13 ms·
U.S. drone pilot leaks footage reveals accidental killing of children and adults
- cameronh90 5y agoIs it cynical to think this was intentionally leaked to boost support for withdrawing from Afghanistan?
- JohnWhigham 5y agoAside from delusional Trump loyalists that have now flip-flopped and are praising the Taliban, most Americans overwhelmingly supported withdrawing years ago.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoFirstly, any goal you support could be achieved wrongly by terrible means. I support stimulatinf the economy, but not by bringing back child labour Secondly, there has been a complete failure of leadership in rebuilding afganistan and in communicating to the public that you can't just pack up and leave. I just listened to the podcast with an afgan vet, he was there for 10 years. On the first year they shipped a hydroelectric turbine to install in a damn. On 10 year when he was leaving, the turbine was still sitting on the construction site, noone even unwrapped it.
- pjc50 5y agoAnother 10 years would not have installed the turbine. > complete failure of leadership in rebuilding Afghanistan Agree. It's been a bipartisan failure with the aid of the media for two decades. But it's also an extremely hard problem, and it ties into an area that America is particularly bad at: state capacity. You can't build a government by being anti-government. > and in communicating to the public that you can't just pack up and leave Well, you can and they have. This is going to get a bunch of people killed, but that doesn't stop it happening this way, because that has basically zero traction with US voters.
- fallingknife 5y agoYou could just support a bunch of preexisting local warlords instead of trying to build a national army. A lot of them probably don't like the Taliban any more than we do.
- AlexandrB 5y agoAh yes, the bastion of freedom: warlords. Not to say that this wouldn't work or is a bad idea! But the US would either have to drop the pretense that they're "liberating" Afghanistan or spin such a move harder than they've ever spun before. It was a lot easier during the Cold War when you could just call the Taliban "communist" to justify just about any military or covert action.
- watwut 5y agoThat is basically what happened and why army never had trus of many Afghans. It contained local warlords responsible for past atrocities and cruelty. Some of these were barely better then Taliban.
- guiriduro 5y agoIs it cynical to think about all the rest of the suppressed material out of the public domain previously to reduce objections to maintaining a military involvement?
- pvaldes 5y agoIs very reasonable, in fact.
- noisy_boy 5y agoEntirely dismissing that possibility given the timing would be naive.
- Borrible 5y agoNo, it isn't. It is realpolitik. Nasty game for nasty people. And it could lead to outrage and spontaneous attacks on civilians and the troops protecting them. Well done, whatever are the reasons for publishing it now, initiated by which player ever.
- f6v 5y agoBecause spending trillions of $ on war instead of other things isn't enough.
- Zenst 5y agoA cynic would probably think this was intentionally leaked to stir up problems that will spill out into the west, leading towards a sentiment of history repeating itself. Though sometimes the timing of things are just coincidences as many a horoscope has surely taught us about connecting dots that are not connected.
- belorn 5y agoThe military method to define any male (and sometimes women) above a certain age as an combatant was leaked 2010. This is simply a reminder that the same indiscriminating warfare are continuing. If anything this article reminds me of domestic terrorists that define a certain demographic as being enemy combatants and then goes to indiscriminate killing spree. The major difference seems to be that the military personal who actually operated the drones know that what they are doing is wrong, otherwise the room would not have gone silent when the two civilians and their child got killed. Then when it comes to write the report the two civilians becomes combatants and the killing get internally justified.
- loonster 5y agoIn certain areas of operation, yes. Anyone found in that area is considered hostile. I have not seen anything that would imply that every male in the entire country is considered an enemy combatant.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- scoopertrooper 5y agoYou think the U.S. government leaked videos of themselves bombing afghan civilians in the middle of tense negotiations with the Taliban?
- radu_floricica 5y agoScrolled through the comments to upvote this, or write it if it wasn't already. If it's just leaked it's pretty obvious. If it's older, I still suspect it was dug up again on purpose, but it's less glaring.
