30 ms·
Ten Years of Bootstrap
- autokad 5y agowow what a ride. I discovered bootstrap a bit late, I think August of 2013. It was so nice though, not having to worry about a lot of CSS details and knowing my page looked ok on many devices.
- franciscop 5y agoWait Bootstrap is only 10 years old? I'd have sworn it was 15 years old or so by now. I created Picnic CSS back in 2014 as an alternative to the big and well-established Bootstrap project, if Bootstrap was created in 2011 it means that it became the main front-end project everyone was using in just under 3 years! That's amazing, and congrats on the 10th anniversary!
- alpha_squared 5y agoThe front-end web realm was really eager for some sort of standardized way of doing things. Every project prior to Bootstrap required revisiting styles and starting from scratch or creating an internal Bootstrap-like base that would be used, which meant very little of that would be carried between jobs for employees. This is also probably why the early days of Angular and React were so unstable; mass adoption through different versions which were still finding a stable approach to iterative evolution.
- ianhawes 5y agoYour comment is spot on. Prior to Bootstrap, the concept of a purely CSS framework was relatively foreign. Aside from jQuery UI (which of course required jQuery and had limitations on styling) the closest thing we had in the 2009-2011 period was reset.css and 960.gs. Even rudimentary things like rounded buttons were still impacted by the lack of uniform border-radius support plus an IE6/IE7 marketshare greater than 30%.
- duxup 5y agoYeah the horror show that is learning every rando dev's personal CSS methods could be really painful. When you just want to move a button ... "oh they're using bootstrap" often saved a ton of time, for things that really shouldn't take time.
- testudovictoria 5y ago> Every project prior to Bootstrap required revisiting styles and starting from scratch or creating an internal Bootstrap-like base that would be used I went through several projects where team leads laughed at the idea of Bootstrap in their projects. They treated Bootstrap as a bulky, unnecessary mess of a framework that only inexperienced code monkeys used in spite of it being small and modular. The dumbest one of all was a team lead who turned out to have little to no real world experience in decision making. He had some help creating an internal CSS framework. It was responsive, modular, mobile first, and had lots of builtin classes for font/element sizes, colors, behavior, etc. Sound familiar? His column-based framework was a terrible drop in for Bootstrap. Even the class attributes were blatant rip-offs, but the lack of robustness meant lots of inline CSS to fix elements.
- brundolf 5y agoThe Angular/React model also threw a huge wrench into the Bootstrap way of doing things. The latter relied on a smattering of ad-hoc JS for things like modals and tooltips. It dovetailed nicely with jQuery, but I remember it was wholly incompatible with Angular. There ended up being an "Angular Bootstrap" package specifically designed for that, and I remember it felt like a regression at the time that everything would get siloed under these JS frameworks.
- jrochkind1 5y agoYeah, it got popular quick. I think the bar was low for good design on the web, and they did a really good of making it out of the box seem like "good design". I remember the first time I saw an open source thing was bootstrap based, without knowing what bootstrap was, I immediately asked "wait, what did you use to make it look that good, and how can I use it?" I could guess it was using some third party tool, it was just so much better than typical.
- antidaily 5y agoMaybe you're thinking of Blueprint, which is about 15 years old now.
- gjvc 5y agoI wish they'd kept the original 3D look-and-feel of the 2.3.x series (the one with 3.x looked slightly different) distributed with all the major versions since (as an option).
- duxup 5y agoI work on some products with a variety of bootstrap versions. Some like 2.3.x style look really nice IMO. Style is cyclical.
- caslon 5y agoYou can just theme modern Twitter Bootstrap to have the old 1.1.1 or 2.x aesthetics. It wouldn't take that much effort.
- gjvc 5y agowell-volunteered. Do you have a link?
- moreshadow 5y ago* { background-image: linear-gradient(a big shadow); border-radius: 5 million pixels; box-shadow: 5 million pixels; text-shadow: 5 million pixels; } ...that should get you most of the way
- caslon 5y agoI said you. My CSS frameworks all emulate styles from long before Twitter Bootstrap was a thing, and I've always found every iteration of it to be incredibly ugly. I love writing CSS, you should also. It isn't that hard to emulate just about any style, especially when you're just theming an existing CSS framework like Twitter Bootstrap. In its case, you can get halfway there by just checking what the gradient parameters, border-radius and button sizes were.
