11 ms·
> Why is everyone so confused that smart TVs are popular? Also the real reason that they're popular: there are no non-smart TVs available.
by pessimizer 5y ago
> Why is everyone so confused that smart TVs are popular?
Also the real reason that they're popular: there are no non-smart TVs available.
- vincentmarle 5y agoI can recommend Sceptre if you want a decent dumb TV.
- bigbaguette 5y agoThinking next time I need a big panel I'll shop in the digital signage area, and take care of inputs and sound externally. Philips got the BDL line, NEC also a big supplier.
- squarefoot 5y agoThe choice is shrinking, but there are still some available. Example: https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV/U750CV-UMRD-75-4K-UHD-TV-product1131category1category73.html https://www.sceptre.com/TV/4K-UHD-TV/U750CV-UMRD-75-4K-UHD-T... Sadly unobtanium in the EU.
- howenterprisey 5y agoI just got this one myself (the 50-inch model, really), and am completely satisfied with the purchase.
- squarefoot 5y agoIf you have time, please could you check somewhere if there are traces of any manufacturer other than Sceptre? Although possible, I don't think they're made exclusively by or for Sceptre as the cost should be much higher due to the smaller market, so I believe there are chances they could exist somewhere else under a different brand, which hopefully would distribute in the EU. Thanks!
- patrickk 5y agoAnecdotally, I heard a German TV brand called Telefunken sells some non-smart TVs, e.g: https://www.amazon.de/-/en/Telefunken-XH32G101N-ready-triple-tuner/dp/B07VHQH6NJ/ref=lp_12622385031_1_8 https://www.amazon.de/-/en/Telefunken-XH32G101N-ready-triple...
- naikrovek 5y agothere are no dumb TVs available because Joe and Jane consumer want a Smart TV, because why the hell wouldn't they? The price of a dumb TV and anything to plug into it to give the same functionality is more than the cost of the equivalent Smart TV alone, AND THEY GET THE SAME STREAMING SERVICES. That was the case when Smart TVs were introduced, anyway. it is an easy choice when you don't know the minutia. Television manufacturers are always looking for a new thing that will prematurely render existing sets obsolete, triggering a new television purchase. Smarts embedded into the TV are one of those things that is very inexpensive to add at scale, but convinces many consumers that their existing devices are no longer "good", which starts that itching that can only be scratched by purchasing a larger TV with the hot new feature du jour. it was only after Smart TVs gained wide adoption that the abuse of network connectivity was capitalized upon by manufacturers, and dumb TVs were virtually made extinct.
- amiga 5y agoAnecdotal, the last "unsmart" TV I found was hobbled to the point of not even having a power indicator LED. It wasn't used much until putting a "good smart" device behind it...in this case a Roku. Orwellian prophecy in real life, the Roku sends data back to the company about anything you watch using that device. The only difference between this setup and a "plus good smart" TV is that anything else displayed on the TV(pc, pirated movies, photos, playstation/xbox/nintendo consoles, etc) will be fingerprinted and sent back to the company analytical department. My opinion is it is none of their business. This is all acceptable because manipulation via marketing/advertising is considered a necessary evil, and, the device is easy to use.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- aaaaaaaaaaab 5y ago>Anecdotal, the last "unsmart" TV I found was hobbled to the point of not even having a power indicator LED. Please, tell me which model was that! I hate it when shiny LEDs ruin my movie experience.
- hilbert42 5y agoMy solution to get a new dumb TV is simple. I don't want and would never own a smart TV so I use a standard monitor with a PVR/STB (Set Top Box). It works perfectly - I've used that solution for years. The real problem is that governments have allowed the free-to-air (dumb) TV service to be bastardized, there's no regulation to protect it. A very simple solution that would end the practice immediately would be for governments to put say 20% tax/duty on all smart TVs made by manufacturers who don't ALSO market dumb TVs. Blame your governments for the lack of dumb TVs!
- wwn_se 5y agoI usually just connect the "smart tv" to the internet once a year and update the firmware (after checking the change log for useful fixes). Then I disconnect it again and use my chromecast to stream.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- hilbert42 5y agoGood idea, but before I'd update I'd doubly check the net to see there are no new/hidden gotchas as some have reported (like the way some manufacturers have coded around Pi-hole, etc.).
- apexalpha 5y agoAny Smart TV that you don't bring online is essentially a dumb TV.
