6 ms·
> by their scarcity By their perceived scarcity Chances are that anyone other than Tim could have done just as well. Still, this is over 10 years, and Apple
by Aeolun 5y ago
> by their scarcity
By their perceived scarcity
Chances are that anyone other than Tim could have done just as well.
Still, this is over 10 years, and Apple shares have increased in value by 1900%.
If they were still the same value he’d have gotten 40M, for about 4M per year. Which is much more reasonable.
I still think it’s high, but in line with what others get.
- UncleMeat 5y agoBecause it should be about productivity. People are highlighting a moral failing of society.
- ChrisLomont 5y agoIs that moral failing related to jealously about how others choose to spend money that isn't theirs?
- UncleMeat 5y agoMoney is not gifted to people by God. It is allocated to people by systems that society chooses. The idea of the specific "rightful" ownership of money we have today is not universal throughout history and can change.
- ChrisLomont 5y ago> It is allocated to people by systems that society chooses Exactly. And history is pretty clear that nearly everyone is worse off when society decides how to spend money instead of letting owners decide how to spend money. It's why every first world economy has a massive dose of capitalism and a tiny dose of socialism in their GDP. And why a significant part of the worst economies of the world don't. >The idea of the specific "rightful" ownership of money we have today is not universal throughout history Yet the poor (and pretty much everybody else too) in most of the world, if not all, today are vastly richer than the poor of the past.... Maybe there's a reason the world has moved away from the economic systems of the past?
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoI'm from former USSR and I can hardly stand this commie foolishness. Go to some socialist country like Cuba, Venezuela that have eliminated the inequality (like the USSR did before), then talk about 'moral failings of the society'.
- diordiderot 5y agoImagine a world where we didn't have to choose exclusively between dictatorial communism and unfettered capitalism. So sad that any other system is completely impossible
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoOur world is unfair only when the corruption interferes, that lets you receive more money than you are actually worth. But in case of foxconn workers and Cook, everything is fair. Foxconn workers are not chained to the benches, that simply don't know any other place where they can earn more. And I think Cook doesn't bribe anyone to achieve such payouts. If anything, he's doing a great job developing a business.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> Our world is unfair only when the corruption interferes, that lets you receive more money than you are actually worth. What is corruption? A software engineer doing the same work gets paid way more in SF than in London. State policies prevent free movement of labor between London and SF. State policies do not prevent free movement of capital across nations, as clearly seen by the number of megacorporations actually owned by weird subsidiaries in strange locations for tax purposes.
- Andrew_nenakhov 5y agoCorruption is profiteering from occupying position of power, or from having ties with people in power. For example, getting a well paid job without necessary skills, because you are a nephew of a company vice president. As for software engineers, recently so many people here are up in arms against the return to the office... But still want to get paid 3x the guy from Indonesia. I'm looking for them replaced with cheaper developers, and what they'll think then about the remote work.
- rglullis 5y agoIf we were to live in a world where we are measured by our productivity, we would ALL be treated like the replaceable cogs from the Chinese factory.
- tclancy 5y agoIf that’s frightening to you, I think you’re seeing the point.
- rglullis 5y agoIsn't that frightening to you? What makes you think you would not be living under the whip?
- AnIdiotOnTheNet 5y agoI think parent's point is: why do we think it is ok to treat some people this way and not others?
- rglullis 5y ago- Because the people that already found a way to display the scarcity of their talent or abilities don't need to subject themselves to a system that measures them by their productivity. - Because it is not on "us" to try to change this at an universal scale. I am all for people that believe in communist ideals and go to live on their own with like-minded people. The problem is those that take this to totalitarianism and think something like "communism can only work if it everyone does it" - Because history has witnessed already many people that tried to change this reality without ignoring scale, and ended up causing more problems that solutions, destroyed more wealth and made the world worse than they started off.
- UncleMeat 5y agoDo you feel that your productivity as a trained professional is the same as anybody else's productivity? The trick would be to allow workers to capture all of their productivity rather than have a large amount of it syphoned off by owners.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoThis is a poor take. Productivity is meaningless, leverage and impact is everything. Tim Cook working for one day could easily have a larger impact than most people will have in their entire lives because he has extremely high leverage. Is it fair? Absolutely not, but life is not fair. I don't understand what moral obligation society should have to base compensation on productivity. PS: you could argue that Tim Cook is far more productive than everyone else because he produces far more results than everyone else.
- UncleMeat 5y ago> PS: you could argue that Tim Cook is far more productive than everyone else because he produces far more results than everyone else. Of course. "Pay by productivity" does not mean "pay everybody the same per hour of labor". Cook's output has greater influence on the company than any (or perhaps almost any) other employee at Apple. He should be paid commensurate to that output.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoOh, how do you think of productivity then? (E.g stock price, revenue growth, etc?) I assumed you meant something along the lines "pay everybody the same per hour of labor" since that seems to be how most people describe productivity.
