9 ms·
When Police Lie, the Innocent Pay. Some Are Fighting Back
- shadowfkers 5y agohttps://ns.reddit.com/r/Bad_Cop_No_Donut/ https://ns.reddit.com/r/Bad_Cop_No_Donut/
- pope_meat 5y agoEven with body cams and cell phone videos, these boys are still lying. You can't reform this, clean slate.
- spiderice 5y agoWhat exactly do you have in mind when you say clean slate?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- erentz 5y agoI’d start by looking at overseas policing and taking lessons from them. Look at basing around something like Peelian principals. Find and adopt practices that discourage corruption, just one easy example here is to do away with overtime, cops become salaried and receive TOIL if they work extra hours but are not incentivized to make work. Actually ask questions and study things like, does carrying a gun all the time make an officer safer, in every circumstance? Is it situational? Does it make the public safer? Etc. Build a new curricula around these principals and findings from your studies, with state level police colleges for training. Then start building out a new state wide police service that over time absorbs the functions of various municipal and county departments. Existing officers who want can go through training and continue their careers in the new service, assuming they qualify. Set up an independence conduct commission to be overseen by the public, selecting a jury at random to review cases. (Not an elected position.) And of course, never stop actually asking the questions how can we improve what we are doing with the principals we have set out.
- spaetzleesser 5y agoThat's basically like a complete software rewrite. If you don't change the environment this works in you end up with the same set of problems eventually. There are a ton of things that could be done to improve american policing. But it's just for ideological grandstanding. This is pretty much the same with healthcare. It's clearly f..ed up but just used as a partisan tool for to win voters.
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoClearly they wish to wipe them out /s
- LeftHandPath 5y agoTo be honest, I don’t think a clean slate would solve the problem. Around the world, police lie. Salesmen lie. Politicians lie. Developers lie. Watchdogs lie. Generals lie. Priests lie. And innocent people get hurt. You are right that you can’t eliminate it from the system with reform. But I don’t think a “clean slate” will do any better either. The goal is marginal improvements, better checks and balances, etc. If you can’t stop a man from lying, the next best thing is to be sure you can catch him.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoBuild robust systems for accountability and oversight. Trust but verify thoroughly. This discourages the casual deceiver, but also identifies the motivated.
- toiletaccount 5y ago...and qualified immunity really needs to be gotten rid of, at least in its current form. there's no reason why a cop having a bad day should be able to ruin your life. also consider that as an citizen that's probably untrained in firearm use, you're liable for stray bullets that hit your neighbor when you shoot at a home intruder, while a cop is trained and on the clock, but has no such liability at all.
- pope_meat 5y agoWhy not a clean slate and improvements/checks and balances together, because the current crop of cops have lost the faith of a lot of people. Google LAPD gangs.
- France_is_bacon 5y ago>And innocent people get hurt. You're saying that everyone lies except for "innocent people"? Where are these innocent people you speaketh of? There's no such thing as "innocent people." Everyone lies their asses off, everyone. There is no such thing as innocent.
- hellbannedguy 5y agoThey could raise the requirements to become a cop, and change the structure of organization. 1. Require at least a bachelor's degree in anything. 2. Nix all paramilitary training. 3. Make each cop civilly/criminally legally liable for for their third screw up. 4. Hire only people over 25. 5. Dissuade military personal, including veterans, from thinking they have a job waiting for themselfs after their stint is up. (We do not need miitiary trained soldiers. We need Sociologists, and Psychologists.) 6. Cameras should be on every cop, without a way to turn the devise off. (Any complaints could then be verified by a third party.) 7. Get rid of all out little police squads. A cops would be federally licensed, and trained. Preferably stationed where they are needed. In my county of Marin, most are not needed. 8. And let's be honest. Most Cops are just Revenue Collectors. They are not going to be there to save our lives. To anyone saying, there won't be enough people applying for the job. Come on? There are a lot of people whom would like to become Police Officers. It usually those people, people who just want an honest job, whom are not hired. Get rid of all the cowboys, and hire level headed people. Ban all high speed chases, unless it involves a kidnapping. Require all police to obey every road law we are expected to abide. Make all uniforms Orange, or Pink. At least we could see them comming, and the bright colors might make the right people apply? 9. I'm not going to debate. I'm sick and tired of looking in my rear view mirror, or trying to figure out what hedge they are hiding behind. I'm as white as they come. I can't imagine what minorities have to put up with.
- baybal2 5y agoGeorgia did abolish the police once. It worked, to a point. "I Abolished and Rebuilt the Police. The United States Can Do the Same." https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/06/11/abolish-police-georgia-brutality-crime/ https://foreignpolicy.com/2020/06/11/abolish-police-georgia-...
- pjc50 5y agoAlso the police service of Northern Ireland was rebuilt from the irrevocably prejudiced RUC.
- alexashka 5y agoAny line of work dealing with power are liars, clean slate. There, I've solved human nature. That easy folks.
- oenetan 5y agohttps://archive.is/NpsZN https://archive.is/NpsZN
- jacquesm 5y agoCan you please stop spamming the site with these archive links? Thanks.
- andyxor 5y agoWhat's the solution, defund the police to "send a message" to bad cops? See how well that works out in Minneapolis , Chicago, Portland. and btw, Floyd overdosed on fentanyl, it's literally in his coroner report, pls stop making him martyr for the cause.
- simfree 5y agohttps://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/04/16/fact-check-fentanyl-george-floyd-not-enough-to-cause-death/7239448002/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/factcheck/2021/04/16/fac...
- olliej 5y agoUntil police are subject to criminal perjury prosecution this won't stop. Until police can't say "we'll stop doing our job if any prosecutor prosecutes us" that won't change.