- cik 5y agoIt's more than that. Ultimately at a certain point TVs are blank slates, and become identical. At that point it's a race to the bottom on price, as opposed to features. TVs might have multiple inputs and outputs - but if they don't, honestly that's a $10 problem so there's a lack of reasonable differentiation. Enter "Smart TVs". Consumers can theoretically choose one based on built-in applications, versions of Android (in theory). At the very least there is differentiation. The frustrating part is that at least here, it seems like these TVs are starting to lose features like optical outputs and multiple inputs. I literally just want a dumb slate with >2 HDMI inputs and an optical output. That's no longer an option in Israel. In calls to 16 different stores based on what's available in the country (zap.co.il) your order is always "out of stock" and the call devolves to upgrade to a newer TV that yay has Android XXX on it. Inter-connectivity is becoming difficult to purchase.
- mschuster91 5y agoYou have to search for Digital Signage monitors, these usually don't have smart crap, a wider selection of inputs, and are built to higher quality standards.
- beebeepka 5y agoThere are. It's just you can't get the good stuff for anywhere near smart TV prices
- risho 5y agothe next logical question is why are they the only tv's available? the reason is the same reason that phones are getting bigger and laptops are getting thinner. (hint it's not some grand conspiracy to ruin your life or to fuck the consumer) the answer is because that's what people buy.
- capitainenemo 5y agoThe last TV I purchased I had to spend a $10-$20 premium over the smart model with similar specs (from a slightly more reputable manufacturer at that) just to get a non-smart model. The data mining definitely plays a huge part.
- dalmo3 5y agoCare to share which model? Last time I checked, the few dumb TVs I could find were at least 30% more expensive than a similar smart one.
- capitainenemo 5y agoI've had the TV for about 5 years now so no information I could share would be too helpful. It's got a 1920x1080 resolution and seems to work well with the living room PC, that's good enough for me.
- wwn_se 5y agoIf you don't give it your wifi password it will not be smart? Its not like they come with a sim card... I would however love a smart tv with an open stack where I can control the software.
- capitainenemo 5y agoPersonally I didn't want passive collection phoning home if, at any point, anyone connected it to anything, and there is also the possibility of connecting to open access points. And, well, saw no reason for leaving around untrusted unreliable crud I couldn't remove. It was worth a modest markup to get rid of it.
- cm2187 5y agoLike death and taxes are popular. And now with embedded ads.
- haunter 5y agoThere are, they are called monitors
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- tfigment 5y agoMonitors generally don't have remote controls or speakers. The latter solved with soundbar but former is important use case.
- nitrogen 5y agoMonitors also generally don't come in 60"+ sizes, or if they do, they don't have HDR or other modern video display technologies.
- julianwachholz 5y agoPossibly some hospitality TVs still come as dumb variants but that seems to be changing too.
- Johnny555 5y agoMy company has monitors for video conferencing and they all have remotes and speakers. I think they are LG's... like this one: https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1526262-REG/lg_55ut640s0ua_55_ut640s_series_uhd.html/overview https://www.bhphotovideo.com/c/product/1526262-REG/lg_55ut64...
- detaro 5y ago> LG UT640S 55" Class HDR 4K UHD Commercial Smart IPS LED TV ;) (Although the key here really is the commercial - different standards of what customers are expected to tolerate there)
- alasdair_ 5y agoI have a 4k 43 inch 144hz hdr “gaming” monitor (ROG Strix) and it has a remote. It’s becoming more common now.
- tshaddox 5y agoIt stretches credulity to suggest that the lack of non-smart TVs on the market causes the popularity of smart TVs. Would you also suggest that the lack of black and white TVs on the market causes the popularity of color TVs?
- MereInterest 5y agoDoes it similarly stretch credulity to suggest that the lack of commercial-free cable channels on the market causes the popularity of cable channels with commercials. Something may be "popular" because it's the only game in town.
- tshaddox 5y agoI challenge the premise. At least in the United States, the number of subscribers to commercial-free cable channels has decreased significantly in the last 10 years, during which time the number of subscribers to streaming services which show fewer or no ads has increased significantly.
- nicce 5y agoI think it was more of example as using term ”popular” in different context, regardless of it is true or not. Arguing if it is not true, does not take this example away.
- tshaddox 5y agoOf course it does, because “popular” in the original example was referring to their ubiquity and lack of over viable alternatives. An example of a once-dominant product that appears to be losing in the market to a fast-rising new alternative is not analogous.
- nicce 5y agoArgument goes then more for “is this scenario possible at all for term ‘popular’?”, when it certainly is. Example was just weak. Another example could be, why driving a car is “too popular” on country side to move between places. It might be popular, because there is no public transportation. Is the situation same with public transportation? Can we call it popular, because it is forced?