- yardie 5y agoThe withdrawal doesn't need more support. The public has been calling for withdrawal for years now. It's already popular. The only ones who still support staying are politicians, military suppliers, and the media.
- ceilingcorner 5y agoI wonder if Facebook Twitter etc. banning violent and bloody content has prevented the public from protesting these things more widely. It is well known that TV broadcasts of Vietnam led to outrage growing against that war.
- baybal2 5y agoIndeed it was. It is a potent infoweapon. Israel tried hard to prevent release of news coverage with blown to bits Palestinian children on every silly pretext, including "gory content." Yet, when it were blown to bits Israeli children from bombings, they were all over CNN. The world's outrage is clearly not poweless.
- poisonarena 5y agoIsraeli media and the state doesn't release gory pictures of their dead children from terrorist attacks for propaganda, out of respect for their citizens. Palestinian Media and Hamas have absolutely no problem releasing footage of dead children to manipulate you on the other hand, no matter how out of context, old, fake, or even children they accidentally killed with failed rockets. They know you want to root for the underdog!
- baybal2 5y ago> Israeli media and the state doesn't release gory pictures of their dead children from terrorist attacks for propaganda, out of respect for their citizens. Please, I want to be proven wrong here
- poisonarena 5y agoThey don't, they dont show it on tv or print or news websites.
- jiggawatts 5y agoConversely, in more than a few asymmetric conflicts around the world, the weaker side would often parade around footage of dead children. Often carried in the arms of a weeping parent, with their tears making very visible streaks down the concrete dust on their face. Later, we'd find out that the "parent" was a soldier that found a dead kid in the nearby morgue or hospital for the photo-op. Or that the video clip was from three years ago, when a building collapsed due to shoddy construction. NOTE: I'm certainly not saying that powerful countries aren't responsible for lots and lots of children being killed, because they most certainly are, and in huge, horrifying numbers. Instead I simply ask that we don't pretend that the lies and propaganda are perpetrated only by one of the sides involved.
- belter 5y agoOriginal source but not accessible from the EU: https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-failed-afghan-drone-campaign-against-taliban https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-fa...
- slezyr 5y agoIt's great to live in Ukraine. You have all the downsides and none of the benefits of the EU.
- joshuaissac 5y agoArchived page: https://web.archive.org/web/20210825045512/https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-failed-afghan-drone-campaign-against-taliban https://web.archive.org/web/20210825045512/https://www.audac...
- bearclaw89 5y agoDon't waste your time, this video doesn't show anything about killing accidentally. War sucks and civilian casualties do happen but this says nothing. Taliban were known for dressing as females to get out of situations and using children as "cover".
- hirundo 5y agoThe article says that the people killed were not the targets. But it's not an accident because some Taliban sometimes use disguises and children, so no problem?
- DoctorNick 5y agoHiding behind women and children, you say? MONSTERS!! http://www.angryflower.com/hiding.html http://www.angryflower.com/hiding.html
- fastball 5y agoAre you being intentionally obtuse or...? It is well known that various freedom fighter / terrorist groups are not just protecting their women and children / taking women and children to the hospital and then getting attacked. These cells have long terms presence in those places. They are firing rockets from the rooftops of schools and hospitals. Like with that building in Palestine that the IDF drone-struck that the AP worked out of but apparently Hamas did too and this was a known quantity.
- torstenvl 5y agoThis kind of sarcastic and emotionally charged comment is not particularly helpful. The fact that a comment by someone you disagree with bears some semblance to a shallow and partisan comic you once read does not constitute meaningful engagement.
- refurb 5y agoThat comic doesn’t even make sense.
- 5y ago
- x14km2d 5y agoFor EU users: https://web.archive.org/web/20210825104534/https://eminetra.co.uk/u-s-drone-pilot-leaks-footage-reveals-accidental-killing-of-two-children-and-two-adults-in-afghanistan/663346/ https://web.archive.org/web/20210825104534/https://eminetra....
