10 ms·
Facebook “transparency report” turns out to be anything but
- bob229 5y agoDelete your Facebook account
- emipop 5y agoI'm shocked, shocked! Shocked! I tell you. Well maybe not that shocked...
- classified 5y agoI would have been much more shocked if they suddenly stopped lying about everything. That would be really unexpected.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- papito 5y agoThat has a fact's chance on Facebook.
- dr-detroit 5y agoI unironically expect better from a CIA sponsored (according to ABC News) sexapp since I paid for it.
- artogahr 5y agoDelete your facebook account
- 2Gkashmiri 5y agobruh.... that does..... not help. don't you know?
- lnxg33k1 5y agoI would say not only it doesn't help but is even worse than demanding entities to be regulated by legislators and leaving the platform free for misinformative(?) entities
- m_eiman 5y agoSo you're saying we should keep using Facebook (making them money) and we should also do the policing Facebook doesn't want to do - for free?
- lnxg33k1 5y agoI am saying you shouldn't boycott facebook to solve the issue with election mangling and profiling, if you want that you need to ask your representative to regulate that, otherwise while you leave, the people most subject to misinformation are still there to be fooled and the society as a whole wouldn't benefit. But of course if you don't want facebook to make money(1), or it doesn't respect your ethical vision, then you're free to leave, knowing that it doesn't solve the problem (1) the whole web is still full of like buttons, so you're making them money anyway I have this kind of conversation with vegans I know most of the time, they boycott meat industry, without triggering any sort of regulation, to switch to agro products, then when put in front of agricultural companies employing clandestine labour without rights and contracts, they dodge it, as you can't boycott all food and eat rocks, boycotting is useless, regulations are king
- _jal 5y ago> the whole web is still full of like buttons Make these addresses non-routable in whatever way is most ergonomic for you and enjoy a less junky internet. whois -h whois.radb.net -- '-i origin AS32934' | grep ^route It isn't hard to cut someone out of your life on the internet.
- sschueller 5y agoNo, you need to keep it but don't use it. It is the only way to keep control if someone tags you etc without you ending up as a shadow profile which you have zero control over.
- teddyh 5y agoIf I don’t have a Facebook account, do I need to create one and agree to their ToS?
- tudorizer 5y agoIt's not my job as a plain person to police their platform. If a shadow profile is created without my knowledge, Facebook should deal with it and be penalised otherwise.
- a_imho 5y agoMaybe even post noise.
- Tenoke 5y agoOver this? I personally see exactly 0 right-wing content on Facebook so the amount of it there is among the last reasons that'd make me delete it.
- slitdangsthroat 5y agoWell you said you see no conservative content which means you are a cunt that lives a liberal bubble. So you are saying that you are a worse human being than the people you attempted to take a jab at, right cunt?
- jensensbutton 5y agoNo I'm good. Actually a pretty nice way to keep up with actual family and friends.
- slitdangsthroat 5y agoAt the expense of destroying your civilization cunt
- corobo 5y agoI really dislike this sort of protest. You there! Do an action. Throw down some reasons why or.. something.. anything. It happens in all sorts of protests. A slogan is coined and you're either with it or against it. It's.. it's fucking stupid* to be honest. Discussion is always better * I know. This means I've stopped thinking. I can't word it better, limited by mental hardware
- lithos 5y agoIt’s not like you can log in anyways. At least without accepting multiple updates TOS, updated arbitration clauses, and similar. There’s legal power to be had in having old clauses that were found invalid in other court cases/new laws to prevent corporate over reach.
- slitdangsthroat 5y agoWell you are on HN where you have to have downs or be on the spectrum to respond. Dang should be coming in and scrubbing this comment for having too much emotion. That is unless you are rich. Rich people get priority on this message board. I genuinely hope dangs family gets raped
- artificialLimbs 5y agoI've deleted down to that one friend who I can't contact any other way (literally no phone), and my wife. I am much less tempted to scroll (waste time) now that I have 1,386 less friends. You would think the algorithms would maybe try to keep me on the platform at this point but no, I now see almost exclusively ads on the rare occasion I do look through (I still look at the marketplace).
- reaperducer 5y agonow that I have 1,386 less friends You never had 1,386 friends. You had 1,386 friends, acquaintances, colleagues, contacts, associates, and people who you know. Facebook has bastardized the word "friend" to make people believe they need to collect other people.
- artificialLimbs 5y agoFrom Merriam-Webster: 1a : one attached to another by affection or esteem b : acquaintance 2a : one that is not hostile b : one that is of the same nation, party, or group The vast majority were 1a. I rather enjoy considering people who are not actively hostile to be friends. It invites all manner of goodness and interest into my life.
