20 ms·
How to bypass Sprint/T-Mobile 2FA in under 5 minutes
- mikece 5y agoWhile I never want to see companies suffer data breaches and breakdowns in security, it's possible that the merging of Sprint and T-Mobile's subscriber base and systems might be the kind of cautionary tale told to management in the future to justify more spending on security budgets, especially around the merging of systems.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoNah. As long as costs are negligible and there's no corporate death sentence for repeat offenders (T-Mobile has had 5 breaches in roughly the same number of years), nothing changes. Equifax is still around, right [1]? [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Equifax_data_breach https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2017_Equifax_data_breach
- robohoe 5y agoProblem with security spending is that a lot of it comes down to useless audits which really don't find any holes - they just "enforce" compliance. Yes, PCI compliance is important but how many PCI compliant companies have been breached in the past decade?
- exabrial 5y agoSMS as a second factor needs to be illegal. Apple, Twilio, and a myriad of other companies cling to it like it's safe when it's not.
- toomuchtodo 5y agoDigital identity, digital identity, digital identity. Until digital identity is a first class citizen in the United States (with support through the various layers of gov from local to federal), private enterprise will continue to lean on suboptimal identity systems (SMS, pictures of government photo ID for proofing a la ID.me and Stripe Identity). https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28203374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28203374 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28194815 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=28194815 https://www.gsa.gov/blog/2021/02/18/logingov-to-provide-authentication-and-identity-proofing-services-to-a-limited-number-of-federally-funded-state-and-local-government-programs https://www.gsa.gov/blog/2021/02/18/logingov-to-provide-auth... https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/8215/text?r=20&s=1 https://www.congress.gov/bill/116th-congress/house-bill/8215... https://billhunt.dev/blog/2020/12/18/federal-policy-recs/#4-solve-identity-once-and-for-all https://billhunt.dev/blog/2020/12/18/federal-policy-recs/#4-...
- kube-system 5y agoI'd be surprised if it happened any time in the next quarter-century. RealID was passed in 2005 and it's not even fully implemented yet, and only about 1/3 of Americans have one. Even if the Feds launched a digital ID, consumer services aren't going to hop on the bandwagon immediately; most people in the US don't have a need for a federal ID, and millions of them don't have any ID at all. Private enterprise is leaning on weak identity because they want more customers with little friction. There's nothing stopping private industry from issuing cryptographic tokens or similar, and many already do. The problem with selling anything to the general public is that you will a very high number of customers who will lose every token you give them, forget every password, and won't be able to produce good proof of ID.
- toomuchtodo 5y ago> The problem with selling anything to the general public is that you will a very high number of customers who will lose every token you give them, forget every password, and won't be able to produce good proof of ID. The US Postal Service (USPS) has successfully piloted a service to check people’s identity in-person at both USPS locations and at people’s homes using their existing portable tablets used for mail delivery [1]. I'd agree that it's uphill, but it (competent digital identity implementation) is necessary for the reliable functioning of government and commerce in the twenty first century. Otherwise, SIM swaps, identity fraud, and similar will continue to be a (costly) thing. iOS 15 is rolling out digital IDs in Wallet. I'm excited to see if this enabled a faster deployment with solid primitives. [1] https://gcn.com/articles/2013/01/28/usps-pilot-cloud-federal-id-credential-hub.aspx?sc_lang=en https://gcn.com/articles/2013/01/28/usps-pilot-cloud-federal...
- kube-system 5y agoThe descendent of that 2013 pilot is today's login.gov, which is not really the kind of 'digital identity' that solves the problems at hand here. It's basically just SSO for government systems and has many of the same security concerns as other SSO systems. Login.gov passwords can be reset by email.
- jandrese 5y agoSMS isn't about security. It's about making it harder for bots to set up accounts. The first thing you should do after SMS verifying an account is delete the phone number so it doesn't leave a back door open.
- mycall 5y agoThen why do many try to force you to enable SMS even though you are a well known customer? Sometimes it is a soft-force and a few URL changes until you bypass the request.
- rexf 5y agoIt does not need to be illegal. It's not ideal 2FA, but it does not need to be legislated away. Apple has a second factor system where you can authorize a new device using another Apple device. While this is convenient, not everybody has 2 Apple devices (for each Apple login). Worse, they use a dark pattern to make enabling this (other device auth) the default choice, so it's really easy to setup when you update your iPhone.
