9 ms·
As someone who has been in one or another meeting with German TV stations I can assure you this is not completely far fetched. The people deciding what is runni
by atoav 5y ago
As someone who has been in one or another meeting with German TV stations I can assure you this is not completely far fetched. The people deciding what is running at these stations are of the mindset (a translated quote):
> Our average viewer is 65 years old and watches TV while doing the dishes, we must not show things that cannot be understood by them
and then they will serenade about how they would "love to have a bit more sophisticated things", but as they are the only ones who really understand their audience, they cannot allow this, although they support the values of the 68 generation etc. pp.
From my standpoint the German television landscape is completely doomed, because the people at the levers are in the illusion they do the good thing for "the small man" while in fact they just think the small man is incomprehensible stupid and must not ever be confronted with content that shows them that there is still stuff to learn and understand in the world.
- mattmanser 5y agoWell, you say that, but isn't that exactly why Netflix got rid of ratings? All the documentaries were getting really high ratings, so would display highly in searches, but not many people actually watched them. It's the same for most content, I read a huge amount. I do read some intellectual books, but only occasionally. The rest of the time I read utter, thoroughly entertaining, trash. I don't want to read about an existential crisis after programming all day, I want someone to hit something with a big sword and get the girl.
- bluGill 5y ago> It's the same for most content, I read a huge amount. I do read some intellectual books, but only occasionally. The rest of the time I read utter, thoroughly entertaining, trash. I feel the same way. However I force myself to read things that will better me once in a while anyway. I too want to hit things with a big sword (without the pain of getting hit), and get the girl (without cheating on my wife), but the world including me is better if I do something else anyway. Which is why I do sometimes read a complex math book.
- q-big 5y ago> Well, you say that, but isn't that exactly why Netflix got rid of ratings? > All the documentaries were getting really high ratings, so would display highly in searches, but not many people actually watched them. This rather shows that ratings do work, but are used wrongly for giving recommendations: If you want to create suggestions for a user, in many case the wrong answer is "suggest what has really high ratings", but rather "given the ratings that this user gave and the films that he watched, what will he also like." The fact that these documentaries get high ratings (the same might hold for art house films) shows that there is some (niche?) audience which really loves this kind of films, but not that "John Doe" will love it, too.
- sempron64 5y agoPredicting exactly this was the premise of the famous Netflix Prize, one of the first open machine learning challenges https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netflix_Prize https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Netflix_Prize
- tehjoker 5y agoI remember my professor talking about the ensemble approach the competitors were taking in a data mining class I took. I was saddened when Netflix ended up not using it because it was too slow and expensive or something.
- dmoy 5y agoI remember when that competition was released, I was working (as an undergrad) in GroupLens, which had MovieLens still around but it was getting a bit of bitrot. It was always weird to me that GroupLens didn't spin up a team for it, but it seemed like everyone in the research group had moved on to other things and didn't want to context switch back. Someone mentioned something like "shame they didn't do this 10 years ago, a million dollars would have been nice". I think someone was doing tagging on movielens, but I don't remember the details. I got the sense that neither Riedl nor Konstan (or any of the current grad students it seemed) wanted to pursue it (Terveen, I think, wasn't in to recommender systems at all in the first place). I don't think the lab had any funding problems haha, so maybe that was what it came down to.
- tehjoker 5y agoThat is how it is with documentaries. Just because they are getting lower viewing numbers doesn't mean you shouldn't keep promoting them. Certainly there should be a mix of entertainment and public interest stuff, but following audience preferences for entertainment creates a feedback loop that damages society.
- eru 5y agoThings like documentaries are mostly watched by already well-off people (mostly middle class and up). In Germany, public TV is paid for by (nearly?) every household. [0] Forcing everyone, including poor people, to subsidize rich people's taste for documentaries seems a bit.. off? Similar arguments apply to public libraries and opera houses, though at least there the financing is done mostly via progressive taxation. Of course, you can argue that we sophisticated people know what's good for those unwashed masses, and if only they watched their documentaries like they are supposed to, they would soon see the light. Colour me skeptical. [0] As far as I am concerned, private broadcasters can and should do what they feel like.
- nitrogen 5y agoWell, when people complain about a growing wealth divide, and those who are doing okay financially say that childhood access to public libraries and documentaries made them who they are, shouldn't those things receive funding?
- eru 5y agoThat's a bit like asking healthy people. You'll get answers ranging from things like exercise to homeopathy. Answers from people can be used to suggest avenues for investigation, but shouldn't make you fund expensive stuff outright. (Assuming here that homeopathy is obvious nonsense, that people still swear by.) And, of course, public libraries and documentaries don't have to just produce good effects. In order to justify public funding, you'd need to do a whole cost-benefit analysis and look at opportunity costs. So look at what you get from public libraries vs libraries financed from private charity _plus_ whatever other good things the public money saved could do (including just outright giving it to poor people). I deliberately picked public libraries here as a provocative examples. I suspect they might actually pass the cost-benefit test without too much contortion of metrics and data. I am much less sanguine about the bang-for-buck of publicly financed opera houses, theatres and symphony orchestras, which Germany is quite fond of. And of course, publicly financed radio and TV broadcasters.
