9 ms·
Phones containing magnets inhibit implantable cardioverter defibrillators
- Forge36 5y agoPlace phone in pants pocket not shirt pocket. I wonder if this is a new phenomena with wireless charging or if other phones could have caused problems and were never tested.
- chimen 5y agoPeople browse the internet laying on their back. I am placing that phone on my chest quite often while doing so
- meowster 5y agoWhen I take a nap and set the alarm on my phone to vibrate only instead of ringing, I place the phone on my chest so that it wakes me up. Because of this post on HN, if I ever get an ICD, I now know better. I wonder how many people don't know.
- ssully 5y agoWhen you get an ICD, they explain all of this to you. Even before the recent warning about iPhone 12's, they explained how the device interacts with magnets and to avoid them.
- sandworm101 5y agoPatient in hospital. In bed. On back. Phone sits of chest while they sleep. Device stops. Alarms. Flashing lights. Nurses running. This is a necessary PSA.
- jaywalk 5y agoA patient in a hospital bed isn't of any real concern with this. There will be no alarms or nurses running if the device is disabled, only if the patient's heart stops. And their heart would have stopped either way, because the ICD isn't keeping their heart running. It's there in case it stops, and if they're in a hospital bed there will be people around ready to attend to them if their heart stops.
- codetrotter 5y ago> Place phone in pants pocket not shirt pocket. I keep my phone in my pocket but I think some people may be hesitant to keep their phone in the pocket for concerns about radiation from the phone in proximity to their testicles. And there may be something to it. In particular if you keep your phone in your pocket while using hands free and having conversations on the phone. https://www.webmd.com/infertility-and-reproduction/news/20080919/cell-phone-use-linked-male-infertility https://www.webmd.com/infertility-and-reproduction/news/2008...
- Retric 5y ago“2.5 centimeters away for 1 hour” that hardly equivalent to real world use and likely due to temperature not radiation.
- FriedPickles 5y agoIt's a PSA: if you have an implanted defibrillator, don't keep iPhone 12 in a shirt pocket. No need for any more drama than that. Reminds me of antennagate, to which Jobs responded: "Don't hold it that way."
- Wowfunhappy 5y agoIdk, with my life on the line I wouldn’t buy an iPhone 12 at all. Sure, I don’t usually keep my phone in my shirt pocket, but it’s a fairly natural thing to do in some circumstances, what if I forget?
- bradknowles 5y agoI’ve carried my iPhone in my shirt pocket for almost as long as the iPhone has been in existence. I’m current,y in the iPhone 7 Plus, because the 8 didn’t have anything I wanted, and I refuse to use Face ID for anything. I’m also over fifty, overweight, and am more likely than average to need a pacemaker or similar device within the next few years. I hadn’t considered the iPhone 12 problem until now, after it has been explained to me. Yikes!
- agent327 5y agoNah, that wouldn't happen more than once.
- multiplegeorges 5y agoThat's a wildly flippant response this issue. "ah, you'll be fine" seriously? Think of the likely user who has a pacemaker. They are probably a man, he's probably in his 60s, 70s, or 80s. He's likely not all that familiar with the intricacies of modern phones. His kids probably convinced him to get a phone so he could stay in touch more easily. That's the audience we're talking about here. It'll happen a lot and while it's happening the lifesaving device is fully disabled. That's a big deal.
- kemayo 5y ago
- argvargc 5y agoThe heart itself is kind of an electromagnetic device - are there any studies on the health implications in healthy people of having powerful magnets placed next to it?
- joezydeco 5y agoDecades of MRI research and clinical use have probably proven this to be safe.
- argvargc 5y agoWhere are the boundaries though? Are they established? There must be a point at which a magnet of power n causes a negative effect that increases along with n, time, and exponentially with proximity?
