10 ms·
More than eighty cultures still speak in whistles
- coatdoor 5y agoEighty-one cultures if you include the Clangers' planet. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOK1YdWalOw https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dOK1YdWalOw
- chansiky 5y agoI’ve always wondered if two Morse code experts could talk to each other in beeps.
- DaiPlusPlus 5y ago> "still speak in whistles" "still"? Why is having more degrees of expressiveness in a vocal language considered an anachronism?
- brink 5y agoSoon we will learn how to eradicate these so-called "whistlers".
- mc32 5y agoIn NYC construction workers are having their whistling curbed because most of it was the of sexist kind or at least a sufficient number of recipients didn’t want them.
- mypastself 5y agoYour interpretation of the title is not supported by the article’s content. In fact, you’re agreeing with it.
- addingnumbers 5y agoThey call whistling languages "vestiges," a "protolanguage," and baselessly speculate that they originate from less-evolved primates. The writer's tone keeps reverting to subtly dismissive and colonialist.
- citrus1330 5y agoThe article actually says the exact opposite. Can you read? Here's the quote: "That doesn’t mean that modern whistled speech is a vestigial remnant of those protolanguages, Meyer cautions. If whistling preceded voiced speech, those earliest whistles wouldn’t have needed to encode sounds produced by the vocal cords. But today’s whistled languages do, which means they arose later, as add-ons to conventional languages, not forerunners of them, Meyer says."
- addingnumbers 5y agoYes, clearly they recognized the need to backpedal somewhat from their long string of intimations that these languages have savage and primal qualities. Did you think that passage was a total non-sequitur? Are they cautioning you from believing something you would have no reason to believe? Or do you think they were aware they had unduly created that impression.
- pcrh 5y agoOn the contrary, they stress that using whistling to discover fundamentals of communication using sound does not imply that whistling was the original form of communication by sound.
- addingnumbers 5y agoThey could have achieved the same effect by never suggesting that whistling languages are primal or antiquated in the first place. I suppose if I say "we shouldn't assume people who comment on HN posts are sad, lonely, and grumpy" I'm not being offensive or disrespectful. After all, I never said outright that anyone was any of those things. On the contrary, it actually says the exact opposite It's a trick of language called insinuation.
- mkotowski 5y agoProbably they worded it this way (assuming good intentions, of course) because whistle-based language forms were created as a tool to combat communication hurdles in a challenging terrain. With the development of long-range communication, I would dare to say it is amazing that there are still practitioners of whistled speech.
- beardyw 5y agoI remember walking in Andalusia an coming across a shepherd sitting on a grass bank, holding his head in his hands, talking to his sheep. It seemed I had stepped back in time and felt it was a very special moment. Looking back I saw he was actually on his mobile phone. Other forms of communication are available.
- momirlan 5y agoThe shepherd i met in Romania had 2 cell phones. One for each side of the mountain
- 1123581321 5y agoRead the article and you’ll have a better idea how to preserve this form of communication.
- dr_dshiv 5y agoBecause languages gradually lose phoenetic features over time. Phonetic diversity is a primary method for determining the age of a language. Hawaiian is a recent language with just 8 consonants and !Kung is ancient with over 50 consonants. The same phenomenon occurs with DNA diversity. Here is an article with explanation: https://www.languagesoftheworld.info/bad-linguistics/phonemic-diversity-prove-africa-theory.html https://www.languagesoftheworld.info/bad-linguistics/phonemi...
- rvense 5y ago> Because languages gradually lose phoenetic features over time I don't think this is accurate. While it certainly does happen, new phonemic distinctions can certainly arise as languages change. The article you link to does not support the idea either, in fact it explicitly contradicts it: "Moreover, there is no bias towards decreasing the size of phonemic inventory over time as human populations moved out of Africa, as phonemes may be added as well as eliminated."
- emodendroket 5y agoFor the same reason you don't see a lot of carrier pigeons anymore: it's been supplanted by something easier requiring less training.
