The Heights of Despair[1]. As a Goodreads review puts it: "The most relentlessly-pessimistic author not to have killed himself and, therefore, the writer of our only true solace... Warning to optimists: Reading... Cioran's work may kill you." [1] http://www.edarcipelago.com/freebooks/CioranHeightsofDespair.pdf http://www.edarcipelago.com/freebooks/CioranHeightsofDespair...
- jhvkjhk 5y agoI love reading beginner books of Philosophy. One of the best books is The Practice of Philosophy: A Handbook for Beginners. That book doesn't tell you the history or branches of Philosophy, it teaches you how to argument in the way of Philosophy. Reading the history and categories is like reading vocabulary books, it won't help you speak unless you learn the grammar first. (grammar => argument)
- curuinor 5y agothe introduction to continental philosophy here is left as footnote, but the argument for understanding continental philosophy and not as a red-headed stepchild of analytic philosophy goes in saying that they've had as equal an effect on the world of art and politics (of the kind in countries opposed to america, tho, of course) as analytic philosophy has in formal linguistics and cs and such. do you think they don't read adorno in beijing university? they do. if the chinese started off the great Deng reform era based upon the marxist doctrine of historical materialism, maybe it's worthwhile to go learn historical materialism! the Bourbaki conversed extensively with the French post-structuralists and various other weirdoes including Dieudonne, Levi-Strauss, Piaget and Lacan: if you understand more of post-structuralism, maybe you'll understand why the hell they are / were that way! they sure didn't have the early-Wittgensteinian idea of philosophy as fundamentally therapy underneath. they lived by philosophy, and slaughtered millions for it, but this is still worth study, if not very useful as life-enrichment.
- curation 5y agoThe worst thing you can do is go to university - 'the only place you cannot study' (Moten/Harney The Undercommons). One must be prepared to confront one's own ideology and individuation which both run counter to the university structure. For me, philosophy was a calling and my first interest in it I can remember was at nine. Truth is a whole in knowledge and paradoxes are what are to be sustained not resolved. Today, universities still teach that Hegel invented thesis/antithesis/synthesis - he did not and nowhere did he write this. His work undermines this very concept. Start with your own curiosity and move from there. Of course, if you want a job, go to university.
- FranzFerdiNaN 5y agoYou should most definitely go to university. Philosophy studied on your own is incomparable. A teacher and class mates to discuss the ideas presented in works is invaluable to help you develop your own ideas. And no university worth it's name will teach what you claim they do.
- kieselguhr_kid 5y agoI'm really pleased that Stoicism is seeing something of a resurgence. While Jack Dorsey and some other silicon valley types espousing it can be off-putting, there's a lot of value in Stoic ideas, and many of their practices anticipated or prefigured modern psychological practices (especially Cognitive-Behavioral therapy). Would recommend Epictetus after a reader got through Seneca and Marcus Aurelius, especially if that reader was intrigued by their ideas. It's a surprisingly easy read for a classical text, and a lot of the humor and sarcasm still hits after 1900 years.
- peter303 5y agoTwo important tenants of Stoicism include (1) the world can be understood through reason- this presages science and the enlightenment. And (2) live life moderately, between wealth and frugality.
- akomtu 5y agoThe modern philosophy, as it's taught in universities, is shallow mental gymnastics in most cases. Find and read all Plato's books, and I mean all, not just the short official list approved for students, and see how much universities intentionally omit.
- ldjkfkdsjnv 5y agoWhich of Platos works are you referencing here? Which ones are commonly not on the accepted list? Asking out of pure curiosity, have been meaning to read more Plato
- dr_dshiv 5y agoTimaeus, Phaedo, 7th letter, Parmenides... Super esoteric— But so good.
- cyber_kinetist 5y agoI’m skeptical that this will actually be useful to people who already have a day job and read philosophy in their spare time. And the curriculum seems to be mostly be centered on analytic philosophy (which is good if you’re interested in that stuff - but it’s probably not the full picture!) I’m personally doing something totally differently from this - trying to read recent texts on philosophy (mostly continental) and backtracking my way through the older ones. I don’t know if that’ll work (given the small amount of free time and mental energy left to devoting on it), but it still seems much more engaging than the usual standard philosophy curriculum.
- Jun8 5y agoTo supplement the material mentioned here I’d suggest the excellent Philosophy Bites podcast (also available as books). Each episode is an interview with an eminent philosopher on an interesting topic and the level of discussion is very understandable.
- broooder 5y agoI would just call it “reading” instead of “studying philosophy” — Philosophy Major
- peter303 5y agoIn Plato's Republic, the ideal rulers were philosophers. However in Plato's era philosophy encompassed science and law, i.e. a philosopher was an educated person.
- orr_eo 5y agoAsked a philosophy phd friend about this list, some thoughts: Why so few primary texts? Why mostly anglosphere authors? Why there's no arab or medieval authors? And most important, where is hegel? Where is his history of philosophy at least?
