8 ms·
Reversing ocean acidification with aggressive CO2 removal will take 700+ years (2015)
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- macawfish 5y agoI'm assuming this article is referring to removal of CO2 from the atmosphere and not directly from the ocean itself? There have been proposals to remove dissolved CO2 directly from the ocean by turning it into calcium carbonate: https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/combat-climate-change-researchers-want-to-pull-carbon-dioxide-from-ocean-and-turn-it-into-rock-180977903/ https://www.smithsonianmag.com/innovation/combat-climate-cha...
- frazbin 5y agoYeah I wondered the same thing. I suspect that it has a part to play at least. There are a lot (LOT) of pretty pure magnesium/iron silicate minerals in the crust (olivine) that can be ground up and reacted with co2 dissolved in seawater to give magnesium/iron carbonate. Check these folks out: https://www.projectvesta.org/ https://www.projectvesta.org/
- nomel 5y agoOff topic, but that page makes me dizzy.
- foerbert 5y agoYes that seems to be the case, but I'm not sure that actually matters here. The timescales involved mean that there is plenty of time for carbon to move between air and water. The only factor of much importance here would be the overall amount of CO2 removed. There might be some small time savings removing it directly from the ocean, but at 700 years out even 25 gigatons a year of carbon removal was insufficient. Given that kind of time scale, a few years earlier or later wouldn't matter.
- pigeonhole123 5y agoIt used to be more energy efficient to take dissolved CO2 out of water instead of air. Not sure whether or not that’s still true.
- revscat 5y ago> I’m assuming Literally the first two sentences of TFA address this.
- macawfish 5y agoI actually did see the word "atmosphere" in there before I wrote this, believe it or not. But my confusion still stands and is "does this change if the CO2 is extracted directly from the ocean?" I think the article could be much more explicit in this regard... It seems like this study is specifically about the time it will take to for CO2 dissolved in the ocean to evaporate out into an atmosphere which has had CO2 removed, but I can't tell because of how it's worded. I will go look for the original study.
- specialist 5y agoNeat. Great share, thanks. FWIW, that's a reprint of this OC [0]: https://www.hakaimagazine.com/news/petrifying-climate-change/ https://www.hakaimagazine.com/news/petrifying-climate-change... [2021/06/03] TLDR: Uses electrolysis to extract calcium and magnesium from ocean water, which can then be used to extract carbon from atmosphere. Happy by product is hydrogen. Question: This is similar to the desalination systems, right? Can future infrastructure do both? One plausible scenario is to have off shore wind and solar farms powering these devices. Drop the limestone into the ocean. Pipe fresh (treated) water back to shore. Bottle up the H2 for collection. What could be easier? [0] It KILLS ME when articles omit meta data like timestamps, bylines, links to legislation being discussed, etc.
- Proven 5y agoThat's why I'd never give 1 cent to this cause
- silisili 5y agoI wish most crises weren't so defeatist. It's a fine line because, you need people to know it's a real problem. But framing it this way makes people say 'whats the point.' 700 years is an eternity, given our lifespans. Put another way, I think it's immensely more useful to frame it in a way humans better relate with. In 20 years, we can do what? It also completely removes the innovation that humans can achieve. Reminds me of the NY Times saying in 1903 that humans wouldn't fly for at least 1 million years. Glad the Wright brothers and others weren't listening.
- foerbert 5y agoHow, exactly, is this defeatist? It's defining the size of the problem. If we don't know what's actually needed to solve the problem, how are we supposed to ever solve it? I'm also rather unsure what innovation you're imagining here. It's literally a model of ocean acidity based on some tons/year of carbon sequestration. Innovation can make this cheaper, but the model isn't about cost.
- silisili 5y agoThe size of the problem is known, sure. But the framing is bad. Tell us what we can do to help, in realistic timespans, and where that gets us. If the answer today is 'nothing', then what would ever get people to care? As for carbon sequestration, I'm not learned enough on the subject to even guess what's possible, or if the idea of doing it faster is feasible from a scientific standpoint. Is the moral of the story that we must do carbon capture better, or that we're all screwed?
