10 ms·
Partisan attachment: How politics is changing dating and relationships (2020)
- Claudus 5y agoMy perception of the mindset of the typical liberal in the past was that it was more about making change for the benefit of everyone in the country (don’t worry conservatives , this will work out for the best). Now it is more about making change that benefits some at the expense of others (screw you conservatives). In order to push political agendas like this, political opposition needs to be more negatively portrayed and demonized. My perception of conservatives is that they are trending in this direction too, and the result is more fracturing of our societies.
- larksimian 5y ago'Liberal' and 'conservative' are just labels that no longer describe the same ideologies as in the past. 19th C liberals were sort of like modern day libertarians, but in the context of the European monarchies at the time which were explicitly oppressive. 20th century progressives with their universal social programs were social democrats. Modern day liberals are split between 'centrist' neo-liberals and more hardcore leftists. The neo-libs are basically still trying to promote universalish improvement, but are not willing to tax their corporate donors to do it. So all they're left with is culture war posturing and legislation, since that's fiscally free. The more hardcore leftists, in America, seem to heavily skew towards helping particular disadvantaged groups, as opposed to the universalizing efforts of early 20th C socialists(be it racial or sexual minorities or whatever). And some of these groups care more about equality than they do absolute improvement for everyone. As for conservatives, modern day American conservatism is HARD reactionary and in no way conservative. The social programs they are trying to privatize and dismantle have existed for 60-80 years. The conservative position would be to preserve things like Social Security and Medicare. If anything the most conservative force, when it comes to the role of government, in American politics right now are the Centrist Democrats, since they're the party of small tweaks.
- andrew_ 5y agoIt's curious that you see a spectrum in the left, but not in the right. That might suggest bias, but I'd like to give you the benefit of doubt. There is no universal conservative position, nor are all conservatives reactionary. Just as those far to the left have strayed from classical liberalism, those far to the right have strayed from classical conservatism. With the rampant labeling and tribalism so popular these days, many of us just don't know what political camp we fit into anymore. Update: If you're downvoting, please do share why, or share a critique or rebuttal. I'd genuinely like to read some opposing opinions. I had thought that was a fair reply to the parent as the political spectrum in U.S. politics has been rather well-documented as diverse both to the left and to the right.
- AmericanChopper 5y agoI’m always a bit entertained by people who claim they want to express a non-biased view of partisan dynamics, and then proceed to express something that is a perfect representation of the fundamental attribution error. Personally I think the primary contention that exists between the dogma of the left and the right is just the contention between collectivism and individualism. But outliers aside, I don’t think you end up with substantially different policies from one side or the other, regardless of the contrast in the dogma. I don’t think members of either tribe are substantially different in their dogmatism, reactionism… or in their proclivity to deeply reflect on the views they hold. For any person who finds themselves substantially aligned with a mainstream political ideology, I think the chance that they’ve put a substantial amount of critical thought into their world view is very close to 0.
- andrew_ 5y ago> is just the contention between collectivism and individualism Yes. > I’m always a bit entertained by people who claim they want to express a non-biased view of partisan dynamics, and then proceed to express something that is a perfect representation of the fundamental attribution error. Were you commenting on the parent to my reply, or to my reply specifically? Genuine curiosity.
- jdsleppy 5y agoThe big ticket, agreed upon progressive priorities are still for the benefit of all: Green New Deal, Medicare for all, accessible higher education. I find it more difficult to find policies for the common good coming from conservatives these days. Does anyone have examples?
- edgyquant 5y agoThe reason you don't know any is because >policies for the common good coming Is a political thing. You disagree with the average conservative on what constitutes policies for the common good.
- fidesomnes 5y agoMandatory sex change for all white males would be good too.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoThe (fiscal) conservative view of those items is that paying for them is going to create poverty, or at least a lot of people being less well off because of the taxes. (And that Modern Monetary Theory is wishful thinking that doesn't work in reality.) The conservatives could be wrong. But they aren't just hard-hearted Scrooge McDuck types who don't want to pay for something that will benefit the poors.