- bakuninsbart 5y agoGerman and French philosophy are completely absent, as is anything non-western. It is completely focused on the anglophone tradition.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- anaphor 5y agoAs someone with a philosophy degree this isn't a great list. Most of the recommended readings seem like random textbooks they found. It's pretty light on actual source material, and when they do list it, it's a bit bizarre, like recommending "On Formally Undecidable Propositions of Principia Mathematica and Related Systems" for philosophy of mathematics (Not that I think it's not worth reading, but not as your introduction to philos of math!), or recommending Kuhn as a supplemental reading, but not Popper, Bacon, Hume, etc. FWIW, for philosophy of mathematics, I'd recommend reading "Introduction To Mathematical Philosophy" by Bertrand Russell. The recommendation of The Frege Reader is actually good, but I'd recommend watching some lectures or something as well, otherwise it'll be a difficult read.
- osullivj 5y agoI'm a phil grad too, and agree. Too many inaccessible dry canonical texts. And no mention of Quine! I'd pick texts that animate the subject; with motivation the classics become more accessible. So for PhilSci I'd have Feyerabend's Farewell to Reason, for PhilMathLogic, Hofstadter's Godel, Escher, Bach. Quine's Essays covers logic, metaphysics, logic and language. And to keep things up to date I'd put Bostrom's Simulation argument.
- keiferski 5y agoThis list is very "philosophy academic" and focuses mostly on "analytic philosophy". In a few words, analytic philosophy is a largely Anglo-American tradition that is focused on language, mathematics, logic, and generally just being "precise." It has antecedents in previous centuries but is largely a 20th century phenomenon. However, analytic philosophy still dominates the academy in English-speaking countries. Analytic philosophy is contrasted with continental philosophy (as in, the European continent), which tends to be more interested in politics, society, the individual, and other less technical topics. An old joke goes like this: "The analytic philosopher will accuse the continental of being insufficiently clear, while the continental philosopher accuses the analytic of being insufficiently." Since this is HN, you might be interested in language, logic, and similar topics. If this is the case, you will likely enjoy analytic philosophy, especially Quine, Wittgenstein, Carnap, and Popper. However, if you are coming at philosophy cold, I really don't recommend the academic analytic path. It's too easy to get lost in the weeds and decide that all this stuff is just too obscure and abstruse to be useful. If that's the case, I suggest a very brief reading list to shake up your default preconceptions of how the world works. The goal here is to make you question your basic assumptions, which is when philosophy is at its best. - Meditations by Marcus Aurelius and On the Shortness of Life by Seneca. Classic Stoic works. Very accessible entry points to classical philosophy and Stoicism. - Beyond Good and Evil by Friedrich Nietzsche. If you read this and understand it, your entire conception of ethics, values, and how we use labels like "good" or "evil" will be shaken up. - Republic by Plato. If you live in a Western country, you probably think that democracy is the highest and best form of government. Plato thinks otherwise and it's worth understanding why. - A Tractate on Japanese Aesthetics by Donald Richie. This is a fairly recent book but it serves as an excellent introduction to East Asian and Japanese thought via art and aesthetics. - I Ching. The Chinese classic is super easy to read and is diametrically opposite to the static, eternal universal Platonic model much of Western thought it built upon. - You should also probably read something from India, the Islamic world, and Russia, but I wanted to keep my list fairly short. Some recommendations here are The Bhagavad Gita, Ḥayy ibn Yaqẓān, and anything by Dostoyevsky. For reference: I have a bachelor's in philosophy from a program in the US which is almost exclusively analytic in nature.
- niklodeon 5y agoI found the following paper extremely enlightening: "What’s wrong with contemporary philosophy?" https://philpapers.org/rec/MULWWW https://philpapers.org/rec/MULWWW
- pknerd 5y agoI found Philosophy 101[0] pretty helpful, it was concise and with practical examples. [0] https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-101-Socrates-Metaphysics-Essential/dp/1440567670 https://www.amazon.com/Philosophy-101-Socrates-Metaphysics-E...
- ttonkytonk 5y agoMost of Plato's dialogues are available for free on an app.
- nathias 5y agoTo anyone that would be interested, skip all introductory texts and the overviews and other secondary stuff, just start with Plato and go on.
- rdevsrex 5y agoI'm planning to back to school soon, and I'm torn between studying Math or Philosophy. I like them both a lot, and there are many similarities, but definitely if I choose Philosophy, I know it's not going to do much for my job prospects as a programmer.
- keiferski 5y agoThere are a few programs that combine CS and philosophy. https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses-listing/computer-science-and-philosophy https://www.ox.ac.uk/admissions/undergraduate/courses-listin...