- 57844743385 5y agoA natural outcome of police being above the law. YouTube is full of videos of police caught planting evidence. You’d think it would destroy all police credibility everywhere but that doesn’t seem to be the case. Check out this example: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_RSsGqhhXMU https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=_RSsGqhhXMU
- toiletaccount 5y agoLook up mumia abu jamal. My memory is hazy, but tldr he's a black panther in the 70s in philly and a cop gets shot on the same block while he's there. every bit of evidence is against him being the perp, and the courts even acknowledged the police tampered with evidence (!!!), but he just managed to get a death penalty commuted or some stupid shit like that, to a life sentence about 10 years ago. don't get tangled up in the criminal court system if he cops do toilet you.
- pope_meat 5y agoThey do a good job protecting the property of the wealthy by harassing the "undesirables" to move to designated areas, and that's why certain parts of town are "ghetto". It's a bit of an unspoken rule that as long as the dirty peasants stay in the ghetto they'll be less likely to be harassed. You generally won't be asked where you're going or why in the sketchy part of town, but looking the wrong way and straying in to a nicer part of town... you'll have 3 cruisers on you in 5 minutes. As long as the police have the support of the upper class, it doesn't matter that the majority of us have lost all faith in the police.
- wpietri 5y agoYou might be interested to read the book Sundown Towns: https://thenewpress.com/books/sundown-towns https://thenewpress.com/books/sundown-towns The author shows via census data and historical research that there were towns all over America where Black people weren't allowed after sundown. This happened from the end of Reconstruction up to the civil rights era. A large amount of that was never documented, so we don't know the mechanisms. But for the places where it was, this ethnic cleansing was often directly enforced by the police or tacitly supported by them when they ignored white intimidation and violence. Growing up in western Michigan, I had never heard of this. But it turns out many towns I was familiar with were examples of it.
- darksaints 5y agoThe Brady List was supposed to combat this, but like nearly every other attempt at reforming the police, it has utterly failed. Do you know what would work? Putting cops in prison for perjury.
- tsjq 5y agofrom the article: "Mr. Cordero’s door-knocking produced quick results. He obtained a doorbell security video from the house across the street. The footage was from a bit of a distance, and it was hardly clear what was happening, but it was obvious that Mr. Cordero had not done what he had been accused of." this is the solution. start using the ubiquitous tech & cameras to pin them down. no more trusting taxpayer-funded bodycams and self-regulations.
- cascom 5y agoThis is the type of thing where private prosecutions make sense. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prosecution https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Private_prosecution
- tjpnz 5y agoNever, ever talk to the police without a lawyer present. https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE https://youtu.be/d-7o9xYp7eE
- mcny 5y agoAbsolutely. The fraternity of police says police officers should ask their superior officers in a certain wording if answering the questions is required as a part of their job duty. Even the police will not talk to the police.
- yason 5y agoThis classic advice alone just underlines how bizarre the situation in the USA appears to be.
- hackeraccount 5y agoI remember seeing a round table discussion with 3 or 4 former US Attorney General's. The moderator asked them not about people having interactions with Law Enforcement and they all said - just speak honestly about what happened. The moderator then asked what they would tell their children and they all said, "Shut up, don't get involved and if you don't have a choice ask for a lawyer." They all recognized that having "civilians" help was vital for investigations but they also saw that there a very real chance of getting caught up in millstone that was doing the grinding.
- Viliam1234 5y agoSo, suppose you don't talk to the police, but the police says that you did. Now what?
- scrps 5y agoI am not trying to excuse bad policing but in the US this is a chimera. You have the police, some are corrupt, some are a bad fit for the job, some are lazy and stupid, and some are run-down and underpaid. You have prosecutors making their careers on win/loss records and being tough on crime so they can make judge or DA. Ibid for politicians with tough on crime, drugs, etc. You have the prison system which has become big business, exploiting prisoners, their families, the legal system, and taxpayers. They do nothing to offer a real chance at reform, are dangerous and breed more hardcore criminals and victims. You have the media which at it's mildest still runs with "if it bleeds it leads", middle of the road "true crime" podcasts and series, and at it's most exploitive preys on scaring the shit out of people (nancy grace is a good example) that 'the bad men are coming for your daughters' and we have to absolutely destroy criminals at all costs. Then there is the populace who under no circumstances will forgive or trust anyone (background checks, public offender lists, mugshots) who has been convicted of a crime (really in the US these days you don't even need to be convicted, just accused of certain crimes and it is a defacto life sentence). I am not saying policing shouldn't be reformed but that is one small step in fixing a very large problem but it is a very convenient target to lay all the blame on, and it feels good and just because it is an easy answer that is popular because in the US we are really all culpable.
- xmprt 5y agoYou hit the nail on its head with how widespread the issue is. When people say policing needs to be reformed, I think they're referring to the system as a whole. But also, policing is the source of a lot of these issues so if you fix the issues with the source then you can cut off the downstream supply.
- WaxProlix 5y agoTotally, let's focus on each of them - I don't think there's a gestalt overall approach that will solve this problem, but chipping away at each of these many problem areas might make some progress.
- readonthegoapp 5y agogood policing is impossible to achieve?
- mshroyer 5y agoI'm not exactly an ACAB kinda guy, but this directed towards a guy who was clearly taking a passive stance: > You ain't pushing up on me, boy? You ain't pushing up on me, you hear me? Fight! Fight with me! Fight! Fight! Look at me! Fight! Fight! It's just me and you, baby! It's just me and you! You move, that dog bites you. Sure, maybe that cop was the lone psychopath in the group. But why did the other cops not step in and do something?
- Threeve303 5y agoThis can’t happen fast enough. Imagine this situation happening for four years and it be a crime if you ever heard what they said about you.