- croes 5y ago"The Wayback Machine has not archived that URL."
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hhsbz 5y agoGee... After seeing this, I wonder why the Taliban have the support of the populace in Afghanistan.
- yonixw 5y agoThe same people that are trying fleeing the country?
- simonh 5y agoIt seems like the general population very largely don't support the Taliban, but for whatever reasons the urban populations aren't willing or able to stand up a credible defence. I suspect the problem is the Taliban are 'only' instituting Islamic law. It's hard to fire up a Muslim population against implementing, er, Islam even if they are against the actual resulting policies.
- hhsbz 5y agoThey don't based on what, UN polls?
- gccs 5y agoBased on the propaganda shown on msm.
- simonh 5y agoSeven rounds of internationally monitored and accredited national and regional elections over the past two decades.
- hhsbz 5y agoThe turnout of the latest election is 19%
- simonh 5y agoFor several elections it's hovered around the 1/3 mark. That's not bad by regional standards, and bear in mind several large and populous regions in Afghanistan are non-Pushtun and even follow different branches of Islam. There's just no way the Taliban can conceivably command anything more than middling minority support. They just have more guns and a bloodier determination to use them. Unfortunately, as is often the case, that’s all it takes.
- kzrdude 5y agoThe journalist seems reckless for publishing a photo of the journal. Transcribe that to protect your source.
- h2odragon 5y ago"protect your source?" We don't do that no more. Leakers are either heroes whose integrity must be honored and anonymity protected, or traitors who should be hounded beyond legal authority. Depending on who likes what they said.
- cies 5y ago> accidental killing of children On purpose is a war crime now, so it has to be accidental. Starting/continuing a war is not accidental though. It sure can be baseless (imho most if not all recent US wars were baseless).
- nceqs3 5y agoThe war on ISIS? I heard Raqqa was lovely under their control.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- BBC-vs-neolibs 5y agoISIS was created from the power vacuum of the toppling of Saddam.
- avh02 5y agoI'm not saying you're wrong, but this might (obvi, wild speculation) just be a premature version of: "I heard kabul was great under the taliban" That said - yeah, I'm glad ISIS's great swoop was thwarted.
- nceqs3 5y agoThe Taliban is like New Zealand compared to ISIS.
- notsureaboutpg 5y agoPyongyang is not lovely but we don't fight a war over it.
- cies 5y ago> The war on ISIS? I heard Raqqa was lovely under their control. You heard something does not make it a good reason to go to war. Some neighbourhoods of the US are "said to be lovely /s" but does that warrant an invasion? ISIS took hold of places in Syria because Assad was facing an "attempt to replace" by the US.
- ubavic 5y agoI wonder will this hatred ever end; I wonder and worry my friend; I wonder; I wonder, wonder don't you? - S. Rodriguez
- A4ET8a8uTh0 5y agoCan someone explain the origins of the slang for 'charger'? That one would not occur to me.
- torstenvl 5y agoWe didn't use this term in Iraq, so I wouldn't call it "military jargon for child" like the article does. It is common for units to come up with code words for various things, especially when the topic is emotionally charged or could be used for propaganda or intel. For example, almost nobody would use the term "FKIA" over the radio, even on a secure channel; they might say "flowers" instead.
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 5y agoRiver City = reduced comms = something very bad happened, probably KIA
- loonster 5y agoThanks. I never knew that River City = Reduced Comms. Sure I knew what it was and what it was for but never what the codeword was originally.
- Toutouxc 5y agoWhat's "FKIA"?
- DangitBobby 5y agoI'm going to guess friendly/ies killed in action.
- rendall 5y agoProbably from "charge" in its sense of something to take care of
- eurasiantiger 5y agoIt means someone who starts running towards a group of soldiers. This may mean they are carrying explosives, but it may just be a play to get the soldiers to shoot an unarmed child in broad daylight.
- nikkinana 5y agoWhere's the wuhan lab leaked footage? That's caused a world catastrophe. I guess everyone involved committed suicide or is busting up rocks?