- beaconstudios 5y agoI'm not sure I'd recommend Aurelius' Meditations as an easy-to-read introduction to Stoicism - it's a hefty tome (in the longer editions, I can't speak for the ~100-200 page versions) and incredibly repetitive, which is no surprise given it's essentially his personal journal. I'd much sooner recommend "Letters from a Stoic", a compilation of Seneca's letters to his friend Lucilius. It's much more conversational but still covers all the important ground of Stoicism.
- pjfin123 5y agoI have condensed notes on "Meditations" https://www.reddit.com/r/Stoicism/comments/pesssf/notes_on_meditations_a_new_translation_by_marcus/ https://www.reddit.com/r/Stoicism/comments/pesssf/notes_on_m...
- 0kl 5y agoHard agree here. Seneca’s letters are intended for a public audience; Aurelius’s meditations are the self-reflective journal writings of a stoic (and emperor). Additionally Epictetus has the enchiridion that is the closest thing to a textbook on Stoicism we have
- throw1234651234 5y agoI really liked Aurelius' quotes, and bought "Meditations" as a result - the book didn't seem to add anything and I quit after 10-20 pages, which I very, very rarely do with books.
- cutler 5y agoRead everything 4 times? How many lifetimes are we talking? Does the author sleep?
- Emma_Goldman 5y agoIt's fairly inane as an unbending rule, given that a large fraction of what you read isn't going to be relevant or interesting. But for those works that are interesting and intricately argued, there is no getting around the need to re-read many times. There are philosophers who have spent their whole lives reading Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit or Kant's three Critiques. That's extreme, but my point is that if you want to read quality philosophy, you're going to have to put some effort and time in.
- stewbrew 5y ago"It’s not enough to sit down and read through the textbooks here once [...] I’ve learned a pretty foolproof method for studying philosophy: read everything four times." While I enjoy a close read as the next guy, I really have difficulties not to get sarcastic. That said: philosophy was cool when public intellectuals had some importance. But that's a thing of the past. Philosophy is done. It still can be a nice hobby but you should look for ways to find people you can discuss things with. This becomes even better if you disagree.
- beaconstudios 5y agoPhilosophy is far from done; especially as it applies to every individual's understanding of the world. We're only just now starting to see the impact that a few strands of postmodernism could have on the world, and I can't imagine how interesting an application of Deleuze or Baudrillard's ideas would be to our politics. Everybody has a philosophy they live by in the ethical, social, scientific (epistemological) etc spheres. If you haven't studied philosophy, it's very possible that there are other ideas that could better inform your thoughts and decisions, or your current ideas might be inconsistent.
- stewbrew 5y agoYou are arrogant and I am old, too old to waste my time. That's a pleasure of the youth.
- beaconstudios 5y agothat's pretty rude. The "you" in my statement is not you personally, but the general "you" - I'm already British enough without using the word "one" in its place for disambiguation. I'm far from well read in philosophy myself, but I've already learned a lot from what I have read and look forward to learning more in future.
- stewbrew 5y agoSorry for that. I said it's a nice hobby. But its heydays are over. Words don't have the magical feeling anymore they once had unless it comes to manipulation and betrayal.
- luizfelberti 5y agoThis is a great place to recommend Standard Ebooks's excellent collection of translated Public Domain works, which includes many of the listed titles in TFA: https://standardebooks.org/ebooks https://standardebooks.org/ebooks
- nbulka 5y agoI majored in Philosophy, thought about doing a PhD but I ended up moving around with my wife (girlfriend at the time) working odd jobs for awhile, winding up as a software engineer. I learned about category theory through HN, and I now believe it should taught in the first semester of philosophy undergrad. It's tough and terse subject matter, but PHIL needs more of those rigorous classes.
- platz 5y agoI'm not sure how knowing what an adjunction or a pullback is helps serve the mission of the undergrad philosophy department.
- myWindoonn 5y agoYour snark is unhelpful. Here's some things philosophy undergrads should know from category theory: * Size issues. All the problems in set theory are back with a vengeance. Exploring size issues makes it clear that Russell's Paradox is not a fluke. * Topoi. A topos is a generalization of the past few millennia of maths, and their existence shows that maths is a multiverse rather than a single collection of rules. Some topoi witness refutations of LEM, making them valuable counterexamples. * Yoneda's lemma. The core of pragmatic philosophy is that objects are not separable from their effects in the world. Yoneda's result takes that to its logical conclusion: An object is equivalent to all of its effects under transformation. * Equivalence of categories. Rel is equivalent to its dual (Rel is daggered) and so is Hilb; the category Set* of sets with an extra point is equivalent to the category Pfn of sets and partial functions. These show us that parts of maths are self-symmetric beyond group theory. In addition, why shouldn't adjunctions be covered at some point? Adjunctions can't be studied without category theory (look up "Galois connections" for a history) and they're hard to avoid once we're talking about enough categories of note. I bet that the adjointness of syntax and semantics is very relevant to philosophy of language.
