4 ms·
>It’s everyone else who suffers. Usually they have no choice but to move somewhere else or stay at home with parents A lot like London without rent control the
by pydry 5y ago
>It’s everyone else who suffers. Usually they have no choice but to move somewhere else or stay at home with parents
A lot like London without rent control then, but if rent control were implemented it would be the primary culprit for what's happening anyway?
Color me skeptical.
Seems to me it's the landlords that really "suffer". E.g. the SF landlords that paid a tenant hundreds of thousands to get them out ( https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-business-san-francisco-4fa0a9df027a5c40855af209dedb88e3 https://apnews.com/article/lifestyle-business-san-francisco-... ). Rent control just decides whether the "spoils" of restricted supply go to landlords with the most capital or the renters who lived in the city the longest.
Hacker news cries bitterly about nimbyism (especially in SF) that restricts development to keep up property values and rents. Whom do they think is most incentivized to do that? Redirect those spoils to leveraged landlords and find out.
- Gimpei 5y agoThere is lots of research on this. Here's one heavily cited paper that finds what the previous poster was suggesting. Fine to disagree, but it would be nice to see some counter evidence. https://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/DMQ.pdf https://web.stanford.edu/~diamondr/DMQ.pdf In terms of London, there is also the problem of building restrictions. I don't think we're going to see tall residential towers popping up in say, Mayfair, anytime soon. I understand that this kind of change would completely transform the character of London. But the price of not wanting change is sky high rents.
- blitzar 5y agoNot in Mayfair, but all around the fringes of the city they are. If you want a £500,000 studio flat 30 minutes away from central london by tube there is a massive amount of supply. If however, you can afford said property, you probably dont want to jam your wife and 2 kids into it.
- philjohn 5y agoAnd with high speed trains on the west coast mainline you can get a 5 bed detached with garden for around that - with Euston reachable in 45-50 minutes in places like Rugby.
- wahern 5y agoI'm generally favorable to rent control (it's a socio-political tradeoff, like all public policies), but rent control on single-family homes or single units (as with renting an in-law), which is what that paper examines, is a horrible policy. The consequences for landlords are far more extreme than rent control on large, multi-unit buildings. This makes it's difficult to infer similar supply effects between rent control on single-family homes and on multi-unit buildings. Turnover in SF is actually quite robust. The vast majority of tenants don't stay in the same apartment for decades. This is especially true during boom periods. IOW, ebbs & flows in turnover actually tend to benefit landlords. But a small number do. The average turnover rate is ~20%, which means the average occupancy is ~5 years. For large buildings what matters is the average. The fewer the number of units (either in a building, or in your portfolio), the riskier things become. The riskiest of all is a single-family home, whether you rent out an in-law or the whole house. In the face of rent control you're not only risking being stuck with the same person indefinitely, paying an increasingly below market rent, but you're locking up for an indefinite period what is probably your largest and most important asset. It's a potential financial nightmare, and one with realistic odds (e.g. maybe 1 in 10 instead 1 in 10000) of befalling you. As the building grows larger, the more the risk is spread and you can rely on the average occupancy term. Moreover, the larger the building, the less likely one would want to tear it down to build something larger. IOW, the larger the building, the more closely your expected future investment returns approach non-rent control levels. Rent control policies should be accompanied by policies that promote densification. All forms of rent control will tend to reduce supply to some extent (at least, that should be the a priori expectation), but rent control also provides important social benefits. IMO, those lines cross, but I would never expect the benefits to be greater than the costs in the context of single-family homes.
- gnopgnip 5y agoRent control in San Francisco doesn't apply to single family homes or condos. As the owner you can raise the rent to market rate.
- wahern 5y agoYou're right. I was confused. It doesn't cover the main residence of single-family homes. But AFAIU the 1994 rent control extension did encompass pre-1980 in-laws in single-family homes, which are quite common in the vast areas of San Francisco containing single-family homes. (Most homes built after 1930 put the primary living space on the 2nd floor. The first floor was a garage, and it was extremely common to build an in-law at the back of the garage.) They would be more common but for the fear people have renting them out. The 1994 law encompassed multi-unit buildings of 4 or less, which were previously excluded from rent control. An elderly neighbor of mine owns a classic 1960s-era 3-story, 2-unit apartment building. He lives in one unit and keeps the other vacant so that his children won't have any trouble refurbishing or selling the asset when he dies. This is a nearly identical scenario to someone living in a single-family home with an ADU. There are several such homes on my block, though I don't know the owners so don't know how many are kept unnecessarily vacant.