- bluGill 5y agoThat is always the problem with data: it is reactive. Sure the average watcher is 65, and wants easy to understand stuff: that is what the data shows (I'll assume for discussion that is what the data shows, but I have no insight into if it is true or not). What the data doesn't show is if content would draw in day 25 year olds, they need several years of trying those other shows to see if it makes a difference - a very risky best that could run them out of business even if true (that is the older crowd stops watching faster than the younger crowd figured out it is worth watching meaning advertisers don't pay enough to keep producing content). Of course TV in the US has figured out that the 65+ crowd is very valuable to customers (the advertisers, not viewers!), so even though they could get more viewers by not showing the nightly news, the nightly news is what they show.
- a4isms 5y agoThis the same problem as interviewing people for a job nd collecting data about which “features” from interviews correlate with job performance… Without tracking the performance of any of the candidates who weren’t offered jobs—or turned down an offer. Something, something, a diagram of a plane showing where the damage was on those that returned from missions.
- andai 5y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias
- errantspark 5y ago> Something, something, a diagram of a plane showing where the damage was on those that returned from missions. Ahahahah I love this dogwhistle. You always know you're in good company when someone waves their hands around and says "put the armor where there AREN'T bullet holes" and gives you a significant look. XD
- ryandrake 5y agoReminds me of a thread a while ago pointing out that a single show dominates the MTV programming lineup almost every day [1]. It's as if there is some algorithm running without human intervention that feeds on itself by reacting only to current viewing habits: foreach (show s in lineup) if (s.viewers > THRESHOLD) lineup.replace_with_more (s) Obviously resulting in this weird local maxima where no other shows get broadcast. 1: https://twitter.com/MTVSchedule/status/1422934028253081603 https://twitter.com/MTVSchedule/status/1422934028253081603
- touristtam 5y agoIn France there is the 50 yo housewife: https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https://www.definitions-marketing.com/definition/menagere-50-ans/ https://translate.google.com/translate?sl=auto&tl=en&u=https...
- jancsika 5y ago> Our average viewer is 65 years old and watches TV while doing the dishes, we must not show things that cannot be understood by them So like, sticking only to the first and second derivative in soap opera plots about retired civil engineers? No late-period Beethoven sonatas as background music? That must be difficult for you as a German. Meanwhile, here in America we're perhaps a few years away from something like the movie "Ass" from Idiocracy winning an Oscar.
- eru 5y agoAre you joking, or do you have perhaps too high an opinion of German TV?
- jancsika 5y agoOn the one hand: yes, I am. On the other-- we have a network that bills itself as educational and spends over a month marketing a full week of programming dedicated to propagandizing its audience to be maximally afraid of sharks. It broadcast a wildly popular movie where a tornado full of sharks attacks a city. German TV could be an order of magnitude worse than my parody and it still wouldn't even register on the American scale of stupidity.
- JTbane 5y ago> Meanwhile, here in America we're perhaps a few years away from something like the movie "Ass" from Idiocracy winning an Oscar. Very true, this is the first thing I thought of when I head of the popular show "Naked and Afraid".
- jandrese 5y agoIt reminds me of the (possibly apocryphal) reasoning behind the cancellation of "Police Squad" back in the day: that people would have to pay attention to get the jokes. https://boingboing.net/2014/07/04/police-squad-was-cancelled-be.html https://boingboing.net/2014/07/04/police-squad-was-cancelled...
- eru 5y agoThe '68 generation' is pretty much the same generation that's now 65 years old and washing dishes.. > From my standpoint the German television landscape is completely doomed, because the people at the levers are in the illusion they do the good thing for "the small man" while in fact they just think the small man is incomprehensible stupid and must not ever be confronted with content that shows them that there is still stuff to learn and understand in the world. Well, that would be more bearable, if half the TV market wouldn't be allowed to essentially tax everyone to finance their drivel.
- blablabla123 5y agoI stopped watching TV more than 10 years ago because I was worried to turn stupid from it. Not so far fetched after all. There are some high quality shows and TV stations though. Namely Phoenix (similar to PBS in the U.S.) and some of the news magazines that run in the late evenings. Of course there are also all the other public stations with higher quality programs but I find the program most of the time quite random and sometimes even a bit elitarian.
- josefx 5y ago> > Our average viewer is 65 years old and watches TV while doing the dishes, we must not show things that cannot be understood by them I haven't watched german TV in ages, but I distinctly remember science shows degrading from science to thinly veiled ads - things like literally running a companies marketing video or making a "scientific comparison" where they hand out random style points at the end to make a specific product win. I think they even got into trouble over it since ads and science/education shows are taxed differently. Anyone pretending that they are doing that for their viewers is living in denial at best, but probably just outright lying.
- type0 5y agoThe biggest problem on television is lying, and that problem is prevalent not just on German TV. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMlMH1RfnF0 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gMlMH1RfnF0
- noAnswer 5y ago> Our average viewer is 65 years old and watches TV while doing the dishes, we must not show things that cannot be understood by them > because the people at the levers are in the illusion they do the good thing for "the small man" while in fact they just think the small man is incomprehensible stupid So basically they have a Hacker News mindset! In every thread about a dumbed down GUI/website it is argued that granny wouldn't understand it otherwise. No power user allowed, because data shows user is monkey.