- citrus1330 5y agoIf you read the article you would know. "Despite their interest to both linguists and casual observers, whistled languages are disappearing rapidly all over the world, and some — such as the whistled form of the Tepehua language in Mexico — have already vanished. Modernization is largely to blame, says Meyer, who points to roads as the biggest factor. “That’s why you still find whistled speech only in places that are very, very remote, that have had less contact with modernity, less access to roads,” he says."
- newsbinator 5y ago> Modernization is largely to blame I'd replace "blame" with "thank": the simpler languages can become, and the fewer of them in daily use we can get to globally, the better for the entire species. I'd love an expressive and terse baseline human language. No problem if people still use other languages too, for cultural or historical reasons.
- xj9 5y agomore language diversity is more fun. common languages are boring. folks should learn more languages, rather than less. its good for your brain too. here's to another babel moment!
- newsbinator 5y agoLearning a lot of complicated things is good for your brain, like programming in various languages or playing various musical instruments. It's fun too. But having a multilingual globe comes at a massive, immeasurable cost. One of the greatest forces to improve economic opportunity and equality in the history of the world would be if everybody suddenly agreed on one simple, terse, expressive human language and switched to it, in all contexts except home life and shared spiritual or community services. No more IELTS tests, no more spelling bees, no more "why is 'wherefore art thou' not about Romeo's location?", no more notarized translation costs everywhere in the world... everybody gets equal access to all media created in all places (although of course there'll still be place-specific references in that media), etc If you were designing an ideal human world, the last thing you'd want to do is build a Tower of Babel on it.
- dang 5y ago"Please respond to the strongest plausible interpretation of what someone says, not a weaker one that's easier to criticize." https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html
- sweettea 5y agoIf you find the notion of whistled languages fascinating, as do I, there is an app on the Play Store for Whistled Turkish: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=ec.self.whistlelang https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=ec.self.whistl... . Last time whistled languages came up, someone else here dropped a link to this app.
- eatonphil 5y agoThere's an episode of one of my favorite anthropological tv series (In the Americas with David Yetman) on the Chinantecan people in Oaxaca, Mexico. All of the episodes in this series are freely available online and on Amazon Prime. https://intheamericas.org/works/210-whistles-in-the-mist-whistled-speech-in-oaxaca/ https://intheamericas.org/works/210-whistles-in-the-mist-whi...
- JoeAltmaier 5y agoMaybe an app that changes any spoken recording into a whistled one?
- Igelau 5y agoI love the lilt of that whistled buenoooo.
- question000 5y agoI honestly would love if we stopped trying to square the circle with speech recognition and just built a phonetic signal based system for computer interaction. Words are overrated, I'd rather whistle at my speakers like I'm R2D2.
- jobigoud 5y agoI was also thinking about this, in the context of silent speech, trying to recognize phonemes directly from muscle activation on the throat. Instead of trying to pattern match an existing language, which is too complicatex/ambiguous, we should construct a language dedicated to that, that is easy to recognize from the EMG. Then we can have the software 'translate' the message.
- yjftsjthsd-h 5y agoI would also happily go for that, but I suspect that most people do not want to learn a new way to communicate just to talk to their computers.
- mr-wendel 5y agoIf you can find it, this documentary is a lot of fun: Pucker Up - The Fine Art of Whistling There is a short, but great segment where this is demonstrated with two men whistling across mountain tops to communicate. The film is filled with gems like one guy explaining as a compulsive whistler he got in trouble once for whistling a tune at a funeral.
- Taylor_OD 5y agoAnyone learn to whistle, in any way or form, later in life? I've always wanted to but never been able to. I've tried a few types of whistles. The closest I've gotten is some quasi duck calls using my hands and whistling with the help of an acorn.
- mypastself 5y agoI actually did, from a Reddit thread that guided me through the process step by step. I’m having trouble finding the exact link at the moment, but it starts with slowly breathing out the letter “Q”. It’s not a loud, booming sound or anything, but I went from blowing soundless air for 20-odd years to actually whistling.
- abdupattoh 5y agoI tried to do that and I puffed out of two places in my body at once and got a questioning look from my wife. My advice is don't try this at home.
