11 ms·
> Because crypto transactions, which are recorded on the blockchain, are untraceable by governments and other central authorities like banks Erm, no, that's no
by ekianjo 5y ago
> Because crypto transactions, which are recorded on the blockchain, are untraceable by governments and other central authorities like banks
Erm, no, that's not how the blockchain transactions work. you can see everything. It's an open ledger.
- IncRnd 5y agoWhat people really mean in these cases is redacted not untraceable.
- rtkwe 5y agoThey can't be easily traced to a particular person is what they mean. Detached from names it's largely meaningless like an encrypted chat, technically the data's all there but it needs other data to be usefully tracked.
- ekianjo 5y ago> They can't be easily traced to a particular person is what they mean Exchanges typically ask for an ID in most countries these day before you can purchase any crypto. I'd be curious how you avoid detection unless you started very early in crypto by mining on your own. You'd still need an ID to exchange back to fiat anyway.
- omginternets 5y agoIt's way easier to correlate activity to a particular person with a blockchain than with traditional banking. There are no administrative hoops to getting access to transaction data.
- rtkwe 5y agoThat assumes it's gone through some deanonymizing transaction like with someone who does know your customer compliance. Tumblers still work right?
- acdha 5y agoMaybe: even assuming that the one you use isn’t run by the FBI, compromised, or sloppy with their security, it’s still easy to block transactions which trace back to one and that both lowers the value of those coins and increases the risk of using them. Some people will say they aren’t doing anything big enough to warrant attention but that’s forgetting that everyone using a tumbler is paying extra to help anonymous strangers launder money. If anyone involved attracts attention it’ll bring scrutiny to everyone else, and potentially the need to prove that you were “just” committing a small-scale crime and didn’t know that most of the other coins being tumbled belonged to a cartel.
- dvt 5y ago> Tumblers still work right? Anything you tumble, you can (provably) de-tumble. It's just expensive and time-consuming (re-building the blockchain state, yadda yadda). Crypto banking is less anonymous than actual banking, especially if you actually want to pull your money into fiat and need to go through an exchange.
- teh_infallible 5y agoBitcoin Cash has CashFusion, which does not rely on a central server, and since transactions are less than a cent, you can shuffle your coins as much as you want. https://cashfusion.org/ https://cashfusion.org/
- 3np 5y agoDo you know how/if CF differs from JoinMarket (both are two-sided CoinJoin implementations, on two different chains) One-sided JM for BTC include Wasabi and Samourai Whirlpool. Though Samourai are a bit sketch IMO.
- tylersmith 5y agoIts anonymity set is basically non-existant, so no real amount of funds can be obfuscated with CashFusion.
- godelski 5y agoThis is exactly the potential danger of countries creating their own digital currency. If they aren't privacy coins then said government has a ledger of every single transaction that its citizens have made. And in that case the gov will know what IDs correspond to which names. Of course if the country adopts a privacy coin this would in turn be a great win for privacy. Of course there's still the danger of if we can ensure that privacy and ensure that it stays that way. So this is something many need to consider during discussions about the FedCoin and Digital Yuan. The "crypto" in "cryptocurrency" isn't necessarily the same "crypto" as we understand in privacy. E.g. Bank transactions are cryptographically secure, but not private.
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoIt can almost always be easily traced to a particular person. if you're using it, you probably bought it from somewhere and spent it somewhere. Mixers/coinjoins can launder it but it is risk-prone and time-consuming, and a redflag.
- stef25 5y ago> It can almost always be easily traced to a particular person Once KYC gets involved. If I receive coins in my desktop wallet for the cookies I'm selling, how will anyone know who I am? Of course they're not much use until I cash out and then it's a different story.
- sennight 5y ago> Of course they're not much use until I cash out... Or you could use the currency as a currency. Sure, there are a lot more flour suppliers who exclusively accept USD vs ones that take BTC - but compared to the way things were 10 years ago...
- xorcist 5y ago"Cashing out" doesn't necessarily mean dollars. Try to buy a Tesla or a house anonymously. All large transactions are subject to KYC.
- sennight 5y agoIt sounds like your definition of "cashing out" means "do anything that has historically involved counterparty risk". Unless you really think a warehouse manager would insist on carding you for several pallets of dishwashing detergent...
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoI tried to pay BTC for a very small electronics purchase recently and the payment processor BitPay literally demanded passport information
- ajkdhcb2 5y agoGenerally true, although there is the exception of Monero
- matheusmoreira 5y agoMonero blockchain lets you see nothing. The only way to track you is via centralized exchanges which are essentially banks anyway. If XMR is used as currency directly, the government is screwed. Last time the US tried to sanction a Monero address, it ended up sanctioning a transaction.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- woodruffw 5y agoYou mean other than the decoy selection vulnerability that could be used to unmask transactions as recently as last month, right[1]? I would take most cryptocurrency outfits’ claims of anonymity with an appropriately sized hunk of salt. [1]: https://github.com/monero-project/monero/issues/7807 https://github.com/monero-project/monero/issues/7807
- flipperto 5y agoThat is not correct, the vulnerability you are talking about is barely a vulnerability. It did not unmask transactions in the sense that no sender, recipient or amount (which are the properties that are hidden in the monero blockchain) was revealed. The issue only arises in some very specific scenarios, and the only information leaked is that you are more likely to be the one making the transaction (as monero hides the sender by using "decoys") in the case were you receive and spend a transaction in a very short span of time. While bold cryptographic claims should be taken with responsibility, monero is researched and implemented by well known criptographers and researchers in a very serious way. Almost all (if not all) aspects of the protocol come directly from proven and well understood theory and published research.