- shadowgovt 5y agoAs far as we can tell... Yes, such a magnet exists. But it costs the power of a small city to maintain its field, and the patient would experience all kinds of strange effects, including levitating in it as it induced magnetic forces across their water molecules... (Seriously though, there are research magnets powerful enough to levitate plastic that people have jammed their hands into with no ill effects. It seems that across a wide range of intensities at least, the human body just does not care. This is, perhaps, surprising given how much electrochemical activity is necessary for continued homeostasis, but it appears to be observationally true).
- lvncelot 5y agoThere actually have been experiments with levitating animals[1] via a very strong magnetic field - they've been fine afterwards. [1] https://www.ru.nl/hfml/research/levitation/diamagnetic-levitation/ https://www.ru.nl/hfml/research/levitation/diamagnetic-levit...
- 5y ago
- culturestate 5y agoFor what it’s worth, the FDA published a similar warning[1] earlier this year. I’m a little surprised the proliferation of random accessories (phone cases, headphones, etc) with strong-ish neodymium magnets over the last few years hadn’t already raised an alarm. 1. https://www.fda.gov/radiation-emitting-products/cell-phones/magnets-cell-phones-and-smart-watches-may-affect-pacemakers-and-other-implanted-medical-devices https://www.fda.gov/radiation-emitting-products/cell-phones/...
- oneplane 5y agoEspecially since magnets are used so widely in so many products you'd think that even some sort of test/certification/measurement that would happen anyway (RFI?) would also note that there is a strong field present. This stuff gets measured all the time, also for equipment that is to be used in aerospace and hospitals... the whole concept of devices interfering with each other isn't new. But apparently it's still overlooked when it's about consumer electronics as if those couldn't possible interfere/cause interference.
- xondono 5y ago> This stuff gets measured all the time, also for equipment that is to be used in aerospace and hospitals... They only measure dynamic magnetic fields (i.e. electromagnetic fields). There are essentially no regulatory limits in static fields, since they don't really interfere with RF signals. In fact, is amazingly easy to purchase neodymium magnets of a size that should not be that easily available, which explains the hilarious safety videos like this one[1] [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0t8yDnyOaQ8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0t8yDnyOaQ8
- oneplane 5y agoNow that I read that, it seems obvious that static fields and RF wouldn't interact like that... Thanks! The video is very well done (for a semi-pro it seems?), it's one of those things where people (including me) might think "oh yeah magnets, I know about those" but you actually don't, or at last not at the scale that you might need. That reminds me of this LPL video about Gallium: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeghGhVdt9s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jeghGhVdt9s where you might think: oh yeah, metals, those are sturdy blocks that you need to weld or saw.
- oever 5y agoGreat opportunity for a killer app.
- Maxburn 5y agoUnexpected humor is the best.
- mensetmanusman 5y agoThis might create a niche market for mu metal iPhone cases.
- stevespang 5y agoLawyers will be upset you published this - - now they cannot make money sueing a REALLY deep pocket.
- dcroley 5y agoI guess those $10 magnetically attached name tags are bad too then.
- KineticLensman 5y agoUK ICD-user here. So three weeks ago I had a severe ventricular fibrillation episode - I fell unconscious, had bystander defibrillation, air ambulance to hospital and two days later had an ICD fitted just below my left collar bone and was out of hospital the next day. I use an iPhone 12Pro. The advice I was given was don't hold any phone closer than six inches away from the device- so holding it to my right ear is fine. Mag fields right next to the device can stop it sensing or in rare circumstances can cause a factory reset. The biggest EM hazards in my house are the induction hobs on my cooker - these are worse than the phone. On full power I have to keep at least 60cm away from them or they will blind / alarm the ICD. So I am more concerned about them than the phone. [Edit] Other hazards are drills held close to my chest and even the capes used by hair-dressers that have magnetic clasps to stay shut. Standing right next to the speakers at a concert is also not-advised.