- revscat 5y agoThe article is reporting upon a scientific study. It is up to you to decide what that means, not them. If you choose to act on it by complaining about tone then that is your problem, not theirs. Perhaps instead you yourself should do something, something more productive than complaining about word choices and/or tone, neither of which are helpful in the slightest.
- zetalyrae 5y agoPDF: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282535729_Long-term_response_of_oceans_to_CO2_removal_from_the_atmosphere https://www.researchgate.net/publication/282535729_Long-term... EDIT: Perhaps should add (2015) to the title, although this result may still be current.
- anigbrowl 5y agoI completely missed that, sorry. I wouldn't have posted it had I noticed it wasn't current.
- dredmorbius 5y agoOlder content is fine and welcomed, though it's preferred to note the year if > 6 months old. Mods can edit that if you've missed it.
- chmaynard 5y ago"The Lord will by no means leave the guilty unpunished, visiting the iniquity of fathers on the children and on the grandchildren to the third and fourth generations." –Exodus
- elil17 5y agoAlternate framing: we can return Earths oceans to their natural state within 25 generations, and in a much shorter time if we stop emissions now.
- lazyjones 5y agoThe ocean's "natural state"? What is their natural state, when we look at the past 4 billion years or so? We know of several extinction events in the oceans tens of millions of years ago, the oceans always recovered without any (known to me anyway) fixed pH value.
- Johnny555 5y agoI'd say the natural state we should aspire to return the environment to is prior to the industrial revolution when we really started messing up the atmospheric CO2 levels. There may be long term climate changes that man is not part of, but those are negligible across the past 150 years or so.
- j-pb 5y agoProtecting the environment is short for "protecting the encironment that humans evolved to live in". It's easy to say "look it's just another extinction event" when you're forgetting that you're the one getting extinct.
- m0llusk 5y agoEarly farming practices were associated with increases in topsoil while current mechanized farming practices are associated with decreases in topsoil. Which practices do you think are more likely to serve mankind well over long periods?
- j-pb 5y agoMechanised early farming, a.k.a. robot swarms that can negate the overhead involved in tending to microplots with 2m*2m squares of one particular crop, and three field cycles. But what does that have to do with my statement?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- wait_a_minute 5y agoThis means this is ripe for innovation that is an order of magnitude improvement. Which means there’s significant startup profit to be made from innovating and bringing this down to 70 years.
- ncmncm 5y agoThis appears to assume that the only way to get the carbonic acid out of the oceans is to wait for it to diffuse out to a CO2-depleted atmosphere. But that's nonsense. Powdering olivine and broadcasting that to the oceans would work overwhelmingly faster, and end up pulling CO2 out of the atmosphere, too. Powdering iron and broadcasting that in the deep ocean would put microbes to work doing the same thing. There is no reason not to do both, not necessarily in the same places. There are certainly other clever avenues I don't know about yet. Just putting iron compounds at micromolar concentration in jet fuel used on trans-oceanic flights, so the exhaust dust settles to the ocean, would automate a huge iron distribution network at practically no cost. Similarly, for bunker fuel burned in ships. Probably this or that idea would turn out not to work as well as hoped. You just try something else, then. Wringing your hands and doing nothing is the worst of all alternatives. We already tried that, it already failed.
- Teever 5y ago> There is no reason not to do both Unintended consequences. The thing proponents of megascale geoengineering projects are the unintended consequences. Which is baffling to me considering that the entire issue that we've gotten ourselves into with the industrial revolution is about the unintended consequences of burning fuel and releasing the CO2 into the atmosphere.
- dannyobrien 5y agoDoesn't that mean we're facing unintended consequences whether we do something or we don't? (I'm not saying that this has to be the solution -- after all, there may be some consequences we determine beforehand that put it out of the running. But worrying about the dangers of a megascale geoengineering project just because it is a megascale geoengineering project, would seem to require our current path to be a known status quo, rather than just another megascale geoengineering project.)
