3 ms·
> What difference is it to a Hindu if the Chaplain was Christian or an atheist None, but is the Chaplain there for the benefit of the Hindu students? Also, w
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> What difference is it to a Hindu if the Chaplain was Christian or an atheist
None, but is the Chaplain there for the benefit of the Hindu students?
Also, while there's not so much difference to a Hindu between a Christian and an atheist, the Hindu might well be more comfortable with a Chaplain who did not deny the existence of Hindu gods.
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoHa! I laughed out loud at that one. So, the Christian Chaplain would accept the existance of Hindu gods? Gotto go get a drink of water.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoDid you somehow read the second half of my second sentence without reading the 1.5 sentences in front of it?
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoDid you not read that last part, where it argued you could distinguish Chaplains based on their definitional similarities?
- orwin 5y agoSorry, i don't understand your last point. Wouldn't a christian (Chaplain or not) deny the existence of hindu gods? I mean, when i was a christian kid, i did not believe at all in 99.99% of all gods and thought people of other religions (and especially polytheists) were dumb not to believe like me. I decided later to round it up and that believing in something is OK and not a intelligence marker, just a cultural one. [edit] Btw i agree with you, the chaplain (if i translate this word correctly) should be christian and shouldn't take care of non-christian people (unless chaplain in the US is a non-religious role, in this case i stand corrected).
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> Sorry, i don't understand your last point. Wouldn't a christian (Chaplain or not) deny the existence of hindu gods? Yes, that is my last point. If you're worried about whether the Chaplain offends the Hindu students, a Christian and an atheist are both bad choices. From a world perspective, Christians are militant atheists. The Hindus would be less offended by e.g. a Wiccan.