- dheera 5y agoI firmly want it to be legislated away, but for a slightly different reason. Specifically, you should never be required to disclose a phone number to a business that doesn't absolutely need your phone number to directly render services. I was eating at a restaurant once -- IN PERSON -- and the fucking web interface they force everyone to use to order food wanted a SMS 2FA. WTF? No. I don't require your waitress to disclose her phone number to order food. And in return, you don't ask for mine. Just take my food order, swipe my credit card, and bring the food to the table, there is no need to disclose a phone number. I think the ideal law should be: Any business that wants 2FA MUST support at least U2F hardware keys. It's okay to also offer SMS but not okay to offer only SMS.
- flatiron 5y agoAt least at the AppleCare call center it’s called “itsme” and it’s a push message. Sadly only works on iOS or macOS
- rsync 5y ago"Apple, Twilio, and a myriad of other companies cling to it like it's safe when it's not ..." You're missing the point. Twilio and Apple (et. al) are not using 2FA for you. It's not to protect you or to help you. They are faced with a brutal and unceasing spam/scam/puppet onslaught. Forcing you to burn a physical SIM identity to create and maintain an account is just a blunt mechanism to slow this process down. It is a way of attaching some costs to creating a (Twilio/Apple) account. They're not doing it for you.
- exabrial 5y agoIndeed, you're correct. It's passing the buck of KYC, with an inevitable credit check to another company.
- anigbrowl 5y agoWell, how would you attack fraudsters instead
- rsync 5y agoI would give them a challenge/response to post in their HN user page and restrict it to accounts >4 years old and >500 karma. Well, you asked ...
- ianmiers 5y agoPartially, but it's also: you will pay for a phone number, you won't pay for icloud, etc. So, as a result a phone number is costs something like 10 cents for an attacker.
- UncleMeat 5y agoPhishing remains a way more common threat than sim swapping, yet you never see these complaints about TOTP. Sim swapping is just sexy and eats up conversation space.
- frankosaurus 5y agoI recently set up yubikey 2FA for several of my important accounts. I was dismayed to find that several of them (Vanguard, BofA, etc.) require SMS security codes as a backup.
- staticassertion 5y agoVanguard also has traditional security questions too. So shit like "where were you born?".
- bcraven 5y agoRemember that your answer to that need not necessarily be accurate. You can invent a 'security city' perhaps and always give that... or just give a randomly generated password that you store alongside in your password locker.
- OJFord 5y agoAnd if you use a long pseudo-randomly generating string, you will amuse support (and annoy yourself) when you have to read it all out... (Switched to correct-horse-battery-staple style for those after that.)
- InitialLastName 5y agoSupport Operator: We need to answer some security questions. To start with, what was your mother's maiden name? Scammer: "Oh, I just entered a long stream of random digits, but I can't find where I wrote it down" Operator: "Good enough. How large a credit line did you say you wanted?"
- OJFord 5y agoWhat happened in my case (password reset for the online account for a credit card) was rather: Operator: ... (Real) me: Err.. all of it? [hoping p,q,r-th characters will be enough] Operator: Yes please.
- scottmcdot 5y agoWhat use is a PUK for sim swapping? Sorry, am I missing something here? What would be the next step after knowing the PUK of a mobile phone number?
- walrus01 5y agoIf you know the PUK you can easily port out the number or obtain a new SIM card with the number and put it in your own burner phone.
- scottmcdot 5y agoThanks. But to "easily port out the new number", how is that done using the PUK?
- OJFord 5y agoIt's exactly (afaik?) what it's for - you want to transfer your number to a different network, you have to request the PUK from the old one and give it to the new one. So if I know yours (and your number) I can transfer it to a different network, registered to an account in my control.
- scottmcdot 5y agoI see. I've changed carriers before but this is something they've managed. Maybe it's different in Australia.
- snuxoll 5y agoPUK is Pin Unlocking Key - it's a burned-in passcode on your sim card that can be used to unlock it should you enter your pin incorrectly too many times.
- dataflow 5y agoI thought PUK was for (un)locking the SIM to manage its usability, not for porting a number out of a carrier? Never heard of them being related before... I thought they're different things entirely?
- sentrysapper 5y agoSo while Sprint and T-Mo are culpable in this poor training, I feel bad for the tech support agent. She clearly just wanted to help this person out.
- kube-system 5y agoThat's precisely the human flaw that most social engineering relies on.
- hda111 5y agoThey didn’t want to lose their job. Most support chats want you to rate the person. This is the real issue.
- walrus01 5y agoThis is why SMS-based "2FA" is not real 2FA. Anything vulnerable to social engineering customer service reps at some giant telecom, or faking documents to port out a number (SS7/PSTN are woefully insecure and should not be trusted by anyone), is a huge gaping hole.