- gjvc 5y ago> I love writing CSS, you should also. No I shouldn't.
- zuhayeer 5y ago22% of all websites – what a stat! Incredible what such a small focused team was able to accomplish.
- conradfr 5y agoMust be 80% of intranet / admin tools.
- mindcrime 5y agoSeeing this makes me feel old. Wow... where does the time go? Jumpin' Jehoshaphat. In a similar vein, I only just now started watching Alias, which premiered in 2001. In one of the first season episodes, one of the characters is talking about MEMS[1] and how it's "the next generation's next generation." I was struck by that as I had no idea that MEMS was as old a technology as it is. Seems like everything is getting old so fast here lately. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microelectromechanical_systems https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microelectromechanical_systems
- jbverschoor 5y agotime goes to: recreating every single library in every new language. Not-invented-here syndrome. Reinventing language features. Webpack. Transpilers. 1000 leaky abstraction layers. Undocumented projects. Unresolved bugs. Trying to create applications in a document model. etc etc etc.
- tomphoolery 5y agobut only 8 years of "lol this government website is bootstrap isn't it"
- Trasmatta 5y agoI remember the first time I saw a friend's site made with Bootstrap, around 2011-2012. I was so impressed by his design skills! ...it was about 6 months later I discovered what Bootstrap was, after noticing half the websites I was visiting looked just like his.
- ratww 5y agoI also remember when developers that only knew and used Bootstrap started appearing. A university I worked at had a beautiful internal website, designed by a Design professor there and tested in students using all the famous methodologies. A few months after I left, a couple new developers were hired and decided to nuke the old design and reimplement it all using Bootstrap because they didn't know CSS/JS. It was never the same.
- jonny_eh 5y ago> I also remember when developers that only knew and used Bootstrap started appearing. They're called "new" developers. They don't have the same skillset of "experienced" developers. Luckily, "new" developers become "experienced" over time.
- radicalbyte 5y agoIf your skillset is HTML + CSS then you're not a developer. You're more of a web designer. Or a masochist if you're actually trying to code with it (being turning complete).
- jonny_eh 5y agoIf anything, a software engineer is more likely to reach for a CSS library like Bootstrap instead of designing and implementing their own styles.
- radicalbyte 5y agoThere are plenty of people who call themselves "frontend developers" whose skill set is: HTML, CSS + image editor (photoshop, indesign or whatever the current fad is).
- taesu 5y agoHere is to another great century for bootstrap!
- runawaybottle 5y agoIt’s important to give respect to jqueryui and bootstrap for defining the core ui components for the web all these years.
- throwawaybchr 5y agoI can't seem to get on board with the new hotness like Tailwind and whatever else the cool kids are using these days. I tried tailwind in a couple of projects. The dependency on PurgeCSS seems to cause all kinds of problems - either with the build tools or cause some unexpected bugs because I have the additional responsibilities of keeping track of which classes won't be caught by the parser for whatever reason.
- paul7986 5y agoIs flexbox the more popular/preferred responsive framework these days, as IE is a thing of the past?
- jagger27 5y agoI wouldn't call flexbox a framework, really. Bootstrap itself uses flexbox nowadays.
- Brajeshwar 5y agoFlex is a CSS Layout Module - https://caniuse.com/?search=flex https://caniuse.com/?search=flex
- peterkos 5y agoBootstrap is one of the things that got me into web development in middle school! My first project was an exam study website. I made a couple of Quizlet sets, embedded the study guide PDFs from teachers (and made my own) into one page. It was a great way to procrastinate on studying and "sort of" study myself. I don't think I'd have done web development without it!
