3 ms·
Apple's New Child Safety Technology Might Harm More Kids Than It Helps
- CozyBearNotSoy 5y ago> LGBTQ youth... are more likely to send explicit images like those Apple seeks to detect and report, in part because of the lack of availability of sexuality education. This is nonsense; a neutral discussion in school about intercourse (straight or gay) isn't going to cause young adults to avoid expressing their sexual urges. If anything it will make them more likely to express such urges, since the neutral discussion in class will make the topic seem more broachable.
- olliej 5y agoThe bigger issue is various groups routinely treat LGBT content of any kind is inherently "adult", how long until stuff like that slips in again.
- istingray 5y agoWhat percentage of USA schools do you assume offer such a "neutral discussion about intercourse (straight or gay)"? If you found the number was 1/10th or 1/100th or 1/1000th as much, would you take action?
- pjmlp 5y agoNeutral discussion in class? Yeah maybe in an ideal school, in countries that allow it to begin with, yes because US is only the first one getting on device surveillance.
- vineyardmike 5y ago> If anything it will make them more likely to express such urges, since the neutral discussion in class will make the topic seem more broachable. I don't think history is on your side here.
- threshold 5y agoIs having perfect privacy worth turning a blind eye to the organized mass rape of children? That’s the choice, no exaggeration. Considering there’s nearly 8 billion alive, there must be a whole lot of activity at this exact moment. I wonder what the current number of ‘victims in progress’ is. Has to be at least 25,000. Visualize that. Quite the price to pay.
- donmcronald 5y ago> Is having perfect privacy worth turning a blind eye to the organized mass rape of children? No, but I'd like some concrete data before giving up my privacy. If Apple said "we think X thousand kids per day are exploited via iMessage and that's why we're putting these mitigations in place", I'd be willing to make some concessions that are congruent with the scope of the problem. Until then I'm going to be skeptical of any surveillance system being put in place to "protect the children."
- GoblinSlayer 5y agoWhat rape had to do with photos? Also this scans messages of people under 13, while child rape happens mostly to people over 17.
- krsdcbl 5y agoThat's absolutely not the choice that is up here. In western societies, child abuse predominantly happens within the family and won't likely be solved just by monitoring childrens online communication
- istingray 5y agoThe article suggests this "feature" may cause even more harm. How many youth will suffer violence, abuse, homelessness because of it?
- istingray 5y agoThe article suggests this "feature" may cause even more harm. How many youth will suffer violence, abuse, homelessness because of Apple's new toy?
- donmcronald 5y ago> Apple will, it says, use “on-device machine learning to analyze image attachments and determine if a photo is sexually explicit.” All photos sent or received by an Apple account held by someone under 18 will be scanned, and parental notifications will be sent if this account is linked to a designated parent account. That's a very steep, very slippery slope. What's next? Will they start detecting drugs, alcohol, smoking, hanging out with the wrong crowd? > When we are overzealous in declaring behavior “bad” or “dangerous”—even the sharing of swimsuit photos between teens—we blur young people’s ability to detect when something actually harmful is happening to them. I think everyone in tech should understand the consequences of warning fatigue enough to know the author is making a pretty good point here. Is Apple's "AI" (aka pattern matching with a fancy name) going to be able to interpret context or intent? Definitely not IMO. I can't imagine being a teenager these days. I'm thankful I grew up in the 90s when massive privacy violations by big tech weren't a thing. Why is it Apple's business what pictures kids are taking on their phones and sending to each other? Does Apple have some kind of massive child predator problem on their platforms that they aren't telling us about that would warrant these types of gargantuan privacy violations? If so, tell us about it. If not, fuck off IMO.
- istingray 5y ago"In fact, even by having this feature, we are teaching young people that they do not have a right to privacy." Interesting take that I haven't seen in the discussion. Teaching kids about privacy and anti-surveillance sounds interesting countermeasure. EFF for example?