- neither_color 5y agoThis is the text I got from T-Mobile: T-Mobile has determined that unauthorized access to some of your information, or others on your account, has occurred, like name, address, phone number and DOB. Importantly, we have NO information that indicates your SSN, personal financial or payment information, credit/debit card information, account numbers, or account passwords were accessed. We take the protection of our customers seriously. Learn more about practices that keep your account secure and general recommendations for protecting yourself: t-mo.co/Protect It's such a shit feeling knowing my name and info are out there and that it's only a matter of time before they make attempts on my accounts or identity, I'm one of tens of millions and can only hope that I'm far down the list. I'm usually pretty good with online security, I don't even reuse usernames or emails to sign up for different services, use 2fa for anything important, use containerized tabs for social websites, use VPNs on non-familiar site so some random guy's blog doesn't have my IP, etc... and there goes my cell phone provider fucking things up for me anyways. I don't even know if this is actionable info, should I even bother? Should I get a new number and replace my number at all services that use this number?
- MeinBlutIstBlau 5y agoThe only time it's actionable is if you inquire damages honestly. And even then it's an uphill battle cause you'll have to prove it was because of the leak and not something else.
- acomjean 5y agoLamentably, we're at the point where your information is likely out there. It is a shitty feeling, being the victim. I got the email from my employeer this year that my application for unemployment was reject because I'm still working (I didn't apply). I had an tax check stolen and attempted to cash.. (the bank stopped that one.. Dominican Republic bank cashed that one..), IBM backup tapes with maybe my personal information went missing.. A friend who is supper vigilant had someone apply for a credit card with his credentials.. The card company sent him a letter asking if he had moved.. The card was approved and ready to go. Its sad, but you have to stay vigilant. I don't know if its worth getting a new cell number. It is kinda your identity now.
- FabHK 5y agoApart from SMS as a second factor, what's this with "What number would you like me to send this [code] to?", where clearly an attacker could give an arbitrary burner number under their control. They should only use numbers already associated with the account, and adding/changing one should by itself require authentication. Oh well.
- chrischen 5y agoThey send it to a number on the account.
- FabHK 5y agoSo the question is in case there are multiple numbers associated with the account?
- lotsofpulp 5y agoIt is common to be part of a family plan in the US. The person in the example must have been in one to have been offered that option. Family plans are much cheaper per phone number than individual plans.
- dylan604 5y agoDepends on the account type. I have had Microsoft and other systems ask me to send a code to a phone number. It wasn't specific, so I asked my co-worker if, for science, I could send the code to their phone. It worked.
- parhamn 5y agoAm I the only one that'd rather we fix the vulnerabilities with SMS verification instead of killing it? The cross platform password manager + OTP (and sidecaring OTP with your passwords is sketchy to begin with) UX is just terrible. Adoption is very important for this stuff and SMS does that best.
- seniorivn 5y agoFido2 hardware 2fa keys are the right solution as to solving sms 2fa security, it's flawed by design, even if it was e2ee
- ghayes 5y agoNot sure why you’ve been downvoted. I generally agree that it’s easy to bypass with a MITM. Obviously that’s a big step up from non-2FA, but it means unauthorized access will still be frequent.
- slg 5y agoSecurity and convenience are usually in direct competition with each other. Customer service people have to listen to people yell at them when convenience is sacrificed and aren't held accountable for security problems. They therefore optimize for customer convenience. I don't completely fault them for it. If anyone has had the frustration of sitting on the phone with a customer service rep trying to remember a PIN code that was setup 5 years ago when signing up with an ISP and was never thought about since, you can probably understand it. It is easy to blame a single person or a single company for poor practices, but I have yet to encounter any real solution to this problem that allows someone to prove they are who they say they are which is able to hit the sweet spot between too many false positives (hijacked accounts) and too many false negatives (valid customers locked out). If I was a security-minded person looking for startup ideas, this is the problem I would be looking to solve.
- lrvick 5y agoWe already have a solution: WebAuthn. Almost every phone and laptop today supports it, and you can optionally have a backup in the form of a $10 keychain device or 24 words written on paper. This does mean people will be best off to keep at least one backup safe with other things they can't afford to lose like their SSN card and drivers license. Once WebAuthn is setup then day to day as long as a person has not lost -all- their devices, then remote identity verification can be fast tracked. If they have lost all their devices it would be like if they lost all citizenship paperwork and will be a longer, generally in person, process involving reference verification and a waiting period.
- haukem 5y agoWhy are only very few services supporting WebAuthn? Google and github supprot WebAuthn, but most services only support OATH-TOTP, OATH-HOTP or even worse only their own app.
