7 ms·
The Battle of Blair Mountain
- AlbertCory 5y agoI would expect the Smithsonian to have a better grasp of history. The Pullman Strike was far, far larger. By this article on Blair Mountain, 10,000 miners marched, and 16 died. According to [1], in the Pullman Strike, about 70 were killed nationwide, 250,000 workers in 27 states were involved, and the President called out the Army. Personal disclosure: I grew up about 2 miles from Pullman, not that that gives me any special insight. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pullman_Strike
- GavinMcG 5y agoWere any of the individual Pullman marches larger than the Blair Mountain one? Since you would expect the Smithsonian to have a good grasp of history, a charitable reading would imagine a reason that they would say "largest" even though they could certainly do the math to compare 10,000 to 250,000.
- AlbertCory 5y ago> "even though they could certainly do the math" Could, but didn't. The headline isn't "Largest Labor March". It's "Largest Labor Uprising". Why are you trying to defend an obvious mistake? Is that where you work or something?
- GavinMcG 5y agoGood lord. I'm arguing for charitable reading because the quality of public discourse has gotten so bad/uncharitable that you're here accusing me of a serious bias, and for what? Pointing out a legitimate alternative reading! Such deep cynicism is really an awful thing to see.
- AlbertCory 5y agoIt's not a "charitable reading." It's a rewriting. They screwed up. It happens in journalism. Let it go.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- adolph 5y ago> I would expect the Smithsonian to have a better grasp of history. It might be good to adjust that expectation. The Smithsonian's interest in these flights was political. The reputation of the Smithsonian had suffered greatly in 1903 when Langley's Aerodrome failed to fly. This made it more difficult to obtain funding, which limited its growth and effectiveness as a scientific organization. The current Secretary, Charles Walcott, felt that the best way to repair this reputation was the show the Aerodrome could have flown; the time and money spent on it had not been wasted. https://www.wright-brothers.org/History_Wing/History_of_the_Airplane/Doers_and_Dreamers/Wright_Smithsonian_Controversy/00_Wright_Smithsonian_Controversy_Intro.htm https://www.wright-brothers.org/History_Wing/History_of_the_...
- AlbertCory 5y ago"these flights"?? what are you talking about? The original title, and the title still on the article, is "What Made the Battle of Blair Mountain the Largest Labor Uprising in American History?"
- bpodgursky 5y agoThey're posting an example of the Smithsonian acting as a political institution as opposed to a neutral observer of history.
- sharkmerry 5y agothe example they are using is from over 100 years ago. Do we have any examples from a little more recently
- bpodgursky 5y agoI was just trying to clarify the OP comment, I don't really care about this debate tbh.
- adolph 5y agoDo you have any examples of Smithsonian operating honestly with regard to something where it would be in their interest to not be honest?
- js2 5y agoThe wikipedia also claims Blair Mountain was the largest strike: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain It was the deadliest by this list: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_worker_deaths_in_United_States_labor_disputes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_worker_deaths_in_Unite...
- AlbertCory 5y agoIn 1941 in the River Rouge strike, [1] says "Sixty thousand workers and their families crowded into Cadillac Square in Detroit" So much for "largest march." However, you're right that Blair Mountain does appear to have had more armed conflict, although River Rouge had more people involved, as did the Pullman Strike. There were just more people in the industrialized North than in Appalachia. Why bother arguing about this? I'm really tired of things being called "the biggest [or worst] in history" when the real meaning is "biggest I can think of, off the top of my head." [1] https://speakoutsocialists.org/the-strike-at-river-rouge-detroit-1941-2/ https://speakoutsocialists.org/the-strike-at-river-rouge-det...
- pope_meat 5y agoWe're a bit overdue for a labor uprising. Fingers crossed the mass evictions heading our way leaves enough people hungry and desperate enough to fight for their future.
- commandlinefan 5y agoOut of curiosity, what would you imagine that fight to look like? I can see it going two completely opposite ways: one, a return to our pre-lockdown lives when people could earn enough money to pay their rent, or two, a push for wealth redistribution.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- munk-a 5y agoI think the next widespread labour action will be focused on benefits - it'll pull in both of the factors you mentioned (increased earnings and wealth redistribution) since I don't think any labour gains will ever happen without those factors (and the first factor necessitates the second factor). But I think the focus will be lowering employee stress by advocating for stronger requirements around healthcare and reducing the workweek.
- pjmorris 5y agoI don't think those alternatives are as opposite as they first appear. One way to restore the pre-2000's relationship between income and housing expense would be to cancel the debts that were created by the stimulus created by the Fed and Congress since that time... which amounts to wealth redistribution.
- pope_meat 5y agoReturn to pre-lockdown conditions is basically saying the system is working. It's not. I've watched the homeless encampments grow over the last 20 years(maybe longer, but I can only speak for my lived experience). The lockdown was perhaps the straw that broke the camel's back to the point where it's hard to ignore, but the problem has been brewing for a while. I blame Ronald Reagan, the ghouls have had it real good since.