- UncleMeat 5y agoThe company produces some amount of economic output in a year. This can be stuff or it can be innovation. That is the total productivity of the company. The sum of all productivity of its employees adds up to that value. Right now, people are paid less than the value of their productivity so there is money leftover for the company to either stick in the bank (profit) or reinvest in other things. Not everybody is equally productive. Somebody who has more skill or knowledge in a profession like software engineering will be considerably more productive than a less skilled engineer. Among leftist circles, I think you'd be very hard pressed to find people who describe productivity as literally just "number of hours worked".
- mombul 5y agoSo the fact that Apple's share price has increased 1,200% since he took over is just a coincidence?
- ubercore 5y agoMaybe, maybe not, but I think the idea is that it's hard to say with certainty. Apple is large and complex enough that any number of factors could have lead to that share price increase. My personal opinion is that probably yeah he had a good chunk to do with it. But it's hard to say that with certainty, it's certainly worth discussing and not taking for granted.
- adwww 5y agoWere the shares previously nosediving before he took over?
- uuddlrlr 5y agoTo be fair Apple was already a giant rolling ball of success, and they have historically had an ingrained culture of caring deeply about their products above all else. Any decisions that would affect their trajectory will get a ton of deliberation from a lot of smart people; i.e. there wouldn't need to be a ton of input or ingenuity from the CEO to see returns like those from Apple, imho. Not to say that Cook isn't great or that it wouldn't be difficult to achieve that success.
- bohemian99 5y agoSo many companies have flatlined after a new CEO took over, think Microsoft after Ballmer took over. So I think there is some difficulty involve.
- uuddlrlr 5y agoI guess my point is that the leadership within Apple is a lot more diffuse than typical; I believe most of Apple's value is from delivering a high degree of consistency and polish; owing to its culture of relentlessly developing the UX of their products. Therefore the CEO's primary roles at Apple would be to maintain that culture, steer the ship into new segments, and discern when the public will care about those segments. I think Cook has done a decent job of that. Making it all possible with RnD and supply chain is another story, but also where Cook is known to excel so maybe I'm underselling him. Jobs had Cook so presumably Cook would find a Cook if he weren't Cook. I don't know much about Microsoft but Balmer was definitely taking over a different beast than Cook.
- rglullis 5y agoIt's been 10 years since Jobs died and I'm yet to see anyone even speculate any other name that would've been better than Cook. Your comment is typical from someone who thinks themselves to be smarter than the whole board. Or the investors that never challenged Tim's management, Or all of Apple's upper management who would love to find a way to take his spot and wouldn't care about exploiting some of Tim's weaknesses to dethrone the king...
- lr4444lr 5y agoYeah, well, boards of directors don't take "chances" like that on 2.5 trillion dollar companies, and when they do, the shareholders start machinating replacements, like Scott Galloway attempted when Jack Dorsey started getting a lot of eye-raising ideas.
- Solstinox 5y agoChances are anyone other than Tim could have done just as well? Did you see what happened to Apple after Steve Jobs got fired? Have you seen what has happened to great civilizations after the roll of monarchical dice or even a democratic election? Have you ever met a bozo? They exist and there's more of them than there are sane people.
- Aeolun 5y agoDo we have numbers on how often that happens? I think it’s generally just fine unless the incoming new CEO is determined to suddenly do everything different.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoI don't think anyone other than Tim could have done just as well. If you look at competing tech corps - HP, IBM, Sun, MIPS, SGI, DEC, Nokia, even MS - their run isn't as long, they fail to adapt after a strong start, and the wheels often come off in spectacular ways. And that's with competent management. (Let's not talk about the multiple management idiocies that happened at HP.) Apple is now one of the longest lived tech corps. IBM is older but a shadow of its old self. MS is a year or so older, but the rest of FAANG are relatively new. Cook has kept the plates spinning and turned Apple into a giant revenue machine with a strong R&D back-up. I don't think that's a small achievement, and even if he's helped by the board and senior execs - which of course he is - it's still easy to underestimate the skill that goes into that. Having said that - he's also turned Apple into a somewhat boring company. The products are nice-looking and usually functional but not particularly thrilling. They feel overpriced. And I suspect some opportunities in home automation, user content creation, and health have been missed. Cook's Apple is an all-American bureaucratic behemoth - a kind of modern General Electric which keeps churning out high levels of competence, but not much inspiration or excitement, and not a little frustration and irritation over nickel-and-diming of users and developers. Someone else might not have made Apple as profitable, but personally I wouldn't have minded a friendlier and more inventive and adventurous company.
- bserge 5y agoYou sure it wasn't Jobs? Looks to me like Cook just kept things going about the same as Jobs would have (at least the last version of him). I do wonder how long it's gonna last.
- OJFord 5y agoI wouldn't have guessed (/remembered) it had been ten years of Cook, but what I do remember is people saying exactly that when he took over. I suppose at some point all companies die/fade into obscurity/are different companies in all but name; maybe in 2080 or whatever we'll be able to say - ah, yep, knew it, Apple was for the dogs as soon as Jobs left, was only a matter of time!
- snowwrestler 5y ago
- Turing_Machine 5y ago> Chances are that anyone other than Tim could have done just as well. The history of Apple CEOs indicates otherwise.