- platz 5y agoIt's clear why Formal Logic is studied in undergrad philosophy programs, but there's only so much space to study the core Philosophy ideas in the undergrad time allotted, and what you're suggesting sounds like they'd be getting a math degree rather than a phil degree. It would be more appropriate for graduate phil courses to consider the ideas you highlighted.
- prvc 5y agoI would be interested in knowing what the rejected alternative texts that the author also read, in order to make the determination that the listed titles were the best (and why so in each case).
- prvc 5y ago>as of today, over six hundred thousand people have used it! If we're talking about page impressions, then it seems less than certain that every one of them corresponds to a unique person who has followed the described advice exactly.
- Schiphol 5y agoA fantastic resource on the history of philosophy, not linked to here, is Peter Adamson's "History of Philosophy Without Any Gaps", both the books and the series of podcasts: https://historyofphilosophy.net/ https://historyofphilosophy.net/. Apart from very good coverage of the usual suspects, here you have much, much more Africana and Islamic philosophy (for example) than the average Western academic philosopher has been exposed to.
- bakuninsbart 5y agoOne thing I love is that he apparently got a Professor position not requiring him to do anything but the podcast and teaching. The Podcast is truly great and possibly the most important piece of work in the field of history of philosophy of the last few decades. I know multiple people who fell deeply in love with the field thanks to his work.
- Koshkin 5y agoIn the process of studying physics, you do not have to study Aristotle, but you do when studying philosophy. This tells me that either progress in philosophy as an area of knowledge is very slow, or, unlike in other areas and not unlike with religion (or culture in general) there are many of them - potentially of equal value, - or that philosophy must always be studied and can only be understood in the historical and/or cultural context.
- freedomben 5y agoWhen I studied physics, we did start with Aristotle. In both physics and philosophy you're not studying Ancient Greece necessarily because they are right, you're studying it because understanding the history of thought helps you understand modern thought.
- guenthert 5y agoBut how common is that? Where/when I studied, history of science was a different major. Sure, we (undergrad students with physics major) knew about Newton and those inclined as much could study the historic context on their own, but otherwise everything (perhaps short of classic mechanic of the rigid body) before the late nineteenth century was of little interest.
- evol262 5y agoTo verify and prove that you have a new, original thought, you essentially need to address everyone who's every written about it before, and their arguments (or at least intermediaries who have already done that). A lot of philosophical texts are "I have this new theory", and the remainder of the text is "so-and-so said this, but they are wrong/my idea is different because...". Think of something like Kant's Metaphysics of Morals. The vast majority of the text is little different from a proof with QED at the end. In physics, you learn formulas, and those can/do build on top of each other (as well as mathematical axioms/shortcuts). Reading Aristotle isn't any different in that sense. You aren't reading Aristotle for The Physics. You're reading it for ethical theory (and virtue ethics in theory), the underpinnings of philosphy of science, and Aristotelian/term logic (so you can understand the arguments of later authors prior to propositional logic). In order to understand philosophical thought and argument, it's necessary to have this knowledge, and it's no different than me saying "in the process of studying physics, you have to study geometry" (as a prerequisite to later mathematics). This isn't any different, and putting the study of philosophy in some sort of "philosophy is slow" or "can only be understood in the historical and/or cultural context" box denigrates the entire discipline from a position of ignorance.
- sodality2 5y agoMaybe soon, philosophy won't be considered a "difficult/advanced topic". I'm beginning to see more philosophy-oriented classes in high school, which is awesome. I am currently taking Theory of Knowledge, an International Baccalaureate class, as a high school senior. The IB heads hate calling it a philosophy class but it aims to "provide an opportunity for students to reflect on the nature of knowledge, and on how we know what we claim to know" (so, philosophy-oriented). It is compulsory for an IB diploma. This has certainly increased interest in philosophy in IB students and it becomes a favorite class for most students and even IB coordinators. Creating early interest in topics will definitely encourage later interest.
- BatFastard 5y agoMy son took a philosophy class in college. He had to read some papers for a project, and asked for my help in understanding them. What I found was a whole new way of describing the world that I can only describe as intellectual masturbation.
- true_maybe 5y agoIt seems to me that an introduction to philosophy that maintains both interest and graspability is in the philosophy of science. All of the sciences began in philosophy. When the great big questions that invoke a great deal of discussion over meaning subside, that science has gone on to supersede its parent: This happened with physics in the 17th century, biology, and psychology. If you want to ask great big questions of a discipline that are often frowned upon within that discipline, philosophy is a place to engage in this type of discourse. Further, the lines of _what a discipline is_ are typically drawn in philosophy, not within the discipline itself. This is a frequent discourse in the philosophy of science. As, the question of, "what is science" doesn't seem well suited to be answered by any science in particular.