- perihelions 5y agoThis reads like an AI-generated translation. It looks like the source that they're plagiarizing is this Daily Mail article: https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9924567/US-drone-pilot-leaks-footage-reveals-accidentally-killed-child-two-adults-Afghanistan.html https://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-9924567/US-drone-pi... The points of difference have a strong smell of machine translation. E.g. "Killing for the sake of killing" turns into "I’ll kill you for the killing"; "Connecting Vets" becomes "Veterinary connection". @dang This article should probably replace the submitted URL (edit: or alternatively, that article in the top reply comments) related discussion thread: (identifying abuse of machine translation in published journal papers) https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28107614 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28107614 ("Tortured phrases: A dubious writing style emerging in science")
- adjkant 5y agoFrom another comment chain (credit to @belter), this seems like the original source: https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-failed-afghan-drone-campaign-against-taliban https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-fa... Comment chain (along with archive link for EU access): https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28299929 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28299929
- Y-bar 5y ago> This site isn't currently available in the EU Do you happen to know another source or archived version? Edit: thanks for the updated links!
- adjkant 5y agohttps://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28300227 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28300227 Added that to the top level as well
- squarefoot 5y agoArchived here. https://web.archive.org/web/20210825045512/https://www.audacy.com/connectingvets/news/inside-america-failed-afghan-drone-campaign-against-taliban https://web.archive.org/web/20210825045512/https://www.audac...
- Zenst 5y agoWhen we often look at drones and the advent of AI and the fear of automated killing drones but lets take another perspective. AI that assists in preventing innocents being killed. Still manually controlled but an AI to override hostile action when it deems it wrong. We all focus upon AI to identify and select targets, but an AI to help identify and prevent innocents being impacted - surely that approach would be a worthy goal? After all - no military want's collateral damage.
- bserge 5y agoSadly, you'd be wrong about that last one. Even in cases where they would want as few casualties as possible, I believe no military would want some "pos tech" telling them what to do (and especially what not to do).
- Zenst 5y ago> I believe no military would want some "pos tech" telling them what to do (and especially what not to do). https://www.wired.com/story/pentagon-inches-toward-letting-ai-control-weapons/ https://www.wired.com/story/pentagon-inches-toward-letting-a... Also many an anti rocket/missile system that is automated and AI is (maybe already is in some aspects of tracking) being worked upon. https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2019/10/7/pentagon-contemplating-role-of-ai-in-missile-defense https://www.nationaldefensemagazine.org/articles/2019/10/7/p... So whilst the step towards automated weapons of destruction does seem inevitable, there is clearly more acceptance of weapons for preventing lives ending unfairly already.
- pjmlp 5y agoI rather avoid an Oblivion like future.
- Zenst 5y agoYes, many do seem to worry about AI more than nuclear weapons - more so if they even cross streams so too speak. But I do wonder how much of things are driven by worst case hoilloywood visualsations of things. Certainly the whole cold war and peoples mentalities, was very much media driven from the fear aspect. Will AI share the same and will we get to the stage that we see anti AI groups form and the term and history of Luddite gets revised! Certainly many worry's, but also opportunities. Certainly don't want any AI working out a way to game Asimov's rules of robotics.
- SandunGunn 5y agoAn old soldiers take: https://www.ted.com/talks/robert_gallimore_why_it_matters_how_we_kill https://www.ted.com/talks/robert_gallimore_why_it_matters_ho... In summary drones make it to easy for the countries like the UK and the US to kill with no risk to their own service men. The missiles are not magic, there will be collateral damage. Solders on the ground could mitigate this
- inglor_cz 5y ago"kill with no risk to their own service men" Reducing the risk to your own troops is a fundamental concern of most armies out there and has been for millennia. Robot warfare is a logical endpoint of such development. I cannot see anyone opting out of this race and remaining militarily relevant.