- philjohn 5y agoHope you're doing better now after the ICD! My 81 year old father had one fitted a few months ago and it's been pretty much life changing (once he was allowed out of the hospital, they managed to nick his lung, which was a whole big thing). Was going to say induction hobs - that's a huge one, especially as gas is eventually phased out and they become the defacto hob type. NHS recommendation[1] is, as you said, 6 inches for most mobile phones, but no special callout for the 12. Apple goes further[2] and says 12 inches when wirelessly charging, which also makes sense. [1] https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/pacemaker-implantation/recovery/ https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/pacemaker-implantation/recover... [2] https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT211900 https://support.apple.com/en-gb/HT211900
- KineticLensman 5y ago> Hope you're doing better now after the ICD! Thank you! I'm just 60 and was (I believed) in good health. My VF episode was a glitch in my heart's conduction cycle, and the various tests I received show that my heart is physically healthy. So I feel 'perfectly okay' apart the almost dying thing. My biggest health issue now is the cracked risks from the superbly enthusiastic CPR I received, but the pain from coughing and moving awkwardly is a small price to pay.
- analog31 5y agoIn addition to heart implants, cochlear implants are an issue too. Not only that but the electronics for controlling the implant require an iPhone app.
- gorkish 5y agoQuestion for phone repair folks: On teardown photos, it seems like the iPhone magnets are accessible after dealing with a few layers of adhesive. Is it possible and if so, how difficult is it to remove the ring of magnets?
- amrcnimgrnt 5y agoThe problem appears to me to be a design problem of the implanted devices, not the iPhone. Unless I'm mistaken this is what's happening: 1. ICDs want/need to communicate with the outside (at least one way). 2.However, this is not trivial since a human body is a bag of salt water. Therefore low frequencies are needed. 3. Low frequencies are very difficult at the necessary length scales with electric fields, so they used the magnetic field instead. So far, so good. But then they assumed that the person would never be next to a magnet? That's a design flaw on their end, not the iPhone's. There's magnets, and low moving large currents, everywhere! The should have implemented a primitive type of port knocking.
- KineticLensman 5y ago> Unless I'm mistaken this is what's happening: The actual problem is that EM fields blind the device so that they can't sense the cardiac arrhythmias they are designed to fix, this rendering them useless. > ICDs want/need to communicate with the outside (at least one way). My St Jude Ellipse ICD communicates bidirectionally (control inputs in, telemetry out).
- amrcnimgrnt 5y agoI'll leave it to you, a user, that strong EM fields also blind the devices. The signals the ICD is trying to measure are very weak. I can imagine that strong 50/60Hz surge currents really screw things up, especially in single conductor power distribution situations (UK ring circuits, rural farms, etc). That being said, the article (TL/DR) appears to focus on "static" magnetic fields. The near field charging feature of the iPhone barely makes mention. I think the "disable ICD" being a simple magnetized reed switch for an implantable medical device is a bit silly. At least tap a code into that reed switch a little!
- bdcravens 5y agoThe entire medical devices industry tackles this issue just fine (for example, I have a percussion vest for respiratory therapy that uses strong magnets, and there's no shortage of warnings).
- nycbenf 5y agoICD patient and avid cell phone user here. They tell us magnets will disable the device. This is by design, they include a hall effect sensor to allow medical personnel to disable the devices. They aren't exactly specific about how big a magnet and how close it has to be. My device sends data to a base station which reports back and is also interrogated every 6 months by a electrophysiologist and they can see if and when it has been disabled. Mine has been disabled twice so far, once by using the Boston Scientific interrogation device to turn it off, and once by a surgeon taping a magnet to my chest!
- TheCapn 5y agoI don't know the entire story, but my wife is a cardiac ICU nurse and says magnets are part of the normal procedures for dealing with ICDs. They'll slap a magnet on the chest of an ICD patient to inhibit the device if it malfunctions. All I'm saying from that is while a lot of comments around here are calling it design flaws, I'm pretty sure to a certain extent its a design decision. If you have a patient on the stretcher and you need to disable that thing now then a magnet seems like a perfectly reasonable & safe thing to use. Requiring specialized devices that might not be available at all times seems like the design flaw. Asking patients with specific health needs to avoid certain activities/devices is not a huge stretch.