- IAmEveryone 5y agoKevin Roose at the NYT deserves praise both for being the reason they went through this exercise in removing all doubt, as well as getting close to writing the complete story before it ever happened: https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/14/technology/facebook-data.html https://www.nytimes.com/2021/07/14/technology/facebook-data....
- Tenoke 5y agoFor what is worth, their methodology also looks flawed and paints an exaggerating picture. If anything I'm not convinced this doesn't just show that Facebook is mostly used by old people, so there's a lot of interacted with right wing or whatever content. I personally see none of it, and very little that's politically charged in general.
- ajross 5y agoThat's correct, but sort of missing the point. Facebook isn't deliberately training people on far right conspiracies. But those conspiracies happen to do a really (really) good job of evading what controls exist and end up being presented as "suggested content" to a bunch of people who, while ideologically susceptible to it, wouldn't ever see it otherwise. And it's a real problem, because this garbage is just swimming in deliberate untruth. And it's asymmetric. There is leftist lunacy in the world too, obviously, but it doesn't end up being presented to people on Facebook just because they clicked on a climate change link or liked a post about racial justice. But if you're a retiree who follows your local evangelical church? Your feed is now telling you that masks don't work, that the government is conspiring in one of various Mind Control theories to control your life, that your relatives (the ones who click on the climate links) are already compromised. It's really, really bad. Just try it. Go to facebook and interact with some totally mainstream right wing entities. Churches, republican party candidates or organizations, the local gun range. And watch what you start seeing.
- Dma54rhs 5y agoVisiting reddit should give you the leftist version of boomer maga Facebook. It's filled always filled with emotionally manipulated misinformation. For each their own I guess.
- huibf 5y agoPerhaps I'm missing something but is the summary of this whole incident that the most shared content on Facebook is not left wing and somehow Facebook should be ashamed of that and hide it?
- mola 5y agoNo. The summary is Facebook creates a transparency report by cherry picking data that fits some narrative that is good for their strategy. Mean while they sunset a research tool that is used by independent researchers making this whole "most transparent platform" thing an obvious lie, and their head of integrity a person without integrity.
- joshspankit 5y agoHere’s the executive summary: - Facebook tries to get more ad dollars by saying they are a platform with high engagement (aka: comments and “likes”) - A journalist using FB’s own tools found that the posts with the highest engagement were right-wing - Facebook then created an entire report to say “Nono: it’s views that are important, and look at all this nice stuff people view” - Facebook tries to avoid mentioning that they themselves directly control what gets put on people’s news feed and when, which means they can simply say “Show 100mil people this cat picture” and then an hour later say “Look! 100mil people looked at a cat picture! That makes it popular and shows that people like to look at cat pictures on FB!” Further evidence: Ever notice that video views on FB are way higher than on other platforms? That’s because every time someone scrolled past a video in their newsfeed it counted as a view, no matter how fast that scroll was. This was likely used to try and entice video creators who equated views with revenue.
- jacquesm 5y agoFB is a study in dark patterns.
- janto 5y agobut isn't views also what you want when you're showing ads? I mean clicking on the ad would be preferable I guess, but I'm not sure how tightly correlated that is to users clicking on user generated content. I can see Facebook wanting to sell views rather than clicks to their customers.
- megamix 5y agoEverything must come to an end, even for Facebook. We didn't think Altavista or Myspace would "die" either..
- papito 5y agoAltavista did not lock hundreds of millions of people in an alternate reality. During COVID lockdowns, my Mom called me, and asked if it was true that at night choppers were going to spray something over NYC. "Ah", I thought, "Facebook".
- SevenSigs 5y agoThey did that in a city I was in, in Florida, but using trucks.. They were poisoning everything to kill mosquitoes/larvae.
- uuddlrlr 5y agoIt's good she asked, and spraying municipalities from planes is pretty common[0]. China was doing similar with sanitizer trucks running up and down streets so it's not terribly unfounded--actually that fake news is likely better than >99% of the actual crap on there. [0] https://www.clarke.com/blog/aerial-mosquito-control-applications-work/ https://www.clarke.com/blog/aerial-mosquito-control-applicat... Edit: footage of the trucks because they're neat https://futurism.com/neoscope/watch-china-spray-entire-city-blocks-contain-outbreak https://futurism.com/neoscope/watch-china-spray-entire-city-... No idea what the efficacy is.
- papito 5y agoThe point is, this was not based in fact. There was no such plan ever, especially with helicopters. Someone generated the bullshit, and we have to spend energy disputing it.
