4 ms·
Payflow: https://www.payflow.es/ https://www.payflow.es/ (surprisingly, no english version) This is a fantastic innovation if it takes off and if the charges a
by pjc50 5y ago
Payflow: https://www.payflow.es/ https://www.payflow.es/ (surprisingly, no english version)
This is a fantastic innovation if it takes off and if the charges aren't prohibitive; it has the potential to obliterate predatory payday lending. In a world of free instant automatic electronic payments, there's no good reason to delay salary payments until the end of the month.
- thaumasiotes 5y ago> it has the potential to obliterate predatory payday lending Say you earn about $200 over expenses in a given month. Your car suffers a problem that requires $1000 to repair. This is 5 months of income, but you probably want to repair the car at the beginning of the 5 month period rather than the end. How much of a difference will it make if your paycheck arrives daily rather than semimonthly?
- pjc50 5y agoPayday lending is usually considered to be for amounts that are less than one month's income.
- thaumasiotes 5y agoAnd? Your monthly income is $200 over expenses.
- Grustaf 5y agoThe point is that it's for people that are living hand to mouth. They're not saving a cent, living constantly on the brink. For them it makes a huge difference to get paid a few days earlier. But this is also why even free payday loans seem to me like a very bad long term idea - if you are living that close to the edge, how will you ever be able to get out of debt?
- Semaphor 5y agoI don’t quite understand the benefit. Surely, if you have to take loans to get over the month, this won’t change anything as your overall income is still the same. I guess for unexpected expenses, you can bridge the gap one-time by borrowing from future-you. What am I missing?
- pjc50 5y agoCashflow, the same as for busineses. If you don't have one months' spare cash as a "float", then you may have to resort to lending at the end of the month.
- Semaphor 5y agoBut again, this reduces next month’s income. So you’ll end up having the same problem every month. Unlike with companies, employed people’s income doesn’t vary between months (or maybe it does for some?).
- meheleventyone 5y agoYes it’s a trap which is why a lot of people see it as predatory particularly as the interest rates are (used to be?) obscene. Payday lending companies can become a leech on poor people. This looks a little different to the usual structure of payday lending but still has the issue you point out.
- pjc50 5y ago> So you’ll end up having the same problem every month Yes. This led to the UK FCA trying to ban rollover loans: https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/tougher-rules-payday-lenders-take-effect https://www.fca.org.uk/news/news-stories/tougher-rules-payda... > employed people’s income doesn’t vary between months (or maybe it does for some?). Exactly: gig economy, variable shift patterns, tipping, benefit payments, delayed cheques, freelancers of all sorts, delayed payment of debts by customers, seasonal employment, sudden unemployment, seasonal expenses, etc. (That said, this app only works for payments from one employer, but I can see it working well for the service industry)
- biztos 5y agoInteresting, I didn't know payday lending was a thing in Spain. Delaying salary payments serves two purposes: first, to benefit the employer by keeping your money in their account longer; and second, at least culturally, to force you into a budget cycle "for your own good." People accept these things culturally but there's no reason they should have to. When I moved to Germany from the US I was a little shocked to discover that I would be paid at the end of the month and not every two weeks. They took the cyclical paternalism one step further, and of course also forced me to give my employer an interest-free credit line. It would be fun to have the leverage to challenge that, but I did not. What do you think the ideal payment frequency would be? For wage labor it seems like you should get paid daily at least, but then why not hourly? Might it even be motivational to see your net pay (after deductions of course) dropping into your account every hour, and you get a notification in some app? For a salaried position I think I'd be quite happy getting paid by the week, especially if my actual salary were set on a weekly basis so I always got the same amount.
- Grustaf 5y agoI don't know if those are the historical reasons, but I'd say the main reason now is that it simplifies book keeping. Just like even the most solvent companies don't pay their purchases right away, you pay on invoice and batch things.
- pjc50 5y agoWeekly feels about right, but as you say: what reason is there for the lower bound? We have high frequency trading, why not high frequency wages? I'm reminded of the minimum wage machine paying out one US penny every five seconds: https://www.blakefallconroy.com/minimum-wage-machine.html https://www.blakefallconroy.com/minimum-wage-machine.html (The minimum granularity is probably that of your timesheet or timeclock, and then we get into how oppressive the surveillance involved in policing that can be, bathroom breaks, screen-watching software, etc.)
- magicalhippo 5y agoI get paid middle of month, which is a nice compromise from the "work delivered" vs "paying up front" perspective. Given that I have a rather fixed income, I don't see why I'd need any higher frequency than that. It wouldn't change anything. If I had a highly variable income I could see weekly making sense, though it would be a bit of a mess in months with a lot of red days.
- fumblebee 5y agoRevolut just launched the same feature this week [1] [1] https://www.revolut.com/payday https://www.revolut.com/payday
- mytailorisrich 5y ago> In a world of free instant automatic electronic payments, there's no good reason to delay salary payments until the end of the month. Salaries are usually paid in arrear simply because employers want you to deliver the work first then get paid. When you call a plumber do you prefer to pay upfront or only after he has fixed the leak? Then, of course the number of payments adds accounting overhead for everyone, so monthly in arrear seems like a good compromise.
- Cthulhu_ 5y agoWhile I agree that it's a good innovation, it's fighting the symptoms of low wages and high cost; people living paycheck to paycheck. Wages should go up and cost of living should go down; people should be entitled to having financial reserves, to not be afraid of not making it to payday.
- NicoJuicy 5y agoPeople mostly don't live paycheck to paycheck in Europe. In Belgium, we're record savings holders. I thought that was more in the US.
- benhurmarcel 5y agoA lot of companies already offer that service, you just request it to HR.