- ThePhysicist 5y agoReally loved Bootstrap when it came out, but nowadays the style and its way of doing things feel a bit dated. That said with the current (good) state of CSS in browsers you can build your own responsive designs without relying on a framework. A negative effect of all these frameworks is that I work with more and more frontend devs that just don't know their way around (S)CSS, so if you throw them into a project that uses a framework they don't know or (gasp) hand-crafted CSS they are completely lost. Same thing with Javascript tooling btw, in a recent project a frontend dev wanted to rewrite the whole codebase because he was not familiar with Webpack and only knew vite (which is the new cool thing it seems), so he wasn't able to work with the existing code.
- vptr 5y agoThis. I wish more devs tried to utilize modern css and js directly instead of relying on frameworks. I try to do this for my own projects but there's gravitational pull toward frameworks in companies.
- traceroute66 5y ago> I wish more devs tried to utilize modern css and js directly instead of relying on frameworks. Its all well and good saying that, as long as you do not value your time. Personally, I would rather use a reasonably up-to-date framework such as Bootstrap 5 because Bootstrap has already taken care of the majority of those CSS hacks that are often required to make things look right on various browsers. And frankly, why re-invent the wheel ? Most "utilize modern css and js directly instead of relying on frameworks" likely ends up looking like "a lot of boilerplate with a few customisations". So why not use Bootstrap for all the boilerplate and spend your time more productively by focusing on the customisations ? P.S. JS is not a strict requirement for Bootstrap, it can be used CSS-only. But one added benefit of Bootstrap 5 in particular is they've removed the jQuery dependency.
- throw_m239339 5y ago> This. I wish more devs tried to utilize modern css and js directly instead of relying on frameworks. Making any large front end application WITHOUT a framework or a view library is just a bad idea, even today. There is nothing in the DOM or spec-wise that is equivalent to the power of React or Vue, period. When it comes to CSS, the situation is better. Flexbox, CSS grids, ... have made creating CSS layouts extremely easy. So CSS kind of successfully brought in a lot of things that were directly exploitable by front-end developers. To this day, HTML and the DOM are JUST NOT RAD for complex UI, period. Web components have a few nice ideas but a lot of flaws (especially support on IOS). Whether you build your own framework or use someone else library, you will absolutely need something that sits on top of the DOM for large front-end applications. So it's not by choice that most front-end devs have to rely on a framework. It's because the standards are not good enough. > I try to do this for my own projects but there's gravitational pull toward frameworks in companies. A simple example. you need a mechanism to manage the life cycle of event handlers on your page, if your app uses the history API. If you do so then you've already started writing your own framework. Web components failed to address a lot of stuff developers use view libraries for. That's why it is not that popular.
- dillondoyle 5y agoNot sure how valuable this comment is except as a thank you! I'm once again back to bootstrap using VueStrap. It's helped me learn(ing) vue and build fast. Just like the original CSS bootstrap helped me learn a lot about CSS. I still use some of their patterns like css 'classes.' I'm indebted again and great to see the dev community keeping up with new tech! For me taking templates and editing and building on them is a great way to pick something new up.
- Raed667 5y agoI remember finding bootstrap when I was in school and it saved me hours! And then I also found a Windows 8 "metro" theme for it [0] I thought it made my web projects so cool... 0: http://aozora.github.io/bootmetro/ http://aozora.github.io/bootmetro/
- brundolf 5y agoMy first introduction to web development was in a summer of 2012 internship at HP. I used Bootstrap and... jQuery Charts I think? to make an internal dashboard that would visualize data dumped out of a SQL database (it was also my first introduction to SQL, and to ASP.NET). The server-side code would just scrape the entire dataset and dump it directly into the client-side script as one big array, lol. And then the UI could filter and narrow the data from there. It was goofy, but it worked. My love for the web began there, and Bootstrap honestly contributed to my experience. Aesthetics are important to me, and the fact that I could so easily make something that looked nice was really gratifying. I haven't really used Bootstrap for anything else since then - I quickly fell in love with and got comfortable with handwritten CSS - but I'm glad it was there at the start.
- jrochkind1 5y agoHow do the core maintainers, no longer at twitter, get paid these days? Is Bootstrap their main job, and if so how does it pay?