- w0mbat 5y agoWho removed all the prepositions from the title? The title on the original article is more readable. I suggest restoring the prepositions and adding a question mark. i.e. "What Made the Battle of Blair Mountain the Largest Labor Uprising in American History?".
- neartheplain 5y agoI'd guess the original title was too long for the submission field.
- ijlx 5y ago*articles you mean, not prepositions. And almost certainly it was too long.
- bryanrasmussen 5y ago"What Made the Battle of Blair Mountain the Largest Labor Uprising in American History?" is 86 characters long - 80 is the limit. Could do "Why was battle of Blair Mountain the largest labor uprising in American History?" 80 characters.
- dang 5y agoThe limit is 80 chars. We've replaced it with something simpler. (Submitted title was "What Made Battle of Blair Mountain Largest Labor Uprising in American History")
- PrinceRichard 5y agoThe plight of miners is one of the obvious go-tos when we try to explain why government must act to regulate industry. One day a friend pointed out something interesting - that those jobs were taken on by the free choice of the individuals working them. What should be done when an individual or group offers a job with poor conditions and wages? Presumably if the job is so bad that noone wants it, noone will take it. If someone does want it, and the two parties mutually agree to the conditions, it is not our business to intervene, other than to keep the peace. It is not the role of government to dictate working conditions or any other terms of employment that are mutually agreed upon by those involved. If there is a disagreement, the interested parties should seek an agreement, and if none can be reached, part ways. Physical violence may not be used to pressure either side to capitulate to the desires of the other. Employers, as with anyone, are to be held accountable for injuries or death resulting from their negligence or misconduct. Government must give neither labor nor employers special rules or treatment. Employers, as individuals, must be free to hire or release anyone they choose. Individual workers must be free act collectively - or not - and to offer their labor under any terms they choose. Neither side may use physical violence to achieve their ends. It is indeed true that mining jobs were and are often disrespectful to the human dignity and wellbeing of the workers. Yet, workers seek out these jobs and offer their labor voluntarily. Consentual agreements are not exploitation. If a person is dissatisfied with their job, it is their responsibility to remove themselves from it. It is also true that poor people are under more economic pressure to take on bad jobs. What should be done? Can we mandate that only safe and well-paying jobs will be offered? We could try, and that choice would inevitably exascerbate the poverty of those people by reducing the availability of employment to them. Further, they would be exposed to even more dangerous and low-paying illegal work. In the end, the principle of human freedom offers reliable guidance.
- teddyh 5y agoTo quote myself¹: Some volontary transactions are nonetheless illegal, because to allow them would negatively affect society as a whole. The usual example is that it is not legal (as it once was) to sell yourself into slavery. Also, overly onerous contracts can (in many jurisdictions) not be enforced. Simply put, “It's a voluntary transaction” can never be a sufficient argument for why something ought to be legal. 1. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26131725 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=26131725
- adolph 5y agoSomehow Smithsonian portrays federal troops as relatively neutral. Though many scholars attribute aerial terror’s beginnings to the Spanish Civil War (1936-9), the US Army Air Service sent bombers to threaten the United Mine Workers and their supporters. After the UMW forces disregarded his threat, President Warren Harding sent in one of the Air Service’s most capable weapons: The Martin MB-1 bomber. The Martin MB-1 was an American bomber/reconnaissance biplane designed towards the end of World War One and carried a crew of three. Unfortunately for the Air Service, a reconnaissance mission failed when one Martin MB-1 crashed, leaving the crew dead and the bomber destroyed. New developments in battlefield archaeology, however, allowed us to study the crash site. Studying the site provided an opportunity to better understand how the bombers were used within the Battle of Blair Mountain as both a military tool and a symbol of federal power. https://digitalcommons.murraystate.edu/postersatthecapitol/2019/Morehead/10/ https://digitalcommons.murraystate.edu/postersatthecapitol/2... By August 29 battle was fully joined. Chafin's men, though outnumbered, had the advantage of higher positions and better weaponry. Private planes were hired to drop homemade bombs on the miners. A combination of poison gas and explosive bombs left over from World War I were dropped in several locations near the towns of Jeffery, Sharples and Blair. At least one did not explode and was recovered by the miners; it was used months later to great effect as evidence for the defense during treason and murder trials. On orders from General Billy Mitchell, Army bombers from Maryland were also used for aerial surveillance. One Martin bomber crashed on its return flight, killing the three crew members. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Blair_Mountain
- handedness 5y agoThe Smithsonian’s federal funding for fiscal year 2021 (Oct. 1, 2020–Sept. 30, 2021) is $1 billion. The Institution is 62% federally funded (a combination of the congressional appropriation and federal grants and contracts). https://www.si.edu/newsdesk/factsheets/smithsonian-institution-fact-sheet https://www.si.edu/newsdesk/factsheets/smithsonian-instituti...