3 ms·
> But it seems like an unwarranted leap to go from this formal comparison of cardinality of infinite sets, to the intuitive English-sentence idea that "almost a
by thaumasiotes 5y ago
> But it seems like an unwarranted leap to go from this formal comparison of cardinality of infinite sets, to the intuitive English-sentence idea that "almost all" real numbers are irrational, as if it had any analogy whatsover to a statement such as e.g. "almost all" values of 1/x are defined.
What's the objection? Almost all values of 1/x are defined. The analogy is... it's the same usage with the same meaning. That's not even an analogy.
- canjobear 5y agoAlmost none of the numbers of the form 1/x have definitions. Definitions have finite length, so there is only a countable number of numbers with definitions. But there are uncountable number of numbers of the form 1/x.
- crazygringo 5y agoNo, it's an entirely different meaning. Because yes, almost all values of 1/x are defined -- for every real value of x except for one, the number zero. While saying "almost all" real numbers are irrational... is saying that real values are all irrational, except for... the entire infinitely large set of rational numbers. The idea of "almost all" and "except for an infinite number of items" is not even close to the same commonsense meaning, not even remotely. That's my whole point -- that meanings are being mixed up, that this way of classifying infinite sets shouldn't be conceptualized as "size" at all because the analogies break down, well, instantly.
- Dylan16807 5y agoI could also mathematically say that "almost all" integers are not powers of 58279. I think that would fit the commonsense meaning, even though there are infinite counterexamples.
- tshaddox 5y ago> While saying "almost all" real numbers are irrational... is saying that real values are all irrational, except for... the entire infinitely large set of rational numbers. You're claiming that the precise mathematical definitions of these terms are ridiculous, and then just repeating those mathematical definitions of the terms to support your claim. > That's my whole point -- that meanings are being mixed up, that this way of classifying infinite sets shouldn't be conceptualized as "size" at all because the analogies break down, well, instantly. The whole point is that when you're comparing infinite sets, common sense terms like "size," "almost all," etc. don't make any sense at all, so mathematicians create precise definitions for the terms that are then used among all mathematicians and do make sense. These terms are common among mathematicians and they do make sense. The fact that these definitions don't precisely match the definitions used by non-mathematicians is precisely the goal, because those definitions make no sense whatsoever when referring to infinite sets. It's okay to complain about using jargon in discussions not related to mathematics, although that's not what is happening here (and it's difficult to imagine a conversation about infinite sets that is not also about mathematics). This complaint is comparable to complaining that the definitions of "sharp" and "flat" in music theory don't at all match the definitions of "sharp" and "flat" used in conversations not about music. I suppose another way to approach this is to ask what you would propose the term "almost all" to mean when referring to an infinite set? For that matter, what do you propose that the term "almost all" means to a layperson referring to small finite sets? What percentage do you need in order to use "almost all"?
- robbedpeter 5y agoMathematics is a language unto itself, and some concepts are more difficult to map to natural language than others. Even if you had a much broader English vocabulary, with unique words assigned to every currently known mathematical abstraction, the intuitive sense in which we speak and read and understand will clash with the behavior and features of mathematical symbols. Natural language maps onto an embodied experience designed by evolution. Math transcends what our brains are built to expect and predict. Infinities, exponentials, quantum entanglement, and an infinite array of other very real things simply exist outside what we are capable of understanding intuitively, without some special conjunction of neural wiring, training, or happenstance. The nature of infinities might seem like navel gazing, but it helps us understand the features of different types of numbers, and those are the building blocks of proofs. Knowing to which infinity class a number belongs might help inform the optimization of real world engineering of chips or data storage, or drug design algorithms, and so on. It could eventually be part of figuring out practical quantum computers, solving p vs np, or maybe just a piece of a better factorization algorithm that improves cryptography.
- btilly 5y agoPlease note, the statement "almost all reals are not rational" has nothing to do with cardinality. It has to do with the fact that we can construct an open set of arbitrarily small size that includes every rational.
- mcguire 5y ago"Arbitrarily small size" and "nothing to do with cardinality" are confusing me.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoA statement is true of 'almost all' x in the set X if, when sampling from X, the probability that the statement will be true of the value you sample is exactly 1. If you think there's a conflict between "arbitrarily small size" and "nothing to do with cardinality", there isn't; this is a different kind of size. (OK, there is a relationship to cardinality, but two sets of the same cardinality can be different sizes by this metric, and two sets of the same size can have different cardinalities.)
- btilly 5y agoFor "nothing to do with cardinality", the Cantor set has the same cardinality as the reals, and yet has measure zero. For arbitrarily small size, let's start with an enumeration of the rationals. Now pick ε > 0. Let's put an open interval of size ε/2 around the first rational, ε/4 around the second, ε/8 around the third and so on. The union of those intervals is an open set of length bounded above by ε/2 + ε/4 + ε/8 + ... = ε. (Note, it is actually smaller than this because some of the intervals overlap...) That constructs an open set, which includes every rational, of size as small as we like. So "cardinality" and "the measure of a set" have no particular relationship, other than that the measure of a countable set is always 0.