- akiselev 5y ago> I’m having trouble finding the exact link at the moment, but it starts with slowly breathing out the letter “Q”. Thank you! That tip was all I needed to figure it out :)
- mypastself 5y agoHa, glad to be of help!
- Taylor_OD 5y agoHoly shit. I tried for about 5 minutes this morning by breathing out Q and I can whistle now. Damn thank you.
- qnsi 5y agoCurious, any reason why you think it might be different later in life? I think it just takes a lot of practice and patience
- estebarb 5y agoThis is extremely cool!!! Also I find surprising that, as a Spanish speaker with no whistle-spanish training, I was able to understand most of the whistles.
- bradrn 5y agoInteresting! Spanish isn’t a tonal language, so how do you ‘translate’ the words into whistles? (And do you think you could do it without subtitles?) (I should note I haven’t actually managed to watch the video yet, because my audio seems to be broken. Perhaps it would be obvious if only I could hear the whistles…)
- chestertn 5y agoSpanish speaker here. Also surprised that I understand the whistles, in particular the second video. Does it happen to you that when you think of a word in English, even if you don't vocalize, some of your vocal cords become tense or move? Well, these whistles feel the same.
- bradrn 5y ago> when you think of a word in English, even if you don't vocalize, some of your vocal cords become tense or move Oddly enough, I haven’t ever perceived this, but I can consciously trigger it, and I do think I understand what you mean.
- yosito 5y agoTo me it literally just sounded like Spanish, but in a high pitched whistle. Some of the sounds don't reproduce 1:1 in a whistle, but the whistling is adapted to still sound similar and comprehensible. I thought I would be able to do this myself by whistling out Spanish words, but it appears that it takes some practice to make all of the correct sounds. I tried in English, Spanish and Hungarian and I'm only able to produce musical notes, not distinguishable letters.
- citrus1330 5y agoI'm not even a native Spanish speaker and I was surprised to find that I could follow along pretty well using the subtitles.
- TheGigaChad 5y agoSavages.
- 29athrowaway 5y agoThere are no IPA keys for whistling.
- bradrn 5y agoSure there are: [s͎˩˧˥˧˨˦˥˧˥˧˨˦] and so on. But really I see no reason why musical notation wouldn’t be sufficient. (I should note that’s not [s]; it’s [s͎] with an arrow below it. It’s hard to tell the difference with the font on my screen.)
- bitdivision 5y agoThat's interesting thanks! There's not much on wikipedia [0] about that character, but it does appear to be for whistled speech! 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%CD%8E https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/S%CD%8E
- bradrn 5y agoYou’re welcome! I first saw it on the Wikipedia page for Shona, which has several whistled consonants within its inventory.
- strict9 5y agoNot the same as emulating vowels and consonants, but my dad used to whistle by with two fingers on his lips and making the loudest whistle. Either to get the dog's attention or my attention as a child. It was a rural area and he used it to communicate (come back home, usually) and as a child I could tell by the sound if it was a normal 'come home' or one where I was in trouble 'come home right now!' I now have a child of my own and kind of wish I could whistle like that, though the utility would be much less living in a city with endless forms of electronic communication.
- bradrn 5y agoApparently that sort of whistling is also used for communication, at least if Wikipedia is to be believed [0] (or if I could track down the source, which I don’t feel like doing just right now): > Sochiapam Chinantec has three different words for whistle-speech: sie³ for whistling with the tongue against the alveolar ridge, jui̵³² for bilabial whistling, and juo² for finger-in-the-mouth whistling. These are used for communication over varying distances. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Whistled_language&oldid=1035732130 https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Whistled_language...
- Dumblydorr 5y agoI use whistling daily. I discovered my dog responds best to whistling, whenever he hears my whistle, he knows it's me and comes running. Now, I use that to my partner ironically, if I don't want to shout and hurt the vocal cords, just whistle and she knows her presence is requested.