- mothsonasloth 5y agoMy 2 pennies: Living in a secular society where religion plays a reduced part on the individual, compared with 50 years ago. People now fill the gaps with other banners to fly and differentiate themselves with.
- adrianb 5y agoI agree, religion offers simple ways to classify actions as good or bad. Following the church teachings or priest's guidance was enough to make an individual confident they are a good person, doing good things. Meanwhile, in real life, everything is complex, few things are clearly good or bad, everything has advantages and disadvantages. People need a simple compass to distinguish good and bad. It seems the "political beliefs" are taking up that space in a secular society.
- snarf21 5y agoThat is the narrative of the religious but most don't go to learn about what they are doing wrong. They go to find out what other people are doing wrong so they can feel superior and rail against the sin of others. Religion has always been a weapon, it is just easier to wield now.
- qsort 5y agoI'm not religious myself, but it is true that if you're going to treat something other than religion as though it were a religion, it's almost always going to be much worse. Most religious prescriptions are either common sense (thou shalt not kill, thou shalt not bear false witness) or recipes to avoid social chaos (thou shalt not commit adultery). Of course religion has also been wielded as a weapon, and I'm the first in line to cherish western secularization, but I don't see it as an inherently socially harmful force.
- seneca 5y ago> That is the narrative of the religious but most don't go to learn about what they are doing wrong. They go to find out what other people are doing wrong so they can feel superior and rail against the sin of others. And this is the narrative of the Extremely Online Atheist. Of the hundreds of religious people I know (though I'm not myself), maybe two fit that description. You are noticing outliers and assuming they represent the entire group.
- irjustin 5y agoThis was me circa 2012-2013. I hadn't realized it yet, but was quite liberal minded compared to my fellow church mates. I tried talking to someone who is rather politically conservative (she eventually ran for office). In our conversations, I just kept finding myself thinking... that's not how I view that... at all. Nothing became of the relationship, but doubt it would have maintained anyway. For me, it was the first time trying to date across the isle with someone who was politically aware and was very eye opening.
- peterburkimsher 5y agoIt's good to have a variety of friends from different perspectives, so that the peer pressure can balance a little. I agree that for relationship commitments, it's often a more enjoyable to find someone with compatible views rather than just what one community expects from you. In my case, I decided it would be a good learning experience to date a non-Christian whose world view and travel experience is more suitable for mine. I thought it would be a good learning experience, and it is! I didn't expect we'd still be together 4.5 years later, but I'd rather stay long-distance with her than be with anyone else, or single again. Every day my mind wonders why we're still together, and every night we chat online and my heart falls madly in love with her all over again. Side note for church, specifically: my favourite church is where the sermon is convicting and the people are encouraging. My least favourite church is where the sermon is encouraging and the people are convicting.
- onionisafruit 5y agoMy favorite is where the people are encouraging and the sermon is under ten minutes.
- neverywhere 5y agoConservatives currently out reproduce liberals for whatever reason, for example: https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-conservative-fertility-advantage https://ifstudies.org/blog/the-conservative-fertility-advant... I wonder if it is purely cultural or is there a genetic component? If there is low fertility because of a genetic component, that is likely going to targeted hard by evolution now. (Will evolution select against women getting higher education like Masters or PhD? Because that is one of the biggest predictors of reduced fertility.) What does this mean for liberal views? Are they destined to become more conservative over time if there is a genetic component which is being selected against? So interesting. I wish we could track genetic changes along with political changes over time. I bet there is more happening there than we think. EDIT: Here is a large meta analysis paper that seems to indicate that genetics influences political ideology: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4038932/pdf/nihms-570512.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4038932/pdf/nih...