- sangnoir 5y ago> Robot warfare is a logical endpoint of such development Robot vs. Robot is unlikely to settle wars - we may as well play chess rather than wage war and humans have too much bloodlust to solve differences that way. What is likely to happen is having country A's robots in country B's homeland killing humans, while battling country B's robots in A's homeland. What constitutes a "war front" will be really confusing when the next war between great powers comes.
- inglor_cz 5y agoThe goal of a war usually isn't to rack the highest bodycount, but to break the opponent's will. IDK how this works with fully robotic armies, but some devastation of the homelands is probably expected. The concept of a war front has been already muddled since the advent of airplanes.
- sangnoir 5y ago> The concept of a war front has been already muddled since the advent of airplanes. True, but airplanes have to fly back. I'd say cruise missiles, then UAVs/drones and loitering munitions have continued to blur the lines. Having loitering bots of war on the ground will be a further escalation.
- ricardobeat 5y agoHaving watched a few documentaries on the war, from multiple periods, my first thought was “who did they target with these drone strikes?” seeing as they usually had no idea who or where the enemy was. The answer is much worse than I could imagine: “a guy with a radio … which is reasonable grounds for suspicion”. Nothing accidental about it. These should be considered war crimes.
- amelius 5y agoTheir defense will probably be something like: but it's one step less reckless than just throwing bombs.
- wayoutthere 5y agoWe need to seriously examine our own morality for allowing these ghouls to basically genocide brown people. We are absolutely the baddies; between Iraq, Afghanistan and our air strikes on Syria, Libya, and Yemen during the same period killed 1 million civilians. We’re within an order of magnitude of the Holocaust, and we all just pretend everything is ok. I really don’t know why there aren’t more discussions of how this is basically the Islamic Holocaust.
- salawat 5y agoUntil you can actually pierce the National Security curtain to have a frank discussion involving details on Ways and Means in the Intelligence Community, this is a "pointless act of hyperbolic futility". The answer will just be "Need to know, and you don't" or some other platitude. As what you're asking in the end is what are the inputs that drive these decision making processes. This will never be a public conversation. Note, I think it's an absolutely sound and necessary thing to happen, I just never see it happening.
- wayoutthere 5y agoYep, as you can see now any discussion of it is downvoted into oblivion / killed immediately. It’s not astroturfing but I think the cognitive dissonance between what we believe our country is versus what it actually does is too great. We all wonder how German citizens could have gone along with Nazi atrocities.. and the truth is that they largely didn’t know about them and what they did find out was considered “fake news”.
- actually_a_dog 5y agoYou know the worst thing about this, and everything else that's happened in Afghanistan in the past 20 years? The Taliban unconditionally surrendered in 2001: https://www.commondreams.org/views/2021/08/18/taliban-surrendered-2001 https://www.commondreams.org/views/2021/08/18/taliban-surren... Talk about a waste: of lives, of money, of time, of effort that could have gone to far more productive purposes.
- dayofthedaleks 5y agoAccording to today's NYTimes, the proffered surrender wasnt quite unconditional - the Taliban requested amnesty in exchange for disarming. Rumsfeld turned them down on the pretense of demanding unconditional surrender. My suspicion is America's persisting collective rage and the firehose of defense spending were beyond anyone's control at that point.
- bzbarsky 5y agoPer https://www.nytimes.com/2001/12/07/news/rumsfeld-rejects-planto-allow-mullah-omar-to-live-in-dignity-taliban.html https://www.nytimes.com/2001/12/07/news/rumsfeld-rejects-pla... which I think is describing the same incident it was not an "unconditional surrender", though it was somewhat close: the conditions were about immunity from prosecution or punishment for Mullah Mohammed Omar (Taliban's leader at the time).
- coliveira 5y agoThe casualties of the Iraq/Afghanistan wars were mostly on civilians. It is not war, it is a genocide or muslim people because they don't want to let the West take their land/resources.