- vanattab 5y ago>Now, I use that to my partner ironically, if I don't want to shout and hurt the vocal cords, just whistle and she knows her presence is requested. Or you know... you COULD walk over to where she is.
- VBprogrammer 5y agoYeah, my partner's family have a "family whistle" which is often employed to find one another. It's useful but also feels a little disrespectful.
- agitator 5y agoThis made me realize that my dad has a specific whistle that he would use throughout my childhood and even today as an adult, to get the attention of my brother and myself if we were out somewhere. Like a "Hey, we're leaving. Let's go"
- Baeocystin 5y agoMy parents had a 'if you hear this whistle, come here', which, depending on the sequence of tones, meant anything from '5 minute heads up before it is time to go' to 'literally drop what you are doing and run to this position'. It wasn't disrespectful at all. It was a great way to communicate over wider distances than is possible with regular voice, and in retrospect it was impressive how little translation it took for all of us kids to understand which meaning was being conveyed.
- ckosidows 5y agoMy dad used to whistle at us all the time as children and he probably still does when I see him. I probably picked it up from him. I whistled to an ex SO and they considered it disrespectful. I'm not sure I yet understand why it's disrespectful, not that I consider either opinion more or less correct. I just don't really understand that opinion. Maybe someone can expand on it?
- Teracotage 5y agoIn Syria, whistling has been essential to those hobbyists who raise birds, to communicate and command them "“Hemeimati (Pigeon fancier)” If you have ever visited Damascus and its countryside, Homs, Aleppo or any other Syrian city, you should have noticed swarms of pigeons hovering over the city, swaying right and left, up and down responding to the signs of a person standing on a roof. This person would be carrying a long stick in his hand with a black or white piece of cloth on its tip, waving it, as if telling the flying swarm to fly higher or fly down towards him, often with a “whistle” https://english.enabbaladi.net/archives/2016/08/mysterious-world-pigeon-fancier-hemeimati-strict-laws-regulating-profession-war/ https://english.enabbaladi.net/archives/2016/08/mysterious-w...
- yellow_lead 5y agoCool video in that article: https://youtu.be/MaIKWtSCx0M?t=110 https://youtu.be/MaIKWtSCx0M?t=110 It doesn't show them doing what you mentioned, but they all go into their coop on command
- frosted-flakes 5y agoHere's a guy who trained his chickens to come on command, using a bell: https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YbaY5mbhQZE https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YbaY5mbhQZE
- tingletech 5y agothe fish in my great grandmother's coy pond were trained to come when you clapped. It was considered rude to call them and not give them any food.
- bitdivision 5y agoDoes anyone know if there are any examples of people whistling English? I'd find it fascinating to see if I could understand anything intuitively.
- eeshanagarwal95 5y agoeeshan
- exdsq 5y agoNot sure if it counts as a whistle but I always find it amusing how my wife, who's a Swedish speaking Finn, inhales sharply to say "yes".
- teddyh 5y agoThat is a regional peculiarity specific to the northernmost parts of Sweden, and, I guess, the northernmost Swedish-speaking minority of Finland. Note: Sweden is very unevenly populated; the overwhelming majority of the population lives in the south half of the country, where also its three major cities are located. The northern parts of Sweden mostly consist of vast stretches of wilderness, forests, mountains, and people who talk funny.
- exdsq 5y agoI think it's a little more common purely for fun, almost like slang, among some Swedish-speaking Finns in Helsinki (where she's from)."Ja" is still more common, but it's fun to inhale sometimes
- ithinkso 5y agoIf anyone is interested, [0] is what OP is talking about I think [0] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URgdIAz4QNg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URgdIAz4QNg
- iandioch 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingressive_sound https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingressive_sound gives some details about that. I knew that some Irish English speakers inhale when saying "yes", but it seems fairly widespread across Europe...
- mrxd 5y agoThis is going to be a real headache for localization.