- kaesar14 5y agoConservatives live in less expensive areas and often have less wealth, two things that often drive reproduction rates up higher. I feel comfortable Occam’s Razoring that up as the explanation
- knubie 5y agoConservative parents don't necessarily produce conservative children.
- neverywhere 5y agoBut papers do indicate that there is a genetic component to political ideology: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4038932/pdf/nihms-570512.pdf https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4038932/pdf/nih... Your argument is akin to a global warming denier saying that yeah, but some days are still cold. Yes, there will always be variation.
- knubie 5y agoThat's not really analogous. I'm just pointing out that there is an underlying assumption in your argument that may or may not be true.
- rejectedandsad 5y agoAt this point in my life I definitely wouldn't try to date a conservative. The cultural gaps between cosmopolitanism and (everything else) have become increasingly large, especially for a person of color like myself. With that said, nobody's really knocking down my door to go out with me either, so I'm mostly just a choosing beggar.
- einpoklum 5y agoThe American Enterprise Institute? That's the pro-corporate think tank which, among other highlights, has been involved in trying to deny climate change, including by paying scientists travel stipends to attend anti-IPCC events.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoI agree, but this article is fairly dry. Conservatives today see anything that shuts them out of any process as alarming because they are traditionally the ones who have held the reins, and I suspect this is why it's an AEI article.
- giantg2 5y agoThis isn't surprising. People want to build a life with someone who shares their values.
- tristor 5y agoCounter-intuitively, my parents have stayed happily married for a very long time and my dad is significantly more conservative than my mom (although my mom has become more "conservative" in the current decade in reaction to how extreme rhetoric on the left has become in the US). I am about to propose to my long-time partner who is significantly more to the left than I am (we are both to the left, I'm barely left of center, my partner is barely to the right of the the edge of the chart). There used to be the phrase "opposites attract". I think there are value systems which underlie politics that need to match up, but those value systems don't necessarily translate into the exact same political beliefs. In fact, in the US historically, men tended to be more conservative and women more progressive, and I don't see that really changing in the current times. Most of my male friends are more conservative than their partners, even as most of us are left of center. This is true, anecdotally, among the people I know across educational attainment and income. On the flip side, when I was still dating, I always brought up politics and religion on the first date because it helped me filter people out. I didn't filter people out because we disagreed politically, but because of /how/ we disagreed (or rather how /they/ disagreed) politically. It was surprising the number of people who were exceedingly disagreeable about politics, completely unable to have a polite conversation on the topic, where any hint of dissent from their view was met with vehemence, even in person in a face-to-face conversation. My experience up to that point was this was how things worked online, but you could have a conversation with someone very different from you over a beer and it'd be alright face-to-face. Dating changed my outlook on this. I think this was a good filter, because while politics was the topic of discussion, the filter had nothing to do with beliefs and everything to do with agreeableness, reasonableness, and behavior. In effect, it became a very good way to filter out assholes, of which there are many, unfortunately the majority of eligible persons in my dating pool. But, no regrets on this filter, because my current partner is wonderful and was found after many years of searching using this filter. My parents relationship, the relationships of my friends (most of whom are married), and my own relationship are all anecdotal, but strong evidence that supports you don't need to politically agree to date successfully and have a long-term relationship or marriage. But it does require the two people involved to not be vehement zealots who dehumanize anyone that disagrees with them, which unfortunately is becoming a rarer situation thanks to the extremist echo chambers we've created online.
- jti107 5y agoit doesn't just affect the two people dating, it makes things awkward for everyone else. my brother is dating a hardcore Trump supporter and its just super awkward during the holidays. i am cordial and respectful but it sucks feeling like you are walking on eggshells.
- rmellow 5y agoThe operative keyword there is "hardcore", and it applies for either political direction: I guarantee lots of conservatives also walk on eggshells around hardcore leftists for the sake of cordiality, just as cordial lefts walk around eggshells near radical conservatives. Naturally, cordial people's politics are harder to tell, especially near a radical.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- ecshafer 5y agoWhy would it be awkward? I am often in very mixed political company, and never share the politics of people I am around. It isn't awkward at all. Either, don't talk about politics. Or just have fun debates, assuming they are able to hold those debates. If you can't talk with people that disagree with you, that's an issue.