- marcus_holmes 5y agoA Hellfire missile apparently costs $150K [0]. Given that it's apparently OK to launch one of these at a single suspected enemy informant, couldn't we have saved a lot of time, money and lives by just bribing the entire population of Afghanistan to not do things that the West doesn't like? [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-114_Hellfire https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/AGM-114_Hellfire
- merpnderp 5y agoInfrastructure and industry were the solution to Afghanistan. A tribe which owns a large share in the local mining operation is a tribe which does its best to keep the peace. The US could have built a lot of roads and propped up a lot of barely profitable enterprises with the money spent on all those military operations.
- uCantCauseUCant 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Resource_curse
- randomopining 5y agoSo like 30-50k per person for the total cost of the war. Or 1.6k-3k per year. I guess that's doable but it's probably not a lot of money. Plus the power structures still want to take advantage of any situation, it's not like 3k is going to pacify a warlord in the country. So nope let's go with teh hellfire.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- gccs 5y agoNo. The purpose of the war is to fund defense contractors and create jobs back at home. Giving the money directly to afganis would not do that.
- 5y ago
- queuesorcs 5y agoAs much as I love to check hackernews, I’m not normally able to chime in with relevant information on most topics. I feel like this may be one where I can actually do that though as I’m former military and my job directly related to drones on a daily basis. Depending on what’s asked, I may not be able to answer but I’d love to help by sharing any knowledge or information on the subject that I can as I’ve gained so much from others sharing on different topics on here. Ask away and I’ll check back in 15-20 minutes. Editing to add on that I’ll continue to check back on this for at least the rest of the day in case there’s anything else I can potentially shed more of a light on.
- whydid 5y agoHow much accountability do remote pilots have for incidents like this? I.e., is there an ammo budget? What happens if a pilot decides to "go GTA" and destroy things for fun?
- queuesorcs 5y agoTo be clear and so I’m not misleading, I was neither a pilot or a sensor operator so I cannot guarantee you that there isn’t more to it than what I know. As far as I understood the drone pilot works in conjunction with a sensor operator. Because the drone pilot is an officer he is the one to fire the missile but the sensor operator controls the laser to direct the missile. I would strongly believe that there are other emergency stops available due to my experiences but at the bare minimum, the sensor operator could always direct the missile away and the sensor operator themselves can’t do anything without the pilot actually launching the missile. Editing to add in that hellfire missiles cannot be redirected once launched.
- robertlagrant 5y ago> "go GTA" Is this an actual thing people think drone operators do? Surely the same that would happen to any military personnel who did the same with their weapons, except with a drone there's perfect camera footage to evidence it as well.
- 5y ago
- noxer 5y agoWhole section about "Trump ended a rule requiring reports of all deaths from drone attacks" an not a single word about the fact that Obama made thous rules just before he left office. This is not Journalism, if you fall for such political theater and intentionally placed stones for the next administration to look bad you are not a real journalist. PS: I'm from Europe you can down vote anyway if you want ;)
- iJohnDoe 5y agoThink about this for a second. Your family is walking into Trader Joe’s or Whole Foods and all get killed by a missile from the sky. Or you send your children off to school and the school gets accidentally hit by a missile. Killed in an instant and the family of those victims listed above have no idea why and have zero recourse. If this started happening on US soil on a daily basis, I wonder if more people would care. The top comment here is talking about the article text and AI vs. the topic of the article. FTA - 3,797 we’re killed by drones. They were killed by drones they had no chance to defend themselves against.
- watwut 5y agoTo be fair, civilians have no way to defend themselves against any even semi organized army.
- nexuist 5y agoThis did happen on US soil: https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/may/10/move-1985-bombing-reconciliation-philadelphia https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2020/may/10/move-1985-bo... Police brutality is our domestic version of drone strikes. No chance to defend yourself and zero recourse. Do we care an adequate amount about it? Maybe, although it seems to not be the culture's cup of tea right now as much as it was in 2020.
- LeoGovender 5y agoDumb US fuckwits Facebook logins Username = yagendreng@gmail.com Password = Alexiag123#
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]