4 ms·
Is the subscription mandatory. What about the minority of users who do have a static IP address. Should all users be given an option to arrange their own stat
by 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y ago
Is the subscription mandatory. What about the minority of users who do have a static IP address. Should all users be given an option to arrange their own static IP address as well as to subscribe to a pre-packaged deal. They might be able to get a better price than $99/yr, or better terms. Whats to lose by having options.
These are honest questions because I have often thought about a similar project where a static IP is required and wondered if and how it could support itself.
- gsreenivas 5y agoWe might consider adding support in the future - we're not philosophically against it, but it is more work to develop and support.
- solarkraft 5y agoIt's honestly a red flag.
- gsreenivas 5y agoA red flag for what? I would like to understand this better.
- solarkraft 5y agoCompany integrity/actually wanting to empower users. This unreasonably forces dependency on the company and bricks the device once support inevitably ends. That's usually a pretty good indication for a user-hostile company.
- gsreenivas 5y agoI'm not sure where you got that the device would be bricked. Can you point me to where you saw this? All data is accessible on local ports on the LAN, with or without the subscription service.
- solarkraft 5y agoThe subscription not being optional ("We don't make the subscription optional at this time", https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28351035 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28351035), with unspecified consequences of not having one. One thing I definitely gather from that comment is that E-Mails wouldn't work, which appears to be the main selling point of the device.
- gsreenivas 5y agoThere is an ongoing cost for email to work (static IP, DNS, tunneling for traffic) - this is why there is a subscription. It's not very complicated or malicious. If a customer doesn't want a subscription, they can still use the Helm on their local network and get access to all their data. Running without a subscription is not something we currently support because of a lot of variables that can prevent email from working consistently, creating a heavy support burden (which is costly) along with bad customer experiences. It's best for people wary of a subscription to go down the DIY path (and we end up with a lot of DIY switchers once they realize how much effort it is).
- carderne 5y agoSo it sounds like if you are acquired/close shop/triple your fees, the hardware will continue working with a limited feature set forever. If HN-type people are at all your target market, I’d make this a lot clearer somewhere. After the umpteenth time, people are wary of hardware that randomly turns into bricks. It’s got nothing to do with “big tech”.
- solarkraft 5y ago> Running without a subscription is not something we currently support because of a lot of variables that can prevent email from working consistently No problem. I see the technical difficulties with that and that you don’t want to support it. But is it possible? If you want peoples’ (definitely mine) trust I’d suggest clearly decoupling the subscription from the device and communicating that it’s only for the E-Mail routing. Otherwise it feels like renting a device with some extra initial cost, which is like 20% as good as actually owning something (If I’m already renting just take away the setup cost and make it 12$/mo).
- 1vuio0pswjnm7 5y agoAnother way to think about this is that the service is a static IP for $99/yr and the rest is "free", i.e., optional. Perhaps the majority of users will be attracted by the "free" stuff, but a minority might see a static IPv4 as having many potentially useful advantages for personal computing.^1 This is how I view the internet. I pay for access, and this gives me access to, among other things, the web, and various "free services" offered on the web by so-called "tech" companies.^2 There is no obligation that I have to use them. I can choose what I think is useful and ignore the rest. 1. Previously we have seen the static IPv4 address marketed by ISPs in the US as a "business account". Personal use is not contemplated. 2. But the IP addresses we get from ISPs suck for things like running a smtpd. We need solutions to this problem besides "tech" company middlemen.