- Teever 5y agoIt's not just that it's a megascale project, it's that it's a potentially unstoppable megascale project. Starting a potentially unstoppable chemical chain reaction to stop another unstoppable chemical chain reaction just seems a bit... dumb to me, you know? If we're going to be doing megascale engineering to mitigate our past mistakes with greenhouse gasses we should look towards using something like space-based lenses or mirrors to lower the amount of energy that the Earth receives. We can always turn them off if we decide that we want to.
- YossarianFrPrez 5y agoI have three competing reactions to this news. The first is something much more extreme than "yikes!" The second is that this news -- as other commenters have noted -- means that there will be plenty of startup opportunities related to climate change. We are already seeing the initial phases of revolutions in food, power, and transportation technologies. Just today I discovered a startup building a radically more efficient small airplane. [https://www.ottoaviation.com https://www.ottoaviation.com] The 700+ years number will likely fall, and the question is by how much. But the technological solutions will only get us so far, which brings me to the third thing: 35 generations seems daunting. Especially because urgent problems usually go hand in hand with fixes that get applied quickly. Climate change however is an urgent problem with long-term implications and long-term solutions. At the same time, the culture(s) of Aboriginal Australian and Torres Straight Islander people the oldest continuous cultures are estimated to be ~ 200 - 250 generations old. In other words, though 35 generations is formidable, it is not unheard of -- certain spas and hotels in Japan have been operating for longer than that. And perhaps we should somehow set a target for ten generations, and see how much progress we can make in that time.
- alexose 5y agoI doubt I'll be able to make much meaningful progress on CO2 removal during my lifetime, but I'm going to try my best. My hope is that on my deathbed, Earth will at least be trending in the right direction.
- xyzzy21 5y agoSounds about right. The time-constants of climate are extremely long. The whole "we must change by 2030 or we all die" meme is summarily stupid in context of the REALITY of these time-constants. How did anyone not know this? Especially if they are so serious and knowledgeable about "climate change". Well, when it's actually religion and ideology rather than science, that's usually what happens.
- qeternity 5y agoWe altered the environment pretty radically in 150 years without trying. How does that reconcile with your time-constants?
- kortilla 5y agoDoesn’t sound “aggressive” all. Sounds like an incredibly defeatist “wait” approach instead. Doomers love these articles though so I suppose that’s why this is taken at face value.m
- qeternity 5y ago> They imagined two scenarios – one where five gigatonnes of carbon is removed every year, which is equivalent to around half of our total annual emissions, and another where 25 gigatonnes of carbon is removed. What?!? 5gt is roughly 15% of annual emissions…
- rataata_jr 5y agoGrow more plants in the ocean? Restore corals? If you remove all the CO2, how will the plants survive? Do we know the balance? Why is CO2 vilified so much?
- Dylan16807 5y ago> Grow more plants in the ocean? That would help, but is a bit risky. > Restore corals? A good goal, but probably too tiny to matter much. > If you remove all the CO2, how will the plants survive? Nobody wants to remove "all the CO2". > Do we know the balance? Not in exact detail, but getting closer to 1900 levels would be good. > Why is CO2 vilified so much? Seriously? You ask this in 2021? Because it changes the weather and those rapid changes cause extinctions and habitability problems. Including killing corals.
- AnimalMuppet 5y agoDumb (probably) question: Do phytoplankton in the ocean consume CO2 in the same way that land plants do? If so, does the increased dissolved CO2 cause them to grow faster?
- uCantCauseUCant 5y agoTo just slow down ocean accidification, what is really needed is behavioural change - on the consumer level, incited by government and the production nobility. And that behaviour has to be very non-protestant - sit at home all day and watch tv and play. Electronic media is by far the best thing that can happen to the planet. Instead of consuming infinite ressources, all the evil upstart monkeys did, was stare at a coloured lights hypnotized all day.
- pfdietz 5y agoSimply adding finely powdered limestone to the ocean will help buffer CO2, increasing pH. Many gigatonnes of limestone would be needed, but there is an enormous amount available.