- dheera 5y agoIf something doesn't support Web'n'Auth you can use TOTP with a Yubikey, the TOTP moves with the key, much better than those dumb authenticator possibly-spyware apps.
- knodi 5y agoFucking idiots!! This is negligence.
- paulpauper 5y agotmobile + gmail + crypto accounts = someone about to lose crypto
- raldi 5y agoWhy does the customer-service system even reveal the sensitive info before the agent inputs the code? It could be sent out-of-loop so it wouldn't even be possible for them to bypass. Related question: What should happen to a customer who legitimately encounters this problem?
- post_break 5y agoWe should have the option to require sim swaps only be done at a physical store with state issued ID. But that will never happen.
- naturalauction 5y agoA few years ago many of the captchas on t-mobile’s site had a massive security flaw (no idea if this is still the case). You could request the captcha image multiple times (using the image url) and each time the captcha would be differently generated on demand while still having the same letters/numbers. This meant you could just request the captcha a few times, put each image through an ocr reader, and see what the captcha was most commonly read as (the correct answer almost every time). I was astonished to find that a multi-billion dollar company had such a massive flaw in their captcha system. That being said these kind of errors are really far too common.
- dathinab 5y agoWhat I don't understand is why the service person can see the PUK (1). There are just way too many ways this can go wrong. (1): Rhetorically, most likely because when their service system was developed this wasn't a concern and since then they never re-evaluated this part for security (or did and didn't care to change it).
- YetAnotherNick 5y agoHas anyone convincingly demonstrated actual being able to read message of someone else through any means? I keep reading many theoretical attacks ranging from weak encryption to social hacking to identity spoofing to cloning. This demonstration was when you have physical access to locked SIM, which means that SIM locking is not effective but having a physical SIM is still required.
- apazzolini 5y agoCheck out this recent episode of Darknet Diaries: https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/97/ https://darknetdiaries.com/episode/97/
- ineedasername 5y agoNot just a 2FA bypass, it bypasses all of the FA's. Then again, somehow losing all 2FA methods is my nightmare reason for being hesitant to turn on 2FA for my Google account because their customer service is so completely awful. Like if my house burned down with my keys, phone, and previously authenticated PC stuck inside. I know, extremely unlikely, but without customer service that is willing to verify my identity without relying on an automated/AI algorithm, I feel safer with a strong unique password along with the other account recovery options. Am I being unreasonable and missing some method of last resort with Google's 2FA?
- filoleg 5y agoI switched away from Google Authenticator app to Microsoft Authenticator app for that reason (it is a generic 2FA, so you can use it as a 2FA for google logins and any other services just fine). One important difference is that Microsoft Authenticator supports recovery from iCloud (in cause you are on iOS; there is probably something similar for Android too), which is something that Google Authenticator does not. So in case my phone explodes, the only thing i need to recover all my 2FA stuff is a recovery key for iCloud (which i can print out and put in a few places, like a bank storage cell and my parents’ house), because my Apple stuff is behind 2FA as well. So essentially, i just pick up my recovery code, buy a new iphone, authenticate using the recovery code, it restores all my data from iCloud backup, and my Microsoft Authenticator app has all my 2FAs for all services i use it for there. It is a fairly recent feature for Microsoft Authenticator on iOS iirc, they added it less than a year ago. A few other 2FA apps, like Authy, support that type of 2FA recovery too (and Authy specifically had that feature for much longer).
- physicles 5y agoI was also using Google Authenticator before I bought a new iPhone a few years ago, when I noticed to my surprise that those 2FA codes were the only thing that didn't automatically populate on my new phone. I immediately switched to Authy. In my threat model, losing my phone is at least 1,000x more likely than the targeted attack it would take to compromise both auth factors for my most important accounts. Besides, as others pointed out in another similar thread: after SMS hijacking and social engineering, the next weakest link is cookie theft.
- derekdahmer 5y agoThis happened to me. My T-Mobile number was ported to a hacker and they used it to get control of my GMail account. They then tried to use that to get at my Coinbase account. Luckily I had device 2FA enabled on that account so when they realized they couldn’t get in they gave up. Meanwhile though my Google account which has everything was inaccessible to me. Getting back control of your gmail when all your 2FA and device codes have been reset is very difficult. I had to call in a favor with a friend who worked there. I use true 2FA on all my accounts now. One thing you can do is call T-Mobile and setup a pass phrase. Phone based customer service won’t do anything for you until you give them that pass phrase.