- yoloyoloyoloa 5y agoIts quite common in some hoods in South Africa to use whistling to communicate if the police or enemy gang are coming. Im pretty sure this isnt unique to South Africa though
- allenu 5y agoYou're probably right. I've just started watching The Wire and in season 2, the loading dock workers whistle to each other to let them know cops are around.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoI was just thinking about the 2-3 whistle communications common in the U.S. and I have no idea how one goes about transcribing them in text. How would one even generate a language to show whistle modes, you would almost have to use sheets of music :)
- etskinner 5y agoElsewhere in the thread, someone used 'high low high' to mean the whistle you use to get someone's attention, and 'low high low' meaning "I'm over here".
- France_is_bacon 5y agoHere in the USA, just this past weekend, I spoke in a whistle to someone. They had their driver's side car door open, and they were in a parking space in a parking lot. Someone drove up and wanted to park in the open space next to them. The person with the open car door didn't see them. I whistled. They looked at me and I pointed with my chin to the waiting car. The person waved at me and closed her door. Maybe my whistle wasn't a regularly used and defined "word" per se, but it was a clear and complete conversation. Now that I think about it, I have different whistles depending on the situation. A high-pitched short whistle is usually "watch out". A short high-low-high whistle is usually reserved for friends to say "Hey, dude, look over here, I have something to say to you" usually followed by a non-verbal sign language, like pointing somewhere - "go over here" or "check that out". A low-high-low is for friends to more get their attention and let them know "I'm over here." The super loud whistle with your fingers in your mouth is "F-ing awesome" when you're in a crowd and the music group is playing a great song. It also has other uses. But mostly when there's a big crowd or the person you want to talk to is a long distance away. A bunch of high pitched whistles in a row usually means "danger/watch out." There are other whistles, too. Just giving a few to illustrate how whistles are used right here in the good ole USA for communication purposes. These are used infrequently, but I find most people understand what I'm whistling about and the different meanings of each whistle.
- dylan604 5y agoAs someone that's been a soccer referee, you can tell a lot by the ref's whistle. Just a short hit is usual for an obvious start or restart. For a serious foul, it's a long hard hit. Just from the whistle, you can tell the ref has intentions of issuing a card. My favorites are when the player refuses to acknowledge the ref to "come get your card" whistle calls when the ref is also "I'm not chasing you down". There's entire conversations conveyed by hitting that little whistle.
- girvo 5y agoI used to referee rugby union, at a quite high level, and we had whole classes where we were taught the "language" of our whistle :)
- peter303 5y agoThe version I read on Pocket had several audio clips of whistled English. It is understandable. Once you learn the conventions for representing fricatives as whistles, you can pretty much whistle English.
- nate00 5y agoThat sounds so interesting! Do you still have a link to it? I wasn't able to find any examples by Googling.
- citruscomputing 5y agohttps://soundcloud.com/knowable-magazine/sets/whistle-languages https://soundcloud.com/knowable-magazine/sets/whistle-langua...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- 0xdeadb00f 5y agoSlightly related: I've always loved the clicking sounds used in a number of (South) African languages. Xhosa for example has 6 different clicking sounds [0]. It's so surprising to me that English and most other languages don't make use of any clicking sounds whatsoever. 0: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xhosa_language https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Xhosa_language
- bradrn 5y agoYep, this is a really interesting question. I had a long discussion about this on another forum, and it turns out linguists really have no idea why clicks are restricted to African languages. The best we could come up with was that click sounds are just too difficult to evolve — there’s no easy way for some random English sound (for instance) to turn into a click. On the other hand, if a neighbouring language has click sounds, that can start to provide almost a ‘pathway’ for clicks to come into the language.
- gfaure 5y agoEnglish does use clicks, as paralinguistic sounds. The first paragraph of https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_consonant https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Click_consonant has a couple of examples.
- bradrn 5y agoBut English clicks are not phonemic consonants in the same way they are in Xhosa and Khoekhoe — that is, clicks are not part of words in English, whereas they are in those languages. (Even the language name Xhosa begins with a click.)
- johnorourke 5y agoCaptain Crunch called, said make that 81.
- dcolkitt 5y agoThe biggest downside I see is that it makes language much harder for young children. It’s rare to see someone under 6 be able to whistle.