- gnopgnip 5y agoThere is lots of research going the other way too. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0264275115001122 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S02642... Forty years of rent control: Reexamining New Jersey’s moderate local policies after the great recession. The short of it is moderate rent control doesn't positively or negatively impact aggregate prices, but it prevents displacement in the short term.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> A lot like London without rent control then, but if rent control were implemented it would be the primary culprit for what's happening anyway? I’m not sure what you’re trying to suggest about hypothetical rent control in London, but it should be clear that London was geographically exhausted long ago and they’ve been debating architectural preservation and building height control ever since. You can’t simply buy a property in London, knock it down, and build a 50-story skyscraper. Using it for your case study on rent control doesn’t make any sense. > Seems to me it's the landlords that really "suffer". This is the fantasy: Stick it to those evil developers and landlords, amirite? The fallacy is assuming that you get the exact same apartment under rent control, but cheaper. You don’t. The truth is that being a rent-controlled landlord is easy mode. You have very little competition, by law, and the waiting list to get into your apartment can be years or decades long. As a result, you don’t have to compete on anything. Who’s going to turn your apartment down when it’s their only shot at housing and no one’s building new construction to compete at artificially depressed prices? Now you don’t have to worry about installing good appliances or even nice carpet. The air condition doesn’t work well? Too bad, as long as it meets regulations (if any) then that’s good enough. Why would you if your tenants aren’t choosing based on competition? The tenants suffer, too. And you’re still ignoring all of the people locked out of the system by the ensuing decade-long wait lines, as is the case in this article.
- pydry 5y ago>I’m not sure what you’re trying to suggest about hypothetical rent control in London I'm stating that the extreme lack of supply ascribed to rent control also exists in similar cities without rent control. So maybe rent control's effect on supply is vastly overblown as you can see by looking at the large amount of house-building in NYC before 1974 in the graph above, which is when rent control laws started getting really watered down. >It should be clear that London was geographically exhausted long ago Thats kind of absurd. It only recently caught up to prewar population levels. Property prices skyrocketed way before that. >The truth is that being a rent-controlled landlord is easy mode. If they like it so much why do they try to trick/bully tenants into leaving or offer large sums of money to tenants to leave if that fails? >And you’re still ignoring all of the people locked out of the system by the ensuing decade-long wait Give leveraged landlords market rent in restricted supply environments like SF and the FIRST thing they will try to do is to inhibit further development with NIMBYism that might bring down their rents and damage their investment. Detractors of rent control tend to feign support for new residents but theyre perfectly happy for them to be priced out alongside the long term residents of the city. More social housing fixes the underlying supply issue. Higher property taxes fixes the underlying supply issue. Wanting to kill rent control before or instead of fixing these things means being concerned with profit, not people. Rent control is a band aid while that happens to keep long term (especially elderly/vulnerable) renters housed. And landlords loathe it.
- nearbuy 5y agoThere are few mechanisms through which rent control can hurt. Rent control discourages building more units. The more you can make from rental, the more companies will invest in new construction projects. Rent control can decrease efficiency of living situations. You can imagine an old woman living alone in a 3 bedroom unit with rent control because it would be more expensive for her to move to a smaller unit. Or someone who gets a new job far from their current rent-controlled apartment but won't move out because the rent is so much cheaper.
- pydry 5y ago>Rent control discourages building more units. Yet the strictest rent controls went hand in hand with the fastest homebuilding spree in 1950s NYC. It clearly didnt discourage that much. Maybe it didnt discourage it at all? Or maybe it does a bit but is eclipsed by the effect of, say, NIMBY landlords inhibiting development, hellbent on staying above water on their eyewatering SF mortgage. >Rent control can decrease efficiency of living situations. You can imagine an old woman living alone in a 3 bedroom unit with rent control because it would be more expensive for her to move to a smaller unit. I can imagine. She could get priced out of the city entirely I suppose. It seems to me that if the market rate is intent on 10x'ing her rent maybe it's the market that should be forced to adjust first, not her. More home building. Higher property taxes. Rent control while the effects kick in.
- Manuel_D 5y agoSeattle (which is for forbidden by the state from implementing rent control) added 2-3x the housing units as San Francisco from 2010-2020 despite similar population growth in both cities. The impact of price controls on supply is a well studied phenomenon. Lower price for something -> less incentive to produce it.
- pydry 5y agoIf you look at the data above it shows home building peaking in the early 1960s in NYC. Rent control laws were strong until the 1970s. That's the point when homebuilding plunged and didn't perk up for decades. Weakening them in 1974 if anything seemed to restrict supply. SF has comically low density housing that is driven by homeowners lobbying to restrict development. The difference between SF and Seattle is probably property taxes (higher in Seattle). It discourages land from being hoarded and used unproductively.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- collyw 5y agoInteresting way of looking at it, but if you want to make a positive impact for the most people then supplying more housing would make a lot more sense than messing with prices.
- paulddraper 5y agoLondon's problem isn't "rent control." It's "construction control." London permitting just will not allow builders to construct enough housing. Perhaps for worthy reasons, or perhaps not, but regardless there's no question as to the source of London's housing shortage.