- kylehotchkiss 5y agoGoogle Advanced protection would lock down your account to only allow physical 2FA (like a Yubikey or their titan keys) and completely disable even the option of SMS or authenticator app like codes.
- pilif 5y agoKnowing about this fact I wonder why so many sites still allow SMS based 2FA and, even worse, sometimes accept just SMS codes as a proof for the password reset workflow. The incentives are all wrong: Telco support people are incentivized to handle as many calls in as little time as possible and to be as helpful to customers as possible. In 99% of calls, being "difficult" about this will cause customers with legitimate issues to be angry and will cause the ticket to stay open for much longer than what's necessary, so I totally understand where they are coming from. I wish my Telco had an option where I could set a flag to never help me with account recovery at the promise of in return never getting angry at them for not helping me. Then "we can't help you" is the quickest way to solve such a ticket for them and it's also the safest for me. Honestly, if I ever lose access to my phone account, I'd rather get a new number than have some helpful person hand over the keys to umpteen accounts I have on the internet which I can't secure adequately because of braindead policies at those accounts.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Ansil849 5y agoMy understanding is that the PUK is used to unlock a SIM that has become locked if too many incorrect SIM PINs were entered. The advantage of the attacker having a PUK is therefore that they could then physically put the SIM into their own phone, or use the SIM in the target's phone (if they have their phone PIN as well as the PUK). This of course means that they need to have physical possession of the target's SIM, and that the target needs to be unaware that their SIM has been taken, because as soon as they realize they don't have a SIM they'll obviously contact their carrier. So the adversarial use-case of having a PUK is pretty limited. Which in turn explains why the security in giving it out is comparatively low. I guess I'm not seeing the issue here too much. There are cases of social engineering carriers that are way more damaging.
- schroeding 5y agoThe german carrier Telekom allows you to take posession (add it to your customer account as a "contract owner") of a phone number with just the PUK and a one-time code sent to the phone number via SMS. I guess many other carriers use the same system. You're then able to modify the contract and, for example, can get a second sim card. The affected phone number gets a "Welcome to our customer portal" message, but that's that. I actually used this to get access to my own phone number after losing access to the connected mail account. :-D
- Ansil849 5y ago> The german carrier Telekom allows you to take posession (add it to your customer account as a "contract owner") of a phone number with just the PUK and a one-time code sent to the phone number via SMS. I guess many other carriers use the same system. Ah, very interesting. I was unaware of this usage of the PUK. If it's used for account ownership authentication, then absolutely carriers should be treating it way more securely.
- rawoke083600 5y agoLol i recently saw the 2auth for an isp in my country. It works like this. To see/change your banking details they bring back the banking info (api call) and display it on screen, BUT their security is to 'quickly' bring up a modal(js) to 'hide' the sensitive information... of course just modify 'display:none' on modal and you can see everything :s
- schroeding 5y agoYeah, it's way too easy to get information like this from the customer service. A while ago, I wanted to log into my carriers customer portal, but my account was so old that they still had an ancient email address in their system that I didn't have access to anymore. Previously, one could just login via the phone number and a code sent via SMS, but suddenly they required a password that was sent to the mail address. One could also reset the mail adress with the PUK, but I lost that too while moving. :-P Ended up "hacking" my own account, by calling customer support a few times. The first two customer support agents wanted me to click on a link on a mail they sent to my mail adress or to go to a physical store with my ID card, to prove I'm not an attacker, even after I told them my name, address, date of birth, customer ID, bank account number, etc. The third one just gave me the PUK, with no questions attached, after telling him just my name and phone number. :-D
- kylehotchkiss 5y agoUse Google Voice for SMS 2FA. Almost every service I use supports it (except for the ones that ping telecom companies to verify your address) and Google seems for now committed to keeping it alive as they’ve added voice as a service for Google for Business
- edf13 5y agoThe problem is here: >As a infosec professional by trade, I just can’t believe how easy this was. Billion dollar company with absolutely no security awareness passed down to there techs They aren't 'techs' manning the support chats. They are (often outsourced) lower skilled workers that follow a script and routine... if anything falls out of that script they are lost.
- hda111 5y agoIt’s easier for the support to say the PUK than to risk their job because of a 1 star review.
- newbamboo 5y agoThe only solution, and people will hate me for saying it, is to replace cash and bitcoins with fully traceable digital currency. All other solutions posted in this thread won’t work. Every hack, scam and cyber crime pushes us further towards this inevitable destination. As long as there are more honest people to be victimized than there are criminals and haxxors to profit, the world will demand traceable secure money. I’ll get super downvoted but think it through. It’s not a conclusion I came to easily or without deep lament.