- topherPedersen 5y agoOne of the creators works for Coinbase, and the other is at Github.
- jrochkind1 5y agoOh wow! Do you know if their employers pay them to work on it on-the-clock (how much of their job?), or if it's actually a s spare-time/hobby project for them? This kind of traditional way of getting paid while working on open source (a company pays you a salary to work for them, you work on open source in some of your time, you don't make money from the open source) sometimes seems like a thing of the past for big/popular projects, interesting to see it still in play here.
- Brajeshwar 5y agoBootstrap was cool. LESS was cool back then but I hated it, so (I believe so), I translated it to SCSS for the very first time around early 2012. Well, someone published just few weeks after me and I believed a lot of my codes were copied (as I could see my own errors/bugs replicated in his). I got lazy but he keep pushing updates and bug-fixes. Soon, I used his instead for a very long time. I remember this because I was approached to write a book on Bootstrap and Sass by Packt. I believe that's when I stopped using Bootstrap! Looked up and found the old post (now deleted/pruned) in the Archives - http://web.archive.org/web/20120207101527/https://brajeshwar.com/2012/sassscss-version-of-twitter-bootstrap-v2-0/ http://web.archive.org/web/20120207101527/https://brajeshwar...
- dorianmariefr 5y agoNobody mentioned it, so I'm just going to say: "tailwind"
- reidjs 5y agoIs another viable frontend design framework to use.
- joshstrange 5y agoI know Bootstrap can get a lot of hate but it's given me the ability to create things that would never have been finished/made without it. It's a little like Electron in that way. I'm terrible at design, just awful at it, but I'm pretty good developer. Bootstrap lets me get my ideas in a working not-too-bad-looking state whereas if I was doing it from scratch I would have given up on a number of projects due to frustration and not being able to see a path forward. Bootstrap might not be the prettiest but it gets the job done. I'm currently in the process of contracting a designer to re-skin/re-design a product I made using a bought bootstrap theme. I honestly doubt I'd have taken on this project (and executed it successfully) or be able to pay a designer to do this so that I can improve for next year's use of this project without Bootstrap. I have a ton of respect for designers and what they do but I don't have those skills and often I either can't afford a good designer or it's not something that the general public will see, for those things Bootstrap is a godsend.
- piyh 5y agoMaking the jump from purely backend work to putting together a web UI for my project was a huge undertaking. Bootstrap gave me a solution that's better than I could have accomplished in any reasonable amount of time and allowed me to focus on building templates, writing my small amount of JS functionality, containerization, hosting, and the 100's of other small things that are needed.
- joshstrange 5y agoExactly, I use bootstrap more as a scaffolding/wireframe type tool and often it's just good enough. For the times when I want to elevate my product I can bring in a designer. Bootstrap lets me be productive and leverage the skills I DO have instead of getting bogged down in how ugly my stuff looks.
- cutler 5y agoI remember the early days of CSS when Jeffrey Zeldman and Eric Meyer were pushing the boundaries of what IE would allow and web standards kicked and screamed their way into existence. Anyone remember CSS Zen Garden? The thing is, though, you had to be full-time front-end to make that stuff and that's why Bootstrap was so successful for most of us who focus on where the real business value is added.
- pier25 5y ago> Anyone remember CSS Zen Garden Yes! Blew ours minds back at the time.
- pier25 5y agoBootstrap is really awesome. People complain that it has a very recognizable style, but they ignore you can use it in SCSS (instead of the compiled CSS) so you can configure it to your leisure and make it look totally different. When using it in SCSS you can also strip modules you don't need to reduce its size too.
- wil421 5y agoMy bootstrap skills probably landed me my first IT job. I stay away from front end work nowadays but I still use it from time to time. Thanks for all the great work over the years!
- westoncb 5y agoCurious if people have opinions on Bootstrap vs Material UI for building responsive web apps in 2021.
- bob229 5y agoThe only good thing to ever come out of twittter
- lloydatkinson 5y agoTen years of making every site look the same and as though they were all made in 2010.