- pessimizer 5y agoThis would be a good thing if it were true. Politics is not a product where your choice of whether to consume the red, blue, or green thing is an irrelevant expression of your personality or style. It's always life or death, and that fact is disguised when it doesn't mean your life or death. This survey is also corrupted by self-reporting. People like to pretend that they're more tolerant than they are (especially when they don't have a comfortable or civil argument for their intolerance.) In fact, I bet if you followed up with a bit of a Keynesian beauty contest, you'd find that they report that the tribe that they belong to is far more tolerant than the enemy tribe. And for a fact pulled out of my ass, I bet if you checked the proportion of people who married outside of their race or religion 50 years ago, it would be <1% (at least for people who claimed a race or religion.) If you checked now, the numbers would be 4-6% IIRC. That's an improvement. You might find a higher percentage of mixed Democrat/Republican relationships 50 years ago (maybe), but if that number has dropped, that's also an improvement. Material differences in opinions about how the world should be run and people should behave should at least be more significant than race or (the mystical aspects, not the moral codes of) religion. It means that society is becoming more supportive of people trying to escape their tribal affiliations. 80 years ago, in the US, there were laws actively preventing this.
- draw_down 5y agoIn America, politics is indeed a middle class-dominated area where people choose their product. When matters do come down to life and death, such as in wars, the two teams do not proceed materially differently. There is a reason we had 20 years of war in Afghanistan for example, and it ain’t because only one of the teams kept it going. I agree on your point about people’s view of their own tolerance.
- reccanti 5y agoPeople on this site like to mindlessly parrot the “we’ve become too partisan and divided these days” narrative, but what are they actually proposing? Oh wait… https://twitter.com/rottenindenmark/status/1432643902322925572?s=21 https://twitter.com/rottenindenmark/status/14326439023229255...
- 5y ago
- reccanti 5y agoThese all seem like things that should be dealbreakers
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoI've been thinking for a while this is really a form of speciation. Conservatives and progressives literally have different brain structures [1] as well as different world views and different psychological triggers. When those differences lead to extreme aversion, they're going to be enhanced by evolution. I'm not sure I want to speculate what the long-term result is likely to be. [1]https://neuro.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/appi.neuropsych.16030051 https://neuro.psychiatryonline.org/doi/full/10.1176/appi.neu...
- bigbillheck 5y agoMost of those numbers don't seem particularly high. The only one I thought was really surprising was: "A majority (59 percent) of Americans say that whether the person shares their views on having children is one of the most important or a very important consideration.", and that only because 59% seemed low.
- aidenn0 5y agoThe question I have is how independent each of these are. If every person has one political view that's a deal-breaker, then it doesn't matter that only 15% of the population has that particular deal-breaker.
- seph-reed 5y agoI think the people this effects the worst are those who don't subscribe to either party, or the idea of a "one-dimensional political spectrum" in general. The dominating political "sides" are full on ideologies at this point, and if you don't worship their sacred cow: you could only ever be the other side in their eyes. So the price for not falling into the two-party trap is that you have to just keep your mouth shut in all situations, lest you be ousted. Anecdote: all of my friends who very much aren't falling for this two-party nonsense have had a common experience of being called Trumpers, Leftists, Anti-fa, Rednecks, and every other slur one side throws at the other. I'm not sure if it's a real litmus test or not, but I start to worry now when I've been getting too much of one and not enough of the other.
- WarOnPrivacy 5y agoI've known a number of folks who were mistreated by people who bore strong resemblance to Trump's personality - Trump was an ongoing trigger for them. Dating someone who embraced Trump's personality - that would seem to be a terrible experience for those folks.