- aeturnum 5y ago> There was no such plan ever, especially with helicopters. The NY health department does use helicopters to drop larvicide on likely mosquito spawning grounds[1]. Your mom did believe a false story and also there absolutely was (and is) a plan to use helicopters to distribute an an anti-disease treatments over NYC. I think the tricky part of the misinformation we are all dealing with is that many elements of it (method of distribution, the idea of spraying down a city) are things that are happening in some way - the false narrative is the particular combination people believe in. I think it's part of why flat denials are often ineffective. [1] https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/health/health-topics/west-nile-virus-spray.page https://www1.nyc.gov/site/doh/health/health-topics/west-nile...
- papito 5y agoI recently finished Chaos Monkeys and An Ugly Truth, and that removed any doubt in terms of how to look at Facebook as a company. It's a place skillful at proactively avoiding any knowledge that is troublesome, to later plead ignorance. "I did not know it, therefore I am innocent". They know their platform is a radicalizing dumpster fire, they know they can fix it. The even did it once, right after the 2020 US election. But there was no money in the "nice" feed. To be clear, there was money in it, but there was no money. In addition, never, EVER believe what they say. Facebook management is a skillful gang of chronically lying, conniving sociopaths with no moral compass, who are so good that they even manage to fool their own employees. WE HEAR YOU AND THE FIXES ARE COMING ANY DAY NOW. The fixes were not coming. Andy Stone can tweet whatever he wants - it's ALL bullshit, and at the end of the day, Mark Zuckerberg will fall back to his usual talking point. "Facebook gives people new ways to destroy the world". Sorry, I meant "connect".
- Applejinx 5y agoHuman nature. (but not the ONLY kind of human nature. But, still…)
- papito 5y agoI am sorry, I don't get the point. I cannot act like an asshole and blame "human nature". No one is perfect, but one has to try.
- slitdangsthroat 5y agoThen maybe get you head out of your ass and start paying attention more?
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y ago> Just after the report was published, the Times revealed that a previous version had been shelved, because it showed one of the top links on the site was to a story that said a doctor died from the COVID-19 vaccine, a report from the Chicago Tribune that was circulated widely by anti-vaccination groups and pages. https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Pillars-of-Russia%E2%80%99s-Disinformation-and-Propaganda-Ecosystem_08-04-20.pdf https://www.state.gov/wp-content/uploads/2020/08/Pillars-of-...
- stevespang 5y agoZuckerberg is a socially obnoxious pathological crook, and deserves to be personally prosecuted for his crimes against humanity . . .
- dr-detroit 5y agobig surprise the ultra right wing globojudeonatonalist HN is trying to downvote all the FB hate.
- anoncow 5y agoI still have completely legitimate websites blocked by the sharing debugger on FB with no recourse.
- philipov 5y agoYour recourse is to stop using FB.
- anoncow 5y agoFBs actions have a significant impact. For example, I cannot create ads with the target domains across FB and Instagram. People cannot organically share links to my website using FB posts/chat or IG chat. IG was responsible for more than 30% of visits before FB’s sharing debugger blocked my domains. I have raised multiple complaints since and I haven’t received one human response yet. And I have successfully contributed to FBs white hat program in the past.
- coldcode 5y agoI just want a Facebook like place to interact with my friends and family, that I pay something for, and has no ads, news, likes or social manipulation. But no one would invest in such a thing, and if they did, Facebook would just buy out the investors and kill it.
- Schiendelman 5y agoI left Facebook a few years ago, and started creating larger iMessage groups for friend groups and family. I create shared iCloud albums of photos for vacations and send the links around. It's a little more work but the interactions are now much more personal.
- aroraneeraj 5y agotry halloapp.com
- inetknght 5y agoIf you're okay with self-hosting then you might checkout nextcloud.
- ectopod 5y agoNextcloud's marketing is very business-focused. It does file hosting and chat rooms, which is great, but does it have anything like the Facebook feed? My elderly relatives don't want to go hunting for information. They want to log in and see a feed with "Cousin Itt posted some baby photos" or whatever. I've looked through the apps [1] but I'm still not sure if this is something that's possible. [1]: https://apps.nextcloud.com/categories/social https://apps.nextcloud.com/categories/social
- dylan604 5y agoIf someone was willing to go to the effort to create this thing, they might just be the type to reject Facebook offers.
- nikola_borisof 5y ago
- samdung 5y agoFB has been lying over and over for the past many years. Yet the firm grows and its profits soar. There must be some fundamental principles/logic for why this happens. Any wise men here?
- cratermoon 5y agoThe wisest person to consult on this would be P.T. Barnum. While mostly known as that circus guy, he really accomplished a lot more than that and wasn't a bad guy. He wrote a couple of books, even. Most apropos is "The Humbugs of the World: An Account of Humbugs, Delusions, Impositions, Quackeries, Deceits and Deceivers Generally, in All Ages" https://www.gutenberg.org/files/26640/26640-h/26640-h.htm https://www.gutenberg.org/files/26640/26640-h/26640-h.htm